Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think working class is not synonymous with 'poor'?

164 replies

lolliwillowes · 07/10/2021 14:32

I know a fairly diverse range of people and have lived an several places where there has been an even mix of social and cultural backgrounds - both rural and urban.

I was just reading a diet/science thread from a few months ago and there is a lot of discussion surround poverty and obesity (which I am certain is true), except many people classified 'poverty' and 'working class'.

I think this is a really odd presumption. I have met many poor MC and well off WC and it has been unpredictable to say the least. The main difference between these groups have mostly been in their tastes, beliefs, interests, and behaviours, not cash flow.
The poorest people I have witnessed were possibly originally in one of the above social groups, but to presume poverty is synonymous with being working class is problematic.

I suppose if one has only ever existed in a very wealthy environment then the presumption may seem genuine, but I'm quite certain it is not. I would personally say that I have observed that different social groups respond differently to poverty, hence creating these stereotypes. Typical WC jobs tend to pay less, that is for certain, but it still seems odd to associate poverty with a group that regularly earns and owns property.

Is there an extra group which fits the definition better? I don't know. What I do know is that noting is simple - I grew up MC, the environment, the education, but have rented all of my life through choice (I am an artist and like to move around), so some may presume, on paper, I am something other than what I am, until they meet me and chat!

I would conclude that much of this lies with education, and I don't just mean academically. Cultural and social capital, and having learned how to react in a crisis, both in the home and later, at school. Many don't have that privilege and never learn how.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Vampsticks · 09/10/2021 17:34

I mean, there may be some social nuances, education levels, etc. But given we are not in feudal times with Lords and agrarian worker and there is economic mobility, isn't affluence THE ultimate class marker between working, middle, upper middle, upper classes (minted old money)? At least broadly speaking

TheKeatingFive · 09/10/2021 17:27

I don't think class markers mean much nowadays, it's all much more nuanced than it used to be. Time for a rethink.

But yanbu to suggest that many traditional WC jobs are not poorly paid in today's terms.

Lockdownbear · 09/10/2021 17:17

Of the 22 UK Cabinet ministers, excluding ,Boris, 7 were either born to parents who were immigrants to the UK or they themselves migrated to the UK as a child. That seems a very high percentage to me to get to that level in one generation.

MolyHolyGuacamole · 09/10/2021 12:15

@Lockdownbear

The heritage and traditions thing is very white British focused though. It isn't very inclusive or anyone outside of this.

This is very true. Something else that has crossed my mind, I struggle to say this without sounding racist. But it's crossed my mind that many people/ families who have come to the UK, particularly from India and Pakistan with very little have within a couple of generations got large houses, kids going to private school etc.

There must be some sort of mindset amongst them, possibly they make more by being self employed rather than employed by others.

Many have also come to the UK from the Caribbean, they don't seem to climb the social ladder in the same way.

I struggle to say this without sounding racist

You've managed to sound racist pretty well 👌🏽

Lockdownbear · 09/10/2021 00:20

have many mentors within the family

I think you might have hit it on the head there. Certainly people will make more money being their own boss than they ever will working for someone else. But I can't imagine having the confidence to open my own business. Which might be where mentoring comes into it.

They certainly value education, with a very high percentage of them choosing private school if they can afford to do it.

How do we get native UK people and other ethic minorities to value education in the same way?

And get that level of confidence to become their own boss?
Is the opening their own shops and stuff related to them supporting people to open a shop and once they are established they then support others to do the same?

The more I think about it they really are breaking the barriers of the UK classes. And a handful making their way into powerful political positions.

I've just looked up Rishi Sunak, born to immigrant parents, who sent him to private school.

It's got me thinking what are the UK state schools lacking ?

peewitsandy · 08/10/2021 23:46

I suppose all working class people like to call each other "Scum" as well !

Where, is the line that somebody becomes middle class or drops into just working class. This line is almost totally invisible and largely depends on how someone chooses to identify what they are.

