Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if there is any point in professional women getting married these days?

109 replies

CinderellaRockafella · 07/10/2021 09:31

Slightly tongue in cheek but....

my niece is about to buy a house with her partner. They are both in their 30s and already own (with mortgages) properties.

I know she's wanting to have children soon - bio clock ticking.

The family 'expect' that an engagement and wedding will follow at some point after the house purchase.

But - she's bringing a lot more equity to the purchase, thanks to a family inheritance. She's sensible and setting up a deed of trust.
She's a professional, has a good income.

It just made me question what, if anything, some women with their own solid finances have to gain by marriage.

I went down that route as in my day it was not acceptable to 'live in sin'. I didn't live with DH before we married and the balance was the opposite for me- he was the higher earner and already owned a home.

Other than Inheritance Tax issues in the future, it's made me wonder what benefits marriage has now for women who are already fully independent with their own homes.

I'm not up to date with benefits etc and child maintenance in cases where couples split, so maybe there are advantages to being married?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Nightbringer · 08/10/2021 13:18

[quote luckyJasmin]@Nightbringer 'So you only have to date someone, for 2 years, to have legal obligations to them? Casually dating? Exclusively dating?

Not sure that's correct. But that sounds awful. I definitely wouldn't want my finances tied to someone I had been with only 2 years. Certainly wouldn't want to be legally tied to them.'

☝🏻 yes you have to be with someone for 2 years in a genuine relationship (don't even have to live together all the time) to have the same rights as a married couple.
Doesn't sounds awful to me, quite the opposite. 2 YEARS is a hell of a long time to decide you don't want to be with that person. As a woman in mid-30s I don't want a man to spend two years with me and then decide 'he's not feeling it' and go off with someone else. Make your mind up sooner mate 😄

If you don't want to be tied up you can write a financial agreement (pre-nup) after two years and keep everything separate. [/quote]
So you can't casually date someone in Australia for 2 years, even if both are happy just casually dating? You must go get the equivalent of a pre-nup? That is truly awful.

I think you are forgetting that not everyone is looking for someone to marry. Your assumption its a good thing is based solely on the assumption that couples are only together to see if it leads to marriageand sharing of finances. And also that women can't propose and wait around for men.

If someone preference is to not involve the law in their relationship, why should they have to then go (and pay) for a prenup. if you want a legally recognised relationship. You can. You get married.

I appreciate that's awesome where you are. But I would find that awful. No long term relationship unless you are OK to be toed to the person.

Its all about perspective. But married by default, to me, is something I would never want.

Thatsplentyjack · 08/10/2021 12:16

No benefits that I can see, especially if she has a better pension.

Blossomtoes · 08/10/2021 12:07

When someone receives a pension, they can nominate whoever they want to receive it when they die.

Not in every scheme. Both of us have public sector pensions and we had to send our marriage certificate with the nomination forms.

inferiorCatSlave · 08/10/2021 11:24

@VodselForDinner

In the case of a marital breakdown, she would be worse-off of her current situation (higher earner of the two) remains the same.

If, for some reason, her earning capability changes in the future (unpaid maternity leave, decides to take time off to be a SAHM/go part-time), becomes disabled in some way and can’t work), and the marriage broke down, she’s be on a much better position.

If the marriage is a happy and long-one that lasts until a spouse dies, they’d both be better off due to inheritance tax rules.

I think this sums it up really.

Plus pregnant and screwed is sadly still not uncommon - happend to me and Dsis and the mummy track is also infurriatingly not always a myth so despite being a professional with good income motherhood can had a detrimental impact even if her priorities don't change - and a child may well change priorities for both of them.

luckyJasmin · 08/10/2021 11:10

@trappedsincesundaymorn
From Australian google search (as your sister seemed to be misinformed): Smile

De facto couples have the same social security rights as married couples. That means if you separate from your de facto partner and you have a dependent child, you could qualify for assistance. You may also qualify for a benefit if you have dependent children and your partner dies.

De facto = 2+ years together.

luckyJasmin · 08/10/2021 11:07

@Nightbringer 'So you only have to date someone, for 2 years, to have legal obligations to them? Casually dating? Exclusively dating?

Not sure that's correct. But that sounds awful. I definitely wouldn't want my finances tied to someone I had been with only 2 years. Certainly wouldn't want to be legally tied to them.'

☝🏻 yes you have to be with someone for 2 years in a genuine relationship (don't even have to live together all the time) to have the same rights as a married couple.
Doesn't sounds awful to me, quite the opposite. 2 YEARS is a hell of a long time to decide you don't want to be with that person. As a woman in mid-30s I don't want a man to spend two years with me and then decide 'he's not feeling it' and go off with someone else. Make your mind up sooner mate 😄

If you don't want to be tied up you can write a financial agreement (pre-nup) after two years and keep everything separate.

PlanDeRaccordement · 08/10/2021 11:00

CinderellaRockafella
I think marriage is smart if you are planning to have children as everyone has mentioned because of the likely change in your income/employment as a result. Marriage is like insurance for you because your 'job' is then taking care of your family.

