Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is there a stigma in dating single mothers?

157 replies

adatingquestion · 07/10/2021 16:27

Not British, so need some cultural guidance. Also probably quite unexperienced relationship wise, so apologies in advance for a stupid question.

Someone I have been dating for a couple of months now (my first relationship after a couple of years spent single), said that he is unsure about how to introduce me to his friends and family, as being in a relationship with a single mother is likely to raise quite a few eyebrows. For clarity, I did not press him or raise this topic, he just said it when we were discussing friendships in general. I asked why, but he just kept changing the topic without giving a specific answer.

I thought this was going well - progressed organically from just casually knowing each other to friends and then to romance - but now unsure. And, to be honest, almost on the brink of quitting this relationship.

He does not have children himself, I have two (quite young), and the relationship is light years away from them being introduced. My question is whether he hinted that there's some sort of a general stigma, or could he have meant something like "I have never been paternal so they'd be surprised"?

OP posts:
Poetrypatty · 07/10/2021 21:35

As if he is mildly scandalised by the very idea of me and my world overlapping with his usual contacts, but tries to be very polite about it

Presumably he knows that the father of your child left you and you are in this position through no decision or fault of your own. It shows a lack of empathy to say what he's said and is unkind and judgmental. Also, if he's 50 with no kids then you'd think his family would be delighted he's met somebody with a kid, since it's likely too late for him to start a family of his own. It's not like he's 25! Negging, as pp said. Don't put up with it.

tiredandmardy · 07/10/2021 21:30

@GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing

Also I think he’s being an arse and it’s a form of negging
Agree…also part of the toolkit of RedPill, MGTOW and PUA sometimes.
adatingquestion · 07/10/2021 21:28

It's not you it's him. This man is in his 50s ffs. Sounds like an arse. How does he not know any single parents. I would consider binning him because next he will be making you feel like you're grateful to have him. You deserve better. It's not a language barrier he's just a dickhead.
Not an arse - he's usually quite attentive and gentlemanly, but I do feel a bit weird about it now. As if he is mildly scandalised by the very idea of me and my world overlapping with his usual contacts, but tries to be very polite about it.

OP posts:
GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 07/10/2021 21:23

Also I think he’s being an arse and it’s a form of negging

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 07/10/2021 21:23

I wouldn’t have said there was a stigma. I would have said some people are warey of baggage/ taking on responsibility for kids. Not really the same thing imo

adatingquestion · 07/10/2021 21:06

@TractorAndHeadphones

Well done for messaging him OP! What is his circle like - perhaps they are prejudiced? For example many people consider anybody who doesn't fit the standard 'below their league'. Whether the standard is race, looks, single parenthood etc etc. Most of my family for example (although a different culture, not British) all married young, had kids and stayed with husbands. Divorce etc unheard of. They don't know any single mums. Perhaps his circle has made judgey comments.

The important thing is that you hash it out. Ask him what he's going to do about it. Or even - he may be overthinking it and they're all going to be perfectly polite. To your face, anyway.

What you can do is meet them and see how you get on. Unless he's refusing evene that.

I think he's from a very typical middle class family, but obviously cannot analyse in detail by not being local. From what I know, his late dad was a bank clerk, his mum a housewife, his sister is a teacher. All live in Midlands, while we are in London. I know little about friends, haven't met any of them (but also - lockdown and then holiday season). All of them are around his age, I wonder if they would naturally be a little bit more old school about single parenthood.
OP posts:
Poetrypatty · 07/10/2021 21:00

So. Got a vague answer about that his circle being very conservative and his friends and family probably don't even know any single mothers socially so won't know what to think and how to be around me.
I am still not quite clear what it means. Feeling just ridiculously socially inept.

It's not you it's him. This man is in his 50s ffs. Sounds like an arse. How does he not know any single parents. I would consider binning him because next he will be making you feel like you're grateful to have him. You deserve better. It's not a language barrier he's just a dickhead.

TractorAndHeadphones · 07/10/2021 20:58

Well done for messaging him OP!
What is his circle like - perhaps they are prejudiced?
For example many people consider anybody who doesn't fit the standard 'below their league'. Whether the standard is race, looks, single parenthood etc etc.
Most of my family for example (although a different culture, not British) all married young, had kids and stayed with husbands. Divorce etc unheard of. They don't know any single mums. Perhaps his circle has made judgey comments.

The important thing is that you hash it out. Ask him what he's going to do about it. Or even - he may be overthinking it and they're all going to be perfectly polite. To your face, anyway.

What you can do is meet them and see how you get on. Unless he's refusing evene that.

TurnUpTurnip · 07/10/2021 20:46

@Gwenhwyfar

"To be honest, it sort of works both ways - some women would prefer not to date a man who already has children."

Yes, but a woman is less likely to end up living 100% with the step-children or, at the dating stage, to be never able to see her boyfriend because he needs a babysitter. I think dating a man with children is probably easier than a woman with children.