Upper Middle class probably is the domain of the very wealthy, because of the lifestyle and likelihood of private education. However, many of the Upper Middle classes are increasingly using state Grammar schools for their D.C.

PickAChew · 08/10/2021 23:35

This is all ameliorated by acknowledging that class (obsession) is bollocks.

EmeraldShamrock · 08/10/2021 23:32

*their.

EmeraldShamrock · 08/10/2021 23:32

This is very true. Something else that has crossed my mind, I struggle to say this without sounding racist. But it's crossed my mind that many people/ families who have come to the UK, particularly from India and Pakistan with very little have within a couple of generations got large houses, kids going to private school etc.

There must be some sort of mindset amongst them, possibly they make more by being self employed rather than employed by others.

I believe it is because they've a good work ethic, they value education and have many mentors within the family.
The DC in DD's class from Pakistan and Indian work really hard always get good grades, there parents work hard too.
The extreme poverty and consequences of no education in their home countries means opportunities are not wasted.

Aged 5 one of DD's friends from India always said "I'm going to be a doctor" she is 13 now, top of the class - she will definitely be a doctor. Smile

Lockdownbear · 08/10/2021 23:15

[quote Waxonwaxoff0]@Lockdownbear no, I would not consider an airline pilot working class, it takes a hell of a lot longer to train to be a pilot than a train driver and it usually costs a 5 figure sum to train to be a pilot. It does not cost that to become a train driver.[/quote]
Training to be a train driver isn't cheap either even although its paid for by the train companies.
It's still a responsible job, train & 100s of passengers, on the drivers shoulders.
I think it on the cusp of WC / MC

FloconDeNeige · 08/10/2021 23:14

@Tippexy

Thing is, that’s me. I’m a Dr of chemistry, ex-pat in Switzerland, very high salary, multiple properties in 3 countries. But I grew up in a shitty part of Birmingham, went to a comp. Dad was a factory worker and Mum a dinner lady (although homeowners).

I’ve been told by various public-school types that I’ll always be working class. An ex-boss said once “remember Flocon, you might have a PhD but you’ll still only ever be a girl from Birmingham”.

I’ve been in Switzerland for 10 years now and I’m glad to be free of the British class system. Which looked down it’s nose at me because I spoke with a Brummie accent.

And no, I don’t associate working class people with poverty or obesity. Most of my family are working class, none are ‘poor’ nor even overweight. Poverty is linked with long-term unemployment, the ‘benefits class’. This group is often erroneously referred to as working class when they aren’t, by very definition.

Lockdownbear · 08/10/2021 22:59

The heritage and traditions thing is very white British focused though. It isn't very inclusive or anyone outside of this.

This is very true. Something else that has crossed my mind, I struggle to say this without sounding racist. But it's crossed my mind that many people/ families who have come to the UK, particularly from India and Pakistan with very little have within a couple of generations got large houses, kids going to private school etc.

There must be some sort of mindset amongst them, possibly they make more by being self employed rather than employed by others.

Many have also come to the UK from the Caribbean, they don't seem to climb the social ladder in the same way.

Waxonwaxoff0 · 08/10/2021 17:29

@Lockdownbear no, I would not consider an airline pilot working class, it takes a hell of a lot longer to train to be a pilot than a train driver and it usually costs a 5 figure sum to train to be a pilot. It does not cost that to become a train driver.

mewkins · 08/10/2021 17:23

@EnidFrighten

The problem is that we talk about class as if nothing had changed since the 1930s. I don't think it means anything. Especially when supposedly middle class young people have higher levels of financial instability, find it harder to buy a property etc than supposedly working class people in professions like building. It's more about heritage and traditions than actual resource and privilege.
The heritage and traditions thing is very white British focused though. It isn't very inclusive or anyone outside of this.
Practicebeingpatient · 08/10/2021 16:26

@HarrietsChariot

YABU I'm afraid. Working class does indeed mean you are poor. If you are working and earn a comfortable amount, you are lower-middle class.

Working class means either on benefits or in low paid jobs, minimum wage and zero hours, that type of thing. You work to survive and just about get by.