Is this not rather outdated?

I wish it were, but if you look at the statistics regarding the gender(sex) gap there is a clear motherhood penalty still affecting most women. The following was a report published only last year...2020.

“The parenthood penalty

For men in the UK aged 35-45, having one or two children is associated with higher median weekly earnings.
In contrast, having children has a clear negative impact on the median earnings of women. For women across the UK aged 35-45, median weekly pay of those with two children in the household is 26.1% lower than among women with no children. In contrast, men with two children have a median weekly pay 21.8% higher than men with no children.
In London, this “motherhood penalty” is even higher at 30.0%. At the same time, the “fatherhood premium” is much lower in the capital at just 2.3%.
The key driver of the “motherhood penalty” for weekly pay is a sharp decline in hours worked among women. While male median working hours are the same among men with no children, one child or two children, female working hours decline dramatically following childbirth.
Childcare costs in London are higher than any other part of the country. Conceivably, this might be a contributing factor to higher levels of female non-participation in the labour market in London. In Inner London, full-time nursery care costs on average £343 per week. This compares with £269 in Outer London and £233 in Great Britain.”
www.smf.co.uk/publications/parenthood-penalty-exploring-gender-family-pay-london/

MilduraS · 08/10/2021 07:48

By that logic, my DH has nothing to gain by marrying me. I have no assets other than my pension. He had a house and a job that paid much much more than mine. I think it just felt like a natural next step and confirmation of our commitment.

I do remember working on an estate for a woman who lost her partner of 30-ish years. We had to argue for her to be entitled to his very generous old style pension. She also wanted to raise a claim against the hospital and wasn't able to bring a claim for herself because in his final two years she had left for several months to look after her sister. I think the rules were you had to be married or cohabiting for 2 years prior to death. The hospitals solicitors argued that she didn't. Not sure how it turned out as I left before the claim went any further but it did add a lot of stress to an already awful situation.

Heronwatcher · 08/10/2021 07:22

No, no point at all, apart from inheritance tax. My partner and I are genuinely equal, we split maternity/ paternity, we do split housework and childcare 50/50, we split bills but keep our own money and both work part time. We have wills and are each other’s next of kin. Don’t plan on leaving, but hey if I do at least it’s not going to cost me the price of several Caribbean holidays. I like my life, I have financial independence and I don’t especially want to be a wife. The idea that the woman is always more secure in marriage isn’t always the case, and I think fewer and fewer people are going to take the marriage path.

Pinkprawns · 08/10/2021 06:43

@Owleti

I don't know if it's just society's impact and millennia of misogyny and my own youthful insecurities which shaped my feelings on the topic - but personally, I was so happy to get married to the man I love.

I didn't even think about money or contracts or legalities. It was decades ago, we were both young, broke students so didn't have a grand wedding or anything like that. But it get magical. It finally felt like we really belonged to someone; that we were taking on life together as equal partners. It's been lovely and I wouldn't change a thing.

No, I didn't "need" marriage practically, I'd have survived without it (and probably done better financially, because he ended up ill and unemployed at one stage and we ate up our savings). But there are all sorts of things you don't "need" to survive that can make you feel happier and more secure. Maybe it's almost that spirituality point a pp made?

Anyway, long post short, for me personally and talking about my life in particular, it hasn't been some worthless document that could have been replicated in other ways.

:) Exactly. Marriage is much more than a contract. Hope you have a lovely long life together!
Pinkprawns · 08/10/2021 06:38

Yes obviously if it's financially necessary to go back to work then you have no choice, but it is also very possible that if/when your daughter goes back to work after children she might then earn less than husband because maybe she wants to go part time or reduce her hours.

DarlingFell · 08/10/2021 06:37

Professional high earning woman here. I married my DH because I love him [shrug]

Pinkprawns · 08/10/2021 06:34

@CinderellaRockafella

I think marriage is smart if you are planning to have children as everyone has mentioned because of the likely change in your income/employment as a result. Marriage is like insurance for you because your 'job' is then taking care of your family.

Is this not rather outdated?

Many couples BOTH have to work full time now because house prices are so high in some areas.

All my niece's friends from uni are back to work after having had a child.

I don't think so, it's certainly my situation. I don't think you can predict how you will feel when you have children. I've worked full time my whole life in a job I loved, but now it's really important to me to parent full time until I feel like I want to go back to work in a few years and when I do it will be part time, if at all! Who knows! You can plan, but life is not predictable.

That may not be her choice at all, but it's a good option to have and marriage provides security for her.

Hattie765 · 08/10/2021 06:27

Well the same could be said for any relationship where one person earns more and has more equity whether that person is a man or woman. 🙄

trappedsincesundaymorn · 08/10/2021 06:22

@luckyJasmin

In Australia if you've been going out with someone for 2 years then you have the same legal rights as husband and wife. I love that.

I don't need to be patiently waiting 'is he going to propose to me', I just know if I've devoted 2 years to a relationship then we have legal obligations to each other.

