Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if there is any point in professional women getting married these days?

109 replies

CinderellaRockafella · 07/10/2021 09:31

Slightly tongue in cheek but....

my niece is about to buy a house with her partner. They are both in their 30s and already own (with mortgages) properties.

I know she's wanting to have children soon - bio clock ticking.

The family 'expect' that an engagement and wedding will follow at some point after the house purchase.

But - she's bringing a lot more equity to the purchase, thanks to a family inheritance. She's sensible and setting up a deed of trust.
She's a professional, has a good income.

It just made me question what, if anything, some women with their own solid finances have to gain by marriage.

I went down that route as in my day it was not acceptable to 'live in sin'. I didn't live with DH before we married and the balance was the opposite for me- he was the higher earner and already owned a home.

Other than Inheritance Tax issues in the future, it's made me wonder what benefits marriage has now for women who are already fully independent with their own homes.

I'm not up to date with benefits etc and child maintenance in cases where couples split, so maybe there are advantages to being married?

OP posts:
MadamMedea · 07/10/2021 11:08

If she’s having kids, getting married is sensible. She’ll most likely be the one taking maternity leave and, if necessary, working part time or reduced hours for the sake of childcare. If her partner ups and leaves her she won’t be entitled to anything in lieu of those lost earnings unless their married.

Of course, maybe she won’t reduce her hours in any way. And maybe she will be lucky and won’t have her earning power reduced by having children. Or maybe her partner will be the one to reduce his hours. But marriage is the safest way to ensure that even if the relationship goes tits up after children, the parent who took time off to raise the kids isn’t financially penalised.

PlanDeRaccordement · 07/10/2021 10:47

[quote Sylvvie]@Aimee1987 - Next of Kin doesn't mean anything legally. It's literally just "Who to contact in an emergency". It's Power of Attorney that is the legal role.[/quote]
Next of Kin does mean a lot legally if the person dies without a will.
“But when someone dies without writing a will – known as dying intestate – there are is a defined order of next of kin relationships that determine how the estate will be received, or shared out.

Spouses and civil partners are defined as next of kin when someone dies intestate. This included if a couple was living apart, but not legally separated. Spouses and civil partners will inherit all of the person’s personal belongings, the first £250,000 of their estate – and a half share of any further wealth in the estate.

Children and grandchildren follow the order of precedence in terms of next of kin when someone dies intestate, followed by other blood relatives.

Surviving long-term life partners, who not married or a civil partnership, are not recognised as next of kin – and can’t inherit under the rules of intestacy. Nor, too, can in-laws.”
www.funeralguide.co.uk/help-resources/when-someone-dies/next-of-kin-all-you-need-to-know

AmaryllisNightAndDay · 07/10/2021 10:43

It just made me question what, if anything, some women with their own solid finances have to gain by marriage.

If they intend to start a family and she intends to take maternity leave and work fewer paid hours to care for the children while he carries on in fulltime paid employment, then oh yes, she needs to be married. Or if they don't intend exactly that but it happens anyway.

Your own solid finances don't usually last beyond children. Couples have to make decisions for the good of the family which mean they aren't financially independent and equal any more. Marriage gives some protection to the person who gives up more of their solid finaces.

Pyewackect · 07/10/2021 10:42

It just made me question what, if anything, some women with their own solid finances have to gain by marriage.

I guess you could say exactly the same thing about men in similar circumstances and yet they are served their arse on a plate on this site !.

123344user · 07/10/2021 10:37

She should get married, but arrange a prenup which ringfences things like gifts and inheritances and what they earned before marriage, while leaving earnings within marriage in the joint marital pot. They will both need independent legal advice for this or it will hold no water.

"Fully intend to keep on working" is fine up to the point where a child has special needs and then...

On the bright side, I don't have DC, but we got married (eventually) to ensure each other got a widow(er)'s pension from our defined benefit pension schemes and to avoid IHT, and then one of us had a shares windfall and saved some capital gains tax by transferring some of the shares over to the other (and then transferring the money back after a sale) - so we've made back the cost of the marriage ceremony already.

Sylvvie · 07/10/2021 10:35

@Aimee1987 - Next of Kin doesn't mean anything legally. It's literally just "Who to contact in an emergency". It's Power of Attorney that is the legal role.

Nightbringer · 07/10/2021 10:34

It seems people are saying that if the woman is in a better financial position she might be better to avoid marriage in case they split up later and she has to share 'her' assets with her husband. Would you think this is acceptable if it was the other way around and the man didn't want to marry in case he had to share

I would give the same advice to men or women. Including 'if you are the higher earner, want kids and exke to the other to take a hit on their career to look after the joint kids, without marriage.....you are a dick'.

Marriage doesn't suit all circumstances and where neither person is taking a financial hit for a joint venture (such as kids or to be a trailing spouse) I wouldn't see the need for marriage. And wouldn't judge the higher earner for not marrying.

