Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To stop financially supporting grown up DD and partner

134 replies

Muddylane · 06/10/2021 20:15

I'm really worried about DD (30) and her partner. 18 + months ago they bought their first home, a large family home in a naice area. The mortgage was mainly on the strength of partners salary (law), as DD is in a low paid profession.

Soon after they moved in partner quit their job - they have history for this and have done it before. Then the pandemic hit, and everything went on hold. Partner has not worked since, and had no job interviews etc.

So DD is struggling to pay the large mortgage and food, bills etc on her low salary. Early in the pandemic they benefitted from the mortgage holidays but these are over now.

Partner's mental health seems to have collapsed, they very rarely leave the house and DD comes home to a filthy house as partner never cleans.

Even before the pandemic I have paid for DD and partners supermarket shop as they don't have a car and we collect it for them. We still do this. Recently I have been "topping up" DD at the end of the month if she runs short. I have also offered to pay their mortgage for a few months if things get desperate.

So my dilemma is this - should I keep supporting them financially? If I don't support them I worry I will plunge DD into a horrendous world of financial ruin. I can afford to now but next year my income will take a drop so would be more difficult.

If I do support them, I worry I am enabling DDs partner not to look for work. Partner won't even get a temp job to bring some cash in.

DD is very worried about the situation but says it's useless to push partner on it as it will make partner worse. She's tried to get partner councelling but they won't make an appointment.

YABU - keep financially supporting them
YANBU - stop supporting them

OP posts:
Eddielzzard · 06/10/2021 22:06

I don't think you have to go in all guns blazing. I think you can sit your DD down and have an adult conversation with her. You're worried about her and her DP, you have been happy to help but you can't carry on indefinitely. Does she have a plan? Is she receptive to ideas? And then go from there. But the future has to be you stepping back, with warning. Firstly stop with the food shop. That is the most infantilising aspect I think.

HollowTalk · 06/10/2021 22:06

@Muddylane

All your comments are really sensible. I just dread making an ultimatum to DD as I think she'll be really angry with me and blame me for the situation.
How can this possibly be your fault?
HollowTalk · 06/10/2021 22:05

The thing is that by helping her at the moment you are also helping him. Save your money. She needs to divorce him and sell up.

He's not going to work again while he's living with her.

TractorAndHeadphones · 06/10/2021 22:02

@Happymum12345

If he has mental health problems, then he needs help. Try to find a way to support them both in a way that is sustainable longer term. Perhaps it’s selling and finding somewhere cheaper? I’m saddened by the responses of some of the posts here about mental health & questioning it. Any other illness and people wouldn’t respond like that:
On the contrary people would be even worse about someone who had cancer and refused chemotherapy.
bowlingalleyblues · 06/10/2021 22:01

I wouldn’t keep supporting financially, when you can’t afford to and the partner is not getting treatment. I would listen to your daughter and say that while your financial support will be ending that you’re there to listen and help her think through her options.

Happymum12345 · 06/10/2021 22:00

If he has mental health problems, then he needs help. Try to find a way to support them both in a way that is sustainable longer term. Perhaps it’s selling and finding somewhere cheaper?
I’m saddened by the responses of some of the posts here about mental health & questioning it. Any other illness and people wouldn’t respond like that:

TedMullins · 06/10/2021 21:58

Based on your update you’ve somewhat made a rod for your own back by enabling and babying your DD and not encouraging her to support herself. My parents are piss poor. When I was really struggling at uni and couldn’t find a job my mum sent me £50 for a food shop but they couldn’t afford to pay my mortgage even if they wanted to, even if I was about to go bankrupt. The option would simply not be there. I’m actually really thankful for this because it’s made me self-sufficient as I always knew there was nobody to bail me out if shit hit the fan. Frankly you’ve turned your DD into an incapable brat and you need to stop, right now. If she was my friend (I’m a similar age) I’d give her a damn good dose of home truths and tell her to start running her own life without mummy and daddy.

FlorenciaFlora · 06/10/2021 21:56

It’s not a choice between cutting them off financially or carrying on.

The middle ground is offering support in different ways, things like offering to support your daughter with seeking debt help, maybe getting a lodger or downsizing.

Is partner claiming any benefits?

itsallgoingpearshaped · 06/10/2021 21:52

Stop paying.

Offer to take her and her DD in, but say the house needs to be sold.

Partner sounds like a liability, tbh, and unless there are solid redeeming qualities, I probably wouldn't include him in the offer.

NumberTheory · 06/10/2021 21:49

Agree you should point out the need for your DD to make long term sustainable plans that do not rely on you. That probably means selling the house (possibly taking in lodgers?). Is there any way your DD can move into a higher paying profession? Probably wouldn't be in the sort of time frame needed to solve current cash crunch, but might make her better able, long term, to support herself and to keep a partner she loves(?) (assuming that the illness is good reason for current lack of job).

altiara · 06/10/2021 21:48

I would give them a warning now that you can support for eg 3 more months and make it clear that your income will be dropping.

They both need to face up to the DP maybe not working long term until they try and sort out their mental health. And even then, not sure law would be a good profession to go back into as assume it’s stressful.
They need to sell the house and find a lifestyle they can afford by themselves and that might be DD having to look for a new job.

