Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think school staff should make care provision for their dogs?

530 replies

LoveTheirDogs · 07/10/2021 12:02

Our headteacher and business manager have both got dogs in the last six months. Now they're bringing those dogs into school. They're saying that the dogs are 'school dogs' which seems to mean that they're dogs that mostly hang around in school. They've also scheduled a number of 'enrichment activities' for the kids so that they can 'learn how to interact with different species' ie their dogs. AIBU to think this is taking the piss and they should just make provision for their dogs same as any other working person rather than having the whole school have to go to these (non-accredited) 'courses' that clearly cost a fortune and are only being put on so that BM and HT can tick a box that says everything is ok with them bringing their pets to work?

OP posts:
BelleOfTheProvince · 07/10/2021 20:04

No one thinks a dog needs to have a psychology degree.

Fact is a rescue from another country is more than likely to have trauma. A dog can be beautifully placid but still have unpredictable reactions. Fil has a wonderful rescue greyhound. Very meek. Obedient. He's done a good job on her. However, she was mistreated. It's on her file. He knows a dog ultimately is a wolf and doesn't let her go around young children unless he's carefully controlling the situation.

And to anyone saying that therapy dogs don't need much training, well that's rather concerning. Everyone thinks their own dog is flawless, but many, many people are attacked by dogs each year. Dogs are animals and I would expect an animal used around children to have adequate training. The RSPCA don't even let a lot of dogs go to households with children in them, as they understand that however nice a dog is it is not a person. It is an animal with animal instincts.

And all that aside, no one has managed to explain why two dogs were needed, who just so happen to belong to the senior staff. It's abusing their position of power for their own gain. Did they offer the opportunity for all staff dogs to have this training? No of course not. How convenient the person with the power owns the perfect dog. What an amazing coincidence.

Ultimately a school is a place of learning and that's why we don't have random dogs, cats and budgies around the place. Usually, in a school all decisions are well planned with steps taken to make sure that learning is paramount.

The school is a workplace. Most workplaces do not have pets because they are distracting and can upset others. Any animal in a school needs proper provision and planning behind it. I've seen no evidence that this has happened in this case.

Will something happen? Probably not. But if it does I guarantee a child or another member of staff will have the blame pinned on them if it does

AlternativePerspective · 07/10/2021 20:02

Why would it have to be a severe allergy? Should people with mild allergies just put up with it? to refuse a guide dog? Yes if they don’t have a medical certificate to prove it.

In a school a child with a mild allergy doesn’t have to interact with the dog.

In a taxi a driver with a mild allergy can gain an exemption certificate or carry the Guide dog, or have his licence revoked if he refuses.

ineedsun · 07/10/2021 19:58

@Comedycook

So maybe learn?

All these people with fears around dogs (or whatever) don’t you want to address that?

Not really. I can walk past them in the street without cowering in fear...I will cross the road when I see a devil dog though or one out of control. Dogs can kill and some do. It's like women who are cautious of certain men...do you think they should learn not to be afraid,?

I think that most people would choose to overcome a fear which is disproportionate to the level of threat and interferes with the way they live their life.
Rinoachicken · 07/10/2021 19:58

*temperament!

Rinoachicken · 07/10/2021 19:57

They have only had the dogs 6months - that is nowhere near long enough to know the term permanent of an adult rescue dog.

That would be my main concern about the whole thing. That they don’t really know the dogs.

RobinPenguins · 07/10/2021 19:52

You’ll look like a bellend if you say anything because everyone is obsessed with dogs these days, but I agree they’re taking the piss and wouldn’t like this.

Mischance · 07/10/2021 19:49

I cannot believe people think this unreasonable

And therein lies the problem - there are many dog-lovers who cannot even begin to grasp the concept that not everyone feels the same. Those who are not confirmed dog lovers (not to be assumed to be dog-haters) can have a more objective approach and we can see the negatives as well as the positives.

Thankfully there are dog lovers who do get it - as we have seen on this thread.

LST · 07/10/2021 19:38

@MrsDonnelly

I cannot believe people think this unreasonable. Dogs can really help create a lovely atmosphere and relax children with anxiety. The dogs will be kept away from students who are scared or allergic, not roaming the school unsupervised. For children who are nervous, getting used to a calm dog in a secure environment could be beneficial but will not be compulsory I’m sure. To suggest that the head teacher is doing this just to save a few quid on dog walkers is laughable. Do you really think the head is that irresponsible? Or broke for that matter? There are way more important things to worry about in education
People are plonkers. Countless threads on here prove this.
Rosesareyellow · 07/10/2021 19:37

Therapy dogs have to be family dogs though, they don’t just get put away in the cupboard at the end of the day.

Wouldn’t surprise me at this point if there are people on this thread who think a therapy dog has studied for a psychology degree. A therapy dog doesn’t need specialist training - it’s just a calm dog that’s comfortable and happy around people, including children. It’s not the same as a service dog. Many therapy dogs belong to volunteers who go into care homes and similar settings, not specialist dog trainers.

IhateBoswell · 07/10/2021 19:37

Or broke for that matter?

You don't have to be broke to want to save some cash 🤔

LST · 07/10/2021 19:36

@Comedycook ahh I didn't realise you'd met the dogs to know that they aren't able to be therapy dogs. Silly me.

BelleOfTheProvince · 07/10/2021 19:35

Do you really think the head is that irresponsible?

Plenty of heads that irresponsible. My ex head for example.
Headteacher: I think we should get the basketball hoops out at break.
Belle(nqt head of pe) I'm not sure. Behaviour is not that good. Hoops are really heavy but unstable. Any climbing on them could cause a really serious accident.
Head: you don't trust our children, belle you are horrible. Self regulation blah blah. I'm implementing it.
Belle: Fine. I want to be on record that I do not agree.

2 days later a child under five had one fall on her head. We were lucky in that she didn't die. Stitches and concussion. And of course the head tried to pin it on the poorly paid dinnerladies on duty.

So yes, heads can definitely be that irresponsible.

MrsDonnelly · 07/10/2021 19:21

I cannot believe people think this unreasonable. Dogs can really help create a lovely atmosphere and relax children with anxiety. The dogs will be kept away from students who are scared or allergic, not roaming the school unsupervised. For children who are nervous, getting used to a calm dog in a secure environment could be beneficial but will not be compulsory I’m sure. To suggest that the head teacher is doing this just to save a few quid on dog walkers is laughable. Do you really think the head is that irresponsible? Or broke for that matter? There are way more important things to worry about in education

Blossomtoes · 07/10/2021 19:20

Was his work place a school?

Makes no difference. It didn’t say “workplace unless it’s a school”. A workplace is a workplace.

toocold54 · 07/10/2021 19:19

They aren't 'school dogs' though. They're family pets that the HT and BM are too tight pay dog walkers for so they bring them to their workplace and call them school dogs.

Therapy dogs have to be family dogs though, they don’t just get put away in the cupboard at the end of the day.

We are actually trying to get a therapy dog for our school as they are very beneficial but the HT isn’t allowing it! I assume it’s because of the risk of allergies.

Skinnyankles · 07/10/2021 19:19

Oh for goodness - all the hysteria, there's going to be a calm, friendly dog in the school, not a bloody tiger roaming around. Hopefully, for all the children they will develop a healthy understanding of dogs without their phobia ridden parents influencing them.

We had a school dog, it was such a special treat to visit her. Dogs have been human companions for thousands of years.

The dog will be assessed and will have to be of a calm nature. All contact with children will be supervised. I cant imagine any school assessments isn't particularly Paperlight or quick to do. I'm sure the dog will have to jump through hoops to get past the school gates.

Here's a literature review on the benefits:

files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ1173578.pdf

Comedycook · 07/10/2021 19:15

@Blossomtoes

standard pet insurance will not cover them being brought to school as school dogs!

It will. My bloke used to take his dog to work and they took a copy of the pet insurance documents. It covered damage at his place of work to the tune of £1 million.

Was his work place a school?
SW1amp · 07/10/2021 19:11

Two random rescue dogs from abroad do not bring enough value to balance out the risk imo

A well trained, therapy dog under strict control may be beneficial enough to warrant the risk.

A) who says they aren’t well trained and haven’t passed the Pets as Therapy assessment
B) therapy dogs don’t need many special skills. They need to be quiet and calm and able to sit still and be stroked.
Some dogs need training, others are born like that
Older dogs are more likely to be calm than puppies

I’m intrigued as to what risk/reward benchmark you are using to evaluate when the risk is ‘balanced out’ for therapy dogs

Blossomtoes · 07/10/2021 18:57

standard pet insurance will not cover them being brought to school as school dogs!

It will. My bloke used to take his dog to work and they took a copy of the pet insurance documents. It covered damage at his place of work to the tune of £1 million.

Comedycook · 07/10/2021 18:40

[quote SW1amp]@Comedycook

So using that logic, there should be no playground equipment, trees or gardens ever added to any schools again?

And no one should be able to bring in their own ingredients for home ec/food and nutrition?

And most sports should be phased out..?

I don’t think you really understand how risk works, especially in a school setting[/quote]
Those things add value.

Two random rescue dogs from abroad do not bring enough value to balance out the risk imo

A well trained, therapy dog under strict control may be beneficial enough to warrant the risk.

Redarrow2017 · 07/10/2021 18:40

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

SW1amp · 07/10/2021 18:36

@Comedycook

So using that logic, there should be no playground equipment, trees or gardens ever added to any schools again?

And no one should be able to bring in their own ingredients for home ec/food and nutrition?

And most sports should be phased out..?

I don’t think you really understand how risk works, especially in a school setting

Comedycook · 07/10/2021 18:32

@Rosesareyellow

In my time as a pupil, parent and governor of schools, I've seen a girl blinded in one eye by a stone, more broken and fractured bones than I care to add up, anaphylactic shocks from pupils smuggling in snacks, emotional trauma from bullying incidents, and yes - actual bite marks, but inflicted by one pupil on another.

Indeed - a child in my DCs class had to be sent to A and E because someone brought in one of their parent’s military grade glow sticks to show off with, snapped it, and the liquid went in the child’s eye. They turned out to be fine - but yes all kinds of crazy unpredictable shit must go down in schools. That’s kids for you. A dog would be the least of my worries!

There is always risk and random things can happen that no one would have predicted. That's no reason to add more risk imo
Blossomtoes · 07/10/2021 18:30

@lawofdistraction

DD is so utterly terrified of all dogs, if this were proposed at her school I would do absolutely everything in my power to try and stop it. Schools aren't the place for bloody dogs.
Then you need to address her phobia. If my child was frightened of something as every day as dogs, I’d do everything in my power to address that.
Eleganz · 07/10/2021 18:22

Is it an academy? If so, good luck getting anywhere with it the HT is pretty much God in most academies.