Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To this this IS extra money

141 replies

WhatsAppening · 08/10/2021 07:42

DH has really confused me. Easily done tbf and it is early and I’m tired.

I get paid 4 weekly. We treat my wage as though it’s a monthly wage though, and all budgets are done accordingly.

This month I got paid on the 1st. So this morning I made an offhand comment about looking forward to us having an extra £1700 this month what with the extra payment.

DH first looked really puzzled and then went into great detail about why that’s not how it works. His logic was that the mortgage (same amount as my wage, coincidentally) comes out on the 1st then the first payment this month pays this month’s and then the payment on the 29th pays November’s so I’m ahead but it’s not spare money.

I KNOW he’s wrong, if we have 12 bills a year and 13 wages then it MUST be extra. But he’s confused me with his (wrong) logic.

I think because he’s focusing on one specific bill? And forgetting that we have lots of monthly bills and his monthly wage as well?

I need a simple explanation so I can convince him that we do indeed have a ‘free’ £1700 this month. It’s for his own good as it will make him happy, he’s all stressed this morning for other reasons.

OP posts:
LemonTT · 08/10/2021 10:11

You are talking about cash flow and he is talking about net income and expenditure. He will be accruing income and expenditure over the year into 12 periods. There may be cash in an account but it will already be committed and cannot be spent.

WhatsAppening · 08/10/2021 10:05

So on my spreadsheet I have my wage, DH wage, CB as income. But I state my wage as the figure I get in my payslip once a month.

I’ve purposely done that so we’d have this ‘bonus’ payment. I know my working out is correct.

I briefly mentioned it to DH when he brought me my morning coffee and he immediately said I’m sure that’s not how it works. He confused me. He’s a numbers guy so that confused me even more.

But he has now admitted he was thinking about it backwards, and in terms of being paid before/after the mortgage.

Anyway I’m in town now trying to spend it Grin not really but I’m looking for a nice dress to wear for dinner tonight and everything is FUGLY. So that’s pooped my mood.

OP posts:
Yerroblemom1923 · 08/10/2021 10:05

Your mortgage payment is quite high. Where do you live,?

Butterflyfluff · 08/10/2021 10:04

@Morph2lcfc

I’ve not read the whole thread so sorry if this has already been said. You need to think of the extra £1700 across the year rather than a an extra amount in one month . If you spend an extra £1700 this month you’d prob run out.
^ This

If you set aside 1/13 of your pay packet every month then this amount, across the year, is your ‘extra’ payment

Just because you get paid twice in 1 month doesn’t make that payment your ‘extra’ one - if you class that as extra money then there’s 8 weeks between your payment before and the one after and many bills will come out twice in that period

lottiegarbanzo · 08/10/2021 09:59

You get paid 13x a year but budget as if you were paid 12x a year. That's the source of your confusion.

To make sense of your wages, you'd need to do an annual budget, then divide by 12, to get a monthly figure. OR declare your 13th wage 'Christmas money', or holiday budget etc. That's quite a nice way of saving for something special, without really noticing you're doing it.

Have you noticed that child benefit is paid 4-weekly too?

RandomLondoner · 08/10/2021 09:54

clarification 2: "your previous payment would have been after the previous mortgage payment"

Shedbuilder · 08/10/2021 09:53

Sorry, that should have read 'All my council tax, mortgage, utilities etc are based on a 12-times a year schedule'

Why so many people are struggling to get their heads around this I don't know.

RandomLondoner · 08/10/2021 09:53

correction: "the second payment in the calendar one is the bonus one"

RandomLondoner · 08/10/2021 09:50

You've said your money doesn't pay the mortgage, but his way of looking at things does explicitly use covering the mortgage as a reference point. In that perspective the extra payment will not be the second one in a calendar month, it will be the second of two payments that arrive between two mortgage payments, where by "between" we mean they are too late for the first one but both in time for the next one.

Your payment on the 1st would have covered this months mortgage payment, and your previous payment would have been after the previous one, so I'd say by his criteria, the payment on the 1st is the extra one.

Your alternative and simpler perspective is always to regard each payment as covering the following calendar month, therefore the second payment in a calendar month is the second one.

Neither way of looking at things is right or wrong, but he has not implemented his correctly.

Shedbuilder · 08/10/2021 09:50

You're right, OP. I do some regular freelance work with a delivery schedule that has a 28-day / 4 week turnaround. 52 weeks of the year divided by 4 = 13. So I deliver 13 times a year, I invoice 13 times a year and I'm paid 13 times a year. All my council tax, mortgage, utilities etc are based on a 12-times a month schedule, so once a year I get an extra payment with no outgoings.

