Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think working class is not synonymous with 'poor'?

164 replies

lolliwillowes · 07/10/2021 14:32

I know a fairly diverse range of people and have lived an several places where there has been an even mix of social and cultural backgrounds - both rural and urban.

I was just reading a diet/science thread from a few months ago and there is a lot of discussion surround poverty and obesity (which I am certain is true), except many people classified 'poverty' and 'working class'.

I think this is a really odd presumption. I have met many poor MC and well off WC and it has been unpredictable to say the least. The main difference between these groups have mostly been in their tastes, beliefs, interests, and behaviours, not cash flow.
The poorest people I have witnessed were possibly originally in one of the above social groups, but to presume poverty is synonymous with being working class is problematic.

I suppose if one has only ever existed in a very wealthy environment then the presumption may seem genuine, but I'm quite certain it is not. I would personally say that I have observed that different social groups respond differently to poverty, hence creating these stereotypes. Typical WC jobs tend to pay less, that is for certain, but it still seems odd to associate poverty with a group that regularly earns and owns property.

Is there an extra group which fits the definition better? I don't know. What I do know is that noting is simple - I grew up MC, the environment, the education, but have rented all of my life through choice (I am an artist and like to move around), so some may presume, on paper, I am something other than what I am, until they meet me and chat!

I would conclude that much of this lies with education, and I don't just mean academically. Cultural and social capital, and having learned how to react in a crisis, both in the home and later, at school. Many don't have that privilege and never learn how.

OP posts:
traumatisednoodle · 08/10/2021 15:14

He was astranged from his sister and his first wife's family. If I had to say when they became part of the Precariat it would be at his mother's death.

EmeraldShamrock · 08/10/2021 15:11

if your parents grew up MC but had, say, lost all their money and for some reason had to take unskilled minimum-wage jobs so you had a relatively poor childhood, they would still be able to hand on their social and cultural capital to their children.
I believe that is true.
Many people are posh and poor likewise some people common and rich, money doesn't guarantee social class climbing.

traumatisednoodle · 08/10/2021 15:10

Yes I'd say he'd lost his social confidence, he did retain a childhood friend who read at his funeral, he was knowledgable, but by the time DSIL was 8 or so there was no money for Theatre trips and she only went to museums when staying with her older half brothers. She spent much of her childhood in front of the TV, as is often the case his alcoholism worsened over her childhood. Her mother was and is worn out trying to manage DFIL addiction, work FT and had little left to give.

Quire · 08/10/2021 15:09

@traumatisednoodle

I’m not so sure about ‘becoming WC from a MC background’ — if your parents grew up MC but had, say, lost all their money and for some reason had to take unskilled minimum-wage jobs so you had a relatively poor childhood, they would still be able to hand on their social and cultural capital to their children

I have 2 examples of this in our family. DFIL was born to an army general and a minor aristocrat. He had by the standards of the time (and now) a very upper middle class upbringing (nannies, public school, sailing, skiing). He didn't go to University but qualified as an accountant. He suffered from a gambling addiction and alcoholism which cost him his first marriage (to DMIL) and the family home. He returned home and was "set up" with a flat and a job , again he lost it all. At this point his DM rewrote her will so that although he had use of the inheritance he couldn't spend it and it would pass directly to his sons (my DH). He then remarried and had futher children but the will was not re-written. He died in Febuary living in a house that DH and DBIL own, on the state pension, begging us for money fairly frequently. His daughter from his second marriage has enjoyed no cultural capital, in fact she has had periods of significant poverty in her childhood, she will always need to work and his widow now has no property and no pension. I would say DSIL is working class.

Sorry, hit ‘post’ too soon. I suppose I think that if DH and I (WC by origin, but highly educated etc) lost all our money tomorrow), our DS would still grow up with parents who, despite being poor, would still have friends from lots of countries, lots of degrees, speak several languages, have lived in several countries, know their way around literature, music etc… We’d still have that to hand on to DS, even if there was no money.
Lockdownbear · 08/10/2021 15:02

@jb7445 a lawyer would struggle to say they were WC. MC from a WC background is probably how I'd describe you.

@traumatisednoodle.
You DFIL sounds like he went completely off the rails.
I did hear something on radio that you Grandparents have a bigger influence on your outcome than your parents, ie if one generation (your parents) get it wrong then the GPs can generally keep the GC on track. However if the two generations have gone of track ie the GPs and the Parents it leaves little hope for the DC to pull themselves up.

Quire · 08/10/2021 15:02

@traumatisednoodle

I’m not so sure about ‘becoming WC from a MC background’ — if your parents grew up MC but had, say, lost all their money and for some reason had to take unskilled minimum-wage jobs so you had a relatively poor childhood, they would still be able to hand on their social and cultural capital to their children

I have 2 examples of this in our family. DFIL was born to an army general and a minor aristocrat. He had by the standards of the time (and now) a very upper middle class upbringing (nannies, public school, sailing, skiing). He didn't go to University but qualified as an accountant. He suffered from a gambling addiction and alcoholism which cost him his first marriage (to DMIL) and the family home. He returned home and was "set up" with a flat and a job , again he lost it all. At this point his DM rewrote her will so that although he had use of the inheritance he couldn't spend it and it would pass directly to his sons (my DH). He then remarried and had futher children but the will was not re-written. He died in Febuary living in a house that DH and DBIL own, on the state pension, begging us for money fairly frequently. His daughter from his second marriage has enjoyed no cultural capital, in fact she has had periods of significant poverty in her childhood, she will always need to work and his widow now has no property and no pension. I would say DSIL is working class.

That’s interesting (and sad). So, are you saying that by the time of his second marriage, along with all money/chance of a career etc being lost through his addictions, he’d also lost the social and cultural capital he’d grown up with — the knowledge, social confidence etc that comes with a privileged upbringing, elite education and so on?
elbea · 08/10/2021 15:00

I think people that really set themselves by these inconsequential classes are limiting themselves.

My friendship group, all met at uni, includes people like me born to teenage working class parents, a few people who will inherit land and titles, one friends parents own a national supermarket chain and another is the child of an international rock star.

We all did the same degree course and all got the same jobs coming out of it. It’s not the 18th century anymore where you are stuck in your class however clever or talented you may be. I think its sad to be stuck in that mentality.

MolyHolyGuacamole · 08/10/2021 14:59

I think that sometimes people is 'working class' as a euphemism for 'poor', but you're right, they're not synonymous

TellySavalashairbrush · 08/10/2021 14:53

I live in a council house, on a council estate and have to say the number of luxury vehicles around here is huge. Lots of construction workers who made good also occupy the very grand private estate about 15 minutes away, the houses are spectacular and massive. I definitely think new money outweighs the numbers of families from old money were I live in London.

traumatisednoodle · 08/10/2021 14:50

So addiction and mental health crises will depreciate your social class pretty quickly

traumatisednoodle · 08/10/2021 14:48

Sorry other one is Dbro.
Middle of the road middle class childhood like me and Dsis. But had a mental health crisis in his 2nd year at University and somehow seems to have " got stuck" he is 34 next week and lives in a rented flat, has a series of short term jobs, no pension. He may still have a middle class accent but his lifestyle is very WC as are his friends and girl friends. I suspect any children he has will not consider themselves MC.

traumatisednoodle · 08/10/2021 14:40

I’m not so sure about ‘becoming WC from a MC background’ — if your parents grew up MC but had, say, lost all their money and for some reason had to take unskilled minimum-wage jobs so you had a relatively poor childhood, they would still be able to hand on their social and cultural capital to their children

I have 2 examples of this in our family. DFIL was born to an army general and a minor aristocrat. He had by the standards of the time (and now) a very upper middle class upbringing (nannies, public school, sailing, skiing). He didn't go to University but qualified as an accountant. He suffered from a gambling addiction and alcoholism which cost him his first marriage (to DMIL) and the family home. He returned home and was "set up" with a flat and a job , again he lost it all. At this point his DM rewrote her will so that although he had use of the inheritance he couldn't spend it and it would pass directly to his sons (my DH). He then remarried and had futher children but the will was not re-written. He died in Febuary living in a house that DH and DBIL own, on the state pension, begging us for money fairly frequently. His daughter from his second marriage has enjoyed no cultural capital, in fact she has had periods of significant poverty in her childhood, she will always need to work and his widow now has no property and no pension. I would say DSIL is working class.

ACPC · 08/10/2021 14:35

I hate the assumption that it's only the upper and middle classes that are interested in art, culture, politics etc it simply isn't true. In my experience, the people who judge and make assumptions are the problem. The class system is outdated rubbish and anyone who thinks they are 'better' than someone else using these ridiculous markers is deluded.

beewritesx · 08/10/2021 14:30

When my friend traded her 50" telly in for a smaller one, her brother said to her, "Well done! You've rejoined the ranks of the middle class". 🙄 I mean, we have a 50" so we're probably "working class" by their definition.

This same friend started seeing a guy who owns a fairly successful business, but her Dad wasn't keen as he wears branded clothes and doesn't know anything about opera (apparently this makes him a "chav".)

It's so complicated!

Quire · 08/10/2021 14:26

I’m not so sure about ‘becoming WC from a MC background’ — if your parents grew up MC but had, say, lost all their money and for some reason had to take unskilled minimum-wage jobs so you had a relatively poor childhood, they would still be able to hand on their social and cultural capital to their children.

The only way I can imagine it happening within in a single generation would be if someone became a refugee and had to start over somewhere with no cultural/social/financial capital.

jb7445 · 08/10/2021 14:25

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Lockdownbear · 08/10/2021 14:08

@Twelveshoes

Of course you can be middle class from a working class background. My parents are.

And I am working class from a middle class background.

I'd agree you can definitely be MC from a WC background and vice versa.

It used to be a thing a Yuppie, Young Upwardly-mobile Professional.

CallMeNutribullet · 08/10/2021 14:00

I really don't feel you can label people as being MC based on things like university education or home ownership anymore. Given right to buy and the drive to make further education more accessible.

For example I was raised by a lone parent in a council house, received free school meals and we even had a period of real poverty while I was at primary school where a local charity paid for some short holidays to a caravan park.

I was an average student at school mainly due to bullying but went to university in my late 20s and got a degree. First in my family to do so.

I have a professional job now but only earn £28k. I'm a lone parent, own my home (very modest terraced ex council), in a solidly working class area we don't struggle financially. I have a Glasgow accent and I don't think anyone would ever describe me as being middle class in any way.

mewkins · 08/10/2021 13:51

Sure you can be proud of your beginnings, community etc. But my point is that you don't have to call yourself anything. I think class has always been a very useful tool for capitalism to ensure it has people in the places they need them. But while this might keep things like manufacturing going, it also places massive limits on people's lives. I think that if you accept traditional ideas of class and, for example, pass that onto your kids you are limiting their ambitions and aspirations and I think that is just rubbish. Everyone should have the opportunity to be the best they can. That isn't going against your class or your background. It is living.

EmeraldShamrock · 08/10/2021 13:43

You can choose to define yourself or not. I seriously doubt the hotel thing is because they labelled you on their system as working class.
I think it is as the hotel are disputing the issue and the bank is placing suspicion on my empty bank, my Dsis had the same issue they accepted her version as the truth immediately.

I am proud of my roots either way, there is a lot of humble pride and community spirit amongst the w.c.

mewkins · 08/10/2021 13:31

@EmeraldShamrock

Why do you need a label? Why do you need to know your rank in society? I didn't ask for it, society issues labels on others and treats them accordingly even in a professional manner. Example, I'm having an issue with my bank since July for a charge book on a service I didn't receive I've had to provide ridiculous statements no refunds to date, my Dsis with a healthy bank balance at the same hotel had the same issue, she'd her money returned within 14 days. I've sent a discriminatory email.
We - people - ARE society. You can choose to define yourself or not. I seriously doubt the hotel thing is because they labelled you on their system as working class.
EmeraldShamrock · 08/10/2021 13:28

Why do you need a label? Why do you need to know your rank in society?
I didn't ask for it, society issues labels on others and treats them accordingly even in a professional manner.
Example, I'm having an issue with my bank since July for a charge book on a service I didn't receive I've had to provide ridiculous statements no refunds to date, my Dsis with a healthy bank balance at the same hotel had the same issue, she'd her money returned within 14 days.
I've sent a discriminatory email.

mewkins · 08/10/2021 13:15

@EmeraldShamrock

Ah so it's impeccable manners and good posture that makes you middle class. I had always wondered. Obviously not only however these markers are there and more noticeable to me as a wc person. There are many rich people I'd consider wc due to background and behaviours. A few rich comedians who live a mc lifestyle but are wc. Katie price is definitely wc as with many reality TV stars who became rich. It comes down to what you are comfortable with. If I won the lottery tomorrow I'm still me happily labelled wc.
Why do you need a label? Why do you need to know your rank in society?
achainisonlyasstrong · 08/10/2021 13:14

All these threads show is that there is no consensus about middle class and working class. I think there is a problem because people tend to think that people who are "posh" are intelligent, when that's just not true. So not sure whether David Cameron or Boris Johnson would have made it to PM if they weren't posh. I think we need to let go of these labels as a society...what good does it do to us to endlessly debate what w/c , m/c and u/c are, and to label people as such. What's the point of it all?

EmeraldShamrock · 08/10/2021 13:11

Ah so it's impeccable manners and good posture that makes you middle class. I had always wondered.
Obviously not only however these markers are there and more noticeable to me as a wc person.
There are many rich people I'd consider wc due to background and behaviours.
A few rich comedians who live a mc lifestyle but are wc.
Katie price is definitely wc as with many reality TV stars who became rich.
It comes down to what you are comfortable with.
If I won the lottery tomorrow I'm still me happily labelled wc.