Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Naked toddler in swimming pool showers

338 replies

Noodella18 · 08/10/2021 14:35

I take my 2 year old swimming on Fridays. After the session we take a shower in the communal showers, next to the lockers and by the entrance to the pool. I didn't think twice about stripping off her swimming costume to wash her but the lifeguard told me today that she wasn't allowed to be nude 'because it's a public area' and she had to keep it on. Am I being naive in thinking that a naked two year old is really no big deal?

Yanbu - no harm in a naked 2 year old
Yabu - keep the cossie on

OP posts:
Skyla2005 · 10/10/2021 13:16

Blossomtoes thats is disgusting. So you would be ok with your child being used by paedophiles if you didn't know about it. Disgraceful

peboh · 10/10/2021 13:15

@Blossomtoes surely just the idea of someone taking pictures of your child for their own pleasure is bad enough? Whilst your child may never know, I personally could never in good conscience be okay with making choices for my child that could lead to that.

Skyla2005 · 10/10/2021 13:12

@notacooldad

*Babies/toddlers young children should not be nude in public even if it is at a swimming pool shower.(

What?! Even on the beach?!
Especially on a beach!

Yes especially on a beach. How can people be so naive? I find it really shocking how many replies on here do not understand basic safeguarding of their children. Perverts go to the places hoping to see children of stupid parents who think it's ok to let them run around naked. Wake up
Blossomtoes · 10/10/2021 13:10

@Pythonista

The issue is photographs not necessarily assault. A pervert could take a photo in seconds, you won't know. And the image could be shared amongst his fellow paedos.
And how would that damage your child? Neither they nor you would ever know. Not that I believe this would happen anywhere except some paranoid parents’ fevered imaginations anyway.
peboh · 10/10/2021 13:07

Hasn't this always been a rule at swimming pools? I don't ever remember a time when we were showered in our costumes. We always had a proper bath when we got home after to ensure fully clean.

Eleganz · 10/10/2021 13:00

I personally wouldn't care with a child that young, but there are changing rooms for a reason. The communal showers at the poolside are really for showing off quickly before entering the pool (although no-one seems to use then for that!).

When my kids were that young I'd quickly hose them off (to wash off the chlorine) in the communal showers before drying and changing them in the changing rooms. They were still getting regular baths at that age.

Skyla2005 · 10/10/2021 12:56

@Snoken

I mesn, at some point the costume will come off. Nobody travels home in a wet costume. It’s completely bonkers not to allow a two year old to shower (in order to get clean!), without clothes. I shower naked too if I have been in a pool. What’s the point otherwise?
What. You shower in full view of the public ?
Skyla2005 · 10/10/2021 12:54

No baby or toddler should be naked anywhere in public full stop. Stupid to think that is ok. There are perverts out there. Why take that chance

Pythonista · 10/10/2021 12:53

The issue is photographs not necessarily assault. A pervert could take a photo in seconds, you won't know. And the image could be shared amongst his fellow paedos.

Lockdownbear · 10/10/2021 12:52

When a mother at your kids nursery got a prison sentence for sharing photos of her kid it kind of opens your eyes.

But bottom line in there is no need for children of any age to be naked in a public place.

Pythonista · 10/10/2021 12:50

I don't think anyone has mentioned kidnapping.

As an adult you can make a decision as to how much of your body you want to expose.

A child doesn't have a choice . But if you really think someone taking a photo from a distance (given the quality of cameras on phones these days) isn't a problem then crack on

Blossomtoes · 10/10/2021 12:49

@rrhuth

There are a tonne of potential hazards, all of which are much more common and obvious than a pervert. These include drowning, getting lost, and slipping on wet surfaces.

I think your statistics are wrong, I think it would more likely that a child were being observed by someone undesirable than that they would have a serious near-drowning incident.

The number of drowning deaths and near misses must be smaller than the number of sexual assaults on minors?

Unless someone can find some official statistics we won’t know. But my money’s on @Londonwriter being right on this one. It must be exhausting and depressing living life as if your child is surrounded by paedophiles round every corner.
Lockdownbear · 10/10/2021 12:49

The point is the more they have access to the more they want. Reduce the availability of photos you reduce the risk to all kids.

Photos are not as innocent and harmless as you think they are.

rrhuth · 10/10/2021 12:38

There are a tonne of potential hazards, all of which are much more common and obvious than a pervert. These include drowning, getting lost, and slipping on wet surfaces.

I think your statistics are wrong, I think it would more likely that a child were being observed by someone undesirable than that they would have a serious near-drowning incident.

The number of drowning deaths and near misses must be smaller than the number of sexual assaults on minors?

Londonwriter · 10/10/2021 12:34

@Pythonista, @Lockdownbear I genuinely don’t understand the ‘threat model’ here.

