Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think working class is not synonymous with 'poor'?

164 replies

lolliwillowes · 07/10/2021 14:32

I know a fairly diverse range of people and have lived an several places where there has been an even mix of social and cultural backgrounds - both rural and urban.

I was just reading a diet/science thread from a few months ago and there is a lot of discussion surround poverty and obesity (which I am certain is true), except many people classified 'poverty' and 'working class'.

I think this is a really odd presumption. I have met many poor MC and well off WC and it has been unpredictable to say the least. The main difference between these groups have mostly been in their tastes, beliefs, interests, and behaviours, not cash flow.
The poorest people I have witnessed were possibly originally in one of the above social groups, but to presume poverty is synonymous with being working class is problematic.

I suppose if one has only ever existed in a very wealthy environment then the presumption may seem genuine, but I'm quite certain it is not. I would personally say that I have observed that different social groups respond differently to poverty, hence creating these stereotypes. Typical WC jobs tend to pay less, that is for certain, but it still seems odd to associate poverty with a group that regularly earns and owns property.

Is there an extra group which fits the definition better? I don't know. What I do know is that noting is simple - I grew up MC, the environment, the education, but have rented all of my life through choice (I am an artist and like to move around), so some may presume, on paper, I am something other than what I am, until they meet me and chat!

I would conclude that much of this lies with education, and I don't just mean academically. Cultural and social capital, and having learned how to react in a crisis, both in the home and later, at school. Many don't have that privilege and never learn how.

OP posts:
pinkhampoppy · 08/10/2021 08:41

@Seesawmummadaw

I find it all really fascinating. I love the different opinions on class.
Ha! Yes, it's all just opinion...
elbea · 08/10/2021 08:23

@Lockdownbear Those jobs all have huge variations. I’m a qualified surveyor but my last admin job as a PA paid £60,000 per annum. My father is a millionaire and also a tradesman.

They are outdated now and don’t really have relevance in everyday life. The only difference maybe is upper class but even then it isn’t really as exclusive as it once was. My husbands family would be described as upper class. Long established family history, lots of family money but he has chosen a working class job out of duty. He could have not worked like the rest of his family if he wanted but has the complete security of his family as a backup. These established class systems were once immovable but aren’t now.

A hundred years ago I would have probably worked in service for my husbands family, they live in absolute poverty in Liverpool and it would have been a scandal. Now nobody cares who my husband married.

speakupattheback · 08/10/2021 08:22

There's also upper middle class, aspiring middle class, lower middle class. What there is not is aspirating upper class. One is born upper class. Even the PP with an upper class life, will not be seen by UC people as UC. Her children may, if her capital continues to grow and if they inhabit a relentlessly UC world.

Class exists in the UK. We all "know" it when we meet someone from "our" or another class. It doesn't mean we cannot befriends with or love someone outside our class, but that there will be big and small differences in attitudes and beliefs. EG For WC, buying used goods is a sign of poverty so often avoided. For MC it's a sign that their other attributes so evidently cancel any sense that used goods mean WC, that they do buy them. EG upper middle class would go to say an opera, and know the opera, and be happy it was in Italian say: while lower Mc hi but would feel uncomfortable/self conscious: WC people would not go.

Mumoblue · 08/10/2021 08:02

Eh, if you’re spending much time trying to figure out if you’re working class or middle class- you’re probably middle class.

I’ve always considered myself working class when the topic has been bought up, but found out through reading this thread that I’m actually “underclass”. That’s just fab.

The UK’s obsession with class is fucking weird. Hmm

BarbaraofSeville · 08/10/2021 07:43

^There's also the availability of food and access to cook it (appliances and fuel) to consider, as well as time - a low paid worker is less likely to turn down extra hours and be working awkward shifts (look up shift worker syndrome, it's a 'thing' and shift workers, especially nights, are at higher risk of all sorts, including obesity) and less likely to have a set routine, especially if they're on a zero hour contract.

My local co-op does a deal for £5 which is usually pizza, chicken dippers, chips, waffles etc, ice cream and a token bag of veg. It costs more than that to buy fresh chicken, potatoes and veg, which is going to take longer and therefore more fuel to cook, a much healthier alternative, but if you've got hungry people, are knackered after 12 hours shifts at strange times, and you've got to keep enough electric on to the end of the month and only £20 to last until then, what you buy is a bit of a no brainer really^

But many poor people have more time because they're poor because they can't get enough work.

And conversely, many well off people work long irregular hours, with days/nights/weekends etc eg doctors, pilots, a lot of engineers and maintenance staff in utilities, chemical plants etc. Shift worker syndrome is a known health risk, but many shift workers are well paid its not all NMW zero hours.

Plus this 'the poor are overweight because they can only afford cheap processed food' is almost uniquely seen in people of white British heritage, and the US, those where English is the first language perhaps.