Yes see I 100% Agree with this but lots of people seem to say it’s the opposite and it’s harder for a woman dating a single father but I just can’t agree, woman are in 90% of cases the RP I don’t know any resident parent dads and despite what MN says 50/50 contact is still very unusual with most contact being EOW that is far more the norm, I also know many women bringing up children alone with no input from the father, don’t personally know any men doing this but I’m sure it does happen but it is much less common, when a man dates a woman with kids he is taking on a lot more than a woman who probably only sees the step kids EOW, a step dad will move into the home with the children and spend far move time with them and financially supporting them
Magicstars · 07/10/2021 20:40

Honestly I had no issues dating nice men as a single mum. I didn't feel it was an issue at all.

I've now met a wonderful & eligible bloke. Decent men will look beyond any old fashioned ideas & 'stigma'. Tbh more blokes would be put off by my dietary choices (vegan) than because I have dc 😂.

tiredandmardy · 07/10/2021 20:39

There is a whole series of advice videos and books for men (MGTOW, Red Pill et al) that is very popular at the moment with men and clearly, repeatedly tells men not to date single mothers, under any circumstances. You can see the (frequently viewed) videos on YouTube.

adatingquestion · 07/10/2021 20:36

@adatingquestion

Got some stupid courage and texted him about this - in a light-hearted way, but it really messes with my head to the point that I am not sure whether we have actually ever been on the same page.
So. Got a vague answer about that his circle being very conservative and his friends and family probably don't even know any single mothers socially so won't know what to think and how to be around me. I am still not quite clear what it means. Feeling just ridiculously socially inept.
OP posts:
spotcheck · 07/10/2021 20:27

He's projecting - he's the one with the problem

Hullbilly · 07/10/2021 20:21

Maybe it's more an age thing? I was surprised my ex bil, in his 50s, was dating a woman with young DC. He wasn't very hands on with his own DC and didn't parent very much. It may well be that sort of thing. He knows his friends/family will be a bit surprised he's made this choice at his age.

WhiskyXray · 07/10/2021 20:21

Do you think he meant but couldn't express that he was worried he would look dodgy, as in pursuing single mothers so he could have access to their kids? I am on a dating forum, and it's full of horror stories and advice on how to avoid men who are looking to groom families. I am not saying your BF is like that or has thoughts in that direction, but it IS known that single mothers are often targeted by abusive types.

PanicStationsAhh · 07/10/2021 20:20

I'm not sure it's a stigma as such, isn't it more that single parents of either sex are inherently more complicated because there are children involved? I'm not sure I'd date a single Dad because of how complicated it could get further down the line, not because there's anything wrong with being a single parent if that makes sense?

DDUW · 07/10/2021 20:17

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

Gwenhwyfar · 07/10/2021 20:13

"To be honest, it sort of works both ways - some women would prefer not to date a man who already has children."

Yes, but a woman is less likely to end up living 100% with the step-children or, at the dating stage, to be never able to see her boyfriend because he needs a babysitter. I think dating a man with children is probably easier than a woman with children.

Gwenhwyfar · 07/10/2021 20:10

"Let's not pretend there isn't a stigma about single mothers. E.g you make poor life choices, hence being a single mum. I'm not saying that I agree by the way."

I don't agree that this stigma exists for a divorced woman with children from one father. It might exist for a woman who has never married and whose children are from multiple fathers as it suggests she chose to reproduce with men who weren't reliable.

I do think some of this guy's friends might just think it's not a great 'deal' to be with a single mother, potentially ending up bringing up another man's children, but many many men do that...

Hullbilly · 07/10/2021 20:04

I think it's about it being more complex, rather than looking down on you.

adatingquestion · 07/10/2021 20:04

@Libertaire

I don’t think there is a ‘stigma’ but is do think there are a lot of single men who are not looking for the hassle of dating a woman who has childcare responsibilities. Nor are they up for the commitment or responsibility of ‘taking on’ someone else’s child. That’s an understandable & perfectly reasonable view.
I agree, totally understandable. In this case we're several months together (just short of a year), so had he been really reluctant to, there were many opportunities to jump the ship.
OP posts:
Ohsugarhoneyicetea · 07/10/2021 20:02

I dont think there is any stigma being a divorced mother in your late 30s or 40s. Isnt half the population divorced? Personally I think being a man in your late 50s who is single with no kids is way more of stigma - what's wrong with him, why no significant relationships? He sounds like a weirdo and I also think he is negging you. Bin him.

Libertaire · 07/10/2021 19:58

I don’t think there is a ‘stigma’ but is do think there are a lot of single men who are not looking for the hassle of dating a woman who has childcare responsibilities. Nor are they up for the commitment or responsibility of ‘taking on’ someone else’s child. That’s an understandable & perfectly reasonable view.

adatingquestion · 07/10/2021 19:58

Got some stupid courage and texted him about this - in a light-hearted way, but it really messes with my head to the point that I am not sure whether we have actually ever been on the same page.

OP posts:
adatingquestion · 07/10/2021 19:54

@EmeraldShamrock

Be reassured OP many single parents meet someone wonderful and it is a none issue.

My Friend met her DH 12 years ago, she was apprehensive about dating him as a single mother, her life is a very happy one now, it happens for lots of him.
This is his issue dump him.
I said up-thread I didn't date parents when I was childfree mainly because I liked freedom.
If I really liked a person it wouldn't matter how complicated it got.

This is also very encouraging. Thank you!
OP posts: