Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is equality in education actually achievable? and is it what we want?

110 replies

SinoohXaenaHide · 08/10/2021 14:52

So, market forces and political currents over many decades seem to have fixed the amount that the taxpayer is willing to pay per year per child in state education as around £7k per year (£7,100 to be precise according to this article)

And in a well-run school with willing and able pupils, that amount of money is enough to provide a fairly decent quality of education. Obviously with more money a school could do more, but that would cost more tax, and this seems to be the level of balance between tax and education quality that we corporately as a population will accept.

In the UK the distribution of individual income means that about 20% of individual earners have more than twice the median disposable income. It's not at all surprising that some more well-off families wish to purchase a different education than that which is provided by taxpayers. About 7% of children are educated privately. In a free society the freedom to choose to educate ones children outside the state system is important and I don't think anyone is saying that it should be illegal to spend ones spare income on education if one chooses, only that this shouldn't be subsidised by the tax payer.

The above linked article says that Labour will abolish the tax advantages of private schools and use the money to fund state schools. We've had thousands of threads which go over and over how the practicalities of achieving that would be complicated (it would require a rebuilding of charity law from the ground up. Let's not get into that again though) but setting that aside, you are only talking about creaming an extra 20% of what is spent on 7% of pupils - although the rocketing of school fees might drop that to only 6% as a lot of self-funders can only just afford the fees as it is - and then you spread that among the 94% of pupils in state education. I've done the maths and that works out as less than £100 extra per pupil per year in state education - that's not going to make much difference.

To actually level up state education to the kind of quality that would begin to make private education obsolete because so many fewer feel the need to opt out of it, would take an injection of income into schools of more like £3,000 per year per pupil. That would be what was needed to get class sizes and facilities to a level that is more similar to the private sector. That would require about £30 billion pounds more per year into the education budget - there are about 30 million tax payers in the UK so that would require each tax payer to pay about £1000 per year more tax. Or if you made it progressive, that would be an extra £625 per tax payer for basic rate, £1,875 per year (3 times as much as basic rate payers) for those who pay at the higher rate and £5,625 per year (9 times as much as basic rate payers) for those who pay at the highest rate. This would raise the required £30 billion per year.

For comparison, the changes to National Insurance coming in next year to fund social care are expected to raise £12 billion - barely a third of that. So the kind of tax rise required is phenomenal.

Do we as a population want to see the kinds of tax rises that would be needed to actually level up our childrens education? Could a political party ever be voted in on a policy of tax rises of that magnitude in exchange for creating a state education sector that is good enough to make private schools obsolete?

Is equality in education actually achievable? and is it what we want?
OP posts:
flippertyop · 08/10/2021 18:15

And thinking about it I am investing in my son because I think it will get him to average grades which means he will do OK in life. If I thought he was not capable of doing more than a menial type role I wouldn't be spending it. That would not be a good investment because he could do that without the extra money being spent

AlexaShutUp · 08/10/2021 18:14

So yes I am doing exactly the opposite of what I would advise are as a tax payer but that is because that he is my child and I have an emotional attachment.

I find this very interesting. As a taxpayer, I guess I want to create a society in which every child has the kind of opportunities that I would strive to give my own dc. And I do feel quite emotional about the fact that some kids don't get those opportunities.

I cannot look at it in a cold, detached way that calculates return on investment. These are actual, real children who we're talking about. Why shouldn't we, as a society, do for them what we would do so willingly for our own kids?

flippertyop · 08/10/2021 18:12

@AlexaShutUp and I know someone in the first situation who now earns loads of money and has bought their siblings houses and given them experiences they never could have had if that time wasn't invested. I guess we just have different views on things but that's what makes the world go round

AlexaShutUp · 08/10/2021 18:08

[quote flippertyop]@alexashutup So if you had a child who was average in a hook and one who was a talented footballer you wouldn't spend more time/money on the one with the talent? You would rather the one that potentially could be a premier league footballer lost out because you can't afford to spend the same amount of time or money (which is I necessary as they don't have a particular talent) on the other one? I find that strange but interesting. Another feiend of mine has a similar dilemma when one of her kids was offered a scholarship at a really food private school but her other son wasn't good a sport so she knew he wouldn't get a scholarship and they couldn't afford to go private. As a result they are spending more on the older one because private school just costs more but they wanted him to have that opportunity not just say no because they can't do the same for the other child. Not trying to be goady I guess I just have a different opinion to you [/quote]
No, I wouldn't invest heavily in one child to the detriment of another.

My friend did do this, actually. Her dd was an elite athlete, competing at national/International level. My friend poured everything into supporting this child and she did extremely well. Meanwhile, the younger kid - who had plenty of talents of her own - went completely off the rails because she resented the excessive focus on her older sister. A couple of years ago, the older sister decided to stop competing because the pressure was impacting on her mental health. The relationship between siblings and between the mum and youngest daughter remains very fraught. How could it not be? She always felt second best.

Re the private school scenario that you mention, if it was only a partial scholarship, I wouldn't feel obliged to make up the difference unless I was able to put a comparable sum by for the other dc in order to support them in whatever way they might need.

flippertyop · 08/10/2021 18:08

@AlexaShutUp as a mother yes as a tax payer I would prefer my money was spent where it's going to get the best return and that is on children that can excel. Those who are more practical can train on the job in many instances and don't need that support in academia. If I had 1k as a tax payer I would wish to spend it on the child who will achieve the most with it - by that I mean will be of the biggest benefit of society as a whole. So yes I am doing exactly the opposite of what I would advise are as a tax payer but that is because that he is my child and I have an emotional attachment. If a child had dyslexia but with help could be a lawyer would I invest more in them than anyone else? Yes. but if they were only going to ever do an unskilled job should they get the same investment? No. It's not black and white

Soontobe60 · 08/10/2021 18:02

@AlexaShutUp

So *@flippertyop*, you are actually doing the opposite for your own family than you are recommending we should do as a country? That's interesting.

Personally, I go by the same principles. The ones with the greatest need probably need the most resources. We don't need to spend more money amplifying the advantages that the most able kids already enjoy. We need to invest more to help the kids without those advantages to overcome the obstacles that they might face.

I don't think that's an emotional argument. It's a perfectly rational one about the kind of society that we wish to create.

Absolutely!
flippertyop · 08/10/2021 18:01

*at school not in a hook

Soontobe60 · 08/10/2021 18:01

You’re assuming that the so called ‘levelling up’ of education will improve outcomes for all pupils, when in fact there are far more powerful factors at play that influence pupil outcomes. These factors include (but are not limited to)

  1. Lack of Early years support - via health visitors, Sure Start, nurseries.
  2. Increasing levels of Poverty.
  3. Mental health of parents

Unless these are addressed, putting more money into actual schools will be like putting a plaster over a broken leg.

AlexaShutUp · 08/10/2021 18:01

So @flippertyop, you are actually doing the opposite for your own family than you are recommending we should do as a country? That's interesting.

Personally, I go by the same principles. The ones with the greatest need probably need the most resources. We don't need to spend more money amplifying the advantages that the most able kids already enjoy. We need to invest more to help the kids without those advantages to overcome the obstacles that they might face.

I don't think that's an emotional argument. It's a perfectly rational one about the kind of society that we wish to create.

flippertyop · 08/10/2021 18:01

@alexashutup So if you had a child who was average in a hook and one who was a talented footballer you wouldn't spend more time/money on the one with the talent? You would rather the one that potentially could be a premier league footballer lost out because you can't afford to spend the same amount of time or money (which is I necessary as they don't have a particular talent) on the other one? I find that strange but interesting. Another feiend of mine has a similar dilemma when one of her kids was offered a scholarship at a really food private school but her other son wasn't good a sport so she knew he wouldn't get a scholarship and they couldn't afford to go private. As a result they are spending more on the older one because private school just costs more but they wanted him to have that opportunity not just say no because they can't do the same for the other child. Not trying to be goady I guess I just have a different opinion to you

AlexaShutUp · 08/10/2021 17:55

[quote flippertyop]@AlexaShutUp but within limited means you would decide where it was best to spend that money you wouldn't necessarily spend the same on both. I have a friend who has remortgaged her house so her middle child can go to dance school because she's very talented. She hasn't remortgaged her house for the others just so it's fair. [/quote]
If I had two children, I would aim to invest in them equally. The only time I could conceive of investing more in one than another would be if one had significant additional needs that might mean they needed more support to live a fairly ordinary life.

