Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Get back to your country...

80 replies

Zeropointzero · 08/10/2021 04:10

Do you think it is ok to critisize the current british state of affair,if you are not british?Since Brexit, I have been told a few times:why dont you go back to your country.I have lived here for 37 years.There are many things I like in Britain,but also things I really loathe.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
TwinsandTrifle · 11/10/2021 08:42

I think it depends on the context. I'll pick somewhere random, let's say you're Spanish.

If you were commenting in general on the poor state of things, I'd be annoyed at someone saying "get back to Spain then". As if you couldn't have an input.

However. If you were "Spain wouldn't be like this, the UK is terrible, Spain is so brilliant, if only the UK could be far more like fabulous Spain" then I wouldn't see someone as saying "go back to Spain then" as racist. They're just pointing out if Spain is so fantastic in comparison, why are you voluntarily somewhere you think is so awful. Why not leave instead of remain somewhere you can't say a good thing about?

ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 11/10/2021 08:38

DH is not from Britain but now has dual nationality. He is as entitled as me to complain about the bits of British life that impact on him. It's not saying Britain shouldn't exist to complain about NHS waiting lists (he is more scathing about the health service in his home country) when one of our DC needs an appointment. Hypocritical and ineffectual politicians are annoying if they make decisions that affect you whilst preserving benefits for themselves.
He knows his life is better here overall than it would be in his home country but that doesn't mean he has to pretend its perfect.

Spidey66 · 11/10/2021 08:36

Apologies for typos, broken arm

Spidey66 · 11/10/2021 08:35

My dad was Irish. He came to the UK in the 50s, when the Celtic Tiger was years away. There was nothing in Ireland when he left.

Although he. Did return when he retired, for years the UK was his home, and he appreciated all it had to offer. He got employment, council housing (for a while) NHS, education for his kids. I don't ever remember him knocking the UK BUT he was still proud to describe himself as Irish, in the same way I'm proud of my background.

As an example during World Cup Games, he'd cheer ROI if they were playing but he'd cheer for England too!

What I'm trying to say is you can feel proud of where you were born, and feel a citizen of that country and still appreciate the UK. They're not mutually exclusive.

SleepOhHowIMissYou · 11/10/2021 08:33

@Rangoon

Brits online seem to be keen on putting the boot into NZ at the moment for our covid outbreak. We've lost 29 people since the beginning of covid so it's not as if it's been rampaging though the days of no community cases and us being unmasked and with large gatherings are probably over. Still we had a very good run and the government always knew the time would come when we would get community cases with Delta. They are criticising our PM - everything from her hair to her teeth. There is a vaccine program - everyone in my household is double vaxed. I guess I am being defensive as a previous poster says. I could say that at least we have plentiful supermarket supplies, plenty of lorries and no shortage of petrol, our taxes aren't rising and, hopefully, our electricity and gas bills are not set to surge. We are not pre-ordering turkeys at least though of course our Christmas is in the middle of summer.
Do you have a British accent Rangoon?

Being in NZ without a New Zealand accent is a whole different experience let me tell you. I have been told to "go home" by many passing strangers away from touristy areas while there. However, one young boy did get confused and instead told me to go back to Japan.

The only time I have ever been tempted to ask the question myself was to a Scottish work colleague who was absolutely up front about hating the English (as well as anyone who wasn't white) but lived and worked in London (his partner was South African). He was bloody miserable here and very vocal about it so I did wonder.

Halfpace · 11/10/2021 08:22

I spent almost 30 years in the UK, paid taxes, voted, volunteered, had a child there — but in the end the xenophobic micro-aggressions grew so much in the wake of the Brexit referendum that I did as the xenophobes told me and left.

Wazzzzzzzup · 11/10/2021 08:12

We pay taxes but can't vote so we can at least say how it is and say our opinion.

Zeropointzero · 11/10/2021 08:09

I personally think,not allowing someone to critisize their country comes from a deep insecurity.my grandparents have fled Germany before the outbreak of the 2.worldwar.Nationalism and flag waving did become a very dangerous movement for my grandparents and they decided to leave Germany in order not to participate in the Regime.I suppose,I have grown up with the mantra: be very very weary of a Regime were flag waving and excessive Nationalism is upheld.I dont like the present popularist Government,it is dangerous and usually ends in tears (or worse) for everybody.it was however good to read,so many people here on this thread agree with me and are equally repulsed by Flag shagging.

OP posts:
Auroreforet · 08/10/2021 17:59

I live in France. I ask my neighbours opinion on Macron, French politics etc.
I’m very careful not to give any opinion of my own though.

It’s like families. I can criticise my dm but if dh criticises her I get defensive.

However I think 37 years would give you a right to voice your opinions.

MuffinsAreJustCakesAtBreakfast · 08/10/2021 16:34

OP I'm really sorry that you have had this said to you; it is an absolutely awful thing to say to someone.

Of course you're entitled to summarise British affairs as you see fit - as much as anyone else! Don't listen to nasty people xxx

Cameleongirl · 08/10/2021 13:39

@HerRoyalNotness

Of course it is ok. People who say that don’t have intelligence to say anything else. Surely they should want better for their country too
I completely agree, Royal. I’m British currently living in the US. I now love both countries and criticize both. There’s nothing wrong with wanting better for both your birth country and your “adopted” home and recognizing their imperfections.
frumpety · 08/10/2021 13:28

To be fair there are a selection of things that you can legitimately moan about in the UK, a couple of which are almost national hobbies, so the weather is always a fairly safe one, roads and traffic another. Wink

AutistAwayWithUrConditionalLuv · 08/10/2021 11:35

Rosesandblossoms

I didn't mean to literally declare, as in citizenship ceremony. If you identify as British or married to a British person, etc, you've already "declared" in that sense, no matter where you're from.

By "not declared", I meant when someone says s/he's a foreigner or an outsider, then criticises the country in the latter way I mentioned. It's not unusual to get pushback from people because of that. Not saying it should be, it's just what I've observed.

No, it's not peculiarly a British thing. I know of at least two other countries where you'd get the same. But yes, the 'go back to your country' rhetoric is usually said with racist or xenophobic overtones.

Just to be clear, I'm also not originally from the UK. As I've written before, I think anyone can criticise the country they live in, it doesn't matter how long they've lived there or if they're married to anyone from there or not or if they identify with it or not.

thinkbiglittleone · 08/10/2021 11:06

@HerRoyalNotness

Of course it is ok. People who say that don’t have intelligence to say anything else. Surely they should want better for their country too
Exactly this,

Of course you pass comment on the state of this country.
People with these views are half the problem, being feed this bile to cause a divide, that then feeds the hostility felt in this country.

Rosesandblossoms · 08/10/2021 10:59

No one likes their country being criticized by someone who's not declared themselves as part of the country.

Not sure that’s true. I think this is peculiarly British. I’ve lived here for decades, I’m married to someone British, I have dual-national children who, when asked, identify as British. I have not, and will not ‘declare’ myself as British. But I have exactly the same right to criticise, and praise, as anyone who is. I participate fully in the life of this country. I’m just not from here.

Hdhdjejdj · 08/10/2021 10:43

What really irks me is that people are furious now when there has been terrible suffering and injustice for such a long time. The truth is that they were happy enough when things were ok for them and still don’t care about issues like social mobility and child poverty.

ChurchofLatterDayPaints · 08/10/2021 10:35

I'm British and temporarily not living in Britain for reasons beyond my control, and I've found that parochialism is rife wherever you go.

I criticise both places freely and at length, but for completely different reasons in each place. We're citizens of Earth, not of some crappy political construct. If you care enough to want to make a positive change to the place you're living in, what does it matter where you were born?

AutistAwayWithUrConditionalLuv · 08/10/2021 10:24

I also think you can criticize any country you live in.

AutistAwayWithUrConditionalLuv · 08/10/2021 10:22

No one likes their country being criticized by someone who's not declared themselves as part of the country. It happens when the person criticising is seen as not coming from the right place: 'I want to see this country get better', not 'I hate this country and I'm happy to keep badmouthing it".

That said, telling people who're criticising a country's whatever to go back to their country or to emigrate to another country is a useless, emotional and tribal reaction, at best. I'm sure they know they can go somewhere else if they want but it's not the point.

pointythings · 08/10/2021 09:56

@HarrietsChariot

I can see both sides of the argument. It is infuriating when someone complains about a situation, has the power to change things but can't be arsed. In your case you have the power to move to the country you are a citizen of, but choose not to. Presumably weighing up all factors you think remaining here, with its flaws, is better than moving away?

I think it's rude to criticise another country whilst in that country. I have major problems with certain aspects of America, but I declined to air them while I was over there because it felt unnecessarily rude.

Ultimately unless you are a citizen of the country you are in, you are a guest, no matter how long you have been there. It's rude to criticise a host's home while you are a guest in it.

Guests don't pay for the running of the household, Harriet. Those of us who have made our lives here, who pay taxes and contribute - we aren't guests. We're residents. Your analogy is faulty.
Whammyyammy · 08/10/2021 09:54

I'm British. I loathe the British attitude to any form of immigration, the get back to your own country and stop stealing our jobs brigade book my piss, used to be proud we were a nation of multi culture, just a nation with many racists.

Then you get the bits that move abroad, they insist on being called ex pats, now you're an immigrant, being British doesn't make us different or special

HarrietsChariot · 08/10/2021 09:26

I can see both sides of the argument. It is infuriating when someone complains about a situation, has the power to change things but can't be arsed. In your case you have the power to move to the country you are a citizen of, but choose not to. Presumably weighing up all factors you think remaining here, with its flaws, is better than moving away?

I think it's rude to criticise another country whilst in that country. I have major problems with certain aspects of America, but I declined to air them while I was over there because it felt unnecessarily rude.

Ultimately unless you are a citizen of the country you are in, you are a guest, no matter how long you have been there. It's rude to criticise a host's home while you are a guest in it.

Hdhdjejdj · 08/10/2021 08:49

I think you are completely entitled to criticising the UK wherever you were born. Personally though, I have had to come off twitter because of the constant complaining about things here. I don’t think it’s great at the moment by any stretch of the imagination but I think things were worse in previous recessions. Certainly it felt like that in the part of the north west were I live. I find it hard to listen to constant complaints, probably because this Covid era was really challenging for me for various reasons. I am not burying my head in the sand but not am I wanting to spend every waking hour complaining. So, if I was in your company and listening to you complaining about the UK I would probably just make an excuse to leave the conversation simply because I need to protect my own mental health.

Mumoblue · 08/10/2021 08:41

You can absolutely criticise the UK if you live here, no matter where you’re from.

I am English, born in England, but lived for a good period of my life in Scotland and I STILL get told “Why don’t you just go back to Scotland” by some people when I mildly suggest this country could be improved in some ways.

Blind loyalty is absolutely useless. If you care about a country, you should always be looking for improvement.

RudestLittleMadam · 08/10/2021 08:39

It doesn’t matter how long you’ve lived here, or if you live here at all, feel free to have an opinion about this country or any other. Even if the opinion is negative. Telling someone to go “home” to their own country has always had racist undertones and is therefore unacceptable.

Swipe left for the next trending thread