Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if there is any point in professional women getting married these days?

109 replies

CinderellaRockafella · 07/10/2021 09:31

Slightly tongue in cheek but....

my niece is about to buy a house with her partner. They are both in their 30s and already own (with mortgages) properties.

I know she's wanting to have children soon - bio clock ticking.

The family 'expect' that an engagement and wedding will follow at some point after the house purchase.

But - she's bringing a lot more equity to the purchase, thanks to a family inheritance. She's sensible and setting up a deed of trust.
She's a professional, has a good income.

It just made me question what, if anything, some women with their own solid finances have to gain by marriage.

I went down that route as in my day it was not acceptable to 'live in sin'. I didn't live with DH before we married and the balance was the opposite for me- he was the higher earner and already owned a home.

Other than Inheritance Tax issues in the future, it's made me wonder what benefits marriage has now for women who are already fully independent with their own homes.

I'm not up to date with benefits etc and child maintenance in cases where couples split, so maybe there are advantages to being married?

OP posts:
StripeyBadger · 07/10/2021 18:40

Surely, for couples where marriage means something important, there is always an advantage to being married. You could equally ask why any man who brings more to the household sees an advantage in marrying these days.

Wazzzzzzzup · 07/10/2021 18:38

We didn't marry for financial reasons because we both had nothing😂 We wanted to marry, iyswim. Neither of us has any family in UK, it's a very practical bonus to be next of kin etc, a ome pps mentioned. It's not just financial, we still keep ours separate.

Eleganz · 07/10/2021 18:29

I think you need to take each circumstance as it comes. Blanket rules don't really help especially if they are just "higher earning women shouldn't marry but lower earning women should" as it expects men to act in the reverse of that which is not really building an equal society.

My partner and I have currently decided not get married at the moment. We are both divorced and have kids from our previous marriages, have our financial independents and our prior experiences of marriage weren't positive! However I wouldn't necessarily advise other women in my position not to remarry and I'm not ruling it out in the future for me either.

TractorAndHeadphones · 07/10/2021 18:07

I’m in two minds about this one.
Being a higher earner isn’t always guaranteed. One could fall ill and become unable to work in which case being married gives you rights to shared assets in case of divorce. OTOH if you were the higher earner and had all the assets anyway this changes nothing.
Marrying a lower income earner who goes on to do fuck all is dangerous because then they get a share of the marital assets for free.

Women certainly don’t see marriage as the ‘default’. There are many reason why they’d choose to. And if both are equals generally marriage doesn’t leave anybody ou. Even a 10K salary difference isn’t much compared to say a millionaire and someone on 40K (above the National median wage).

Re gender difference - it’s because women take the hit when bearing children so they’re advised to marry. Even if they were on minimum wage before. Pregnancy is tough on the body. OTOH lower earning men don’t take the same hit and unless they’ve expressly declared that they’re going to be SAHD/part time there’s no reason to marry them.
All depends on the balance of assets, work and personalities.

MsTSwift · 07/10/2021 17:31

If you have a larger estate inheritance tax hits an unmarried couple hard. Have known numerous successful couples marry in later life when they figure that one out.

CinderellaRockafella · 07/10/2021 17:17

I think marriage is smart if you are planning to have children as everyone has mentioned because of the likely change in your income/employment as a result. Marriage is like insurance for you because your 'job' is then taking care of your family.

Is this not rather outdated?

Many couples BOTH have to work full time now because house prices are so high in some areas.

All my niece's friends from uni are back to work after having had a child.

OP posts:
CinderellaRockafella · 07/10/2021 17:16

As I said, next of kin is NOT legally meaningless if the person dies without a will and this is not uncommon....the news is littered with relatively young people dying in car crashes with no will.

That really is NOT common @PlanDeRaccordement Sadly the young people dying in car accidents are often very young males, still living at home. Their assets (which would be not a lot) would go to their parents - they'd be classed as next of kin.

A will is only relevant if you have assets worth sharing.

NOK is pretty meaningless.

POA is what counts.

A lot of the posts here are really about spousal maintenance is the marriage breaks down. It assumes the man earns more and the woman can't support herself without him.

