Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is equality in education actually achievable? and is it what we want?

110 replies

SinoohXaenaHide · 08/10/2021 14:52

So, market forces and political currents over many decades seem to have fixed the amount that the taxpayer is willing to pay per year per child in state education as around £7k per year (£7,100 to be precise according to this article)

And in a well-run school with willing and able pupils, that amount of money is enough to provide a fairly decent quality of education. Obviously with more money a school could do more, but that would cost more tax, and this seems to be the level of balance between tax and education quality that we corporately as a population will accept.

In the UK the distribution of individual income means that about 20% of individual earners have more than twice the median disposable income. It's not at all surprising that some more well-off families wish to purchase a different education than that which is provided by taxpayers. About 7% of children are educated privately. In a free society the freedom to choose to educate ones children outside the state system is important and I don't think anyone is saying that it should be illegal to spend ones spare income on education if one chooses, only that this shouldn't be subsidised by the tax payer.

The above linked article says that Labour will abolish the tax advantages of private schools and use the money to fund state schools. We've had thousands of threads which go over and over how the practicalities of achieving that would be complicated (it would require a rebuilding of charity law from the ground up. Let's not get into that again though) but setting that aside, you are only talking about creaming an extra 20% of what is spent on 7% of pupils - although the rocketing of school fees might drop that to only 6% as a lot of self-funders can only just afford the fees as it is - and then you spread that among the 94% of pupils in state education. I've done the maths and that works out as less than £100 extra per pupil per year in state education - that's not going to make much difference.

To actually level up state education to the kind of quality that would begin to make private education obsolete because so many fewer feel the need to opt out of it, would take an injection of income into schools of more like £3,000 per year per pupil. That would be what was needed to get class sizes and facilities to a level that is more similar to the private sector. That would require about £30 billion pounds more per year into the education budget - there are about 30 million tax payers in the UK so that would require each tax payer to pay about £1000 per year more tax. Or if you made it progressive, that would be an extra £625 per tax payer for basic rate, £1,875 per year (3 times as much as basic rate payers) for those who pay at the higher rate and £5,625 per year (9 times as much as basic rate payers) for those who pay at the highest rate. This would raise the required £30 billion per year.

For comparison, the changes to National Insurance coming in next year to fund social care are expected to raise £12 billion - barely a third of that. So the kind of tax rise required is phenomenal.

Do we as a population want to see the kinds of tax rises that would be needed to actually level up our childrens education? Could a political party ever be voted in on a policy of tax rises of that magnitude in exchange for creating a state education sector that is good enough to make private schools obsolete?

Is equality in education actually achievable? and is it what we want?
OP posts:
montysma1 · 08/10/2021 17:25

Ut's not even the education that's unfair... plenty in state schools put perfotmprovate school pupils.
Its about the hidden advantages. Contacts, privilege and the old school tie.

AlexaShutUp · 08/10/2021 17:23

Society can never be equal for everyone.

I agree with this, but I don't think it means that we shouldn't try to make it as equal as possible.

Gardenlass · 08/10/2021 17:22

Honestly I hate paying so much tax, but education is the one thing I would be very happy to pay much more tax for. It’s not just the unfairness in the disparity in the standard of education that bothers me about the idea of private schools, it’s the social apartheid which I really hate
Even if there were no private schools, there will always be children and families who will congregate with others of the same background and values. Society can never be equal for everyone.

Kite22 · 08/10/2021 17:21

Interesting. Perhaps there ought to be a requirement for people to work for a minimum number of years within the state sector or else pay back the costs of their training?

It is fairly staggering that this isn't built in to the agreement, I think most normal people would agree. The concept of saying to students "come and do this training for a year and we will pay you thousands" without any sort of contract where they have to commit to using that training, is frankly ridiculous, and could only have ever been thought to be a sensible use of public money by people who do not live in the real world.

I agree that more needs to be done to retain existing teachers, but it seems to me that a lot of things would need to change in order to tackle this?

Oh yes, lots and lots. But including a lot of stuff that wouldn't cost money.

Fr0thandBubble · 08/10/2021 17:07

Honestly I hate paying so much tax, but education is the one thing I would be very happy to pay much more tax for. It’s not just the unfairness in the disparity in the standard of education that bothers me about the idea of private schools, it’s the social apartheid which I really hate.

I am generally pretty right-wing and believe in a low-tax state, but anything to do with children and their education and life opportunities, I am very happy for the state to throw money at; and I wish they’d do more.

AlexaShutUp · 08/10/2021 17:06

@noblegiraffe

It wouldn’t necessarily need massive tax rises to improve education. The govt currently wastes huge amounts of money training new teachers who either go straight to the private sector (no requirement to teach in a state school), quit teaching before they start, or leave within the first few years.

No investment is made into retaining experienced teachers either.

It’s a massive and costly drain on the system to constantly be throwing money at training teachers, which is effectively pouring water into an extremely leaky bucket.

