Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Wanting to rehome a dog

158 replies

Newmama93 · 08/10/2021 05:13

I’m in a horrible situation, I’ve rehomed a dog before,I had two dogs, both were XL American bullies, my male was attacking my other female dog repeatively, with a baby on the way we found the male a beautiful property where we see daily photos of him and he is so happy. That almost killed me! DH then proposed to me with another dog for our female as she developed severe seperation anxiety once our male was gone (even though she was scared and hid from him all day prior) I was shocked that he bought another dog and also a big dog which I did not want. Fast forward a year and this dog is aggressive toward other animals, people and kids. He is good with my 6 month old and mum, that is it. I still do t trust him. He is aggressive toward people we have come to the house (friends and family) and I’m so anxious constantly whenever someone wants to come over and see my son.

I am such an animal lover, I donate to a shelter monthly, I would never have imagined giving up my first dog let alone two but I really can’t cope with this aggression. He’s a 60kg dog.

What would you do? I can’t stop crying, I can’t eat. DH is not on board and says just put him outside away from everyone but I’m so anxious someone will accidentally walk outside and I also feel it’s a bad life for him.

Please no judgement - I would never dump my dog at a shelter or anything like that. I’d keep him if we couldn’t find anyone to take him.

OP posts:
Newmama93 · 10/10/2021 09:10

[quote Nightbringer]@Newmama93 unlucky twice? You have been unlucky 3 times. As you have 3 dogs with fear and anxiety issues

No one is unlucky 3 times. At some point you need to start looking closer to home for where the problem lies.

A small rescue, that's likely to have issues itself is not the best choice to home with a large dog who has separation anxiety.[/quote]
I do everything right by my dogs and I don’t need to explain myself to your small mind. Bye now

OP posts:
Nightbringer · 10/10/2021 08:58

@Newmama93 unlucky twice? You have been unlucky 3 times. As you have 3 dogs with fear and anxiety issues

No one is unlucky 3 times. At some point you need to start looking closer to home for where the problem lies.

A small rescue, that's likely to have issues itself is not the best choice to home with a large dog who has separation anxiety.

Indoctro · 10/10/2021 08:49

@Newmama93

That’s why I wanted a small dog to keep my female company, perhaps an adult rescue even. I wasn’t even considering it as I’d just given away a dog. But DH didn’t consult me before purchasing this dog. I wouldn’t have agreed on another dog of this breed due to past experience.
You shouldn't be keeping dogs together unattended, if a fight breaks out one will be killed

This shows your lack of understanding of dog behaviour

Dogs should never be left alone together especially not a powerful breed

Indoctro · 10/10/2021 08:47

@Newmama93

Ahhh don’t start on the breed thing, you are wrong there. Fear aggressive is amongst every breed and although more dangerous in powerful dogs, they can very well be domestic dogs and the American bully was supposed to be bred for the perfect family pet, taking the drive out of the American staffy. Unfortunately we’ve gotten unlucky twice now, although I don’t discriminate against bull breeds, I will be getting a dog I can handle next incase issues arise with temperament as I’m only 5”4 and tiny lol
You haven't got unlucky you have created the dogs issues as your not experienced on training them correctly.

Rehome both dogs and dogs not get a dog again especially a large powerful breed.

Indoctro · 10/10/2021 08:45

You need to rehome both dogs

You don't have the experience to deal with the issues they have as these issues wouldn't be here if you did.

I wouldn't get another dog again, if you want a pet get a cat.

Nightbringer · 10/10/2021 08:39

@MyDcAreMarvel op said

DH then proposed to me with another dog for our female as she developed severe seperation anxiety once our male was gone (even though she was scared and hid from him all day prior) I was shocked that he bought another dog and also a big dog which I did not want

Op didn't say he prosed they got a dog. She was shocked he had bought another dog that she did not want.

Had . As in past tense. The dog had been bought.

He proposed marriage....with a dog.

Offmyfence · 10/10/2021 08:39

You must rehome him.

YouTubeAddict · 10/10/2021 08:35

Oh dear. This has ‘recipe for disaster’ written all over it. How is it going to cope in a new home? Would it be best if you re-homed your female at the same time if she gets anxious alone? I hope your partner doesn’t go getting silly ideas about getting another dog.

Summersun2020 · 10/10/2021 08:32

@MyDcAreMarvel yes I know what proposed means, don’t be a dick.
The op isn’t written like “my partner proposed that we get another dog”. It literally says “proposed to me with a dog”. Like got down on bended knee and held out an XL bully.

RAFHercules · 10/10/2021 00:08

I think you should safeguard you child and get rid of the dog, and your DH, who sounds stupid.

MyDcAreMarvel · 09/10/2021 23:19

@Summersun2020 verb
past tense: proposed; past participle: proposed
1.
put forward (a plan or suggestion) for consideration by others.

Summersun2020 · 09/10/2021 23:12

I’m sorry, he proposed…with a dog?

BeenHereForAges · 09/10/2021 23:04

Another vote for removing the dog from your home asap OP. I'm sure nobody is meaning to be rude to you. They are genuinely worried about you and your lovely little boy who I am sure means the world to you. I really hope you sort the situation tomorrow.

Helenluvsrob · 09/10/2021 22:29

What the flip ?
Why do people have such large dogs with aggressive tendencies ?
With a tiny baby in the house that’ll become an annoying toddler soon?

Whycangirlsbesonasty · 09/10/2021 21:24

I just don’t understand why anyone would ever bring a dog like this into their home. It’s just unfathomable to me.

Ohwhatfunwehad · 09/10/2021 19:12

Once you have rehome your boy, deal with your girls separation anxiety with a behaviourist. Don't get a second dog, that is not the solution.

icedcoffees · 09/10/2021 15:41

@SirenSays

What training have you done? That's an awful lot of money to be getting this result.
Sadly, you can't necessarily train aggression out of a dog, no matter how much money you spend.

Some kinds of aggression can be managed pretty well - things like resource guarding, or reactivity towards other dogs can be generally be managed safely if you really put the work in, but aggression towards strangers is very, very hard to handle as you can't manage the behaviour and actions of other people.

You can do everything right with the dog, but if they think someone has come into their space, or is threatening them or going to hurt them, it's not always possible to stop them reacting.

Also, dogs are generally much faster than people and a breed like an XL bully is going to be bloody hard work to hold back should it decide to lunge towards someone. They're big, strong, muscular dogs - it's not like handling an aggressive Westie or Chihuahua.

IMO the kindest thing you can do for an aggressive dog is have it PTS. Dogs have no concept of life and death - they don't fear it like we do. But if you re-home an aggressive dog, it's likely to spend it's life going from home to home, rescue centre to rescue centre, until the inevitable happens and it's PTS surrounded by strangers.

As owners, we have to do the hardest thing, which is to decide when it's time to say goodbye. An aggressive, fear-reactive dog is not a happy dog. It would, IMO, be kinder to have it PTS than to put it through a life of re-homing and rescue centres.

Muminabun · 09/10/2021 15:26

You have looked after the dog well and made a huge effort to train him. He probably has a strong guarding instinct and is best suited to actually having the job of a guard dog. Contact a rescue and they may be able to find him a suitable new home with someone who needs that type of guarding breed for example a park ranger. There is no shame in it the dog is not best suited to a domestic pet home and that is ok. Your husband on the other hand needs to check his ego and do what is best for the dog. The best family dogs are sweet, medium energy happy go lucky and docile.

cansu · 09/10/2021 15:20

You seem to be very sure of the dog around your child. This is v foolish. Many of the cases where a dog attacked a child in the home the family all thought the dog was safe. You need to wake up to what could happen. I would also recommend you think about how you will feel if one of your guests is harmed by this dog. Buying a dog to propose is also one of the most stupid things I have heard in a long time.

Xmassprout · 09/10/2021 15:20

The dog needs to go elsewhere. The dog needs to go to a child free home with someone experienced with the breed and with fear aggressive dogs so they can start addressing the issues. You need to contact rescue shelters and see if they have any foster carers that can take him on. Kennels would most likely make his issues worse

EishetChayil · 09/10/2021 15:18

Rehome DP!

SirenSays · 09/10/2021 15:17

What training have you done? That's an awful lot of money to be getting this result.

RunningFromInsanity · 09/10/2021 15:13

It’s not like I just have a wild, vicious dog. He is still a loving, sweet dog keep this in mind when everyone is saying put him to sleep, it is very hard to do that to a dog that is perfect with us.

Make sure you say that after your dog kills your MIL or baby.

2bazookas · 09/10/2021 14:20

You don't just "dump your dog at a shelter", What you do need to do is contact a shelter, explain the situation in full and ask them to take the dog and rehome it. You can then make a donation to their expenses while he is with them.

Don't get another dog, Consider getting another partner.

RincewindsHat · 09/10/2021 13:47

Yes, rehome.

Apart from the risks to you and your family (I know he's not aggressive towards you but if he has multiple triggers and has anxiety anyway, he will become increasingly unpredictable) your dog deserves to be in a home which meets his needs better and where he's not triggered all the time.

This situation is not worth the stress for you or the dog.