Pretty much everywhere else, people cook a great range of simple cheap dishes, that often take little in terms of time, fuel or even fresh ingredients to cook, eg many Italian pasta dishes and soups can be made with dried pasta, canned tomatoes, canned fish, preserved olives/capers and a bit of oil. Or dhals with lentils and cheap dried spices, whatever cheap in season veg is available served with rice. Money or time is rarely the primary barrier to eating well and staying a healthy weight on a budget.

traumatisednoodle · 08/10/2021 06:29

From the Marmot Review

To think working class is not synonymous with 'poor'?
traumatisednoodle · 08/10/2021 06:20

To go back to your OP, obesity shows an almost perfect inverse correlation with income. So the poorer you are the more likely you are to be obese.

I agree that social class is defined by much more than income (traditionally by your profession), I think you are also right that it takes a couple of generations to really change class. The Duchess of Cambridge's mother was born lower middle class her children were UMC but her grandchildren are aristocrats. However this amount of social mobility is rare and sadly becoming less common.

Maverickess · 08/10/2021 03:10

@freelions

Working class is absolutely not synonymous with 'poor' but when it comes to making links between poverty and obesity it is likely that a lack of education (both formal and by having parents who taught you to shop, cook, budget etc) is going to compound the problems causes by a lack of money

I come from a fairly MC background and am confident that even if money was really tight this would not cause me to become obese because I know how to cook nutritious meals with basic and cheap ingredients

Obviously there are people from MC backgrounds who can't cook or budget and people from WC backgrounds who are brilliant cooks but on a population level people with a more WC background are less likely to have benefited from a decent education and parents who had the time, knowledge and inclination to pass on important life skills

In addition if you come from a MC background you are far more likely to have friends or family who can help you out if you end up in financial dire straits

There's also the availability of food and access to cook it (appliances and fuel) to consider, as well as time - a low paid worker is less likely to turn down extra hours and be working awkward shifts (look up shift worker syndrome, it's a 'thing' and shift workers, especially nights, are at higher risk of all sorts, including obesity) and less likely to have a set routine, especially if they're on a zero hour contract.

My local co-op does a deal for £5 which is usually pizza, chicken dippers, chips, waffles etc, ice cream and a token bag of veg. It costs more than that to buy fresh chicken, potatoes and veg, which is going to take longer and therefore more fuel to cook, a much healthier alternative, but if you've got hungry people, are knackered after 12 hours shifts at strange times, and you've got to keep enough electric on to the end of the month and only £20 to last until then, what you buy is a bit of a no brainer really.

Underclass, people who survive on benefits.

Working class, blue collar manual workers, tradesmen, labourers, cleaners. Secretarial / receptionist type roles. Often hourly paid with poor Terms & Conditions.

These two classes have blurred imo because of the necessity of tax credits (and now UC) to be bridging the gap between wages and cost of living.

Lockdownbear · 08/10/2021 01:38

I'd agree it pigeon holes people making it hard to go up the ladder. The lack of tolerance is definitely a MC thing, along with keeping up with the Jones or trying to be the Jones

Anordinarymum · 08/10/2021 01:33

I have a problem with the class system. It stifles people. It stops people from being able to connect.
My mother's parents were upstanding members of the community. They had a maid. My mother and her sisters were privately educated
My father's parents were working class. My grandmother could barely read or write and had worked in the mill.
My Grandfather was a sportsman and quite famous
My father was privately educated
One set of parents looked down on the other, and had no right to do so. It fucked up my parents marriage, and my mother was crippled by how she acted and spoke, and her lack of tolerance for anyone who she considered to be beneath her socially when in fact we were so poor, the working class neighbours had a better standard of living then us.
My grandmother who was looked upon as being lower class and therefore thick was the best person I have ever known and comfortable in her own skin despite being looked down upon and knowing it.

What a fuck up

Lockdownbear · 08/10/2021 01:31

Middle class includes doctors, lawyers, accountants, engineers, surveyors, teachers.
People who had higher education before degrees were common place.

DroopyClematis · 08/10/2021 01:25

I always thought, according to history, that the working class meant anyone who had to earn money to live. Upper classes were people ( generally nobility) who lived on 'old' money, ie inherited wealth.

Middle class people were a relatively new class ( mainly Victorians) who made money from working class people and could live off the profits of their entrepreneurship.

donttrustanyoneever · 08/10/2021 01:19

Am disabled. Disability class is poor.

Lockdownbear · 08/10/2021 01:13

I thought they were defined as

Underclass, people who survive on benefits.

Working class, blue collar manual workers, tradesmen, labourers, cleaners. Secretarial / receptionist type roles. Often hourly paid with poor Terms & Conditions.

Middle class, Degree educated, professional roles, teachers, lawyers, doctors. Usually salaried, stable income, job security and better terms & Conditions.

Upper classes, Often money passed down, business owners, elite,

What difference does any of it make, it can be very difficult to budget on hourly paid money, that might vary weekly, illness is likely only to be SSP.
Banks are loathed to lend to hourly paid people making it difficult to get mortgages.

Lockdownbear · 08/10/2021 00:36

@Waxonwaxoff0

YANBU. My ex husband is working class and not poor, he earns over £60k driving trains. You don't suddenly change class when your financial status changes.

I am working class and earn less than £10 an hour but due to good fortune I own my own home as a single person. I do not think of myself as poor, I don't have to worry about paying the bills.