OP posts:
Sweetchocolatecandy · 07/10/2021 15:22

We’re getting married because A- we love each other and B- we want legal rights as a married couple in terms of inheritance, next of kin etc. Having looked into it, cohabiting couples have got absolutely no legal rights and we were both worried about the implications if one of us was to die for example. Sure, we could appoint solicitors and do a ton of legal paperwork but if I’m being honest? We can’t be bothered and planning a wedding is more fun Grin

Pinkprawns · 07/10/2021 15:06

I think marriage is smart if you are planning to have children as everyone has mentioned because of the likely change in your income/employment as a result. Marriage is like insurance for you because your 'job' is then taking care of your family.

Yes, lots of legal ways to split things agree things blah blah but marriage is much easier.

More importantly though I do think that there's a spiritual element to marriage (not religious necessarily) that I would not have considered before I got married myself. We didn't have a wedding, just signed papers at a court house but the difference it made to our relationship was huge and unquantifiable. It felt like a very special, serious, and life changing thing to do. Bit hard to explain it on mumsnet, but I think it's very beneficial whether you go on to have children or not.

DriftingBlue · 07/10/2021 14:21

Marriage is a legal and economic partnership. If you look at the statistics of who is still choosing to marry, you will see that it is high earning professional couples. They also have lower rates of divorce. Marriage is rapidly becoming the domain of the economic upper classes.

You can find all sorts of studies hand-wringing over what this is doing to society because this group is becoming less connected to the rest of society and harder to break into. Those marriages yield children who will be raised in privilege, specifically groomed to enter professional careers, and statistically expected to go on to marry other people of their same class.

While she could try to mimic the legal framework and economic protections marriage provides, your family member is probably best off just looking at the success of her peers and following the trend.

Nitw1t · 07/10/2021 14:10

I ("professional woman") out-earn DH x 3.

We have 2DCs.

DH took 2-3 years (largely) out of the workforce when DCs were under 3. I took 6 and 3 mo mat leave respectively.

We got married 3 years ago (after DCs and house purchase!).

I appreciate we are not typical, we both felt we'd already made sufficient lifelong commitment to each other in having a family and making a home-for-life together so weren't that fussed about marriage: but we did get married, and my reasons were:
a) protect DHs interest in our family assets (which yes, I might have PAID more cash for, but he has contributed to in his commitment to raising our children and supporting my career by doing so
b) streamline insurance/pension/death admin
c) inheritance tax

We had a paperwork "ceremony" - neither of us are 'wedding' people.

Yes - if our relationship fails down the line, he will be entitled to more if "my" wealth than if we weren't married, but i will have done right by him in respect of our current standing as partners in life.

It allows for things to change as well, I recently made a risky career move (left a secure corporate job to set up a new business) and the fact that we BOTH have the legal protection of marriage vis-a-vis (mostly) the equity in our property being equal in the eyes of the law would have worked in MY favour if I earn less for a few years.

Myusernameisnotmyusernameno · 07/10/2021 13:35

I got married to my husband after 19 years of being together, ten years engaged and 1 dd (8). I married him because I love him and can't imagine being with anyone else.

DrSbaitso · 07/10/2021 12:40

She's planning on having kids, so yes.

Figmentofmyimagination · 07/10/2021 12:33

I think they need to have the discussion about whose career is going to take the childcare hit - someone will - if she’s absolutely confident it’s not going to be her - and that she’s not going to change her mind after the birth - then fine, but nobody really knows what’s around the corner.

Ozanj · 07/10/2021 11:53

I agree that independently wealthy women don’t need marriage.

minipie · 07/10/2021 11:51

Do you mean that in the event of a divorce, if a spouse has had reduced earning power owing to bringing up children, the court would award them a higher share of their joint assets?

It’s more that in the event of a divorce the starting point is 50:50 - including things like house, ISAs and pensions, whoever’s name they are in. There may be spousal maintenance awarded too (to recognise the limited earning power of the SAHP) although this is rarer these days and usually has a time limit.

But if you are unmarried and split then assets are not split 50:50 but on whose name they are in. So a woman who has not been working, or has compromised her earning potential to spend more time looking after DC, and so has limited pension/investments in her name (and maybe not even house in her name in some cases) will be worse off on a split compared with a married woman in the same position.

