Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think working class is not synonymous with 'poor'?

164 replies

lolliwillowes · 07/10/2021 14:32

I know a fairly diverse range of people and have lived an several places where there has been an even mix of social and cultural backgrounds - both rural and urban.

I was just reading a diet/science thread from a few months ago and there is a lot of discussion surround poverty and obesity (which I am certain is true), except many people classified 'poverty' and 'working class'.

I think this is a really odd presumption. I have met many poor MC and well off WC and it has been unpredictable to say the least. The main difference between these groups have mostly been in their tastes, beliefs, interests, and behaviours, not cash flow.
The poorest people I have witnessed were possibly originally in one of the above social groups, but to presume poverty is synonymous with being working class is problematic.

I suppose if one has only ever existed in a very wealthy environment then the presumption may seem genuine, but I'm quite certain it is not. I would personally say that I have observed that different social groups respond differently to poverty, hence creating these stereotypes. Typical WC jobs tend to pay less, that is for certain, but it still seems odd to associate poverty with a group that regularly earns and owns property.

Is there an extra group which fits the definition better? I don't know. What I do know is that noting is simple - I grew up MC, the environment, the education, but have rented all of my life through choice (I am an artist and like to move around), so some may presume, on paper, I am something other than what I am, until they meet me and chat!

I would conclude that much of this lies with education, and I don't just mean academically. Cultural and social capital, and having learned how to react in a crisis, both in the home and later, at school. Many don't have that privilege and never learn how.

OP posts:
massistar · 08/10/2021 13:04

@Rosesareyellow I just find myself out of step sometimes with my lovely MC friends. Eg. Huge monetary rewards for getting good GCSEs after tutoring them to that point. I told my son that his good grades were reward in themselves as they were for his benefit. My children have jobs so they can buy themselves designer gear if they want it. I'm hyper aware of them becoming entitled because they grow up in this lovely little MC bubble.

mewkins · 08/10/2021 13:03

@EmeraldShamrock

I class myself as middle class, from a working class background. I don't believe that is possible. You might live a middle class lifestyle but you're not middle class. I'm sure MC people would agree with me. We had a neighbour who was born MC educated sophisticated she was disabled so financially poor living in a working class area, that lady couldn't be wc if she tried. She had impeccable manners and a posh posture, we loved that lady. Similarly a wc person may be educated making good money live in an affluent area but they're still working class for a few generations based on real class not the newly defined class massaging ones ego.
Ah so it's impeccable manners and good posture that makes you middle class. I had always wondered....
Twelveshoes · 08/10/2021 12:51

Of course you can be middle class from a working class background. My parents are.

And I am working class from a middle class background.

EmeraldShamrock · 08/10/2021 12:46

I class myself as middle class, from a working class background.
I don't believe that is possible.
You might live a middle class lifestyle but you're not middle class.
I'm sure MC people would agree with me.
We had a neighbour who was born MC educated sophisticated she was disabled so financially poor living in a working class area, that lady couldn't be wc if she tried.
She had impeccable manners and a posh posture, we loved that lady.
Similarly a wc person may be educated making good money live in an affluent area but they're still working class for a few generations based on real class not the newly defined class massaging ones ego.

Rosesareyellow · 08/10/2021 12:29

But I still have a very strong regional accent and what I can only describe as working class values.

@massistar what are they?

massistar · 08/10/2021 12:13

I grew up on a council estate and went to a shit school but managed to get myself to Uni and have a good professional job that pays well. But I still have a very strong regional accent and what I can only describe as working class values.

But given that my children are growing up in a lovely area, go to a very nice school snd go on regular ski holidays it would be disingenuous of me to describe our family as working class.

So I prefer not to describe myself in terms of class at all. As a PP said it's the upper classes who still rule this bloody country anyway!

mewkins · 08/10/2021 12:05

@speakupattheback

Katie Price not working class???
What makes her 'working class'?

What does she having in common with someone who eg. Works in a supermarket or drives a lorry?

BogRollBOGOF · 08/10/2021 12:05

Class is more about the package of education, culture and experience than pure income.

