Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is equality in education actually achievable? and is it what we want?

110 replies

SinoohXaenaHide · 08/10/2021 14:52

So, market forces and political currents over many decades seem to have fixed the amount that the taxpayer is willing to pay per year per child in state education as around £7k per year (£7,100 to be precise according to this article)

And in a well-run school with willing and able pupils, that amount of money is enough to provide a fairly decent quality of education. Obviously with more money a school could do more, but that would cost more tax, and this seems to be the level of balance between tax and education quality that we corporately as a population will accept.

In the UK the distribution of individual income means that about 20% of individual earners have more than twice the median disposable income. It's not at all surprising that some more well-off families wish to purchase a different education than that which is provided by taxpayers. About 7% of children are educated privately. In a free society the freedom to choose to educate ones children outside the state system is important and I don't think anyone is saying that it should be illegal to spend ones spare income on education if one chooses, only that this shouldn't be subsidised by the tax payer.

The above linked article says that Labour will abolish the tax advantages of private schools and use the money to fund state schools. We've had thousands of threads which go over and over how the practicalities of achieving that would be complicated (it would require a rebuilding of charity law from the ground up. Let's not get into that again though) but setting that aside, you are only talking about creaming an extra 20% of what is spent on 7% of pupils - although the rocketing of school fees might drop that to only 6% as a lot of self-funders can only just afford the fees as it is - and then you spread that among the 94% of pupils in state education. I've done the maths and that works out as less than £100 extra per pupil per year in state education - that's not going to make much difference.

To actually level up state education to the kind of quality that would begin to make private education obsolete because so many fewer feel the need to opt out of it, would take an injection of income into schools of more like £3,000 per year per pupil. That would be what was needed to get class sizes and facilities to a level that is more similar to the private sector. That would require about £30 billion pounds more per year into the education budget - there are about 30 million tax payers in the UK so that would require each tax payer to pay about £1000 per year more tax. Or if you made it progressive, that would be an extra £625 per tax payer for basic rate, £1,875 per year (3 times as much as basic rate payers) for those who pay at the higher rate and £5,625 per year (9 times as much as basic rate payers) for those who pay at the highest rate. This would raise the required £30 billion per year.

For comparison, the changes to National Insurance coming in next year to fund social care are expected to raise £12 billion - barely a third of that. So the kind of tax rise required is phenomenal.

Do we as a population want to see the kinds of tax rises that would be needed to actually level up our childrens education? Could a political party ever be voted in on a policy of tax rises of that magnitude in exchange for creating a state education sector that is good enough to make private schools obsolete?

Is equality in education actually achievable? and is it what we want?
OP posts:
MarshaBradyo · 08/10/2021 20:08

Now Labour want me to pay even more so they can grab a few class-war type headlines.

Completely agree with this and rest. They’ve annoyed me with it and it’s a vote changer.

Xenia · 08/10/2021 20:05

Well said Sky. Perhaps let all parents opt out of state schools and get a £7000 a year voucher per child which they can use at private schools. For those which cost £10k a year outside the SE that would mean a parent would "only" need £3k a year (more in the SE) and cold mean more children access the better education the private sector provides.

fournonblondes · 08/10/2021 20:03

@ all Skysblue yes, same situation for us. It is outrageous!

Phineyj · 08/10/2021 20:01

The teacher training system is certainly not fit for purpose but it's not as straightforward as "private schools/individual teachers are leeching off the state funded system", as some posters like to argue. Private schools host placements for state teachers and vice versa and this is particularly important in subjects like music where the state provision is dying off due to neglect. Also the govt ignores training for non National Curriculum subjects even when tens of thousands of students take them. There isn't necessarily a great match between teachers trained and jobs available (another downside of a system that is both overly centralised and overly fragmented, which lurches from surplus to shortage) and the onus now is on teachers to train on the job and even to get loans to do so. My (state) school did pay to train me but I also had sole responsibility for my subject. It was a pretty cheap deal for them!

I actually did leave the state sector because of large class sizes - not because of the classes but because of the intolerable amount of marking. I was getting up at 5am on a Sunday and creeping out of bed in the hope of doing an hour's marking before my DH and baby woke up. Miserable.

If I were trying to fix the school system I would start with SEN support. The private schools round here are overflowing with SEN DC at secondary level, and there's a reason for that! If their parents thought the needs could be met in state, surely that's what most would do.

Skysblue · 08/10/2021 19:58

I’ve been thinking about this a lot lately, because I was going to vote Labour (despise BJ and his pack!) but now can’t. We moved to private education because the State system badly let down DD and we had limited options in our area. We don’t actually want to be paying £20k/yr on private ed. We don’t have a big house, our car is ten years old, we’ve holidayed abroad twice in last 8 years. Now Labour want me to pay even more so they can grab a few class-war type headlines. It won’t raise the quality of State education and they know that. The only thing that would make a serious difference to that is investing in class sizes of max 20 children, not 32/class. More teachers, more classrooms, more equipment. Punishing those who have fled the system for whatever reason doesn’t help.

Also, it seems to me that the people attacking the private system are often people who aren’t paying much towards the State system and think it’s somehow free. In addition to the £20k/ yr we’re spending on DD’s education, we also pay more than £100k in income tax every year, to fund services we rarely use. Sure we use the bin lorry and the street lighting but I’m not sure it’s worth £100k+

We’ve paid at least twice already for education, for DD privately and also for many others’ children in State system.

BasiliskStare · 08/10/2021 19:45

I think the main point is what is the minimum standard of education we want for our children and what does it cost ( let me put special needs , SEN aside for one moment because I think that is a discussion in itself)

Ds went to Oxford - loads of state school peers / friends - so something is working . ( I use this merely as an example )

I am not sure that it is realistic to make state schools give all the things that private schools can. What is realistic it would seem to me ( teachers leaving state sector clearly a factor ) is the standard of teaching and for want of a better word mentoring / encouragement is the same. In whatever sphere the DC wants to end up.

I went to a private school - I have looked at it now - I would not pay thruppence to send a child there - indeed I would not have paid it when I went there.

AlexaShutUp · 08/10/2021 19:36

Maybe some extra funding to provide some cultural exposure but unless they show a talent it’s a waste to fund it for several years.

Is that how you view it for your own dc?

If my dd enjoyed an activity and found enrichment in it, I would happily continue to pay for it, regardless of whether she had any talent. In my experience, that's what most middle class parents do for their kids. Are we saying that poorer kids only deserve such enrichment if they are talented enough to earn it?

Again, I guess it comes back to a question of values and the kind of society we aspire to create.

KeyboardWorriers · 08/10/2021 19:32

If private schools wish to retain their charitable status then I would like to see them really work for it.
My first career was as a researcher in charity law and I do think that we should welcome legislative changes that push private schools to do far more to provide a genuine public benefit (above and beyond educating the 7%). I agree that stripping them of the status has a whole pile of complex consequences, but they can and should be pushed to do more to open up their benefit to others.

astoundedgoat · 08/10/2021 19:32

I’d much rather pay the tax! We’re immigrants and I’m shocked at how poor the education is here and yet how people defend it. Poor kids are just left to fend for themselves, never mind kids with SEN.

We have gone private because I don’t think state is good enough. I’m not seeking an advantage, I’m seeking quality. It would be infinitely preferable if the local state school could provide that for all children in my town for a bit of a tax increase, to paying a bewildering sum of money to a private school.

Quite a high number of kids with mild SEN are forced to go private if they can afford it too, because their local state can’t support them, I’ve noticed, which should be a point of mortification for the government, and yet… 🤷🏻‍♀️

TractorAndHeadphones · 08/10/2021 19:31

Also to add we’re talking about a world with education as a thing to fund by itself.
In an ideal world we would build a society with economic help etc (much like Scandanavuan countries) with engaged parents which would solve a large amount of these issues in one go.

