Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think my neighbour should have dealt with this tree 10 years ago

33 replies

Hadjab · 07/10/2021 15:27

When we bought our house 21 years ago, our neighbour was a lovely elderly widowed American woman. She had a gardener who would come in once a month to tend to the garden, keeping everything in check, including two trees. When she died, a property developer bought the house and converted it to three flats, the bottom and top he rents out, the middle, privately owned.

Ten years ago, my husband contacted the landlord to ask him to trim the tree next to our fence back, as it was beginning to block the light into our kitchen. Basically, he fobbed us off constantly for a number of years. We offered to go halves on the cost several times, as it was in our interest to do so - average cost of the quotes at that time were around £800.

Fast forwards to now, and the tree is approximately 60ft or more, and we have to have the light on in the kitchen during the day if we want to use it. I got more quotes recently, which are, on average, around £3k to deal with it. I’ve contacted the council’s tree department, but have heard nothing back in three months - COVID I expect. The neighbours who rent the downstairs flat have also been trying to get him to deal with it for the past five years - he has told them that they need to pay the full cost. Their garden is pretty much pitch black on even the sunniest of days.

Photos attached. What can I do now?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
SallyDoTheDishes · 08/10/2021 08:57

Sadly I think if you want something doing then you need to pay for it, I would speak to everyone in the flats and see if you can all chip in for it. It doesn't affect the landlord day to day so they will keep their hand in their pocket.

Ultimately you have to ask yourself is it worth £3k to you to get rid of the tree?

Tototipple · 08/10/2021 08:46

(Oh we have always had permission from the council with the trees with tpos on though before maintained)

Tototipple · 08/10/2021 08:45

Even if there were a TPO you still need to look after trees (a good tree surgeon will lift the crown/ shape the tree as it grows).

3k is extortionate, we had 2 large trees removed of a similar size plus others maintained/ shaped and it cost under £2k (and they removed the debris) I’d get another quote. It was about £200 to then get the two stumps ground out.

Meet with the downstairs neighbour, if he’s said it can be removed if they pay perhaps you can split the cost with them and have it taken down. We paid for a neighbours tree to be removed, they didn’t care but it blocked a huge amount of our light. They could of said no but we’re kind enough to let us. I didn’t expect them to pay despite it being their tree as it wasn’t causing them issues.

MargaretThursday · 08/10/2021 08:36

@Griselda1

I've spent several thousand cutting trees back this year. If you read your insurance documents you may realize you're not covered by it if you've trees that height so close to your home.
I live on an estate with lots of trees covered by tree protection orders. The trees are older than the estate.

Some insurance companies will not insure on the estate because of the trees. But most have no problems, and unless your insurance asks whether you are a certain distance from a large tree, it's no problem.
If a tree/branch comes down it is for the insurance of the person whose house it came down on, not the owner of the tree. The only exception to this is if the tree was clearly dangerous, and by that I mean dead or diseased in at least part.

If you have a tree with a protection order on you can't even trim the tree without permission.

superram · 07/10/2021 21:03

It sounds awful and I feel for you. However, once you knew the ll wasn’t interested you should have offered to pay then-it would have been cheaper!

Griselda1 · 07/10/2021 21:00

I've spent several thousand cutting trees back this year. If you read your insurance documents you may realize you're not covered by it if you've trees that height so close to your home.

user1493494961 · 07/10/2021 20:57

You shou!d have chopped it down when the old lady died, not much you can do now except trim the branches on your side.

Yesitsbess · 07/10/2021 20:52

You could try and approach him with the insurance angle, if he's declared a tree that big and that close to the house he could have lower premiums if it was sensitively made more safe (proper pollarding and checks for disease and branches that may hot the building during bad storms). If he hasn't declared the tree he might find himself in a bit of a sticky wicket if it does damage property and there's a long trail of people who have asked him to deal with it.

Am not an expert but I do love a tree dispute. Please don't kill the tree though!

Speakuptomakeyourselfheard · 07/10/2021 20:43

I think you need to take legal advice on this OP, as you may well have a right to a certain amount of light depending on how long you've lived in your home and how much light you had originally. Whatever you do, don't take this into your own hands or encourage your neighbours tenants to do so. Perhaps club together to pay for legal advice, or you could perhaps point out to the owner of the tree that if it, or any part of it should come down in a storm then they are likely to be liable for damages, in which case it might be beneficial to remove the tree before this becomes an issue.

CrotchetyQuaver · 07/10/2021 20:28

I think I'd be talking with the tenants and offering to share the cost of getting it felled

SpiderinaWingMirror · 07/10/2021 20:10

Agree. If he will allow it, pay the 3k to have it taken down. Can't see that he has any legal obligation at all.

NoSquirrels · 07/10/2021 20:07

Well, the LL owner is never going to deal with it.

The council won’t do anything unless it’s dangerous.

So, is it worth up to £3K to you?

(What do the £3K quotes involve - is this to cut it down, raise the canopy, reduce in height, what?)

Aprilx · 07/10/2021 19:41

Unfortunately the answer to your question is that maybe you should have dealt with it ten years ago as you are the ones that it bothered. If the landlord doesn’t want to cut it down they are not likely to be made to, I think you and the other neighbours that it bothers May need to club together.

FreshFreesias · 07/10/2021 19:30

@ThreeLittleDots What a horrible comment.
Some people have no soul.
Roundup should be banned.

SewingWarriorQueen76 · 07/10/2021 19:27

Is it a Leilandii? There is a lot of info on those quick growing trees

Skysblue · 07/10/2021 17:23

I think all you can do is probably pay a tree surgeon to lop off any branches that cross into the air above your property.

But a solicitor might have other ideas eg nuisance / is it restricting your legal right to peaceful enjoyment of your property. Is also possible that a legal neighbour dispute might be covered by your home insurance. If was me I’d pay for a quick chat with a lawyer who knows about the tort law of nuisance etc.

Is possible that if the landlord starts getting lawyer letters he might decide is easier to fell tree than to defend a claim…

IveGotASongThatllGetOnYNerves · 07/10/2021 17:21

That picture is really pretty.
I'd rather have a nice view of trees and need my light on than a view of houses but don't need my light on.

this is the view from my bedroom window. In the winter when the trees have no leaves on them it is dull.

AIBU to think my neighbour should have dealt with this tree 10 years ago
Whatamesssss · 07/10/2021 16:18

But a chainsaw and some rope and chop off the lower branches to raise the canopy.

What tree is it?

ThreeLittleDots · 07/10/2021 16:12

LOL

Moneysavvymam · 07/10/2021 16:05

@ThreeLittleDots

I would certainly not advise anyone to bore holes into the bark, injecting it with neat Roundup before covering the holes over again, causing it to die, become dangerous and forcing the LL to fell it.
Some people on this site are just plain stupid and reckless
RainbowCrossing · 07/10/2021 16:01

I mean if someone wanted to erect a building. Not if one grew there...

RainbowCrossing · 07/10/2021 16:01

Don't you have a right to light? I know if it were a building you would...

beinglikedisoverrated · 07/10/2021 15:59

Could you go half with the tenant neighbour?

MargaretThursday · 07/10/2021 15:53

@ThreeLittleDots

I would certainly not advise anyone to bore holes into the bark, injecting it with neat Roundup before covering the holes over again, causing it to die, become dangerous and forcing the LL to fell it.
Killing/getting rid of the tree will mean that the roots shrink and the whole building may be at risk of subsidence, possible quite severely depending on the type of tree/depth of roots etc. So yes, it would be a spectacularly stupid thing to do.
ThreeLittleDots · 07/10/2021 15:45

I would certainly not advise anyone to bore holes into the bark, injecting it with neat Roundup before covering the holes over again, causing it to die, become dangerous and forcing the LL to fell it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread