Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Boy wearing pink shoes

131 replies

bruntontrex · 07/10/2021 10:36

My son is 3 and very much influenced by his big sister. He's never been told 'boys like blue and girls like pink' so he, quite rightly, assumes all clothing and shoes are freely used by all genders. He loves ballet tutus and flowery tops just as much as he loves dinosaur wellies and monster truck jumpers.
Recently he's acquired a pair of pink sparkly Lelly Kelly shoes which his sister grew out of last year. He has asked several times to wear them to nursery which we've allowed him to do without hesitation.

This morning my daughter tells me 'a girl at nursery was laughing because she said my brother was wearing my shoes' and it's broken my heart. Although these were his sisters shoes I'm 100% confident this comment is based on the fact that they are pink and not because she's seen my daughter wearing them- don't imagine a 4 year old would remember the footwear of her classmate 1 year on.

Some of my most traumatic memories as a child were being laughed at by other kids and I despise that this has happened to my child. In honesty, he has not seemed bothered by this and is quite happily wearing the shoes to nursery today, however AIBU for not safeguarding him from peer ridicule by letting him think that it's not 'different' for boys to wear 'girls' shoes?
Or alternatively, AIBU by overreacting to one comment?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
always2tired · 09/10/2021 12:28

@MrsSkylerWhite

always2tired I wonder why so many posters on here say their son was exactly the same wanting to wear pink and sequins and then tell of their daughter wanting everything boyish? How many choices are influenced by the parents for both children to not conform to "normal" stereotypes of clothing. 🤔

Less I imagine than the number of children who are heavily influenced by parents who decide what is “appropriate” for girls and boys.

Our son had a friend who at 7 was told by his dad that he couldn’t go to dance class, because he didn’t want him turning out a “poof”. That was 11 years ago and I’d really hoped such ridiculous attitudes were long gone. Reading this thread, they clearly aren’t.

Less I imagine than the number of children who are heavily influenced by parents who decide what is “appropriate” for girls and boys.

So the OP daughter wore "girls" shoes so she influenced her into wearing them but let's her son have his own identity? Confused

Skinnytailedsquirrel · 09/10/2021 10:54

@WorraLiberty I'm not confusing sex and gender. The OP stated "all genders" What the heck is that supposed to mean. There are 2 genders, male and female.

I am pointing out that her son has a sex. That sex is male.

tiggerwhocamefortea · 08/10/2021 05:31

My 4 year old remembers who of her friends has lelly kelly shoes so I think YABU

Not sure what you thought would happen to be honest - those shoes are pink sparkly and gaudy AF so of course he is going to be ridiculed

And yes it is "different" to let a boy wear those shoes

Homebird8 · 08/10/2021 04:48

DS2 loved everything pink until he was about 11 or 12. In infant school he had pink wellies with butterflies on, a pink raincoat, and pink flowery wooly tights which he wore in winter under his school trousers. Of course the children asked him ‘why are you wearing a pink coat?’ To which his answer was ‘because it’s raining’. I didn’t coach him or talk to him about what others might think and I delighted in his straightforward answer when I heard him reply at home time.

Let’s hope your DS thinks the same. My DS now favours black (being nearly 17) but wouldn’t think twice about choosing pink if he saw something he fancied. If your DS sticks with the pink and sparkly then he does and, as long as he’s not upset, it’s his choice.

We also have rainbow Alice bands, sparkly hair clips and a certificate for the best accessorised player on the hockey pitch from when DS was 10.

ThumbWitchesAbroad · 08/10/2021 04:00

The sooner everyone teaches their children (and themselves!) that everyone is allowed to wear whatever they like and feel comfortable in without passing comment the better, IMO. Although it would be preferable if it conformed to decency standards, obviously.

All these regressive comments will just continue to perpetuate the ridiculous gender stereotype nonsense that has pervaded for far too long.

I also like GloGirl's response and agree that this IS the way forward.
Clothes are not inherently "gendered" - and if a boy wants to wear an item of clothing, then that becomes that boy's clothing and is therefore "boy clothes".

Age appropriate and decent - that's all they need to be. Coupled with the resilience to be able to answer "and?" or "so?" when challenged by ignorant people.