I certainly wouldn't invest more in one just because they were cleverer or more talented. I have seen that scenario play out in some families and it never ends well in my view. Bound to lead to resentment and allegations of favouritism.

Luckily, I only have one child. Grin

flippertyop · 08/10/2021 17:53

I spend more on my child with SEN because I think he needs it to catch up but that's an emotional decision made with my money. It's different when you are asking someone with no emotional attachment to make the investment. No emotions involved you would do what's best for the whole not the individual

randomsabreuse · 08/10/2021 17:53

The vast majority of private schools do not confer the networking advantages suggested. Of those open to girls I'd say it would be the co ed schools like St Paul's or those closely linked with big old boys' schools.

I'm privately educated, my school made doctors mostly, the odd lawyer/management consultant but no one who would be able to network my kids into super well paid jobs.

Yes my kids will get the privilege of having an educated mother with a posh (English) accent - less useful now we're in Scotland. DH is similar, professional parents, middle ranked private school, now a vet...

Our kids won't be going private, couldn't get close to affording at and can add much better quality extra curricular activities with a wider range of peers than any in school clubs could have offered.

It would advantage all children if the children with additional educational needs could be fully supported in a way that is most appropriate for them - my private school (and various people from grammar and private schools I met through sport) was good at supporting pupils with dyslexia - and a decent number now have PhDs. I suspect a number of girls with high functioning autism find it much easier to cope/mask in private schools as well...

flippertyop · 08/10/2021 17:50

@AlexaShutUp but within limited means you would decide where it was best to spend that money you wouldn't necessarily spend the same on both. I have a friend who has remortgaged her house so her middle child can go to dance school because she's very talented. She hasn't remortgaged her house for the others just so it's fair.

Invasionofthegutsnatchers · 08/10/2021 17:46

OP do you work in a school?

AlexaShutUp · 08/10/2021 17:46

[quote flippertyop]@AlexaShutUp I disagree. This is tax payers money it's never going to be limitless and it should be used in the best way. When you have a limited budget you choose to spend it to maximise its return. We do this as parents - we find an academic kid through Uni or take a kid that's good at drama to stage school. [/quote]
But that's the point, isn't it?

As parents, we wouldn't just say, well, the older one isn't very smart so we'll invest everything we have in the younger one because we'll get a greater return on that? We would surely try to invest in such a way that enables each child to fulfil their unique potential. Whatever that might look like.

And yes, of course we have to spend public money in the best possible way. We just disagree about what's best.

My own dd is at the very top of the ability range. She is doing fine as it is, and I'm not convinced that she needs more resources thrown at her. I am much more concerned about the needs of the kids who are struggling in the current system. Those are the kids who we need to invest in so that they don't get stuck in a negative cycle.

flippertyop · 08/10/2021 17:45

@SarahAndQuack intelligence is innate although certainly you can improve or under utilise your natural abilities. There is no doubt though that intelligence is varied amongst the population. Personality is also a factor. Two children can have the same start in life and one is driven to a hieve and one is not. Luckily we are not all the same and we don't all want the same things or there would be an issue

Choccyp1g · 08/10/2021 17:42

@Elephantsparade

Nobody would vote to increase spending by that much. The reality is for a huge section of society state education is 'good enough'. If i only had my eldest child and didnt work in a school, my opinion would be that the education he had has been good and he has thrived so why spend more? My work though shows me how precarious it all is

My other son has SEN and its a system in crisis so I actually do think a pot that equated £100 a head but targeted at specific groups such as SEN or PP would make a huge difference. Eg the school he went to that failed him as they didnt understand autism could have covered an extra floating TA and whole school training just from the £100 a head.

My first thought was surely the 7% of people who currently pay a fortune in school fees would vote to get the same quality of education for only £1000 extra tax. But then I realised they wouldn't because they want BETTER education than everyone else in order to give their children an advantage.
AlexaShutUp · 08/10/2021 17:40

@Gardenlass

I agree with this, but I don't think it means that we shouldn't try to make it as equal as possible. I suppose that's what Boris is talking about with his 'levelling up' mantra. In terms of transport, job creation, housing etc he can try. With education, I'm not sure. I think there are too many extraneous factors to ever achieve equality.
I agree, some kids will always have the advantage. We can never make it perfect. But we can do better than we're doing right now. And we owe it to those kids to try.
Cherryana · 08/10/2021 17:40

Some of the replies on this thread have been some of the best I have ever read on Mumsnet about education.

Actually, I thought Labour did a good job for a government (about 15 years ago). There was the 'building schools for the future' which rebuilt some really grotty schools in my area. Plus there was all the investment in 'Surestart centres'. A pronged 'attack' on social mobility that really did connect with parents and offer support from infancy.

I also think the Warnock review and its impact on SEN education and inclusion was great in theory and poor in practise and does not serve many well. It formed the basis for shutting down special schools.

To create a climate for equality of opportunity I would:

  • Create more specialist provisions so some pupils had a more tailored education in a less sensory stimulating environment.
- Focus on working conditions for mainstream teachers with less face to face contact so that planning and marking to be done in the working day. (This would mean there would need to be an increase in teachers).
  • Fund services and support eg Speech and Language, Ed Psych, Mental Health
  • Re-open Surestart in communities to support vulnerable families and children from infancy.
SarahAndQuack · 08/10/2021 17:39

Anyway, sorry, that was a rant, but, OP, I am sceptical about this:

So, market forces and political currents over many decades seem to have fixed the amount that the taxpayer is willing to pay per year per child in state education as around £7k per year (£7,100 to be precise according to this article).

That makes it sound as if this number is fixed. But you give no good reason to believe it really is. We have no clue what taxpayers are willing to pay - all we know is guesstimates. I think this claim is really just passing the buck, from governments who have a fair amount of freedom in assigning budget priorities, to individual tax payers. It's a way of saying 'oh look, we have educational inequality - well, it can't be the government's fault, it must be us meanies who won't pay more tax'.

SarahAndQuack · 08/10/2021 17:36

@Gardenlass

The assumption is that all children are equally intelligent and will benefit from a good education. Sadly that is not the case. If a child has SEN, then their education needs to be tailored to their needs, and mainstream school is not the best place to do this. Even allowing for no special needs, much success in education involves factors other than the school setting. Parental support and involvement is the main one. If parents are unable or unwilling to offer support, then only an extremely bright child will succeed, and most will leave school without the necessary qualifications for further education.
Why on earth would you think a 'good education' couldn't cater to a child with SEN?

Thousands of children have SEN and can do well in mainstream schools. I have SEN and I excelled at school. I've a friend whose child has Down's Syndrome, and she has also done extremely well in a mainstream school.

Having taught at very good universities for nearly a decade, I can tell you that being intelligent is not as important as you might think, and 'intelligence' is something that happens in tandem with good teaching - it is not innate.

flippertyop · 08/10/2021 17:34

@AlexaShutUp I disagree. This is tax payers money it's never going to be limitless and it should be used in the best way. When you have a limited budget you choose to spend it to maximise its return. We do this as parents - we find an academic kid through Uni or take a kid that's good at drama to stage school.

TreaslakeandBack · 08/10/2021 17:33

No thanks. I have one child. I would rather pay my taxes to contribute to state education and then spend 10-15k of my own money per year on education for my child. Once he’s educated that’s done with and I can spend my money where I like.

Gardenlass · 08/10/2021 17:29

I agree with this, but I don't think it means that we shouldn't try to make it as equal as possible.
I suppose that's what Boris is talking about with his 'levelling up' mantra. In terms of transport, job creation, housing etc he can try. With education, I'm not sure. I think there are too many extraneous factors to ever achieve equality.

Swipe left for the next trending thread