I have a middle class friend who works as a teacher earning more than me but rents a room in a flat share.

Would you class an Airline Pilot working class? Before planes Engine Drivers held the same status.
SD1978 · 08/10/2021 00:30

The class thing that the UK is obsessed with is no longer that straightforward. As others have said- people earning millions claiming to be working class, even someone on here (not a dig) whose husband earns £60,000 as a skilled train driver saying it's a working class job. The classifications don't work anymore. Working class was low skilled, low paid. Lower standard of living, usually less focus on education and earlier school leaving. Now it's a badge of honour to 'prove' your working classness, whilst having none of the difficulties which being truly a low income, low skill, usually early school leaver with no career but a job, actually entails.

elbea · 07/10/2021 23:30

@Alpacinoshoohaa what a thing to say - for clarity people who have stereotypically working class jobs don’t all have learning difficulties. I know quite a few white collar professionals who have dyslexia or ASD.

Just because people chose to do manual jobs doesn’t mean they have learning difficulties. My husband left his international career and all his degrees behind and now works in what might be described as a working class job. It was entirely his choice and he earns significantly less but enjoys his job a lot more.

womaninatightspot · 07/10/2021 23:21

@lolliwillowes

If I was a fully employed working class (renter or homeowner - because renting is expensive unless you receive assistance) adult I would feel confused. Seeing people online refer to WC as obese and poor.

I just want to add that I obviously do not assign any judgement value to any these groups, hence I do not consider poverty to be beneath me.

I would also like to know what defines an 'underclass'? How does it form and progress? Is it created by the system or a result of handed down values, etc? We all know most of us could experience poverty to some degree in a lifetime, but I do wonder what creates a class that is considered beneath....class.

Thanks for sharing your thoughts.

The underclass is the segment of the population below the working class generally classified by long term unemployment. I didn't know that there was an underclass until I was at Uni.
ACPC · 07/10/2021 23:12

Yanbu. I'm from a MC background, parents and siblings all professionals with degrees, none of us have earned anywhere close to my WC dh. He's a bricklayer. I agree with a pp though, none of this matters as it's the upper classes who hold all the big cards as it always has been.

Beancounter1 · 07/10/2021 23:02

So many people here trying to tease out what is middle class and what is working class / lower class / underclass
And more people pretending that class doesn't matter (tip - it does!)
And some people saying they read about it on MN but no-one in real life talks about it - well that is because it is socially taboo, even more so that striking up a casual conversation about death or sex.

What really matters is the upper class. They know who they are, they know who each other are, and they know that you are not one of them.
They own most of the land, run almost everything, and try their very best to remain invisible. They try to pretend class doesn't matter in this day and age, whilst silently defending to the hilt their own class privilege and exclusivity.
I can't see that we can do much about it though - it goes too deep in our society.

rossclare · 07/10/2021 22:51

I class myself as middle class, from a working class background (Dad was East End, large family living in 2 rooms, Mum similar). They 'bettered' themselves and i grew up in a 4 bed detached.

I now own my business, private school for my 2 children, private health, 3 foreign hols etc etc, lots of property.

On paper we could perhaps be described as upper-middle but i would never describe or think of myself as that.

Social class definitely goes beyond money.

EmeraldShamrock · 07/10/2021 22:42

No, not at all.
We're working class, my Dbro is a millionaire he is a builder by trade, my Dsis is an accountant/landlord of 4 properties.
They haven't changed, both proud WC.

Money doesn't change class, unfortunately some people get notions about money and believe it puts them in a new league.

Similarly some mc people lose their money but that doesn't make them wc they've all the traits of their upbringing regardless of their bank balance.

The Underclass fits this definition. This is my background. I grew up in a council house with a single mother on benefits. I had FSM throughout my entire school career, and most of my clothes and toys were secondhand (through necessity, not because of fashion hmm). Most of my childhood friends were also in the underclass with similar living standards to me.
Underclass - fucking hell. Who labels people like that it is vile. Shock

AnnieSnap · 07/10/2021 22:33

@girlmom21

I don't classes are even a thing anymore really, are they?
They absolutely are. It’s about power and control over your life!
AnnieSnap · 07/10/2021 22:30

No definition of working class sees it as poverty. Working class is either working in a non-professional job where the worker and their family has no control over their terms and conditions, whether or not they have the job etc. Middle class is not about having a particular income, but rather having some control of income. That may come from being a professional such that their skills can be marketed independently or owning the business.

Riada · 07/10/2021 22:28

@Bluntness100

Some people on here are really obsessed with class in real life I’ve never met a person who gives it a second thought

Snd op if you were genuinely curious you’d have read some more articles and seen many that define working class like that, but that’s not as fun is it

I honestly think it’d the same posters whi name change and keep starting these threads.

I think it’s like that slightly odd recent thread by a poster who claimed she’d never come across the acronym ‘SAHM’’ (which she thought was pronounced ‘sarm’) outside of Mn, because she lived in a bubble where no women worked, hence the term SAHM was redundant. Because most people don’t talk explicitly about social class, and people are franker about their class prejudices etc on an anonymous forum, some people think Mn invented social class.