XelaM · 08/10/2021 02:59

You are setting your son up to fail. If you don't want kids to laugh at him, stop dressing him in his sister's clothes!

Fl0w3ry · 08/10/2021 02:31

I think childhood is a time when children should be able to explore freely what they like and dislike. Children shouldn't be encouraged to feel shame for liking a particular colour or type of clothing and children who say unkind things to other children should be discouraged by teachers and parents, rather than a child being expected to stop wearing a colour they love. We live in a world that is changing a lot and is becoming much more accepting. In order for that acceptance to be ingrained into future generations and more pronounced, children need to be taught to be more accepting of differences. Young children are naturally accepting of differences, they can be curious and honest about what they think, but that's different to being unkind. and I would like to think that by the time current nursery aged children are teens, the outdated concept of colours being associated with a particular sex will be the thing that's laughed at. I find it ridiculous, a colour is a colour. How it ever even got associated with the sex of a person in the first place baffles me. I wonder who or what decided blue = boy, pink = girl in the past.
To answer your question I would let him wear the pink shoes if he wants to wear them. Let him explore what he likes or dislikes now and teach him to stand strong and resilient in the choices he is allowed to make.

ShowOfHands · 07/10/2021 22:03

@isadoradancing123

I think its very cruel to knowingly leave him vulnerable to being laughed at, which he will be, rightly or wrongly
And is it cruel to knowingly force your child to conform? Where do you draw the line? My DD is gay for example. She's been bullied and has met some nasty homophobia. Is it up to me to teach her to hide that part of herself? Or when she was sexually assaulted at 12, was it her fault for not wearing baggier clothes and hiding her developing body? At what point do other people's poor choices become the focus rather than our children's bodily autonomy? DS slept over at a friend's house recently and took his toy monkey and blanket because he'd never stayed with a friend before and was nervous. He might have been teased for this. Should I have denied him the comfort and security? Or should we teach other children better behaviours instead?
Flowiththego · 07/10/2021 20:58

I have boy/girl twins and DS often wore DD's clothes to.playgroup. My FIL said this would "turn him gay". It hasn't, so far (he's 27). But as he grew up he chose to dress more like his mates. Other than this fascinating info, I have no advice Grin

MrsSkylerWhite · 07/10/2021 20:49

Hardly rose tinted glasses. It’s what we experienced with our 3 year olds, years ago. No-one ever picked on them for their interesting choices at nursery.

seaandsandcastles · 07/10/2021 20:42

@MrsSkylerWhite You can wear rose tinted glasses if you want.

isadoradancing123 · 07/10/2021 20:34

I think its very cruel to knowingly leave him vulnerable to being laughed at, which he will be, rightly or wrongly

MrsSkylerWhite · 07/10/2021 20:33

always2tired
I wonder why so many posters on here say their son was exactly the same wanting to wear pink and sequins and then tell of their daughter wanting everything boyish? How many choices are influenced by the parents for both children to not conform to "normal" stereotypes of clothing. 🤔

Less I imagine than the number of children who are heavily influenced by parents who decide what is “appropriate” for girls and boys.

Our son had a friend who at 7 was told by his dad that he couldn’t go to dance class, because he didn’t want him turning out a “poof”. That was 11 years ago and I’d really hoped such ridiculous attitudes were long gone. Reading this thread, they clearly aren’t.

ShowOfHands · 07/10/2021 20:28

@always2tired

I wonder why so many posters on here say their son was exactly the same wanting to wear pink and sequins and then tell of their daughter wanting everything boyish? How many choices are influenced by the parents for both children to not conform to "normal" stereotypes of clothing. 🤔
Or... It's a thread about ways in which children don't conform to stereotypes so people are describing the way their children do this.

So, for example, I may have told you that my DS has long hair, wears the girls' uniform to school etc and DD shaves her head and wears the boys' uniform. But start a new thread and ask a different question about conformity and I'll tell you how DS's friendship groups structure their play and how DD likes learning make up skills from YouTube and dressing up in v ethereal elf cosplay.

Because isn't the point that left to our own devices, none of us fit into the stereotypes and most of us break them in some way. I have hobbies and interests which are attended by only men apart from me, I don't wear make up or do any kind of beautification stuff but I wear dresses sometimes and braid my hair. Why would my children be any different in their myriad choices?