Hardbackwriter · 06/10/2021 21:48

Re the shopping - I admit we have always been generous, maybe over generous with DD.

I note you later say that you also have a DS - do you have the same dynamic with him or is it just your DD that you've been financially supporting in this way?

TractorAndHeadphones · 06/10/2021 21:48

@BrilloPaddy

We are in a position of constantly financially supporting our eldest DD and her DH...... it's draining, exhausting and often thankless. There are DC involved though, so we feel powerless.

You need to lay out clear boundaries while showing concern for their issues........ say that you will support her emotionally, but financially, this can't continue.

At least OP won't have to deal with a surprise pregnancy if they're a lesbian couple
TractorAndHeadphones · 06/10/2021 21:46

@Muddylane

Tractor - they've been together about 5 years. Partner masked their MH issues very well the first few years. Overall there is much about partner that is lovely, they are a lovely relative to our DGSs for example (Our DSs children)
If they're generally a good partner I think it would be cruel to turn your back on them. However you have yourself to worry about as well - how much provision have you made for your own retirement? You don't seem that well off yourself. Can your daughter afford a flat on her salary alone? Help her sell the house and find a flat but leave it at that. She will then make her own choice as to how far she's willing to go with her partner.

Even if you let them both stay in your house nothing will change if your DD is unwilling to co-operate in pushing her partner. And it will be impossible to get them out once they're in.

You can give as much as possible but your DD is an adult. You can help but she must be the main driver of her own life.

BrilloPaddy · 06/10/2021 21:46

We are in a position of constantly financially supporting our eldest DD and her DH...... it's draining, exhausting and often thankless. There are DC involved though, so we feel powerless.

You need to lay out clear boundaries while showing concern for their issues........ say that you will support her emotionally, but financially, this can't continue.

NoTimeToDye · 06/10/2021 21:45

I think you need to 'give notice' that your financial support will finish on a certain date and stick to that.

It gives them time to make a plan. If the only way through is to sell, they have time to start that process.

UntilYourNextHairBrainedScheme · 06/10/2021 21:44

Really you could just say she. Nobody on MN is going to be less sympathetic if they're a lesbian couple! The "they" thing is clunky to read.

Aside from that its quite worrying that your DD has you over such barrel. Dobyou handle your DS with kid gloves too? Does he also live in a big house in a naice area, regardless of whether he can afford to? Do you pay his mortgage? Could you pay his mortgage and DD's simultaneously if he or his partner follow suit and ditch their jobs - whether through ill health or whimsy?

If you treat your children wildly unfairly you'll eventually alienate the one you think doesn't need support, or probably both of them because it sounds as though it'll never be enough for DD - if you're right and she'd get angry if you stopped paying her mortgage on a bigger than she needs house for her!

playmelikeasymphony · 06/10/2021 21:44

IMO you should stop OP.

I have an old friend who is nearly 40 and still being financially supported by her parents, has been her whole life.

In my friend’s case I can remember her dad giving me a lift home just after we graduated and him being surprised my parents weren’t giving me money (I’d just moved into a flat he was asking about rent/costs). He said he wanted to give her a bit of time to find her feet. Which was fine.

But it’s 20 years later and there’s been reason after reason why she still needed the money. And now they’ve had to reduce it post their retirement she complains they don’t give her enough support (both financial and practical).

Aquamarine1029 · 06/10/2021 21:44

You aren't helping your daughter, you're enabling her. She's been mollycoddled long enough, it's time she grew up and face reality.

Muddylane · 06/10/2021 21:41

Trees, as direct as you are I know you are right. I am thinking about some therapy for myself as well to help me support her in a healthy way (ie tolerate her being upset better!)

OP posts:
JohnStonesMissus · 06/10/2021 21:39

The house needs to go, it's not sustainable long term.

Beautiful3 · 06/10/2021 21:38

Sounds lovely what you have been doing. However it was never meant to be a long term arrangement. Its stopping the partner from seeking help and getting on his feet, or selling the house. They need to have an end date for your support so they can plan out what they're going to do.

PaulGallico · 06/10/2021 21:37

Your daughter and her partner are clearly struggling. How can you think about posting their story on Aibu and ask for people to vote on whether or not you should continue supporting them?

treesandweeds · 06/10/2021 21:37

@Muddylane

Re the shopping - I admit we have always been generous, maybe over generous with DD.

I do think she will get very angry with me if I try make her face up to the situation. I find it very upsetting when she is upset.

She HATES making decisions / taking the reins and the decision to "go large" on the house / mortgage was all partners as they were the one with the income.

You don't think this is because you have treated her like a child even when she is an adult? Getting her shopping abs paying her bills is ridiculous. You've enabled and encouraged her helplessness and reliance on you and now you are backing off she's angry as you haven't trained her or shown her or expected her to be a self sufficient adult therefore she isn't acting like one. What did you expect would happen ?
DroopyClematis · 06/10/2021 21:36

Tell her that you can only afford to help her until your salary drops ( give her a date in the future.)
After that , you can no longer support her.

That way, you're giving her notice that her current lifeline will end. This should enable her to focus on her way forward which will be to sell her house and deal with her , possibly, feckless partner.
She needs to realise herself that her current situation is untenable but stopping her drip feed of money now might make her resentful which , you've said, you don't want.