Interesting. Perhaps there ought to be a requirement for people to work for a minimum number of years within the state sector or else pay back the costs of their training?

I agree that more needs to be done to retain existing teachers, but it seems to me that a lot of things would need to change in order to tackle this?

AlexaShutUp · 08/10/2021 16:53

@flippertyop

It depends on what you mean by equality I guess. If there are two children - same ability but one has an advantage from a private school system I would agree - but should the tax payer foot a large bill for someone who isn't going to deliver much back into society? Does someone who is only ever going to stack shelves need the same level of investment as someone who is going to be a doctor? I don't know. For me the grammar school systems makes more sense. Invest equally in the cleverer ones ensuring this is accessible by all not just distance from home etc. Private school pupils have entrance exams - they don't just take anyone so perhaps that is the answer. That said I can't see anyone bothering to pay for schooling if they can get it free at an equal level. My children go to state by the way, no grammar in this area before people make assumptions
I fundamentally disagree with your suggestion that we should invest more in the "cleverer" children.

Firstly, it's almost impossible to have a fair system that separates the kids who are likely to succeed academically and those who are not. The 11+ very clearly favours those with wealthy, supportive parents. So some poor kids will end up as shelf stackers not because of their inherent lack of ability but because they were never given a chance to develop their academic potential.

Secondly, not all kids are academic but the vast majority will have other skills that are potentially very valuable to our society - whether they are practical skills, interpersonal skills or whatever. We should be investing at least as much in these kids and their talents as the very academic kids. However, there needs to be enough diversity within our education for them to find the right path that suits their talents.

Thirdly, some kids may not have obvious talents in any particular field. Indeed, they may struggle with everything due to SEN, disability or whatever. Nonetheless, they still deserve at least as much support as the next kid - arguably even more - to fulfil their individual potential. Their achievements may not be Nobel prize winning, but they may nevertheless be enormously significant for them.

I see education and the opportunity to fulfil potential as a fundamental human right. Not something where we need to calculate a return on investment and only bet on the kids who are most likely to win!

flippertyop · 08/10/2021 16:49

@Elephantsparade that is not what I mean and I am sure you know it. Anyone can stack a shelf not anyone can be a doctor. We should be encouraging those who can and want to be doctors to do this and investing in their educations to achieve this regardless of family income. We do not need to invest in the same level of education for someone who does not have that same level of intelligence

zoemum2006 · 08/10/2021 16:48

It's a very British thing to be so obsessed with private schools and class. Most countries realise it's better for the general population to be well educated.

It does us no favours having some kids with loads more privilege than others and then whining about a skills shortage.

worrybutterfly · 08/10/2021 16:46

I'm interested in where the £3k a student figure comes from and how it would be spent.

I don't mind paying extra but I feel like £3k a year would just go down the drain at a lot of schools. Instead what our local school needs is a lump sum of £££ to rebuilt it, when £3k a year per student would just be used to plug the holes.

That said I do think that teaching as a job needs to be made more appealing, especially in secondary. I work in STEM and after after having children looked into moving across to teaching. But £25k a year isn't exactly enticing, especially when I can earn over double that in industry. However, teaching in the private sector did look appealing once you factored in the free education for your children that a lot of them offer to staff.

Elephantsparade · 08/10/2021 16:43

Wow @flippertyop im very grateful to shelf stackers and their contribution to society.

DazzlePaintedBattlePants · 08/10/2021 16:38

Schools actually get around £4K per child, nothing near the £7k.

flippertyop · 08/10/2021 16:37

It depends on what you mean by equality I guess. If there are two children - same ability but one has an advantage from a private school system I would agree - but should the tax payer foot a large bill for someone who isn't going to deliver much back into society? Does someone who is only ever going to stack shelves need the same level of investment as someone who is going to be a doctor? I don't know. For me the grammar school systems makes more sense. Invest equally in the cleverer ones ensuring this is accessible by all not just distance from home etc. Private school pupils have entrance exams - they don't just take anyone so perhaps that is the answer. That said I can't see anyone bothering to pay for schooling if they can get it free at an equal level. My children go to state by the way, no grammar in this area before people make assumptions

Hollowgast · 08/10/2021 16:35

Nothing to add to the discussion, but wanted to express my thanks for a fascinating post that explains things so simply.

As ever, the answer to the question "but why can't you just..." is much more complicated than it initially appears.

noblegiraffe · 08/10/2021 16:34

It wouldn’t necessarily need massive tax rises to improve education. The govt currently wastes huge amounts of money training new teachers who either go straight to the private sector (no requirement to teach in a state school), quit teaching before they start, or leave within the first few years.

No investment is made into retaining experienced teachers either.

It’s a massive and costly drain on the system to constantly be throwing money at training teachers, which is effectively pouring water into an extremely leaky bucket.