Really? I thought the whole campaign for same-sex marriage over there was because those legal right weren't recognised. I guess my sister and her longterm girlfriend must have mis-informed me then.
Owleti · 08/10/2021 06:20

I don't know if it's just society's impact and millennia of misogyny and my own youthful insecurities which shaped my feelings on the topic - but personally, I was so happy to get married to the man I love.

I didn't even think about money or contracts or legalities. It was decades ago, we were both young, broke students so didn't have a grand wedding or anything like that. But it get magical. It finally felt like we really belonged to someone; that we were taking on life together as equal partners. It's been lovely and I wouldn't change a thing.

No, I didn't "need" marriage practically, I'd have survived without it (and probably done better financially, because he ended up ill and unemployed at one stage and we ate up our savings). But there are all sorts of things you don't "need" to survive that can make you feel happier and more secure. Maybe it's almost that spirituality point a pp made?

Anyway, long post short, for me personally and talking about my life in particular, it hasn't been some worthless document that could have been replicated in other ways.

CayrolBaaaskin · 08/10/2021 05:38

@PlanDeRaccordement - next of kin is legally meaningless. Yes there are intestacy rules if you don’t have a will but these people are not “next of kin”. Also if you don’t want intestacy rules to apply, you can make a will.

In any event you may wish the people who would inherit on intestacy to get your assets- in my case dds rather than ex partner (who is their father).

CayrolBaaaskin · 08/10/2021 05:25

@PlanDeRaccordement - op is asking about a situation where the woman is the much wealthier party. As you say assets aren’t split for unmarried couples do she would likely be better off if not married (of course depends on what happens in the future finance wise for both parties. But if she’s married and she could end up having to sell up her house to downsize etc to meet his housing needs on divorce, even if she is the main carer of any children. She could be forced to give him half her pension too or at least a portion of it.

I don’t agree with the mn “marriage is always protection for women”. I didn’t marry and because of that was able to keep my assets on my breakup with dp. Now I can make a much better life for dds than if I had been married and look forward to a better retirement. Marriage doesn’t benefit all women.

Nightbringer · 08/10/2021 04:29

@luckyJasmin

In Australia if you've been going out with someone for 2 years then you have the same legal rights as husband and wife. I love that.

I don't need to be patiently waiting 'is he going to propose to me', I just know if I've devoted 2 years to a relationship then we have legal obligations to each other.

So you only have to date someone, for 2 years, to have legal obligations to them? Casually dating? Exclusively dating?

Not sure that's correct. But that sounds awful. I definitely wouldn't want my finances tied to someone I had been with only 2 years. Certainly wouldn't want to be legally tied to them.

Also, you do realise women don't have to sit around and wonder 'hmmmm will he propose'. You are an active participant in your own life.

If you want to marry your partner and he has proposed, have a conversation.

MintJulia · 08/10/2021 03:05

I'm a professional woman with a dc. I chose not to marry.

Today I own our home, have an ok pension pot & 35 years NI paid. My lifestyle is not at risk from a partner getting into debt or finding himself a younger model. Me & DS have a secure, happy home, a good life in a nice place.

My life is the exact opposite of my DM's, I've spent 40 years making sure of that.

BUT, when ds heads off to his own life and I retire in a few years, will I be lonely? I don't know. I don't think so. I might meet someone when I'm no longer focused on work but I won't marry. I'll never make myself vulnerable. No man is worth that.

luckyJasmin · 08/10/2021 02:47

In Australia if you've been going out with someone for 2 years then you have the same legal rights as husband and wife. I love that.

I don't need to be patiently waiting 'is he going to propose to me', I just know if I've devoted 2 years to a relationship then we have legal obligations to each other.

Goldbar · 07/10/2021 21:05

Stuff happens in life. You might get ill, lose your job or have a child with additional needs which means you have to cut back on work. Your partner might turn out to be useless or abusive so you end up parenting on your own while trying to keep your stressful high-paying job. It might end up being impossible to juggle everything.

It's not true that on marriage assets will necessarily be divided 50/50. That will be an important consideration but often the courts will depart from 50/50 to put the needs of any children first. So if you have a disabled child, for instance, you'll get a much larger share of the assets to meet their needs if you're going to be primary carer. Compare that to being unmarried where all you will be entitled to is child maintenance calculated by reference to your ex's income not your DC's needs.

sophiasnail · 07/10/2021 20:24

I married my wife (well, "civil partner-shipped") because I love her and wanted to make a public, lifelong statement of commitment to her in front of our friends and family. We are both professionals, and there was no financial incentive to do it.

Livpool · 07/10/2021 19:14

I married DH because I love him and wanted an extra commitment. Plus, a mortgage is harder to get out of (more messy) than a divorce

Rabblesthecat · 07/10/2021 19:13

Yes. I earn three times my husband but I’d still have insisted on marriage.

I’m 45 and as professional and non conforming as they come

My wedding was in a ref office with three witnesses (one my mother - e other two my landlord and wife)

Wasn’t the big party or the do but wanted to be married

Swipe left for the next trending thread