Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to want him to just die?

114 replies

PyongyangKipperbang · 08/10/2021 01:34

Some of you will know my history but for those that dont...

horrifically abusive ex, attempted murder of me that didnt get to court thanks to a police fuck up. Had a trigger moment today that has left me in pieces. Spoke to a "friend" who said that I shoudlnt wish him dead as that is horrible thing to wish on anyone.

AIBU.

OP posts:
Orgasmagorical · 08/10/2021 07:05

PyongyangKipperbang and others who have been in similar situations, I totally understand why you would wish that. I thought it was the only way I would be able to get away from my ex, the number of times I would wake up in the morning hoping he wouldn't.

He came back a couple of times after he'd left and on one occasion he actually put the back of his hand to his forehead and dramatically exlaimed "It would have been better for everyone if I had just died!". I thought 'Well yes, it would' but all I said was "Oh, Richard". He maybe thought it was a sympathetic "Oh Richard" but I was just embarrassed for him. What an ARSEHOLE Grin

Bloody hell, Munchysox Flowers

Choochi · 08/10/2021 07:03

Glad you know your friend is on your side. I have wished someone dead, she didn't attempt to kill me though. But I know she wishes me and my kids nothing good. She's caused decades long hatred, emotional and physical suffering to many in my family, especially a parent of mine. But when she's nearly dying, I don't feeling like forgiving her but am sorry that I wished her dead and I take it back. I've been feeling bad that I wished her dead and now she could have an untimely death. I know that she'll be the same if she recovers by some miracle but still I don't want to be responsible for my wish in the past if it came true.

Bogeyes · 08/10/2021 06:56

Don't blame you and I hope you get your wish!

HelloDulling · 08/10/2021 06:56

I’m sorry he’s not, OP.

My mum was in an abusive relationship for more than 20 years. We found out this week he was having a heart operation and I genuinely spend the day hoping he would die in surgery. Alas it was not to be.

I don’t wish anyone else dead, but I’d rejoice at his funeral.

irishoak · 08/10/2021 06:50

My favourite daydream about my abusive ex these days is getting a knock on the door from the police who tell me I need to identify a body. After all those times of threatening to kill himself to scare and manipulate me into doing what he wanted, in my daydream he's finally bloody done it. In my daydream I would check that it's him and finally know that it's all over forever and that I'm safe from him at last.

So no, I don't think it's a horrible thing for you to think at all!

TheSquashyHatOfMrGnosspelius · 08/10/2021 06:48

If I could have a pound for every time I wished my Ex dead I would be loaded!

He tried to kill me too. If I hadn't seen him behind me with a lump of wood in his hands, reflected in a window, I would be dead and I think he has killed people before when I analyse situations and things others have said.

You are only human. The friend that said what she said is just lucky she has never had to endure what you have, that's all.

Owleti · 08/10/2021 06:48

Over time, I went from wishing someone dead in every way possible, to wishing they'd had a happier childhood and had been a happier kinder person etc.

This wasn't for them, it was for me. It helped me personally in my head to feel less filled with venomous rage about them, and replaced it with a quieter sense of pity for their excuse of a life. But it took years (and I'm not suggesting that others should want or need to reframe thoughts like that).

I wonder if your friend said something less out of worry for him and his fate, and more out of wishing that you felt better somehow?

Zombielandand · 08/10/2021 06:46

I’d want him dead too. I’m sorry for what he has put you through.
Your friend is wrong I’m afraid, and clearly cannot imagine the torment behind your experiences.
X

Obvsnamechanger · 08/10/2021 06:42

When people haven't been through what you've been through they just don't get it.

I wished my abuser dead numerous times. And then he did die. I do feel guilt for having those feelings but the sense of freedom is immense. Counseling helped me see both of these feelings are perfectly valid. As yours certainly are.

PurBal · 08/10/2021 06:41

I wouldn’t wish him dead because he doesn’t deserve that amount of energy spent on him.

mylovelydd · 08/10/2021 06:35

I wish him dead too.

Massive hugs to you @PyongyangKipperbang @Munchysox and anyone else on this thread and mn who needs one Flowers

2018SoFarSoGreat · 08/10/2021 06:34

@PyongyangKipperbang i hope you have savored the many ways karma can come bite his ass, and I too hope it does. He's a snake, or a snail, or a toad. To be detested and sent all the bad wishes one can muster.

I'm glad your friend is lovely and did not mean to trigger you. I hope you can help her understand why it did, one day. For now, just swear here with us!

Mummyoflittledragon · 08/10/2021 06:18

I see you around a lot too. Your friend has possibly never truly suffered greatly. Or if she has, she is hiding it from herself. Please take no heed. Your feelings and emotions are the right ones for you. Don’t deny them. They’re a fantasy rather than a reality. Flowers

Crikey @Munchysox Flowers

SinoohXaenaHide · 08/10/2021 05:22

She hasn't walked in your shoes, and neither have I or anyone else om this thread. Only you know what you have been through. The feelings you have adter having experienced what you have are valid, no one gets to tell you not to feel the way you do.

Your friend was being insensitive, but probably meant well and spoke out of concern for your own wellbeing not his. It's a valid viewpoint to believe that harbouring hatred and resentment towards those who have wronged us does more harm to the hater than to the hated. However, there's a big difference between promoting that viewpoint where someone's ex is just a "normal" level of bastard (cheating, lying, lazy and unappreciative for example) where they can't actually harm you further once the relationship ends, vs your situation where he actually tried to kill you and his ongoing existence is a genuine ongoing source of distress and fear to you. Your friend didn't understand that the hatm is still ongoing for you. But it's not your job to give her lessons in emotional literacy and sensitivity. You don't need to set her straight and you don't need her permission or approval for your feelings. You are ok.

Munchysox · 08/10/2021 05:21

Very briefly...I was sexually, emotionally and physically abused by my stepfather . He was a bully who terrorised everyone, but I was his pet project. By the time I started school I was so indoctrinated to feel useless and horrible so I automatically took on the "victim" role. So much so that I was bullied and picked on by most of the other children, even some of the teachers picked on me, I was such an easy target.I just wanted to be loved and thought that if I allowed my abuse to carry on eventually he would love me and the abuse would stop. I think my heroin addiction was a direct result of his treatment of me.

When my marriage broke down I'd been using for 40 years and had to go into rehab, it was that or die. I was there for 3 years and they allowed me to be me, to find power I'd never had, to find my voice,to find me. My true inner strength. I needed that 3 years. Most people were there for a year but I was so emotionally broken I couldn't cope with life, I was never given the skill to do so. You'd think that would feel really great but it was so painful, raking up memories and feelings that had been smothered by heroin.

Long story short, I got the chance to confront my abuser in my own way. When he started to become senile I helped my mum care for him and at the beginning he knew what was wrong with him and he was so scared. But for me it was the powerlessness that he felt, the same powerlessness that I'd felt all of those years, that was Karma at work.

Funnily enough after confronting him it was like a weight was lifted from my shoulders, an amazing feeling. YeaH I still have the flashbacks and I struggle at times with a fearfulnees that kinda takes me back, but it can't hurt me, it's just a feeling and I know it will pass. I'm 66 and although it's no longer as painful, the memories sometimes come back unexpectedly and catch me out. But that's just life isn't t?

Thanks for listening.

Munchy
XXX

Rangoon · 08/10/2021 04:58

I just hope that people who have acted badly get exactly what they deserve. Sometimes it gives me pleasure imagining what that might be. Your friend is being a bit silly.

PrincessNutella · 08/10/2021 04:53

Your bad wishes do nothing to harm him so go right ahead and wish him ill.

fourquenelles · 08/10/2021 04:53

Sorry Witches oh for an edit button.

fourquenelles · 08/10/2021 04:52

Thank you ThumbWitchAbroad. This was 5 years ago now and she is doing really well and has a toddler so her life has moved on. It took a while not least because he left her financially as well as emotionally ruined.

Munchysox · 08/10/2021 04:50

Oh yes, I get those feelings too. Thank you for making me feel so welcome ThumbWitchesAbroad. Wow what a cool name.

Munchy.
XXX

Munchysox · 08/10/2021 04:47

Best way would be to strap him to a table and inserting a venflon (needle used replace fluids or remove blood through a vein) then set it to remove his blood one drop at a time. Allow the blood to collect in pint bottles and as they fill place them on a table that he can see. Then watch the fear in his eyes as he realises that with each drop of blood, with each bottle you place on that table in front of him, he is slowly dying and you have the power, the control. See how he likes the feeling. Bastard.
Munchy.
X

ThumbWitchesAbroad · 08/10/2021 04:45

@fourquenelles - hope your DD was ok in the end?

@Munchysox - that's a lovely post. Sorry you went through abuse too. MN is a bit "hardarse" when it comes to posting style but you didn't do anything wrong, don't worry! And feel free to swear as much as you like. Wink

fourquenelles · 08/10/2021 04:34

I fantasised about killing my DD's cockroach of an extremely abusive boyfriend. Stabbing him in the neck was a top method. I was in my early 60s, a widow and even shared with the police that I might enjoy prison as I could study inside. I would have missed my dogs though. In our case the universe listened and it had a fatal heart attack after taking a cocktail of drugs. I was positively gleeful on hearing the news and then for a fleeting second questioned my reaction but it was for a fleeting second. The world is a better place without it in it.

Munchysox · 08/10/2021 04:32

I'm new here so I apologise now for anything I get wrong. All abused women get these flashbacks, I know that I do, so if that's how you feel and it gives you some relief then go for it hate that bastard. But when this desperate feeling eases, as it does until the next time, please try to see this feeling as a way that the bastard still has some power over you. Never ever forget that you're a survivor, a very strong lady. It's ok to feel however you want to feel, no one (even a good friend) has the right to tell you how to feel. I know it may sound really cheesy but time does heal and each time you get through one of these desperate episodes you will emerge stronger for having gone through it. You feel needy at the moment and I have so much love and compassion in my heart for you and your situation so I'm sending you all of the love I can.You're loved and cared for by so many people but at times like this it doesn't feel like it, does it. You're also an inspiration to others sweetheart, always try to remember that. I think you're incredibly brave for sharing your experiences with us. Thank you so much.
Munchy
XXX

Wegobshite · 08/10/2021 04:29

I’ve wished a few people could die
For much less than what you mentioned
In fact the person I really hate mother died and while I wish his mother no ill, I’m glad that her passing caused him immense pain which I will settle for .

A friend of mine was shocked when I said this and said it wasn’t nice but 1. I never said I was nice
& 2 to as I can’t kill the fucker and get away with it I will take whatever causes him pain 😀