Of course if you ensure there is no greater impact on your career or pension than on your DP’s career as a result of having children, and/or you ensure assets are all in joint names, then this is not an issue. But most women do find their career is disproportionately affected.

TuftyMarmoset · 07/10/2021 11:51

He actually had a fairly sizeable inheritance recently @CinderellaRockafella, which we are using for house things. He’s also not with me for my money (he is the most frugal person alive). Other reasons I want to marry him include wanting us to be an official family unit and wanting us and our children to all have the same last name. Not an issue for someone I know whose girlfriend already has the same last name as him!

PlanDeRaccordement · 07/10/2021 11:47

[quote CinderellaRockafella]@PlanDeRaccordement If someone has a Will this deals with who gets what on their death.

Also, inheritance tax kicks in at over £325K. It's only an issue if the estate is in excess of that.

Next of kin is meaningless, as it's simply a contact in cases of life and death. Childless or unmarried adults could name a sibling or cousin if they wanted a blood relative.

Power of Attorney is what is important.

I have known several older couples who were together for 35- 40 years and only married when one of them became ill, or much older, in order to simplify tax matters.[/quote]
As I said, next of kin is NOT legally meaningless if the person dies without a will and this is not uncommon....the news is littered with relatively young people dying in car crashes with no will.

PlanDeRaccordement · 07/10/2021 11:45

Do you mean that in the event of a divorce, if a spouse has had reduced earning power owing to bringing up children, the court would award them a higher share of their joint assets?

Yes it does. And there are no joint assets outside marriage unless specifically legally documented and specified. Example girlfriend sells her home and moves in with boyfriend. He never adds her to the deeds, so they are not joint tenants or tenants in common. If they split, she has no claim on his house because it is solely in his name. If they were married, even if the house is still in only his name it is considered a joint asset and she has a claim on it.

Eastie77Returns · 07/10/2021 11:41

OP I agree with you. There is an assumption on MN that every unmarried mother is at a disadvantage because they earn less than their DP, have long gaps in their career due to maternity leave, will be shafted and left financially worse off in the case of a breakup. I have yet to see a convincing argument on here for marriage when a woman is the higher earner and owns all assets. Can anyone explain the benefits to a woman in that case?

vickibee · 07/10/2021 11:30

My husband died in June, had we been partners, things would have been far more difficult from an admin point of view as you are not next of kin and have limited rights
Do you get bereavement allowance if you are not married ? not sure

CinderellaRockafella · 07/10/2021 11:25

@TuftyMarmoset

I earn more than my DP and I put more money in when we bought our house than he did. Call me crazy but I want to marry him because I love him, not for his money.
But from what you say he doesn't have much money!

I don't get all this starry eyed stuff when marriage is really a legal contract.

OP posts:
CinderellaRockafella · 07/10/2021 11:23

@PlanDeRaccordement If someone has a Will this deals with who gets what on their death.

Also, inheritance tax kicks in at over £325K. It's only an issue if the estate is in excess of that.

Next of kin is meaningless, as it's simply a contact in cases of life and death. Childless or unmarried adults could name a sibling or cousin if they wanted a blood relative.

Power of Attorney is what is important.

I have known several older couples who were together for 35- 40 years and only married when one of them became ill, or much older, in order to simplify tax matters.

OP posts:
TuftyMarmoset · 07/10/2021 11:23

I earn more than my DP and I put more money in when we bought our house than he did. Call me crazy but I want to marry him because I love him, not for his money.

CinderellaRockafella · 07/10/2021 11:20

@MadamMedea

If she’s having kids, getting married is sensible. She’ll most likely be the one taking maternity leave and, if necessary, working part time or reduced hours for the sake of childcare. If her partner ups and leaves her she won’t be entitled to anything in lieu of those lost earnings unless their married.

Of course, maybe she won’t reduce her hours in any way. And maybe she will be lucky and won’t have her earning power reduced by having children. Or maybe her partner will be the one to reduce his hours. But marriage is the safest way to ensure that even if the relationship goes tits up after children, the parent who took time off to raise the kids isn’t financially penalised.

So what do you mean?

Do you mean that in the event of a divorce, if a spouse has had reduced earning power owing to bringing up children, the court would award them a higher share of their joint assets?

OP posts: