Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think you can't be environmentally friendly on a low income?

68 replies

Mummamama · 08/10/2021 19:55

How do you be green on a low income? I try and find ways to reduce my impact but the green options are expensive! Particularly lately i've been looking at all the plastic waste of bottles of shampoo/shower gel but when i've looked for alternatives shampoo bars are really expensive considering I spend 90p on a bottle of shampoo!

OP posts:
Griefmonster · 08/10/2021 20:26

Making ethical choices in what you buy new is - generally - not for those on a limited budget/low income e.g. eco toiletries, organic food, organic and sustainable clothing and shoes. But as others have said, there will be lifestyle factors that limit your carbon footprint in any case.

Mummamama · 08/10/2021 20:25

@CatNamedEaster

I agree with pp's. If you are on a low income you need to lose the guilt and prioritise based on your situation. On a bigger scale, it's the responsibility of richer nations to help poorer ones on tackling this.

If you want to feel like you are playing a part, do things that don't cost you any more than you would normally spend and don't eat into your time - recycling, planning meals/using leftovers to cut your food waste, using pulses and lentils to bulk out any meat dishes, buy loose fruit and veg if it's cheaper than packaged, etc - but don't feel bad about buying shampoo in a plastic bottle or having to use the car if there's no feasible alternative. Your mental load will already be high enough, you don't need to add saving the planet to it.Flowers

Thank you. I think I do need to learn to let go of what I can't control
OP posts:
Mummamama · 08/10/2021 20:23

Oh and I am already a lover of second hand clothes. DD is 14 months and 90% of her clothes and lots of toys too are preloved, saves us a fortune. I started buying my own clothes second hand off ebay just before DD was born and I'll never go back now!

OP posts:
Mummamama · 08/10/2021 20:21

Thanks everyone. I should have added we already walk whenever possible, and we live in a village so post office and a couple shops nearby which makes that doable for certain things, however my job is 40 mins away by car so unfortunately I cannot cycle it. We drastically reduced meat a few years ago and enjoy veggie options which does also save alot of money so win win there! Our vegetable waste is fed to our chickens.
Zero waste shop is a good idea but I've just checked there isn't one local. Hopefully in the future more shops will offer this and brands will stop using so much plastic.

OP posts:
PomegranateQueen · 08/10/2021 20:20

My children are still little and I have noticed that it is hard to be 'fashionably' environmentally friendly on a budget. I'm thinking scandi organic cotton clothes, the latest cloth nappy prints, fancy cloth pads, Kleen kanteens for the whole family, eye wateringly expensive wooden toys etc etc.
Some changes are easier to make on a budget, most of my DS's clothes were my DN's first I use public transport or walk and I holiday in the UK if at all.

Thesearmsofmine · 08/10/2021 20:18

The best swap we did was shower gel to bar soap, we used to go through so much shower gel it was ridiculous. I still buy shampoo though because I don't get on well with the bars and can’t afford to buy loads to try until I do find one that works for me.
I do what I can but it’s a drop on the ocean compared to some.

CatNamedEaster · 08/10/2021 20:11

I agree with pp's. If you are on a low income you need to lose the guilt and prioritise based on your situation.
On a bigger scale, it's the responsibility of richer nations to help poorer ones on tackling this.

If you want to feel like you are playing a part, do things that don't cost you any more than you would normally spend and don't eat into your time - recycling, planning meals/using leftovers to cut your food waste, using pulses and lentils to bulk out any meat dishes, buy loose fruit and veg if it's cheaper than packaged, etc - but don't feel bad about buying shampoo in a plastic bottle or having to use the car if there's no feasible alternative. Your mental load will already be high enough, you don't need to add saving the planet to it.Flowers

JapanJetplane · 08/10/2021 20:10

People on low incomes tend not to fly lots which helps! If you aren’t going on long haul holidays cut yourself some slack on the smaller stuff.

Giving up meat is the most significant difference you can make, and will generally save money.

Things like shampoo bars are cheaper in the long run because they last a lot longer but the upfront cost can be prohibitive. This is often a trap that catches poorer people - they don’t have the funds to make a large upfront payment which would save money in the long term.

PurpleDaisies · 08/10/2021 20:07

Changing your diet to eat less meat would be a money saver as well as an environmentally friendly one.

Chicchicchicchiclana · 08/10/2021 20:06

But, yes, I agree. The really wealthy are of course fucking up the planet. But still hopefully everyone else can do their bit anyway.

PartyStory · 08/10/2021 20:05

I can almost guarantee that your carbon footprint is already smaller than a rich person's. Aside from that, it's companies that produce the vast amount of greenhouse gases and that's the real issue. Blaming individuals is just a distraction. It's good to not be wasteful but don't beat yourself up over something that is beyond your control. Voting and campaigning will make a much bigger difference than whether you throw away an extra shampoo bottle or not.

Bontanics · 08/10/2021 20:05

Move you money into a bank that doesn't invest in fossil fuels.
Change energy suppliers who only invest in renewable energy.

Chicchicchicchiclana · 08/10/2021 20:04

Shampoo bars last a lot longer than you think.

You can buy bars of soap for showering and hand washing and they are always cheaper, especially if you get supermarket own brand.

Washing powder is cheaper than liquid or pods that come in plastic packaging.

You can really cut down on disposables for cleaning - washing up liquid and hot water with boosters like salt or bicarb or soda crystals will clean almost everything. Cut up old shirts for dusters, old t-shirts for cleaning cloths. You don't need wipes or even paper towel, sponges or dishcloths if you put your mind to it.

FellInLoveWithABanana · 08/10/2021 20:04

YABU with your example. Okay so you can’t afford the £5 shampoo bar but do you walk and cycle? Compost? Use food waste apps like Olio and Too Good To Go?

Lemonnhoney · 08/10/2021 20:02

www.friendlysoap.co.uk/shampoo/

I’ve been getting this shampoo bar for years and it’s one of the cheapest I’ve found about. I agree spending over £5 on one is a bit much.. but they do last a lot longer than bottled shampoo.

Also find you’re nearest zero waste shop and check it out. Not everything is cheaper but figure out what is and where you can actually save money and plastics.. herbs for example will always be cheaper but some stuff isn’t worth it

SameToo · 08/10/2021 20:00

Definitely the rich who need to change. Drives me mad people who could afford to shop better choosing fast fashion and then flying all over the place.

You’re doing the best you can but you shouldn’t be going short because of it.

People should change what they can reasonably afford to change.

adasills · 08/10/2021 19:59

Some of the best ways to go green are also the best to save money.
bike or walk rather than car
buying less in general
buying second hand
fixing rather than buying new
going vegetarian
etc

Summerhillsquare · 08/10/2021 19:58

On the contrary OP. Its rich people who need to change their behaviour, people who take multiple plane journeys, big cars, overheated huge houses, loads of clothes and gadgets and so on. Those of us who live modestly don't have such a huge carbon footprint. Dont worry too much about your shampoo.

Swipe left for the next trending thread