Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think working class is not synonymous with 'poor'?

164 replies

lolliwillowes · 07/10/2021 14:32

I know a fairly diverse range of people and have lived an several places where there has been an even mix of social and cultural backgrounds - both rural and urban.

I was just reading a diet/science thread from a few months ago and there is a lot of discussion surround poverty and obesity (which I am certain is true), except many people classified 'poverty' and 'working class'.

I think this is a really odd presumption. I have met many poor MC and well off WC and it has been unpredictable to say the least. The main difference between these groups have mostly been in their tastes, beliefs, interests, and behaviours, not cash flow.
The poorest people I have witnessed were possibly originally in one of the above social groups, but to presume poverty is synonymous with being working class is problematic.

I suppose if one has only ever existed in a very wealthy environment then the presumption may seem genuine, but I'm quite certain it is not. I would personally say that I have observed that different social groups respond differently to poverty, hence creating these stereotypes. Typical WC jobs tend to pay less, that is for certain, but it still seems odd to associate poverty with a group that regularly earns and owns property.

Is there an extra group which fits the definition better? I don't know. What I do know is that noting is simple - I grew up MC, the environment, the education, but have rented all of my life through choice (I am an artist and like to move around), so some may presume, on paper, I am something other than what I am, until they meet me and chat!

I would conclude that much of this lies with education, and I don't just mean academically. Cultural and social capital, and having learned how to react in a crisis, both in the home and later, at school. Many don't have that privilege and never learn how.

OP posts:
Sn0tnose · 07/10/2021 22:22

I think that there are limbos between the classes. Some of the posters on here who are describing their education and their home ownership sound pretty posh to me, so I’m not sure I’d consider them working class. They’d stick out like a sore thumb where I live. But having read some of the mc attitudes on here, I don’t necessarily think they’d be accepted as middle class either.

freelions · 07/10/2021 22:20

@TractorAndHeadphones most of the time I don't know or care whether people are WC or MC (or aristocrats for that matter!)

If the person is a good friend then chances are I will know a bit about their background so will have an idea of whether they have WC or MC roots but it really isn't something I spend much time thinking about and I certainly don't judge friends and acquaintances on their upbringing as it is obviously something that none of us having any choice in!

nancy75 · 07/10/2021 22:17

It’s interesting how the class lines have blurred.
Take the example of ‘celebrity’ plumber Charlie Mullins - brought up on a council estate in total absolute poverty, left school with limited education & now worth many millions of pounds - he definitely was working class, is he now? Can you move up (or down) a class?
My own parents ( dad especially) very poor upbringing (14 kids in a 3 bed council flat, dad in & out of prison) now worth a considerable amount. Parents live a very comfortable life but as soon as you heard either one of them speak you would know they were working class.

Bluntness100 · 07/10/2021 22:16

Some people on here are really obsessed with class in real life I’ve never met a person who gives it a second thought

Snd op if you were genuinely curious you’d have read some more articles and seen many that define working class like that, but that’s not as fun is it

I honestly think it’d the same posters whi name change and keep starting these threads.

ZednotZee · 07/10/2021 22:16

I thought working class is defined by non home-owning, non- Uni educated manual worker.

Well that was the case a couple of generations ago I suppose.
Half of the WC now own property and have been to university if aged under forty or so.
All of my family are second generation homeowners and most of my generation have degrees; teaching/nursing/social sciences/business etc.

Anycolourwilldo · 07/10/2021 22:15

Yes, they are definitely separate. I know some middle class families without a penny to spare but live a certain way (off-grid) because they know deep down they have family wealth if really needed.
On the other hand, I know working class families with newly acquired wealth who just seem to do things a bit differently to middle class families (obsession with cleaning / winter sun / big cars).

Alpacinoshoohaa · 07/10/2021 22:14

It's all changed now working class is very different to what it was supposedly categorised as.

What I have noticed is really the new wc or below are actually people with many different sen that have not been diagnosed at all so they have a simply been left without an education, often extremely bright, sometimes not. But they have fallen through our education system.

On another note in my family, df side don't value education at all but they are cash rich. They have a holiday home in tenerife and a caravan in Tenby. They rarely venture anywhere else.

They don't really read books or go to the theatre etc.
They seem to be very narrow in what they like or do. The other side where much poorer but valued eduction to a massive degree, and a large poor Catholic family became very educated, music, literature and they simply seem more interesting to be around in terms of conversation and life style etc.
Some now have more modest homes than the other side, some far larger but nealry all are world wide travelers and enjoy the arts.
I can't help but feel their lives are richer.