It is important to recognise the trends of class and their consequences.
Two children of equal ability in a leafy suburb and struggling inner city school are very likely to have different outcomes of where they progress to. Leafy suburb school is more likely to push towards better esteemed universities and understand their application processes. Their equivilent is more likely to have barriers of contacts who know the system, affordability of going to university, and even the push that university is for "someone like them".
A child who is struggling with a SEN like dyslexia is more likely to get it recognised if their parents are well educated and unfortunately now, diagnosis is often avaliable to those with spare £££. How many children of working and underclass backgrounds are failed because SENs are not recognised, diagnosed and supported. SENs can be part of the "normal" culture of a family and it's hard to see when a child is repeating those family patterns, and where they affect educational outcomes they can get tangled up in the whole cycle of life through a family and affect family confidence with societal systems.

On a population level, there are clear correlations of class and outcomes of education and health. Traditions can be supportive, or they can be restrictive and stiffling.

Social mobility has stalled since the later half of the 20th century.
My dad had a very working class background in what was verging on slums. Bright lad, his biggest regret was not going to grammar school and following his friends to the secondary modern. He worked his way up through night school and worked his way up from the shop floor of factories to the top of management. It was his social skills that made him and he managed the duality of maintaining his working class roots and integrating with the upper middle class management. That kind of progression is harder to achieve today with university being a springboard partway in and more separation of practical experience and qualifications.

FourTeaFallOut · 08/10/2021 12:05

I've seen a million formulations when it comes to markers of class here, but temperament? Really? That's a first.

dashoflime · 08/10/2021 12:01

"Certain working class people could never rise above lower-middle class, no matter what they earned. Others might have the right temperament to become middle class proper"

I think this is my favorite ever Mumsnet quote

lockdownmadnessdotcom · 08/10/2021 12:00

And more people pretending that class doesn't matter (tip - it does

It doesn't. Wealth does.

lockdownmadnessdotcom · 08/10/2021 11:56

I define working class as people who need to work for a living. I absolutely think it is to do with wealth or lack of it.

Apparently though, if you like football you are working class (despite season tickets costing a fortune) but if you like opera you have "cultural capital" and are middle class. Utter nonsense.

Lockdownbear · 08/10/2021 11:53

I'd agree boundaries aren't clear and some more blurry than ever.
Doctor is definitely a MC profession.
Health care assistant is working class.

Nurses - I'm sure in the past they'd be classed as WC. But the role has become more highly skilled, taking on work that would have been Doctors in the past are they now firmly a MC profession?

I don't know any of it makes any difference however I do think there are mindset differences between WC and MC.

I think MC are more likely to want to climb the tree, where WC possibly get to the got their trade stage and happy to keep at that level.
Obviously not everyone is the same and some jobs it's easier to get promotion than in others.

speakupattheback · 08/10/2021 11:50

Katie Price not working class???

mewkins · 08/10/2021 11:36

@MythicalBiologicalFennel

All of these mean you really can't define class. So the differences between Katie Price and Kate Middleton are....

Hair colour
Eye colour
Age
Qualifications

Right?

Sorry to be so stark. Social class is not a judgement on people's character but it definitely exists and is particularly suffocating in the UK.

I'm not saying there are no differences between people. But more that there are NO clear boundaries. I would definitely NOT describe Katie Price as working class. Nor Kate Middleton as middle class.
MythicalBiologicalFennel · 08/10/2021 11:33

All of these mean you really can't define class.
So the differences between Katie Price and Kate Middleton are....

Hair colour
Eye colour
Age
Qualifications

Right?

Sorry to be so stark. Social class is not a judgement on people's character but it definitely exists and is particularly suffocating in the UK.

HarrietsChariot · 08/10/2021 11:32

YABU I'm afraid. Working class does indeed mean you are poor. If you are working and earn a comfortable amount, you are lower-middle class.

Working class means either on benefits or in low paid jobs, minimum wage and zero hours, that type of thing. You work to survive and just about get by.

There's the social aspect too of course, it's not just money. Certain working class people could never rise above lower-middle class, no matter what they earned. Others might have the right temperament to become middle class proper.

There's overlap and it's not a hard-and-fast rule.

FindingMeno · 08/10/2021 11:27

Class is a thing, it does matter, and you do notice if you fall into my definition of working class.
The divide is very obvious when you're a minimum wage tenant, with little opportunity for upward progression because of lack of further/ higher education certificates.

FourTeaFallOut · 08/10/2021 11:01

No. Of course not. There are lots of WC jobs that command good wages. Most of which don't involved being tethered to the most expensive housing in the country.

mewkins · 08/10/2021 11:01

@girlmom21

I don't classes are even a thing anymore really, are they?
I was going to say the same. I studied sociology in the late 90s and early 00s and 'class' definitions had pretty much been abandoned then. We no longer have a set of jobs which are working class and middle class. Everything is much more fluid. Weird housing booms, rise in divorce rates or people not marrying at all, increase in kids from the ' working classes' going to university etc and meeting, mixing and partnering with people from across the spectrum. All of these mean you really can't define class.

Also the rise of random stuff like people making money from social media etc means that class is a really bizarre concept now.

Lockdownbear · 08/10/2021 10:59

@SinisterBumFacedCat if it's not being degree educated where would you say the line is between working and middle classes?

SinisterBumFacedCat · 08/10/2021 10:43

I think it’s a bit of a fallacy that middle class people are degree educated, I would say most people I know are middle class and most didn’t go to university but did well through work or property.

On paper you would say I had a working class upbringing, single mother, council estate etc but honestly it was actually quite a nice estate and I was encouraged to learn and explore my creativity at home. Both mum and I ended up in fairly middle class occupations.

It helps where you come from. Social mobility was made very easy for previous generations but I think we will start to see it become impossible again for many poorer people.

Lockdownbear · 08/10/2021 10:27

@elbea there are definitely overlaps in income, not all WC are poor equally not all middle class are rolling in it.

But once you go into management your definitely climbing into MC territory. Your DDad may well have started out as a tradesman, but when did he last physically pick up his tools rather than get someone else to do the physical work.

I have noticed a change that when they talk about tax and stuff they tend to lump working and middle classes together. Because money wise there is often little difference.

But as I say the biggest difference is in T&C, middle class salaried jobs are more likely to have sickness benefits, enhanced maternity & paternity pay, rather than working classes hourly paid who tend to end up relying on the basic state payments.

Another one is pensions all employers now need to provide pension plans but in the past working classes didn't have such things unless they were in nationalised industries with a good union backing them.

TractorAndHeadphones · 08/10/2021 08:57

Also to add OP I’m quite interested in all this as I’m heavily involved with diversity initiatives where I work. And there’s a lot of talk about ‘working class’ ones. Which make no sense.

TractorAndHeadphones · 08/10/2021 08:55

@speakupattheback

There's also upper middle class, aspiring middle class, lower middle class. What there is not is aspirating upper class. One is born upper class. Even the PP with an upper class life, will not be seen by UC people as UC. Her children may, if her capital continues to grow and if they inhabit a relentlessly UC world.

Class exists in the UK. We all "know" it when we meet someone from "our" or another class. It doesn't mean we cannot befriends with or love someone outside our class, but that there will be big and small differences in attitudes and beliefs. EG For WC, buying used goods is a sign of poverty so often avoided. For MC it's a sign that their other attributes so evidently cancel any sense that used goods mean WC, that they do buy them. EG upper middle class would go to say an opera, and know the opera, and be happy it was in Italian say: while lower Mc hi but would feel uncomfortable/self conscious: WC people would not go.

All of this may be true but the point is - is WC synonymous with poor? Can they be used interchangeably? From the perspective of social analysis and mobility schemes : If class is synonymous with poverty there’s no need to mention class at all. All diversity etc initiatives for the poor. If it’s not - how do you know who is WC? You cannot apply any subjective criteria. And if you use things like ‘ no university degree’ why is a millionaire plumber’s son deserving of any help or special places at all given that his life wasn’t deprived?