If I go to the swimming pool with a toddler, I stay with them 100% of the time. There are a tonne of potential hazards, all of which are much more common and obvious than a pervert. These include drowning, getting lost, and slipping on wet surfaces.

As a result, the only thing a pervert can do is a) take a photo from a distance to share on websites, and b) masturbate discretely while looking at naked body parts. Both of these things, a pervert can also do if you’re a breastfeeding mum in a cafe. In both cases, the revealed sexual parts aren’t being flaunted sexually - but there’s the potential for a pervert to discretely take and share photos.

I just don’t understand why a pervert would try to kidnap a temporarily naked toddler accompanied 100% of the time by a parent in a public swimming pool. Why not kidnap an unaccompanied or lost toddler? Or a toddler who is already neglected/at risk of abuse?

Pythonista · 10/10/2021 10:46

@Londonwriter

YANBU. Some people are writing as if the problem with naked toddlers is naked toddlers, not perverts sharing pictures on the internet.

Once you make a rule that everyone has to avoid doing anything that could lead to a weirdo taking and sharing sexualised pictures on the internet, then you’re also stopping women uncovered breastfeeding in cafes, stooping while wearing tight shorts, etc…

I, personally, wouldn’t have a toddler naked in the changing area of a swimming pool because I’d be horrifically embarrassed if they peed or pooed themselves. However, I think a pre-pubescent child naked in a swimming pool shower should be a… meh, whatever… situation.

As a parent it's your job to protect your kid, you can't compare breastfeeding or bending over AS AN ADULT with leaving your child open to being photographed or leered at.
Lockdownbear · 10/10/2021 10:46

I see a huge difference between naked toddlers and breastfeeding.
Most women who are breastfeeding are discreet, and ones baby is on there's nothing to see. If a woman wants to flaunt herself that is her choice. She will also be more able to handle sexually motivated advances.

Toddlers have no discretion, nor are they able to reject sexual advances they need protection.

Londonwriter · 10/10/2021 10:27

YANBU. Some people are writing as if the problem with naked toddlers is naked toddlers, not perverts sharing pictures on the internet.

Once you make a rule that everyone has to avoid doing anything that could lead to a weirdo taking and sharing sexualised pictures on the internet, then you’re also stopping women uncovered breastfeeding in cafes, stooping while wearing tight shorts, etc…

I, personally, wouldn’t have a toddler naked in the changing area of a swimming pool because I’d be horrifically embarrassed if they peed or pooed themselves. However, I think a pre-pubescent child naked in a swimming pool shower should be a… meh, whatever… situation.

rainbowmash · 10/10/2021 09:20

It's an area available to the public, just like a ladies' changing room in a shop. Would you have nude children there? Why is it ok just because everyone is a bit soggy?

For the record, I cringe when grown women walk around naked in the changing rooms. There are booths for showers and changing. There are so many reasons and opportunities NOT to be naked, yet here you are. Always struck me as a bit of a performance...

I think nude children at the beach is even worse - not because I'm overthinking about strangers having inappropriate ideas - but because I find it scruffy and horribly undignified.

Lockdownbear · 10/10/2021 09:11

I can't even understand why people let toddlers be naked on the beach, surely it's easier to protect their skin with a sunsuit than sunscreen?

It's not just the photos that are taken and then passed around. The more photos and access these people get the more they want. The more likely they are too seek out children to physically abuse. It's all stepping stones.

Newmumatlast · 10/10/2021 01:25

Personally think you're being irresponsible having your child naked in a public area accessible by anyone. You don't know who they are. In a cubicle fine. Shared showers, why would you want to risk anyone inappropriate viewing your toddler? And yes on the beach too. Especially so as people can take photographs on the beach and you've no way of knowing who is and when. You have no control over any images. You'd have to be niave not to realise what people can be like and the risks they pose to children. Yes you shouldn't have to think that way but unfortunately to safeguard your child, you do

FlyingPandas · 10/10/2021 01:22

I think it’s entirely right that they have this policy - it’s about protecting the rights and privacy of the child. No parent should allow a toddler or baby to be naked in any public place and that includes a beach-they are so vulnerable as it is, why make them even more vulnerable?

Pythonista · 10/10/2021 01:09

Of course I can but the point being it has suited him to exploit his appearance on the album for years (because otherwise nobody would know who he was).

I didn't even know his private parts were on show on the album.

SleepOhHowIMissYou · 10/10/2021 00:57

@Pythonista did the man restaging the Nirvana cover album do it with his penis on display again or did he "choose" to keep his private parts private in the photoshoot? Not use of word "choose".

Do you see the difference?

Ellarain · 09/10/2021 16:19

@thebestnamesweregone, exactly, quick rinse and then proper wash at home.