Again, everyone should look at their own circumstances and decide for themsleevs

Kotatsu · 07/10/2021 10:34

I think it's difficult, and you need to take care. I'm afraid that following the sudden breakdown (well, sudden for me, turns out he was up to all sorts for over a year before I found out), I don't trust people to honour their previously loved-up commitments.

My ex (unmarried) is trying to pay as little as humanly possible, and to diddle me out of as much of my fair share of what we accumulated together as he can. I made a perfectly reasonable offer, and we could have had it all wrapped up with just a couple of grand in legal fees, instead it's going to last at least a year and probably cost us both 20odd thousand each, and I'd lay odds that the courts will basically decide what I suggested (I looked at it all ways round. I only wanted maintenance for the kids, not me, and a 50/50 split of property - my solicitor is telling me to go for more like 2/3rds - so the court can make a compromise and I still end up where I want to be)

scarpa · 07/10/2021 10:30

I felt much like this.

In the end, we decided to do it partly for boring tax efficiency reasons (one of us earns considerably more, worked out better) and partly because DH really wanted to do the party bit with the little family he has left.

We're not having children so that wasn't a consideration, nobody has changed their name, and it hasn't changed our lives otherwise.

CSJobseeker · 07/10/2021 10:27

@CinderellaRockafella

One of the most significant benefits to me is what would happen in the event of serious illness or death - things like for example, my husband being able to receive my (relatively generous) pension or visa versa. Everything is set up by default because we are married.

@Dieselweasel When someone receives a pension, they can nominate whoever they want to receive it when they die.

I am in receipt of a pension as is DH and we had to nominate whoever we wanted to receive it when we die.

Ok, let's say you weren't married, and you split up. Who would DH nominate to receive his pension then? Not you.

If a married couple divorces, pensions are just another one of the marital assets and can be split if considered appropriate (e.g. if the woman's pension has taken a hit due to having children).

If a woman's pension takes a hit due to having children, and she's not married, she has no financial protection at all when she splits from her partner.

PlanDeRaccordement · 07/10/2021 10:27

You can be dedicated and committed without tying up your finances in a way that may leave you worse off in the case of a divorce.

But not to the same level of commitment and dedication as you have in marriage. I’m not talking “until death do us part” but the commitment that you are equal partners under the law and this will be enforced by courts if necessary such that neither partner is left worse off than the other in the event of divorce.

There is no such commitment to equality in a cohabitation situation. It’s a fair weather commitment....and during a split it’s look out for #1.

Milkbottlelegs · 07/10/2021 10:27

Its exactly the reason I won't marry dp. I have far more in assets and earn more.

I’m just thinking through the reverse scenario. An OP comes on to say DP won’t marry me because he says I don’t earn enough and don’t bring enough financial interest to the relationship. Pretty sure most people would say LTB.

StrychnineInTheSandwiches · 07/10/2021 10:26

It's interesting. Marriage has generally been an institution in which men held all the power. I can see why some women might now reject it.

Aimee1987 · 07/10/2021 10:25

@im0gen I didnt mean men should get more I meant that incentives should be equal. My employer offers women 6 months full pay which is great but they only offer men 2 months full pay. This is in a field where alot of women drop out of the field after having kids. I think offering men the equal time off work with the same pay would be better and may work towards equalizing the imbalance.
My partners employers offers both men and women 4 months full pay which is a better system. In terms of goverment input I think they need to increase statutory mat pay/ shared parental leave pay to reflect the cost of living something akin to the swedish system. But I do agree that's a very liberal approach that would require more taxation.

CSJobseeker · 07/10/2021 10:23

@PlanDeRaccordement

Because even today most professional women still take long maternity leaves and that then results in a large % being out of the workforce for literally years. Not working for maternity leave or longer reduces your lifetime earnings and can set back your career progression such that your nonchildbearing partner speeds ahead of you and becomes the higher earner. Even after the professional mother returns to work, the dynamic of her as primary caregiver is established and she is the one with flexible work, part time, taking time off for sick child...further hamstringing her earnings and career.

Children also stress a relationship....breakups are very common and if you are just the girlfriend with two DC under age 5, all you get is child maintenance of lucky. Assets are not split 50/50 like they are with a marriage.

I’d agree with you if the couple had no intention of ever having children, but in todays world marriage is the best protection for a woman intending to start a family.

This. If no children are planned, and both partners are financially secure, then marriage is a 'nice to have'.

If you have children, imo it's essential. One partner usually takes an earnings/pension hit, and that partner is usually the woman.

The fact that she was previously a professional who earned well doesn't change the fact that she may well look at her pension 30 years later and realise it's worth half what the child's father has due to the impact of mat leave, career breaks, PT working etc.

PlanDeRaccordement · 07/10/2021 10:22

@Aimee1987
I think the imbalance in careers is changing in society but slowly and I think more goverment and employer incentives to give dads as well mums time at home would help balance it.

I agree.

From my perspective, my DH I always knew would earn less than me because he’s in the nonprofit sector and I see us as a team in everything. While he doesn’t earn as much as me, he works just as hard as I do and we support each other equally. Even if we had not had DC, I would have wanted him to not be worse off than me if we split. Marriage was an easy way to make that commitment legally binding....that if we split, the distribution of assets will be done fairly no matter how much we might be hurt or resentful or hating on each other during a split. Most couples I know have gone from reasonable and caring to irrationally vindictive when they split. So I have no illusions, if we do split, I don’t assume I’ll be all calm and sweet.

mustlovegin · 07/10/2021 10:21

Some couples want to get married due to religious reasons

vivainsomnia · 07/10/2021 10:18

So men who are much better off than their partners are bastards for not marrying them.

Women should never consider marriage u less they have something to gain financially from it.

And her we cry about our mysogynistic society....

IM0GEN · 07/10/2021 10:18

[quote Aimee1987]@imogen
Yeah he does half the nursery runs, half the housework, half the time off when DS is out of nursery for whatever reason. If anything hes been doing more house stuff this week as I've been under the weather but I would do the same if he was unwell.
I think the imbalance in careers is changing in society but slowly and I think more goverment and employer incentives to give dads as well mums time at home would help balance it.[/quote]
Well he’s a keeper !

However I disagree with you on government/ employer incentives - they are already there for both sexes. Why should men get given more money than women to stay at home with their children ?

leakymcleakleak · 07/10/2021 10:17

@IM0GEN I took the longer maternity leave (I needed it to physically recover/breastfeed) though DH did do shared parental leave at the end which really supported my return to work and I can honestly say now I have a 3 year old and another on the way my DH does 50% of the housework/care/'lifework' - he is rubbish at picking birthday gifts, but he does all the cooking and most of the cleaning day to day so I think I win! In lockdown, despite the fact I was officially on an 80% contract, we split the available working time vs toddler-minding time straight down the line. He doesn't view my career or ambitions as inferior to his, and does more night wakings, still.He may be a unicorn, but he exists, and I'm lucky enough to live in a bubble where quite a few of the dads are stepping up.

However, I entirely agree that its far from certain. I've read on here men who did 50/50 before children then downed tools. I know people who have been discriminated against in the workplace for having children based on their employers assumptions, so regardless of their actual home life there's no way around that. I also know of equal earners with no intention of stepping back from their careers who have had a chid with additional needs and in all cases it has been the mother who has dropped hours/taken time out as a carer.

So, I think given the stats, it makes sense to factor in the fact that women are more likely to be affected by having children. There are some ways you can protect yourself, but I really have personally seen all of them fail one way or another. For me, having and maintaining an equal relationship is a feminist issue, but so is marriage.

CinderellaRockafella · 07/10/2021 10:16

One of the most significant benefits to me is what would happen in the event of serious illness or death - things like for example, my husband being able to receive my (relatively generous) pension or visa versa. Everything is set up by default because we are married.

@Dieselweasel When someone receives a pension, they can nominate whoever they want to receive it when they die.

I am in receipt of a pension as is DH and we had to nominate whoever we wanted to receive it when we die.

OP posts:
TheUnbearable · 07/10/2021 10:15

My friend is a professional on about 60k pa, she married a guy on minimum wage when she was in her late forties. No dc for either. He had a mortgage on a house that she moved in to, a little terrace that’s not worth much. She owns a house a really beautiful one in a village I would imagine it’s worth a lot. In those circumstances I would not have married.

Marriage is a risk for a higher earner, man or woman, the issue is children.

Aimee1987 · 07/10/2021 10:13

@imogen
Yeah he does half the nursery runs, half the housework, half the time off when DS is out of nursery for whatever reason. If anything hes been doing more house stuff this week as I've been under the weather but I would do the same if he was unwell.
I think the imbalance in careers is changing in society but slowly and I think more goverment and employer incentives to give dads as well mums time at home would help balance it.

CinderellaRockafella · 07/10/2021 10:13

Would you think this is acceptable if it was the other way around and the man didn't want to marry in case he had to share?

Yes I would.

OP posts:
CinderellaRockafella · 07/10/2021 10:12

@DeepaBeesKit

Maybe because they love each other?

A marriage is a dedication, a commitment.

I am sure that the 40% of couples who divorce also believed that on their wedding day.

You can be dedicated and committed without tying up your finances in a way that may leave you worse off in the case of a divorce.

No one was more traditional than I was. White church wedding, never lived with DH before marriage, etc.

But now, I'm just re-thinking the whole thing.

OP posts: