Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is there a stigma in dating single mothers?

157 replies

adatingquestion · 07/10/2021 16:27

Not British, so need some cultural guidance. Also probably quite unexperienced relationship wise, so apologies in advance for a stupid question.

Someone I have been dating for a couple of months now (my first relationship after a couple of years spent single), said that he is unsure about how to introduce me to his friends and family, as being in a relationship with a single mother is likely to raise quite a few eyebrows. For clarity, I did not press him or raise this topic, he just said it when we were discussing friendships in general. I asked why, but he just kept changing the topic without giving a specific answer.

I thought this was going well - progressed organically from just casually knowing each other to friends and then to romance - but now unsure. And, to be honest, almost on the brink of quitting this relationship.

He does not have children himself, I have two (quite young), and the relationship is light years away from them being introduced. My question is whether he hinted that there's some sort of a general stigma, or could he have meant something like "I have never been paternal so they'd be surprised"?

OP posts:
TracyLords · 08/10/2021 09:40

Just read all your messages now OP. And you don’t sound “beneath” anyone. You sounds like an amazing catch: good job, sensible, very articulate.. actually, I think I’ve got a girl crush now!

adatingquestion · 08/10/2021 09:38

@Poetrypatty

No, not a billionaire, a college lecturer. I honestly was not looking for sponsorship

I wasn't meaning that- simply that 59/60 year olds with the exception of perhaps a few billionaires, are not in demand among women wanting to have babies. Hope you're not too upset about it OP but it sounds like a lucky escape. You can do much better.

Upset, but I think I will survive. I think he maybe has a bit of billionaire-level ambition as he told me once that there are a couple of female students developing obvious crushes on him every year, and it is tricky to navigate without offending or causing misunderstanding. I mean adult students obviously, he's lecturing to early - mid 20's audience usually, not teenagers.
OP posts:
TracyLords · 08/10/2021 09:34

Could there be any sinister reason he doesn’t want his friends to know he is dating a woman with kids? Just as thing to think of

Willyoujustbequiet · 08/10/2021 09:30

No I really don't think there is anymore. 30 years ago maybe but with half of all marriages failing single parenthood is becoming the norm.

Poetrypatty · 08/10/2021 09:29

No, not a billionaire, a college lecturer. I honestly was not looking for sponsorship

I wasn't meaning that- simply that 59/60 year olds with the exception of perhaps a few billionaires, are not in demand among women wanting to have babies. Hope you're not too upset about it OP but it sounds like a lucky escape. You can do much better.

Generallystruggling · 08/10/2021 09:27

Yes, I think so. My best friend is a single Mum and she’s quite young but she’s a brilliant woman and has a great career, her own home, kids are great too. She attracts lots of men around her own age (mid 20s) because she’s attractive but most of them are eventually put off by the fact she has children. Some of them have said they’re unsure how to tell their family/friends because it’s embarrassing so she’s just ditched them at that point. She’s finding the dating game quite difficult, I’ve told her to maybe give it a rest for a while until she’s a bit older and other guys are more likely to also have children.

Think it would be less of an issue with men who also have children but then that brings up problems in itself.

Catcrazy83 · 08/10/2021 09:22

I’d seriously be wondering what’s wrong with him. Wants children at almost 60, but never had any. I am not far from your age and would not date a 45 year old in that situation, never mind 60. Stinks of Peter Pan syndrome

adatingquestion · 08/10/2021 09:21

@Poetrypatty

Naturally, it is much easier for men to become a parent later in life.

Is he a billionaire? How many women realistically want to have a baby with a 59/60 year old? He sounds immature at best.

No, not a billionaire, a college lecturer. I honestly was not looking for sponsorship.
OP posts:
adatingquestion · 08/10/2021 09:20

So we had a text exchange this morning and indeed we are seeing the situation differently. He thought that we already had "the talk" when he explained that he wants a family with someone without any prior baggage, and therefore implicitly agreed to keep it casual / temporary. I did not understand it like that at that time, thought it was more of an "in the ideal world, I would like..." discussion, and not a memorandum of understanding. So yes, basically confirmed I don't meet his standards but otherwise a great person and he wishes me all the best.

I guess this closes the topic. @Pretzelcoatl and all, thank you for your contributions, it was quite interesting to read the male perspective, by the way.

OP posts:
Poetrypatty · 08/10/2021 08:46

Naturally, it is much easier for men to become a parent later in life.

Is he a billionaire? How many women realistically want to have a baby with a 59/60 year old? He sounds immature at best.

apalledandshocked · 08/10/2021 08:12

@Pretzelcoatl But here's the thing (and I have no idea how or why the relationship ended so I really don't want to cause offence*). You dated them for just 2 years. That doesn't sound like she was the love of your life even if you liked her. If you had ended with "and that person has been my wife for 15 years" it would be different. Obviously there is nothing wrong with just casually dating someone. There is nothing wrong with 2 people just hooking as FWB for that matter. But if the OP is really into the relationship from her end, and for him she is someone he is only seeing but doesn't plan to introduce to his family/friends then she is likely to get hurt.

*As I said, my unreserved apologies if she died tragically or ran away with the postman the day you planned to propose etc.

Pretzelcoatl · 08/10/2021 07:55

@adatingquestion

He’s introducing you to his people - that’s not what a guy does if you’re just a single mum putting out. Ah, that's the problem. I don't think he ever will, the whole problem I have is that he said he wouldn't even know where to start with this.
I dated someone twenty-four years younger than myself for a couple of years, and I was also reluctant to introduce her to family and friends.

I was living close to 1500 km away from the nearest of them at the time, so it wouldn’t be a casual thing, but... guys of a certain generation (I’m Gen X) who grew up being taught to suppress certain emotions take a fair amount of joking at their expense whenever they have someone that they care about.

There are the remarks to the guy, and there are the attempts to embarrass him to the girl. And it makes those initial introductions... easy to put off sometimes.

Doubly worse if there’s something even remotely non-standard which will be additional ammunition in the onslaught of hilarious jokes at his expense. In this case, your children and your age difference.

Not that it’s an excuse, mind you, but like any unpleasant formality, it can wait until tomorrow. Or the next day.

If it’s important to you, then he’ll have to suck it up and do it sooner rather than later. If it’s not of pressing importance to you, he’ll be relieved.

apalledandshocked · 08/10/2021 07:45

Also - I don't have an issue with age gap relationships generally (so long as everyone is a mature adult) but I don't think its a great sign when someone is consistently dating people much younger/older than themselves. So I would be fine if I was a 15 years younger than my partner. I would be weirded out if I found out his last ex was 20 years younger, and the one before that 14 years younger etc etc

apalledandshocked · 08/10/2021 07:42

@adatingquestion

He’s introducing you to his people - that’s not what a guy does if you’re just a single mum putting out. Ah, that's the problem. I don't think he ever will, the whole problem I have is that he said he wouldn't even know where to start with this.
I don't think thats a great sign. Yes, for some people, there can be a stigma around single mothers just as there can be a stigma against people from different ethnicities, or particular financial backgrounds, or people that dont have a university education, or those that do, or class. But generally - if someone is properly into you they SHOULD actually be eager to show you off/introduce you to the people they care about. Even were people have very difficult families and are worried about their reaction I would expect them to be protective of their partner when introducing rather than not at all. So - it seems quite likely the single mother thing is coming from his own insecurities/stigma rather than his friends. And also, I hate to say it, that even though he's lovely to you, he's not as into you as you are into him.
MrJollyLivesNextDoor · 08/10/2021 07:19

Whether or not it's possible or likely for him to have kids etc is irrelevant

He's told you that he wants kids with someone who doesn't already have them

He's reluctant to introduce you to his circle because of how they might perceive you...he should be bursting with pride to introduce you to them

You can do better than this!

adatingquestion · 08/10/2021 07:02

@Blinkingheckythump

He's 59 and he genuinely wants to have a baby of his own and considers there to be a chance his partner wouldn't already have kids? He's already lucky enough to be dating someone as young as you. The chance of him dating anyone young enough to give him a baby and not already have their own is slim to none. If he wants a family he should be grateful to be able to become a step father. Also at the age of 59 most people are becoming grandparents soon, not parents. I'd have expected him to accept he's not going to have biological children a long time ago
I think it could be possible, his previous partner was several years younger than me and did not have children of her own (but also did not want any, hence the break up). Naturally, it is much easier for men to become a parent later in life.
OP posts:
Itsnotdeep · 08/10/2021 07:01

I think you need to look at what he's done rather than what he says. He's kept you a secret for nearly a year. Are you happy with that?