TractorAndHeadphones · 07/10/2021 22:12

@freelions

Working class is absolutely not synonymous with 'poor' but when it comes to making links between poverty and obesity it is likely that a lack of education (both formal and by having parents who taught you to shop, cook, budget etc) is going to compound the problems causes by a lack of money

I come from a fairly MC background and am confident that even if money was really tight this would not cause me to become obese because I know how to cook nutritious meals with basic and cheap ingredients

Obviously there are people from MC backgrounds who can't cook or budget and people from WC backgrounds who are brilliant cooks but on a population level people with a more WC background are less likely to have benefited from a decent education and parents who had the time, knowledge and inclination to pass on important life skills

In addition if you come from a MC background you are far more likely to have friends or family who can help you out if you end up in financial dire straits

Ok, but how do you know whether people are MC or WC?
freelions · 07/10/2021 22:06

Working class is absolutely not synonymous with 'poor' but when it comes to making links between poverty and obesity it is likely that a lack of education (both formal and by having parents who taught you to shop, cook, budget etc) is going to compound the problems causes by a lack of money

I come from a fairly MC background and am confident that even if money was really tight this would not cause me to become obese because I know how to cook nutritious meals with basic and cheap ingredients

Obviously there are people from MC backgrounds who can't cook or budget and people from WC backgrounds who are brilliant cooks but on a population level people with a more WC background are less likely to have benefited from a decent education and parents who had the time, knowledge and inclination to pass on important life skills

In addition if you come from a MC background you are far more likely to have friends or family who can help you out if you end up in financial dire straits

FindingMeno · 07/10/2021 22:06

I thought working class is defined by non home-owning, non- Uni educated manual worker.

TractorAndHeadphones · 07/10/2021 22:04

WC not MC sorry

TractorAndHeadphones · 07/10/2021 22:03

@BarbaraofSeville because as part of diversity initiatives there's an attempt to 'open' things up to 'WC'.
KPMG has openly announce its intention to recruite more 'MC' workers.
The LSE has a Social Mobility officer who's supposed to represent the WC.

as with everything it's an oversimplification using outdated notions. With the abundance of degrees not everyone having one will be walking into a well paid job. While a shortage of people in 'WC' professions (HGV drivers, tube drivers anyone?) mean that they can be far more financially privielged.

Come to think of it - the TRUE defintion of WC maybe be as pp mentioned be related to mindset. But you can't measure people's mindsets can you? So the proxies of income and education levels are used which (when one is high and the other low) may not reflect the truth of whether a background is 'deprived' enough to merit special consideration to improve 'diversity'.

Just like how a lot of participants of big graduate employer racial diversity programmes are the children of rich international students/migrant professionals , not the born and bred British BAME brought up on council estates.

Spidey66 · 07/10/2021 22:03

Sorry to clarify my brother is the only one with an income like our dad's.

We werent rich when I was a kid but we weren't poor. We owned our home and car etc. My brothers went to independent schools via scholarships but this was then stopped by the LEA so me and my sister went to a comprehensive.

THisbackwithavengeance · 07/10/2021 22:02

The builder that did our loft drives an Audi convertible at weekends (when not in his van) and lives in a house easily worth £750k and this is the North of England. The new housing estate up from the road from me with lovely 4 and 5 bedroomed detached houses have all been bought by tradesmen - their vans are all parked up at weekends.

I am desperately trying to persuade my kids to be plumbers and sparkies, none of your middle class nonsense here!

therespectablecardigan · 07/10/2021 22:02

@GoodnightGrandma it is the common term, but the actual posh girls hadn't heard it used before, so declared it as old fashioned and posh 😂

Spidey66 · 07/10/2021 21:56

Class has nothing to do with money. My late father had virtually no education and could barely read and write, but had a strong work ethic. He worked in the building trade and was very successful.