TractorAndHeadphones · 08/10/2021 19:30

2 things

  1. Even with the best teachers in the world it’ll be impossible for equal education to be achieved in isolation as a stable home life is a major determinant.
  2. It will be very expensive to let kids ‘try’ a range of extracurriculars the way private schools do. Even for parents earning a decent amount activities are expensive.

Education (like healthcare) will never scale. It’s individual.

I’d happily support things like special schools and smaller class sizes but to bring state schools up to the level of private is a waste of money (of course depending on the type of private!). Maybe some extra funding to provide some cultural exposure but unless they show a talent it’s a waste to fund it for several years.

bettyboodecia · 08/10/2021 19:25

Good post. I'm a higher rate tax payer and happy to pay £5,625 extra pa - cheaper than the £40,000 pa we'll pay for our kids because the local comp's shit.

Sockwomble · 08/10/2021 18:58

"but should the tax payer foot a large bill for someone who isn't going to deliver much back into society"

So in practice how does that work.
Children with severe sen usually have higher funding. Would you reduce that funding to less than the average child gets? How does that work? Children with severe learning difficulties in classes of 50 with one teacher?

SinoohXaenaHide · 08/10/2021 18:52

Catching up reading through the replies so far.

Good point made by a few that the additional money for the state sector wouldn't be just spent at a level £100 per head and would probably make a significant impact for those who are being failed the most egregiously by the current system. So yes that's good. The other side of that coin is that a very large number of pupils whose current education is at the "ok/acceptable" level would see pretty much no benefit.

Also I really appreciated the point about the leaky bucket of pouring resources into training teachers who then don't stay in the state sector. I definitely agree that something should change there - but if teacher training involved signing a contract to pay back the costs of training if you don't then work in the sector for X years, wouldn't that cause some even more serious barriers to getting people to sign up? I couldn't be a teacher myself I know I don't have the skills, but if I ever considered it then I know a contract like that would be massively offputting. Better to make the conditions for teachers at state school more attractive so that they actively want to stay because they enjoy their work and feel supported and appreciated, rather than trying to handcuff them into a job they can't wait to leave but have to serve their indentured time.

I disagree with the idea that it's right to invest more money in the more able. If anything, the more able should be easier and cheaper to teach. Those who are less likely to get academic qualifications need significant attention and resources to get their basic skills to a reasonable enough level that they can be employable in a range of possible careers, and should yes also have access to good quality vocational qualifications. Every child of whatever attainment level deserves the opportunity to reach their full potential and be celebrated for that - and never made to feel that if their full potential is greatest on an axis other than academic prowess then that is somehow inferior.

I know I haven't addressed all the points above. Will keep reading and considering the further points made...

OP posts:
Dixiechickonhols · 08/10/2021 18:40

DD went to a private primary. Fees were £5,500 a year. They are currently £7038 a year so same cost as state in Op’s post. This is a year not a term - deprived northern town before people say no private is that cheap. Included a longer school day as standard (no wrap around care costs) and 2 weeks extra holidays - by going away then we saved a lot.
It was noticeably more old fashioned than local primaries - functional but definitely had whiff of bygone era. Facilities weren’t fancy some parents painted the gym, lots of donated items, old equipment.
Small classes my DD’s was largest at 15 pupils.
Very much emphasis on basics in terms of education - reading, maths, grammar. Speech was corrected. They didn’t have all the dress up days and projects etc like other primary schools.
Behaviour standards were very high they stood out positively at events with other schools.
There were pupils with additional needs - my dd has a physical disability. It was ideal for children who needed a bit of extra help but not enough to qualify for sufficient support in state.
Emphasis on public speaking - things like English speaking board, poetry vanguard.
11 plus prep done as part of school day.
Obviously all parents were invested in education and co operative.
It was a very positive experience for my DD and set her up well for secondary (she’s now at a state grammar)

BasiliskStare · 08/10/2021 18:33

@randomsabreuse "The vast majority of private schools do not confer the networking advantages suggested"

I do agree with this - I think it is a myth. Pay for school for many reasons if you will , but being part of an old boy's or old girl's network is ( these days ) a pretty rubbish reason - More likely that Uncle Bill can put a word in to his mate who knows someone to get you an interview ( in any sphere of work. )

AlexaShutUp · 08/10/2021 18:28

@StarCat2020

I suppose that's what Boris is talking about with his 'levelling up' mantra Sorry but I don't think that "levelling up" is anything more than a slogan with no real substance.
Agreed. I doubt that Boris has any tangible idea of what it is supposed to mean.

It's a bit like "building back better"

Nobody disagrees with the slogans but let's have a strategy to back them up.

noblegiraffe · 08/10/2021 18:25

I have since found other CS NQTs like myself (with a CS degree) with similar issues and unable to get a teaching role.

We've been totally unable to recruit a CS teacher for the last few months and have had issues with recruitment for years. Very surprised to hear of CS teachers unable to get a job!

StarCat2020 · 08/10/2021 18:24

I suppose that's what Boris is talking about with his 'levelling up' mantra
Sorry but I don't think that "levelling up" is anything more than a slogan with no real substance.

londonmummy1966 · 08/10/2021 18:21

I found your analysis very helpful but I'm not sure a per child allowance is the right way. Some schools have good facilities and some don't and that is the case in both the state and the private sector. Some teachers can teach and inspire in the most dire of circumstances and some will never be able to do that no matter how elaborate the facilities. The vast majority do a good job in trying times. I agree with a PP that we also need to do more to make teaching an attractive option - experienced teachers ought to earn the same as GPs and have similar hours imo.

Often where private schools score is not so much the facilities and class sizes as much as the intangible extras - being able to weed out the children with behavioural issues who should often be in special schools more suited to their needs but the LA doesn't want to fund so keeps them in mainstream disrupting the education of 30+ children instead. They are able to offer more in terms of extra curricular often by buying in support etc.

£100 a head doesn't go far in terms of a facilities budget but might well be enough to bring in a music specialist once a week to run choirs and instrumental groups/bring in someone to coach debating/acting/ceative writing regularly, introduce a different sport or two etc etc - all things that private schools I know do.

MarshaBradyo · 08/10/2021 18:20

I've done the maths and that works out as less than £100 extra per pupil per year in state education - that's not going to make much difference.

Haven’t rtft but bravo on doing the maths. This has been my point too.

AlexaShutUp · 08/10/2021 18:19

The mind boggles @Elephantsparade.

Some kids will be relegated to the shelf stacking cohort, whereas others will be placed on the doctor track. I too would love to know how and when this selection will be made.

StarCat2020 · 08/10/2021 18:18

The govt currently wastes huge amounts of money training new teachers who either go straight to the private sector (no requirement to teach in a state school), quit teaching before they start, or leave within the first few years
It also works the other way.

I completed teacher training in Computer Science in 2019 and I desperately tried to find a teaching job after the course.

Contrary to Government hype, many schools computing education is being ignored today.

During my training I often encountered schools where computing equipment was so old that it had a major impact on whatr could be taught in class.

Another aspect was the fact that in many schools the existing CS teachers did not have any computing qualifications themselves.

I have seen A-Level CS taught by someone who was teaching themselves the syllabus a couple of weekas ahead of the students.

I have since found other CS NQTs like myself (with a CS degree) with similar issues and unable to get a teaching role.

Elephantsparade · 08/10/2021 18:17

Im mesmerised by this. How early in the state education process do we decide to heavily invest in the naturally intelligent and invest less in our future low skilled job people. Do we decide when they do their base line assessments aged 4/5 or their SATs in year 6. Why would giving an 'intellogent' child a suitable education cost so much more than giving a 'i can function in society' education to someone else.

AlexaShutUp · 08/10/2021 18:16

We clearly have very different values @flippertyop.

Swipe left for the next trending thread