Maybe he does love you, but if so, why isn't he proud of you? Why won't he introduce you to his friends? I dunno, as a59 year old bloke, with friends the same age, maybe they are going to judge him for going out with a much younger, foreign, mum. The age gap is massive. quite frankly it's ridiculous of him to be thinking of having kids at his age.

I'd just look at his actions. He's kept you a secret from his friends for a nearly a year. Maybe they will think you're a gold digger. Maybe they will think that you're looking for a father for your kids. Maybe they will think that he should stick with someone his own age. Who knows? But he shouldn't care, and he's being an arse.

adatingquestion · 08/10/2021 06:59

@jimmyjammy001 I am absolutely accepting of the fact that dating a single parent is not for everyone. Here I have a situation where we are already dating for some time, so he is presumably OK with my issues around childcare and attention he gets.

OP posts:
adatingquestion · 08/10/2021 06:55

He’s introducing you to his people - that’s not what a guy does if you’re just a single mum putting out.
Ah, that's the problem. I don't think he ever will, the whole problem I have is that he said he wouldn't even know where to start with this.

OP posts:
Blinkingheckythump · 08/10/2021 05:27

He's 59 and he genuinely wants to have a baby of his own and considers there to be a chance his partner wouldn't already have kids? He's already lucky enough to be dating someone as young as you. The chance of him dating anyone young enough to give him a baby and not already have their own is slim to none. If he wants a family he should be grateful to be able to become a step father. Also at the age of 59 most people are becoming grandparents soon, not parents. I'd have expected him to accept he's not going to have biological children a long time ago

tiredandmardy · 08/10/2021 05:11

@malificent7

Most men i know would date a single mum if they fancy her enough. Lots of my single mum friends and myself as a single mum dated a lot.
Dating sure…but was it generally harder to get long-term relationships with the high-quality men you wanted as a single parent? That seems to be the issue the OP has here. He is a good match and impressive for her in a number of ways apparently and they seem to be getting more serious…then this issue comes along like ‘a bucket of cold water’.
SnackSizeRaisin · 08/10/2021 04:39

Why don't you just ask him what he meant? Chances are that it was a throwaway comment, that reflects more on how his parents see things than how he does.
Yes in certain circles single mothers are still assumed to be feckless. But it's far more likely to be related to practical concerns, as others have said.
My parents are pretty old fashioned and would tend to look down on single mothers in a general sense. But when my brother actually dated one they soon got past that and developed a good relationship with the woman and her children. Often these prejudices are just inherent from their own upbringing and melt away when they realise they actually like the person.

malificent7 · 08/10/2021 04:23

Most men i know would date a single mum if they fancy her enough. Lots of my single mum friends and myself as a single mum dated a lot.

Resilience · 08/10/2021 02:08

Stigma against single mothers definitely exists. Far less so if they're a bit older, financially solvent and/or divorced (as opposed to unmarried).

Comments about single mothers are often indicative of someone's level of misogyny (and not limited to men). When I overhear the sexist trope about feckless single mothers living on benefits in council houses with children from different fathers, I like to point out that for every child there is a father. The mother might possibly be guilty of poor judgment but at least she's actually meeting her responsibilities and raising the children. Where is the same judgment (and financial and life-limiting penalties) on the fathers who walked away and abdicated both practical and financial responsibility?

Pretzelcoatl · 08/10/2021 01:34

@adatingquestion

I don’t know though whether it’s actually ‘respectful’ of people to not date single mothers if they don’t want kids as part of the package. Presumably it’s better than using and ditching them if they want an LTR but that goes for any woman and shouldn’t assume that every single mum wants another relationship. Yes, I wasn't specifically looking for a relationship as such (not registered on the dating sites, not reciprocating any attempts from men in the wild - just no desire or time). It just somehow happened naturally and I was quite happy that it progressed slowly and without any undue pressure from any side. Now I am concerned that maybe he's seeing it completely differently - as someone said above, just a single mum "putting out". I think now he was even genuinely surprised at first that I was surprised by his comment - as if he expected that we had an implicit understanding of me being "spoiled goods" of sorts, if that makes sense. Don't know how to explain it better.
He’s introducing you to his people - that’s not what a guy does if you’re just a single mum putting out.

Nor is that the behaviour of someone “lowering himself to your league” or doing you a favour.

Relax - this is almost certainly more about the dynamics between him and whoever he’s planning on introducing you to.