Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Wanting to rehome a dog

158 replies

Newmama93 · 08/10/2021 05:13

I’m in a horrible situation, I’ve rehomed a dog before,I had two dogs, both were XL American bullies, my male was attacking my other female dog repeatively, with a baby on the way we found the male a beautiful property where we see daily photos of him and he is so happy. That almost killed me! DH then proposed to me with another dog for our female as she developed severe seperation anxiety once our male was gone (even though she was scared and hid from him all day prior) I was shocked that he bought another dog and also a big dog which I did not want. Fast forward a year and this dog is aggressive toward other animals, people and kids. He is good with my 6 month old and mum, that is it. I still do t trust him. He is aggressive toward people we have come to the house (friends and family) and I’m so anxious constantly whenever someone wants to come over and see my son.

I am such an animal lover, I donate to a shelter monthly, I would never have imagined giving up my first dog let alone two but I really can’t cope with this aggression. He’s a 60kg dog.

What would you do? I can’t stop crying, I can’t eat. DH is not on board and says just put him outside away from everyone but I’m so anxious someone will accidentally walk outside and I also feel it’s a bad life for him.

Please no judgement - I would never dump my dog at a shelter or anything like that. I’d keep him if we couldn’t find anyone to take him.

OP posts:
icedcoffees · 09/10/2021 10:46

If someone approaches he will growl and I get very anxious amd scared as he’s so unpredictable so I have a collar that says NERVOUS, STAY AWAY on him.

This in itself is a HUGE worry. What will you do if someone ignores the collar (and in my experience, most people do) and goes to stroke him and he lunges or goes to bite? What if that person is a small child?

Even if you muzzle him, he could still knock a child flying and cause some nasty bruises. It's pretty irrelevant how good he is at home, you need to be able to keep visitors and the public safe too. It's part of owning a dog.

Newmama93 · 09/10/2021 10:44

He is lazy and doesn’t pull when we are out. He sticks by my leg and doesn’t want to be approached by people. If someone approaches he will growl and I get very anxious amd scared as he’s so unpredictable so I have a collar that says NERVOUS, STAY AWAY on him.

Thanks everyone, as beautiful as he is with our immediate family, it is really ruining my life with having guests and his unpredictability:(

OP posts:
icedcoffees · 09/10/2021 10:39

American bully was supposed to be bred for the perfect family pet, taking the drive out of the American staffy. Unfortunately we’ve gotten unlucky twice now, although I don’t discriminate against bull breeds

I don't think you've been unlucky - they're clearly not a breed that's suitable for you or your family set-up. American bullies are big, strong dogs which is why things can go badly wrong when they're in the wrong hands. If you're only 5'4" and you have a big dog, you need to have it impeccably trained - what happens if you're out in public and it pulls you over and you drop the lead? An aggressive dog that's loose could really do some awful damage.

TooMuchPaper · 09/10/2021 10:35

Please rehome the dog before he kills a child. Or an adult.

nothingcanhurtmewithmyeyesshut · 09/10/2021 10:33

The thing is OP, it doesn't matter the cause of the aggression. He is a very large and powerful breed and would be difficult to overpower if he really tried to get away from you.

Aggression is a major problem with any breed but one so large and strong could easily kill a child without meaning to. I love my dogs and am the first to stick up for dogs on here but a dog of that size who is aggressive towards children does sadly need to be put to sleep. Imagine if he accidentally killed a child. How would you feel? All it takes is one unpredictable toddler scaring him while your attention is elsewhere. You can't be on them 100 percent, every single second, its impossible.

Given that you know of his previous history of aggression, you would likely go to prison.

I think you and your DH were very irresponsible to get another dog in your situation but that is done and you have to think serious about this dogs future. However loving he is with you, he poses a risk to others.

I've had to do it myself with my own dog years ago and it broke my heart but I just couldn't trust him. If something happened it would have been my fault. I knew he wasn't right and was dangerous. So I know how it feels but as their owners we take on a responsibility for them when we adopt them.

Its cruel and unfair but we know when we get them that we are settling ourselves up for heartbreak down the line.

MrsTerryPratchett · 09/10/2021 10:33

@SentDeliveredRead

Perhaps if you've been unlucky twice you are not suited for that breed, especially now that your circumstances have changed
Or dogs generally.

The thing about breeds is that no, bully breeds aren't worse. However, when they are not bred and managed properly bullies are much more dangerous. They are also frequently bought by irresponsible wankers. Which means the dog gets the rep while the owner is to blame.

The only breed I can't stand is mini Pinschers.

There's no 'luck' with dogs that could kill you easily, especially buying more than one.

Suzi888 · 09/10/2021 10:28

DH is not on board and says just put him outside away from everyone but I’m so anxious someone will accidentally walk outside and I also feel it’s a bad life for him. - do NOT do that.
That’s going to make aggression worse and it’s quite frankly an accident waiting to happen. He will want to get inside, he will be jealous and want to destroy the source. It’s happened in the U.K. and the outcome was the child’s death and the dog’s destruction I believe. You will not be able to keep the dog away and what a sad life for the dog!

These dogs can be hard to train, I love them but I’m not sure I’d get one myself as I’m too soft and I don’t have the time to exercise them.

You must rehome the dog, to someone who has no children and has dealt with this issue before. @Ohwhatfunwehad is correct.

You are doing the best for the dog, he will be happier with more attention.

SentDeliveredRead · 09/10/2021 10:20

Perhaps if you've been unlucky twice you are not suited for that breed, especially now that your circumstances have changed

HomeSliceKnowsBest · 09/10/2021 10:03

This is awful OP. Rehome both dogs, through a reputable rehousing kennel. Do not get any more dogs. You cannot have either of your dogs around your baby/kids, neither sound reliable in their temperament or behaviour.

IamaBluebird · 09/10/2021 10:02

Why not rehome the aggressive dog straight away before someone gets hurt. Concentrate on giving your remaining dog a good life. Don’t get another dog regardless of size.

Newmama93 · 09/10/2021 10:01

We are in Australia so I don’t think you’ll know and I’m not here to bash a breeder down

OP posts:
SentDeliveredRead · 09/10/2021 09:58

I love the breed personally but again, where did your partner get it from?

Newmama93 · 09/10/2021 09:55

Ahhh don’t start on the breed thing, you are wrong there. Fear aggressive is amongst every breed and although more dangerous in powerful dogs, they can very well be domestic dogs and the American bully was supposed to be bred for the perfect family pet, taking the drive out of the American staffy. Unfortunately we’ve gotten unlucky twice now, although I don’t discriminate against bull breeds, I will be getting a dog I can handle next incase issues arise with temperament as I’m only 5”4 and tiny lol

OP posts:
SentDeliveredRead · 09/10/2021 09:46

I think putting a healthy animal down is generally wrong, however the OP has a very powerful aggressive and unpredictable animal and regrettably I think there is only one answer
These breeds were never meant to be domestic pets.
That's what I was getting at @Scrollonthroughtherain, sorry I should have been clearer

Scrollonthroughtherain · 09/10/2021 09:31

that's transferring the problem to someone else

Absolutely reasonable thing to do when there's a baby in the house. Baby comes first over any dog, especially a vicious one.

Bottleup · 09/10/2021 09:18

Please, please keep this dog completely away from your baby. And rehome him immediately.

Pantah630 · 09/10/2021 09:11

@MrsTerryPratchett

A massive bully breed that's aggressive to children? What the worst that could happen? Hmm

I'd rehome the DH and talk to a breed specific rescue to rehome(or PTS) the dog.

^this
MrsTerryPratchett · 09/10/2021 09:07

A massive bully breed that's aggressive to children? What the worst that could happen? Hmm

I'd rehome the DH and talk to a breed specific rescue to rehome(or PTS) the dog.

HikingforScenery · 09/10/2021 09:00

I’ve never heard of anyone being proposed to with a dog. I’d this common among “animal lovers”?

SentDeliveredRead · 09/10/2021 09:00

You'd be rehoming to ease your guilt, that's not being a responsible, that's transferring the problem to someone else
Where exactly did your partner get this dog? I'm curious to know

Scrollonthroughtherain · 09/10/2021 08:57

Get rid of it. A snap in the wrong direction and your baby child be horribly injured or dead.

catless · 09/10/2021 08:57

Get over your guilt and feeling 'horrid' and let your friend take the dog.

MargosKaftan · 09/10/2021 08:56

Rehome. Speak with your DP, what was he thinking, surprising you with a dog?! Q dog isn't a bunch of flowers or a weekend away, its a 15+ year commitment, part of the family, and you would be the one dealing with it most of the time. A pet of any kind needs to have the agreement of all adults in the household and assessed for how well it would fit in with your family and other pets.

Rehome. If your older dog can't settle without company of another dog, look at rehoming her or buying a different, more family friendly breed. But she might well settle after a while on her own rather than paying out for another dog, could you send her to a group doggy day care a couple of times a week? There's ones here who will pick up from your home and drop back.

HeartsAndClubs · 09/10/2021 08:50

IMO rehoming an aggressive dog is irresponsible, you’re just passing the problem on to someone else, and if/when that dog attacks someone and causes serious injury you will be partly culpable.

Also if that dog harmed someone else and it was ill-treated as a result you will be partly culpable.

The only responsible thing to do would be to have the dog put to sleep. There are enough unwanted dogs in rescue without adding a 60kg aggressive one who no-one in their right mind would recommend for rehoming in the mix.

No reputable rescue would agree to take on that kind of dog.

icedcoffees · 09/10/2021 08:44

I'm a dog lover but this is a disaster waiting to happen. You have a large, very strong breed of dog on your hands and he's aggressive and reactive to strangers, plus a six month old and family with small children who visit regularly.

Please, please either get this dog rehomed via a rescue or PTS. Honestly, I think PTS is the kinder option - a large, aggressive dog who is fear reactive will struggle to find anywhere else to go.

Have him PTS, put him out of his misery and keep your family safe. And if your DP tries to bring home any more dogs, tell him to fuck off Grin