Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is equality in education actually achievable? and is it what we want?

110 replies

SinoohXaenaHide · 08/10/2021 14:52

So, market forces and political currents over many decades seem to have fixed the amount that the taxpayer is willing to pay per year per child in state education as around £7k per year (£7,100 to be precise according to this article)

And in a well-run school with willing and able pupils, that amount of money is enough to provide a fairly decent quality of education. Obviously with more money a school could do more, but that would cost more tax, and this seems to be the level of balance between tax and education quality that we corporately as a population will accept.

In the UK the distribution of individual income means that about 20% of individual earners have more than twice the median disposable income. It's not at all surprising that some more well-off families wish to purchase a different education than that which is provided by taxpayers. About 7% of children are educated privately. In a free society the freedom to choose to educate ones children outside the state system is important and I don't think anyone is saying that it should be illegal to spend ones spare income on education if one chooses, only that this shouldn't be subsidised by the tax payer.

The above linked article says that Labour will abolish the tax advantages of private schools and use the money to fund state schools. We've had thousands of threads which go over and over how the practicalities of achieving that would be complicated (it would require a rebuilding of charity law from the ground up. Let's not get into that again though) but setting that aside, you are only talking about creaming an extra 20% of what is spent on 7% of pupils - although the rocketing of school fees might drop that to only 6% as a lot of self-funders can only just afford the fees as it is - and then you spread that among the 94% of pupils in state education. I've done the maths and that works out as less than £100 extra per pupil per year in state education - that's not going to make much difference.

To actually level up state education to the kind of quality that would begin to make private education obsolete because so many fewer feel the need to opt out of it, would take an injection of income into schools of more like £3,000 per year per pupil. That would be what was needed to get class sizes and facilities to a level that is more similar to the private sector. That would require about £30 billion pounds more per year into the education budget - there are about 30 million tax payers in the UK so that would require each tax payer to pay about £1000 per year more tax. Or if you made it progressive, that would be an extra £625 per tax payer for basic rate, £1,875 per year (3 times as much as basic rate payers) for those who pay at the higher rate and £5,625 per year (9 times as much as basic rate payers) for those who pay at the highest rate. This would raise the required £30 billion per year.

For comparison, the changes to National Insurance coming in next year to fund social care are expected to raise £12 billion - barely a third of that. So the kind of tax rise required is phenomenal.

Do we as a population want to see the kinds of tax rises that would be needed to actually level up our childrens education? Could a political party ever be voted in on a policy of tax rises of that magnitude in exchange for creating a state education sector that is good enough to make private schools obsolete?

Is equality in education actually achievable? and is it what we want?
OP posts:
AlexaShutUp · 08/10/2021 16:02

@Gardenlass, some children with SEN function very well in mainstream schools. Others need more specialist provision. Both options need to be adequately funded.

And yes, parental support and involvement makes a huge difference. Arguably, this is why private schools do so well, rather than the actual spend per pupil. Some kids do not have the advantage of having engaged and supportive parents from birth, for a whole raft of reasons. I agree that it is very difficult to fully compensate for that disadvantage, but we should at least do what we can to improve their life chances. You sound like you think we should just give up on most of them, but I'm sure that's not what you actually mean?!

Gardenlass · 08/10/2021 15:55

The assumption is that all children are equally intelligent and will benefit from a good education. Sadly that is not the case. If a child has SEN, then their education needs to be tailored to their needs, and mainstream school is not the best place to do this.
Even allowing for no special needs, much success in education involves factors other than the school setting. Parental support and involvement is the main one. If parents are unable or unwilling to offer support, then only an extremely bright child will succeed, and most will leave school without the necessary qualifications for further education.

AlexaShutUp · 08/10/2021 15:47

You assume that any additional funding for state schools would be split equally between all children in the state sector. I agree that this wouldn't go very far.

However, if you decided to concentrate that funding on those pupils who are currently at the greatest disadvantage - either because of their socio-economic circumstances, family circumstances or disability etc - then you could potentially make a significant difference to their life chances.

My dd has done very well in the state sector and does not need any additional resource to be able to compete with her privately educated counterparts. There are many other kids like her. However, those who are most disadvantaged would benefit. I would like to see them get those opportunities.

Moonlaserbearwolf · 08/10/2021 15:40

@RedMarauder

But, I wonder how many teachers who have left the profession in recent years would be tempted back if class sizes were smaller?

If you know any teachers in rl ask they why they left teaching. Absolutely no-one I know who was a teacher left because of class sizes.

BTW I went to two state schools where the parents funded raised to provide the schools with facilities and to keep them running. One was in a working class area the other was in a more diverse social area. Now they are both in MC areas.

I am a teacher and I know several people who did! We are allowed to have different opinions you know!
RedMarauder · 08/10/2021 15:25

But, I wonder how many teachers who have left the profession in recent years would be tempted back if class sizes were smaller?

If you know any teachers in rl ask they why they left teaching. Absolutely no-one I know who was a teacher left because of class sizes.

BTW I went to two state schools where the parents funded raised to provide the schools with facilities and to keep them running. One was in a working class area the other was in a more diverse social area. Now they are both in MC areas.

ftw163532 · 08/10/2021 15:22

I would be perfectly happy to pay more tax in exchange for decent public services instead of the shitshow we currently have.

Brindle88 · 08/10/2021 15:20

It’s that old dilemma of people wanting services but not wanting to be the ones to pay the tax.

Ionlydomassiveones · 08/10/2021 15:04

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn at the poster's request.

Moonlaserbearwolf · 08/10/2021 15:00

That’s really interesting! Thanks for explaining the figures. I imagine most people (including me) had no idea what the impact of abolishing charity status for private schools would be. Sadly, assuming your numbers are right, not a huge impact.

It would be amazing to level up the system by finding £3k per pupil to increase the staff:pupil ratio in schools. Of course we’d then have to suddenly find a lot more teachers from somewhere. But, I wonder how many teachers who have left the profession in recent years would be tempted back if class sizes were smaller?

lifeturnsonadime · 08/10/2021 14:55

Well it would be a nice start if the government would offer a fair education to ALL children. As it is it does not. Disabled, Autistic and SEN children do not receive a fair education and families are left to pick up the pieces due to the lack of specialist provisions and the fact that Local Authorities actively seek to deny provision to children who cannot go to mainstream schools.

Swipe left for the next trending thread