MrsSkylerWhite · 07/10/2021 20:16

seaandsandcastles

YABU. Regardless of whether it should be okay for boys to wear pink, it isn’t, and kids will laugh and point.“

Wasn’t our experience with our 3 year olds, 23 and 15 years ago.

This thread is depressing.

Thankfully, neither of ours give a monkey’s what other people think anyway.

AmaryllisNightAndDay · 07/10/2021 20:07

How many choices are influenced by the parents for both children to not conform to "normal" stereotypes of clothing.

At three years old, none at all. Three year olds don't care. It was older sister's playmate who laughed.

herecomesthsun · 07/10/2021 18:57

I think in my son's case it was the sequins rather than the pink, probably. He had very colourful clothes as a toddler and now has gone a bit goth.

His little sister also liked choosing her own style and has tended to opt for rainbows and tutus. She also likes flippy sequins but currently prefers blue to pink.

always2tired · 07/10/2021 17:33

I wonder why so many posters on here say their son was exactly the same wanting to wear pink and sequins and then tell of their daughter wanting everything boyish? How many choices are influenced by the parents for both children to not conform to "normal" stereotypes of clothing. 🤔

AmaryllisNightAndDay · 07/10/2021 14:27

there's a difference between what should be the case and what currently is the case.

Not for three year olds at nursery. Don't overthink it.

Somethingsnappy · 07/10/2021 14:05

I find threads like these a little disingenuous. Yes, kids (and adults) should be able to wear what they like. But there's a difference between what should be the case and what currently is the case. Challenging this is a noble cause, but your choice entirely whether you include your son in this.

seaandsandcastles · 07/10/2021 13:55

YABU. Regardless of whether it should be okay for boys to wear pink, it isn’t, and kids will laugh and point.

You have to adapt to the world you’re in, not hope you were in another one and expect people to act how you want them to.

If you don’t want kids to laugh at your son, don’t let him wear girls clothing. It’s that simple.

ImFree2doasiwant · 07/10/2021 13:46

If your son wants to wear them,arm him with some responses. One of mine has long hair . Since he was 3, he has been able to say (in quite a pithy tone) "I'm a boy. With long hair". Whenever anyone refers to him as a girl. My other son likes pink (and any other colours) he used to say "pink isn't a girls colour, it's just 'a colour'". Now he's more likely to say that he doesn't subscribe to outdated gender stereotypes. Grin

Coyoacan · 07/10/2021 13:45

Can we live in the real world here, kids are cruel, and they're picking on a boy wearing girls shoes. Simple

Frankly the little girl that made the comment was neither a bully nor cruel.

Children are little scientists discovering the patterns of human existence. They find the patterns in language and also the patterns in what is permitted for each sex. Obviously pink and sparkly being a monopoly of girls is very entrenched in 2021 and that is not her fault. But with the level of conformism demonstrated on this thread, women would never have got the vote, let alone been able to study to be doctors, instead of nurses.

BogRollBOGOF · 07/10/2021 13:42

It gets easier as they get older and can assert their own likes and put-downs more easily.

My 8yo recently wore some multi-coloured leggings that feature neon pink, pretty practical in the world of sportswear. He got a stupid comment about them and we just pointed out that he runs fast in them.

About 5 is the hardest age. DS1 was put off some things like blue finger nails because of silly sexist comments from classmates. At 10, for a number of years he's been able to correct people who can't quietly process concepts like a boy with long hair.

There have been times when I've directed choices about what to wear/ when, and it's striking a balance between young children expressing themselves and not facing the burden of peoples' stupidity before they have the confidence and skills to deal with it.

TheGirlCat · 07/10/2021 13:41

@DizzyLollipop82

I'm sorry? Can we live in the real world here, kids are cruel, and they're picking on a boy wearing girls shoes. Simple. I would never allow my son to wear pink shoes or a sparkly dress. It's only recently this has become a thing to allow boys and girls wear what they want, but come on I actually think you're being quite cruel in allowing your son to wear girl things. Sorry but that's my opinion..Let all the snowflakes who are offended by everything unleash :-)
It seems you're the snowflake here.