Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think you can't be environmentally friendly on a low income?

68 replies

Mummamama · 08/10/2021 19:55

How do you be green on a low income? I try and find ways to reduce my impact but the green options are expensive! Particularly lately i've been looking at all the plastic waste of bottles of shampoo/shower gel but when i've looked for alternatives shampoo bars are really expensive considering I spend 90p on a bottle of shampoo!

OP posts:
Mynameismargot · 08/10/2021 21:06

Buy second hand. All of our furniture pretty much is second hand, lots of clothes, anything we need I look for it second hand first. Stops the need for new things to be created, stops old things going to landfill and its easier on the pocket.

LibrariesGiveUsPower45321 · 08/10/2021 21:04

One of the biggest things we can all do is stop very short drives. Driving 5 mins up the road to get a loaf of bread, go to the post office, gp, school, etc. If we walk those very short distances that makes a massive difference.

Wear a jumper and blankets when cold over boosting heating.

Little things add up. Otherwise I do agree, a lot of the trendy eco things are very expensive, and not all are as eco as they seem.

MrsRobbieHart · 08/10/2021 21:04

@Mummamama

How do you be green on a low income? I try and find ways to reduce my impact but the green options are expensive! Particularly lately i've been looking at all the plastic waste of bottles of shampoo/shower gel but when i've looked for alternatives shampoo bars are really expensive considering I spend 90p on a bottle of shampoo!
Don’t even bother wasting your time. I work for lots of well off people. The waste they produce will undo any and all of your good work. It’s utterly pointless. You’re almost definitely beating them all in the green game anyway.
lifecoachingandotherbollocks · 08/10/2021 21:00

Shampoo bars last for ages if you can afford the initial out lay!

DdraigGoch · 08/10/2021 20:56

Nonsense OP. Reducing consumption saves money. That's common sense. How can it cost money to not-fly? I got rid of my car in favour of a bike. £1-2k saved per year. Thinking "do I really need that?" before each purchase - also saves a fortune.

As for the cost of a bar of shampoo, how often do you need a new bottle compared with how long a bar lasts?

MojoMoon · 08/10/2021 20:49

www.friendlysoap.co.uk/product/lavender-tea-tree-shampoo-bar/. is £2.75 and will likely last much longer than a bottle.

While it's great to cut down on plastic, the biggest impact you have on the atmosphere is by heating your home, your choice of surface transport and your diet.

Poorer people normally have smaller homes (so less home to heat) and are watching the pennies so don't have the heating on much, don't drive a car and eat less meat. So you definitely can be environmentally friendly on a budget - in fact compared to richer people, it's highly likely you are already.

EmeraldShamrock · 08/10/2021 20:46

You can make small changes every bit helps.
I buy the 5ltr water bottle over small bottles still not great but am improvement.

If you can fork out on an industrial bottle of shampoo from a salon stockist.

I don't drive a car or fly because I can't afford it, it helps the environment.

You're making a conscious effort more than a lot of people have managed.

DowntonCrabby · 08/10/2021 20:41

Maybe not massively eco friendly to send things in the post but PM me your address if you’d like to try a bar shampoo OP and I’ll send one.
I stocked up about a year ago but they last so long and it’s only me that uses it in the family.

You might love it and feel it’s worth it for the future if one bar lasts as long as several bottles and if not, no big deal.

Absolutely it’s the gas guzzling, massive carbon footprint folks and companies who should be doing their bit though to have the biggest impact.

rrhuth · 08/10/2021 20:39

@DollyDinkle

Conkers make amazing clothes washing powder
I don't understand this - please elaborate!
DollyDinkle · 08/10/2021 20:38

Conkers make amazing clothes washing powder

rrhuth · 08/10/2021 20:36

Oh typos, sorry! Just have a guess Grin

HarrisMcCoo · 08/10/2021 20:36

I use basic bars of soap for handwashing. Very cheap compared to all those bottles of hand wash.

AnneLovesGilbert · 08/10/2021 20:35

My shampoo bar is under a fiver and I use two and a bit a year with long very thick hair. I can’t think of a cheaper way to wash your hair.

Eating less meat is good.

Buying second hand is good.

No food miles on your eggs if your chickens make them Smile

You’re doing a lot already!

rrhuth · 08/10/2021 20:35

@Mummamama

Thanks everyone. I should have added we already walk whenever possible, and we live in a village so post office and a couple shops nearby which makes that doable for certain things, however my job is 40 mins away by car so unfortunately I cannot cycle it. We drastically reduced meat a few years ago and enjoy veggie options which does also save alot of money so win win there! Our vegetable waste is fed to our chickens. Zero waste shop is a good idea but I've just checked there isn't one local. Hopefully in the future more shops will offer this and brands will stop using so much plastic.
You are already doing a lot - have you measures you family carbon footprint agai at a) the average and b) the target?

I completely disagree with your premise, I think it is entirely possible to be green on a low income - buying less, travelling less, eating less meat are all good actions.

LikeTheOceansWeRise · 08/10/2021 20:35

Also a massive yes to ebay, it's so great especially for baby and toddler clothes

IVflytrap · 08/10/2021 20:35

Not sure where that "remember" came from Hmm

Chicchicchicchiclana · 08/10/2021 20:35

@PomegranateQueen

My children are still little and I have noticed that it is hard to be 'fashionably' environmentally friendly on a budget. I'm thinking scandi organic cotton clothes, the latest cloth nappy prints, fancy cloth pads, Kleen kanteens for the whole family, eye wateringly expensive wooden toys etc etc. Some changes are easier to make on a budget, most of my DS's clothes were my DN's first I use public transport or walk and I holiday in the UK if at all.
But of course no one needs to be fashionably environmentally friendly. Buying second hand (as op does) is better. I think most of us appreciate this.

And having smaller families in the wealthy 3rd world. That's a contentious one but one of the least sustainable things you can do is put more children onto the planet than will replace you.

Today I was walking down my high street and I walked past a woman obviously much younger than me who was carrying a gigantic helium balloon in the shape of the letter 4. Obviously for her child's birthday. What happens to that plastic and that helium tomorrow? We've got to stop with the throwaway.

IVflytrap · 08/10/2021 20:34

Well I can't remember afford a car so either walk or take the bus everywhere. I line dry all my washing as no dryer and never fly anywhere because I can't afford to travel. I mend clothes or buy second hand and only rarely buy new. I keep the thermostat low. I can't afford to eat meat every day. I'll also probably never have kids as I'll never earn enough. I'd say I'm pretty green compared to most rich people who fly and drive everywhere even if it's more out of necessity.

Obviously we should be reducing plastic waste and single-use packaging, but as you know it's not always affordable. If your main green concern is climate change, then reducing packaging waste is less essential in tackling climate change than stopping flying or reducing unnecessary car journeys. Although obviously it's still something worth trying to do if you can.

Reducing packaging isn't always expensive: bar soap for washing hands over liquid soap, for example. Bring your own bags to the supermarket. Avoid overpackaged fruit and veg in favour of loose (if affordable).

LikeTheOceansWeRise · 08/10/2021 20:33

I agree with PP about not worrying about the small stuff. Changing your bank to one that doesn't invest in fossil fuels or deforestation (like the Co-op) will make a lot more difference than using a shampoo bar.

Plastic free seems to have become the frontman for being environmentally friendly. I'm a sucker for it, recently I spent money on 'non paper towels', they are just bits of bloody fabric, could've made them myself! There are a lot of pointless 'green' products out there that we could just make at home. We should 100% be reducing our plastic, but often that means spending loads more money and its easy to slip up when you need to buy an emergency bottle of conditioner and then feel guilty for being an eco failure.

Eating less or no meat, not flying, walking rather than driving and changing your bank are cheap but powerful ways to do your bit.

Alpacinoshoohaa · 08/10/2021 20:32

Op I agree, even in terms of having the time to give brain space to it. We certainly try and could do more but I notice far more well off friends who have more time and money are able to think about it more and so more

ivykaty44 · 08/10/2021 20:32

90p for a shampoo bottle that lasts how long?

my shampoo bar in Sainsbury was £3 and last 3 months

I started using bum loo roll thats £36 per 48 rolls, but they are double the size of the cheap rolls and last twice as long. we used to get through 3/4 bog rolls from supermarket per week but now 1/2 per week

might be false economy buying cheap

KeyboardWorriers · 08/10/2021 20:30

It sounds like you are already really doing a lot.

I struggle watching people not bother at all - like our neighbours who all drive huge 4x4s and constantly seem to be getting new kitchens etc.

It helps me stick to my principles just to hear from other people who are trying.

adasills · 08/10/2021 20:30

op..you already do loads!

Caspianberg · 08/10/2021 20:29

We use cloth nappies. They are white. I don’t understand the craze at all with ‘fashionable’ new nappy prints, as they just encourage buying more which defies the whole point. Ds nappies are worn under clothing, so no one sees them anyway

Bars of soap rather than hand liquid soap or shower gel are far cheaper. They last longer too. We use dove which isn’t a super eco friendly soap, but just bog standard bar in cardboard box for about 50p. Can be used as shampoo on occasion ( I do when travelling to save taking extras products)

Griefmonster · 08/10/2021 20:27

I am on a higher than average salary and recognise that I have a responsibility to make more ethical choices in how I spend my money precisely because not everyone has that choice.

Swipe left for the next trending thread