I'm one of 4, all of us have either degrees or professional qualifications. Only 1 (my brother) has anywhere near the same income. Most people would describe our professions as MC but our incomes don't, but our dad was the opposite

TractorAndHeadphones · 07/10/2021 21:56

@SprayedWithDettol

The fact that there isn’t any true consensus on what working class or middle class really means would suggest that they are redundant markers for ‘labelling’ sections of society.
Yes exactly. Also to people saying 'class' is a reality of British society - that may be true but it's much more nuanced than the binary 'working class poor, middle class privileged/rich'. Another example that comes to mind is a friend's relative - a plumber who owns his own business no higher education. His wife is a science graduate whose father went to uni (a big deal in those days!) but is a counsellor and doesn't earn very much. Unlike her husband. What class are they? Out of their 3 children one went to Oxbridge to study classics and is now in the Civil Service, very 'MC' based on all the stereotypes down to the accent. She married an investment banker and is very comfortable there. Her wining, dining and networking abilites would put anybody to shame. One is a farm worker and has a strong 'WC' accent. Is not interested or able to converse about anything other than farm related stuff. Also no higher ed. I have no idea how his accent sounds v different. The other child is only interested in video games, watching a couple of sports and nothing else. Quite an introvert, not many friends. Has a degree but not ambitious, lives in a houseshare and does admin with a small local firm with no desire for anything else. He doesn't earn much but enough to fund his current lifestyle.

What class are all of these three? The first seems clearly MC, the second WC, and the third works in an easily replaceable job with not much income but has a degree.

What is the point of WC and MC by themselves being used as indicators of privilege or otherwise?

GoodnightGrandma · 07/10/2021 21:52

@therespectablecardigan

Must add that dd got bullied in school for saying settee as that was posh apparently, but I learned on MN that that is aspirational!
I though settee was common, and couch was posh !!!
Riada · 07/10/2021 21:49

@Tippexy

I think the issue is that you have so many middle class people adamant that they are working class.

For example I have a family member, they have just sold their house for £500k and her husband earns six figures, but no, they are working class! I also know a couple of “working class” Professors who have about four degrees each 😂

I have four degrees, and while I’m also an academic, I’d probably identify as ‘educated WC’. When you grow up with barely literate parents working in low paid jobs, living in fairly severe deprivation, education, working in a MC profession, and liking opera doesn’t necessarily alter your sense of your own class status.
therespectablecardigan · 07/10/2021 21:47

Must add that dd got bullied in school for saying settee as that was posh apparently, but I learned on MN that that is aspirational!

therespectablecardigan · 07/10/2021 21:45

It's only really on MN I see this class obsession.
I'm educated to masters level, live in naice area, dc attend the grammar school. I consider hummus, OLIVES and avocado as everyday foods. I'm also on full benefits, dc get FSM due to me being a full time carer for disabled ds. I think I'm now considered underclass on MN.

elbea · 07/10/2021 21:43

I don’t think it’s really much of a thing anymore. I was born to teenage parents, my dad had a trade. Grandparents were factory workers and still live in the most deprived borough in the country. Now my dad owns his own company, has a fleet of expensive classic cars and a number of boats and yachts.

I was born into a working class family but have a degree, (the first in my family) and well paid job that was traditionally an upper middle job (Estate Manager). My husband comes from a historically titled family that can trace their family back a thousand years. Social mobility now means that people aren’t limited to their birth circumstances.

BarbaraofSeville · 07/10/2021 21:36

@MythicalBiologicalFennel

Social class is very real and inescapable in British society. We probably need new labels, especially for these groups:

White-collar professionals in jobs that don't pay much. They might call themselves working class in that they need to work for a living- but are probably degree-educated, ballet and horseriding lessons blah di blah

Manual workers in jobs that are in great demand (plumbers etc swimming in cash)

People in precarious, low-paid employment ("the working poor" I suppose?)

People out of work, living in social housing and dependent on state benefits long-term.

All of the above could be described as working class but they have nothing to do with the traditional "salt of the earth" type.

But why label people at all? I can see why separating people into groups like those would be useful for service provision or advertising but I can't see the use in labelling people as working/middle class when no-one can agree what it means.

I also think there's a lot of confusion amongst people who call themselves MC about what they think WC people are like, interested in, value etc. A lot of the time it's exactly the same as MC people, there's no distinction. But somehow a lot of the MC people seem to think that WC people behave/think differently to how they do.

GoodnightGrandma · 07/10/2021 21:25

I don’t know what class I would be, it’s not something I think about.

ZednotZee · 07/10/2021 21:24

@lolliwillowes

They are a different type of WC to my family who have fully embraced my uncle who is a now quite a renowned contemporary choreographer.
Then again, they don't have an issue articulating themselves or understanding those who are themselves articulate.