Gardenlass · 08/10/2021 16:32

And yes, parental support and involvement makes a huge difference. Arguably, this is why private schools do so well, rather than the actual spend per pupil. Some kids do not have the advantage of having engaged and supportive parents from birth, for a whole raft of reasons. I agree that it is very difficult to fully compensate for that disadvantage, but we should at least do what we can to improve their life chances. You sound like you think we should just give up on most of them, but I'm sure that's not what you actually mean?!
No, I'm not suggesting giving up on children. Merely pointing out that with the best will in the world, superb teaching, small class sizes etc, there will always be children who won't be able to take advantage of these opportunities. It depends on what level of attainment is being aimed for. For every child to be literate and numerate enough to function properly, yes, this is achievable. For every child to gain A levels, not achievable even with every opportunity. The whole system needs overhauling, to give each child the best chance of achieving what they are capable of.
For instance, when it is obvious that a child is not academic, schools should provide alternative programmes such as training in hairdressing, electrical engineering, plumbing, beauty, cookery, agriculture etc. This should be available from a younger age, instead of insisting that all children must have GCSE maths and English, before they can access suitable college courses.
And, AlexaShutUp I do agree with your comment on SEN children.
I also agree with ss1234.

Ibelieveinghosts · 08/10/2021 16:30

Education, like society is never going to be levelled up. Formal education rewards certain attributes, mainly being able to grasp concepts, apply them in a certain way and play the game/do the test at the end. The more natural intelligence (often inherited), better behaved and the more parental support you have the better you will generally do in this system. Typically these things are more common in higher earning families who will generally tend to live in certain areas and attend certain schools. A small amount of money gained from an ideologically motivated attack on one sector is not going to solve this.
To truly level up education we need to be addressing a lot of the priorities of wider society, ensure parents are better engaged inc providing support for parents who struggle to support their children.

Of course you are always going to get outliers but whilst society is unequal (which in a hierarchical based species like humans is inevitable) education will always remain unequal.

FrazzledY9Parent · 08/10/2021 16:30

"All human societies tend towards the creation and maintenance of an 'elite' and that has been observed over and over and over again, across history and geography."

This is actually not true, hunter-gatherer societies go to great lengths to avoid and hinder the emergence of elites. You may well be right about agricultural-industrial societies (i.e. where property plays a role), but I don't think it's human nature.

Sockwomble · 08/10/2021 16:26

"The assumption is that all children are equally intelligent and will benefit from a good education."

So which children don't deserve a good education? Why do they deserve a poor one?

Phineyj · 08/10/2021 16:24

I don't have any solutions but I just wanted to say that as an Economics teacher, I thought your analysis was very good Grin.

Elephantsparade · 08/10/2021 16:23

Nobody would vote to increase spending by that much. The reality is for a huge section of society state education is 'good enough'. If i only had my eldest child and didnt work in a school, my opinion would be that the education he had has been good and he has thrived so why spend more? My work though shows me how precarious it all is

My other son has SEN and its a system in crisis so I actually do think a pot that equated £100 a head but targeted at specific groups such as SEN or PP would make a huge difference. Eg the school he went to that failed him as they didnt understand autism could have covered an extra floating TA and whole school training just from the £100 a head.

sst1234 · 08/10/2021 16:18

There will never be equality of education as long as feral children with feckless parents are disrupting the education of the majority who want to learn. The problem in any school is not the teachers or the curriculum, it’s the wasted resources on controlling poor behaviour and discipline. There is thread after thread on this very forum about this issue.

AlexaShutUp · 08/10/2021 16:15

Absolutely @Kite22

Kite22 · 08/10/2021 16:13

If I had millions more ££ to spend on Education though, I wouldn't spend if "per head". I would spend it to provide services for the children that just can't access appropriate education.

There are nowhere near enough special school places in our LA for the children with massively significant needs, whose parents want that provision. These dc end up out of school, or shoved into mainstream classes who are not equipped to cope. Then of course, the children in mainstream school who could cope with additional support, get nowhere near enough support. Then there is lack of mental health support, lack of services such as Speech and language or occupational therapy, lack of behavioural support, pastoral support, family support, and social care, which means so many thousands of teacher hours get sucked in to all those roles and that not only impacts on teachers leaving the profession, but it means there are far fewer teacher hours available to the pupils who want to learn and who are able to come to school ready to learn.
Even if you are mistakenly thinking that it is quite a small number of children who need lots of additional support, the time being spent by all school staff dealing with those who struggle to access mainstream provision, really impacts on all school pupils.

workwoes123 · 08/10/2021 16:13

Q1. Do you mean equality of outcome or equality of provision or equality of opportunity?

  1. No, I don't think 'we' do actually want equality. All human societies tend towards the creation and maintenance of an 'elite' and that has been observed over and over and over again, across history and geography. If private schools are reduced or removed from the system in the UK, the 'elite' will find other ways to recreate itself, and those currently outside the elite will continue to aspire to join it. Thats human nature.
Swipe left for the next trending thread