There's the social aspect too of course, it's not just money. Certain working class people could never rise above lower-middle class, no matter what they earned. Others might have the right temperament to become middle class proper.

There's overlap and it's not a hard-and-fast rule.

I disagree. My DH's boss is a self made man. He comes from a WC background, left school with no qualifications but massive intelligence and common sense and worked his way from an office junior in the city running errands for posh boys to owning several companies in about 15 years. He owns many properties across the world and has a timeshare in a private jet. But he is still very much WC. He is still married to his childhood sweetheart and still has his east London accent. When he gets on the jet he reads the Daily Mirror and eats sausage sandwiches with ketchup. He didn't suddenly switch to a broadsheet and pesto once he made his first 5 million.

His now adult children are a different story, they have been raised with money and went to excellent boarding schools so are highly educated and very much MC. They seem to be very proud of him and all he has achieved.

Newoneagain20 · 08/10/2021 16:21

I hate this talk of class :(

I come from a low income upbringing. Living in a rough council estate to teen parents. Both parents family’s none had gone onto further education etc. When I mentioned I would like to go to uni and load of that’s not for us. So frustratingly I didn’t but have worked hard and have a fairly ok career in IT and pay a mortgage on our home . My eldest has just gone to uni - my mother still saying why you sure it’s the right thing grhhhh

I don’t feel the need to fit into a class or be defined by it. I feel it can create limitations and I had to and still have to remove those walls. Within myself and others.
I have friends who are on paper upper class very well spoken, private education & when younger had a house in the country as well as London etc etc the money ran out. The sisters one is a teacher one is a nurse. Brother works as a manger of a supermarket. They are also a lot happier without the class system each doing a job they enjoy without the expectations.

The quicker we dump the idea of class - it’s meaningless and it’s another one of those Instagram life (fake)

Pippapet · 08/10/2021 16:12

Personally I think any perceived difference might be due to education or exposure to wider education, and also exposure to MC or WC "norms" in terms of (for example) social behaviour, rather than finance.

boobot1 · 08/10/2021 16:08

@Tippexy

I think the issue is that you have so many middle class people adamant that they are working class.

For example I have a family member, they have just sold their house for £500k and her husband earns six figures, but no, they are working class! I also know a couple of “working class” Professors who have about four degrees each 😂

That all applies to DH and I. We are definitely working class.
EnidFrighten · 08/10/2021 16:08

The problem is that we talk about class as if nothing had changed since the 1930s. I don't think it means anything. Especially when supposedly middle class young people have higher levels of financial instability, find it harder to buy a property etc than supposedly working class people in professions like building. It's more about heritage and traditions than actual resource and privilege.

traumatisednoodle · 08/10/2021 16:07

Thanks she is fine really. But not as middle class as her half brothers or cousins.

EmeraldShamrock · 08/10/2021 16:01

@traumatisednoodle Flowers I'm sure those things helped make a difference to her life.

traumatisednoodle · 08/10/2021 15:53

Another one DS's classmate (SS grammar school) very middle class. His DF hung himself on the boy's rope swing. The house had to sold, of course the DS had massive mental health issues, got into drugs, ended up dealing- sent to a juvenile detention centre ( for armed robbery). This was before GCSEs not sure how middle class he will end up.....

traumatisednoodle · 08/10/2021 15:30

I preferred to buy things for her (and we didn't have loads ourselves with 2 young children) then put money into that house as you knew it would be drunk away.:(

traumatisednoodle · 08/10/2021 15:21

We honestly tried, we paid for dance classes, bought her clothes when she was with us (other end of the country so mainly holidays). But yes her lived experience was not pleasant, I actually offered for her to come and live with us when she was 15, she preferred to stay and support her mother- who I have to say is a saintly women.

EmeraldShamrock · 08/10/2021 15:18

He was astranged from his sister and his first wife's family. If I had to say when they became part of the Precariat it would be at his mother's death.
So sad that no-one saved that young girl from her horrible life when there was family who had the means towards helping her.

Swipe left for the next trending thread