Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think school staff should make care provision for their dogs?

530 replies

LoveTheirDogs · 07/10/2021 12:02

Our headteacher and business manager have both got dogs in the last six months. Now they're bringing those dogs into school. They're saying that the dogs are 'school dogs' which seems to mean that they're dogs that mostly hang around in school. They've also scheduled a number of 'enrichment activities' for the kids so that they can 'learn how to interact with different species' ie their dogs. AIBU to think this is taking the piss and they should just make provision for their dogs same as any other working person rather than having the whole school have to go to these (non-accredited) 'courses' that clearly cost a fortune and are only being put on so that BM and HT can tick a box that says everything is ok with them bringing their pets to work?

OP posts:
Justgorgeous · 07/10/2021 14:26

Our HT brings her dog in, I think it’s lovely and so do the kids.

forinborin · 07/10/2021 14:23

Our school has a dog too, with the difference that the initial purchase price (must have been eye watering, it is one of designer breeds) and the ongoing expense is on the school budget but yes, lives as a pet in a senior staff member's household. Ours actually has been barely seen at school, with covid and all.

BelleOfTheProvince · 07/10/2021 14:18

@LeaveYourHatOn

I love the way basically everyone on the thread whose kids have a school dog or who had one as a child thinks it's a brilliant idea and explains exactly why it's good, and how it's dealt with re. allergies and fear of dogs. And then you have all the ones who have no experience in this going "OMG NO risk assessment alleriges fear attacks unpredictable distracting blah blah blah"
From what I gather, this is oranges and apples. Presumably the posters who have a school dog have a trained dog, in suitable environment which means that the level of risk is low.

A head bringing their own rescue jobs brings up several issues. Firstly, that the animal is not trained and suitable to be in that environment, secondly because unless they'd allow all staff to bring their dogs in they are abusing their position of power. Thirdly, because presumably well planned school dogs have an environment that doesn't impact allergy sufferers. I'm hideously allergic to cats, if children even went out to cuddle it and I then had to work with them I'd not be able to teach due to eyes streaming and swollen face.

This particular case is a very clear example of it being done badly, and dog lovers shouldn't be championing it. The more of these lax school pets there are, the more likely something terrible will happen triggering a ban for everyone, even schools that do it responsibily.

Littleducks · 07/10/2021 14:17

I had a pre interview visit for a job in a school with a school dog. He jumped up on me as I went in room. I was not overly impressed and did not apply to school after that.

I think reading to dogs and certain activities could be beneficial. However there always seem to be the same type of dog owners who expect everyone to love their dog and not understand people not wanting to be around them.

Comedycook · 07/10/2021 14:15

And dogs have the potential to bite, permanently disfigure and even kill. Their faeces has the potential to cause blindness.

Hiccuppppp · 07/10/2021 14:15

@Mischance

Hiccuppppp

The risk assessment should include:

  • a recognition that there is risk with dogs around children
  • details of actions that are to be taken to minimize this risk: where and when the children will be in contact with the dog, who will be responsible for supervision at each of those occasions.
  • details of how potential allergy problems are to be identified and dealt with.
  • details of how children who are not happy around dogs are to be identified and how this is to be respected. How these children are to be given free choice about whether they are near the dog or not without censure or indoctrination
  • how excrement is to be dealt with - who is responsible for this
  • details of how parents can have input into this process, and how their choices can be respected

A detailed risk assessment has to be done for everything on school, short of when and where you fart, so this should be no different, especially as the risk is very real.

Dogs are unpredictable, especially around children, who are also unpredictable. This is a dangerous combination. Dogs have teeth and they bite - there is no way they can be exempt from a proper risk assessment.

Again I say - speak to the school governors - it is they who are obliged to ensure that all proper safeguarding is taking place.

I love all these armchair school dog risk assessment experts.

You have actually missed 2 of the most important things that it has to contain.

Comedycook · 07/10/2021 14:14

@Hiccuppppp

Well we're talking about the op...I doubt she'd bring any expertise (I could be wrong) but the op presumably doesn't want to help write the risk assessment...just view it so that she knows how the school will mitigate any risks, thats if the risk assessment exists obviously...

It wasn't the OP I was relying to
But if as parent you trust the schools little that you feel that you need check risk assessments when you have no qualifications or experience so then maybe you should be looking for a school where you feel your children will be safe.

My DC go to a fantastic school that I trust. I'd have serious questions to ask if a couple of Romanian rescue dogs became permanent members of the school community.
Hiccuppppp · 07/10/2021 14:12

Well we're talking about the op...I doubt she'd bring any expertise (I could be wrong) but the op presumably doesn't want to help write the risk assessment...just view it so that she knows how the school will mitigate any risks, thats if the risk assessment exists obviously...

It wasn't the OP I was relying to
But if as parent you trust the schools little that you feel that you need check risk assessments when you have no qualifications or experience so then maybe you should be looking for a school where you feel your children will be safe.

Mischance · 07/10/2021 14:11

Hiccuppppp

The risk assessment should include:

  • a recognition that there is risk with dogs around children
  • details of actions that are to be taken to minimize this risk: where and when the children will be in contact with the dog, who will be responsible for supervision at each of those occasions.
  • details of how potential allergy problems are to be identified and dealt with.
  • details of how children who are not happy around dogs are to be identified and how this is to be respected. How these children are to be given free choice about whether they are near the dog or not without censure or indoctrination
  • how excrement is to be dealt with - who is responsible for this
  • details of how parents can have input into this process, and how their choices can be respected

A detailed risk assessment has to be done for everything on school, short of when and where you fart, so this should be no different, especially as the risk is very real.

Dogs are unpredictable, especially around children, who are also unpredictable. This is a dangerous combination. Dogs have teeth and they bite - there is no way they can be exempt from a proper risk assessment.

Again I say - speak to the school governors - it is they who are obliged to ensure that all proper safeguarding is taking place.

FictionalCharacter · 07/10/2021 14:11

I agree, they’re just bringing their pets in and calling them school dogs, and there’s very little benefit to pupils if any. My dd’s school had 2 teachers do this.

Comedycook · 07/10/2021 14:10

If you have no professional expertise to add then what is the purpose of you checking the risk assessment

To see if it even exists...I can't see how anyone would approve rescue dogs from abroad being in a school? What's their history?

Blossomtoes · 07/10/2021 14:10

[quote Comedycook]@Hiccuppppp

What a ridiculous comment. I'd like to see the risk assessment because there should be one[/quote]
How would you know if it was any good?

ImNotDancing · 07/10/2021 14:09

Absolutely missing the point but why does a school have a business manager?

Comedycook · 07/10/2021 14:09

why should you see it?

It will have been seen by the insurance underwriter (LA or ESFA) and by the governors. It will have been checked as part of an Ofsted inspection (in my experience they always ask for the dog risk assessment)

What additional expertise do you bring

Well we're talking about the op...I doubt she'd bring any expertise (I could be wrong) but the op presumably doesn't want to help write the risk assessment...just view it so that she knows how the school will mitigate any risks, thats if the risk assessment exists obviously...

Hiccuppppp · 07/10/2021 14:08

[quote Comedycook]@Hiccuppppp

What a ridiculous comment. I'd like to see the risk assessment because there should be one[/quote]
It isn't your responsibility as a parent to check that one in place.

If you have no professional expertise to add then what is the purpose of you checking the risk assessment?

ArrrMeHearties · 07/10/2021 14:07

notonthestairs your dd's school sounds absolutely amazing 😍😍

LeaveYourHatOn · 07/10/2021 14:07

I love the way basically everyone on the thread whose kids have a school dog or who had one as a child thinks it's a brilliant idea and explains exactly why it's good, and how it's dealt with re. allergies and fear of dogs.
And then you have all the ones who have no experience in this going "OMG NO risk assessment alleriges fear attacks unpredictable distracting blah blah blah"

Hiccuppppp · 07/10/2021 14:06

[quote Comedycook]@Hiccuppppp

What a ridiculous comment. I'd like to see the risk assessment because there should be one[/quote]
And why should you see it?

It will have been seen by the insurance underwriter (LA or ESFA) and by the governors. It will have been checked as part of an Ofsted inspection (in my experience they always ask for the dog risk assessment)

What additional expertise do you bring?

Hiccuppppp · 07/10/2021 14:04

@Powertoyou

I wonder if a teaching assistant would be allowed to bring in their dog?
Lots of school dogs live with TAs.
Comedycook · 07/10/2021 14:03

@Hiccuppppp

What a ridiculous comment. I'd like to see the risk assessment because there should be one

Nillynally · 07/10/2021 14:02

@PesosBandage

Dammit. I left my teaching job to stay at home with my toddler, as I didn't want to put him into nursery just yet. Kicking myself for not pitching the idea to the school of a "school toddler".
This would be wonderful, I'm going to pitch it to my head (Who has a school dog so can't complain) we could use the toddler for reward time, they could read to the toddler, the older ones could even have a go at changing nappies and dealing with tantrums to help towards future parenting or child care studies. This is genius!
Hiccuppppp · 07/10/2021 14:01

Complain to the Board, and the LEA itself about this. They're not "school dogs", they're pets who are being exploited at a potential risk to children (not to mention the fact that there will be pupils with allergies to their dander/fur).

What Board? RSPCA? Dogs Trust?
The term LEA hasn't existed for years and approx 50% of schools are not under LA control.

Mischance · 07/10/2021 14:00

Just because the two staff love their dogs does not mean that others should also do so.

Ask to see the risk assessment and make sure they have done one - which they are obliged to do.

It is simply wrong in principle, firstly because it is a piss-take; and secondly because dogs and children only mix in small numbers with very close supervision. This is not possible in school.

And the school is there to cater for ALL their pupils, some of whom might not be keen on dogs. They are allowed to not be keen.

XelaM · 07/10/2021 13:58

It's so lovely for the kids to have school pets! My daughter's nursery had an amazing huge Persian cat and that made the kids fay so much more fun. You are being totally unreasonable

Hiccuppppp · 07/10/2021 13:58

@Comedycook

I'd ask to see the risk assessment
Why would you want to see one?

Are you a specialist in canine risk assessment?