If your husband doesn't believe you I suggest you keep that money for yourself and put it into your pension fund as your reward.

WhatsAppening · 08/10/2021 09:50

@namechange30455

This really depends if you already have £1700 waiting in the bank as well as your 1st October pay OP. Do you?
Yep, my wage from last week is untouched.
OP posts:
IveGotASongThatllGetOnYNerves · 08/10/2021 09:49

Put it in a separate account.

If all bills are paid the same, you have the same spending money etc then you're right and it is spare money.

If you need to dip into it for regular bills then he's right.

ejhhhhh · 08/10/2021 09:49

If you spend it all in one go (thinking it's extra), in one particular month, and you haven't saved any from previous months, you'll be short of spending money for 4 weeks until you're next paid surely? If you want to see it as "extra" money, it would be more sensible save 1/12 of your wages every four weeks, them after a year, you really would have an extra payment.

namechange30455 · 08/10/2021 09:48

This really depends if you already have £1700 waiting in the bank as well as your 1st October pay OP. Do you?

3scape · 08/10/2021 09:48

I used to get my wage 4 weekly. It was great as everything I budgeted monthly. So yes, this extra "month" happened.

KnobJockey · 08/10/2021 09:46

Maybe it's easier to explain to him that the October 1st mortgage payment was in the bank waiting on September 3rd (your last payment, that wasn't in time for the 1st September). Your November 1st mortgage payment will be in the bank on October 29th. Therefore it's the wages that are paid on October 1st that were the 'bonus' payment.

Fluffypastelslippers · 08/10/2021 09:43

It does work if you are talking about things that are being paid on a monthly basis, OPS mortgage money is spare this 4 weeks, the rest of her money isn't.

It wouldn't be though, if this money paid the mortgage. How would next months payment be made if OP used it as spare and her next pay date it the end of nov?

I agree with others though it's not actually this month but last month where the extra happened.

darklindor · 08/10/2021 09:43

We have a similar issue. All income is every 4 weeks, all bills are once every calendar month. As different bills come out at different times of the month though, there is no one time when suddenly there is a whole extra months money.

DH assures me he gets it, I know he doesn't.

Marmite27 · 08/10/2021 09:41

Obviously that last payment should be 01/01/22 Confused

Bluntness100 · 08/10/2021 09:38

I think if you both are sure you have the money to pay the mortgage and bills it’s irrelevant. You need to both manage your money across the year inc savings etc

Is the issue here you both have a different attitude to money? You see it as extra to go buy crap and he is looking more maturely long term.

I’m not sure I’ve heard an adult so it was extra money like this.

Peanutsandchilli · 08/10/2021 09:37

Each month, you earn £1841. Instead of saying that you have an extra £1700 this month, just tell him you've had an extra £141 per month for the past year, and it's been saved up to be paid in a lump sum.

I agree with you that it's extra to your monthly budget.

WhatsAppening · 08/10/2021 09:36

I think it’s confusing because it’s all one pot, regardless of when in the month my money has gone in.

So we have £X income (his plus mine but counting mine as monthly). Minus £Y fixed bills. That leaves £N amount that we spend, part cash and part credit card. This month we have £N + £1700.

We’re a bit ahead anyway so there’s always enough money in the bank to pay the recurring bills so when mine hits in the month doesn’t really affect us, we’re not reliant on it to pay eg
the mortgage payment.

Hence: extra money to spend on shiny things. Save, I mean save.

OP posts:
MiddlesexGirl · 08/10/2021 09:34

If you get paid in cash then just keep the cash somewhere safe.
That will soon prove that it's an extra amount not needed for day to day spending.

Marmite27 · 08/10/2021 09:34

I would actually say last months was your spare month, as the money from 06/08 would pay September’s bills, and you get paid and the bill goes out on the same day 01/10.

If that money is still in the bank (from September) then yes you have two lots of wages available now.

I couldn’t work it out in my head, so had to use excel.

To this this IS extra money
Boatingforthestars · 08/10/2021 09:30

@Fluffypastelslippers

You might get paid twice this month but the money paid at the start has been your 'this month' money and the money at the end is next months. If you treat the payment as extra you will not have anything to live on for nov as you won't get paid until nearer the end. So it may be extra as in, you get another payment in the month, but without your next payment coming at the start of nov you will need the extra to live as with any other wage.

You can't compare 4 weekly to monthly - it doesn't work.

It does work if you are talking about things that are being paid on a monthly basis, OPS mortgage money is spare this 4 weeks, the rest of her money isn't. Obviously she can't go snd blow her hole pay packet but anything that would go out on the 1st of the month for her is extra money this month as she will be paid again at the end of the month to cover the payment due on the 1st of next month
Swipe left for the next trending thread