Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to turn down developer’s offer of £££ and keep our garden?

414 replies

Emelene · 06/10/2021 18:19

Hi MN. I would appreciate some opinions. We have very recently moved to a village, with an outstanding school, village green out the front and a garden in excess of 100 ft out the back. Our kids are almost 3 and 1 and we see ourselves living here for at least a decade.

The thing is the last owner was intending to sell 60% of the garden to developers, along with the next 3 neighbours along (we are the end plot on the plans). She lost patience and sold the lot to us. Planning permission has finally been granted after previous appeals were turned down.

Under the plans, there would be a house and a half built on our land, so we would be overlooked and lose 60 percent of the garden. We don’t have to sell, but the developers have offered a final offer of £100k. That would pay off about a third of our mortgage. They are pressuring us to make a decision ASAP.

Obviously it’s a huge amount of money and a privileged position to be in … it’s very hard to say no. But. Losing the garden is a high price. We’d planned chickens, Wendy house etc. The house currently feels so peaceful, trees out the back (that would be cut down) and birdsong. So I think it would change the whole feel of our home. But there will be a house built in the neighbour’s garden, so there will be a small element of overlooking…

I’m scared we will regret turning down the money. But our kids are so young and we moved here to give them a wonderful childhood (with a garden!)

So AIBU to turn the developers down and keep the garden? WWYD?

OP posts:
Winter2020 · 06/10/2021 21:32

Would you have bought your house if it was 100k cheaper but had the small garden/patio and a new build overlooking you? I’m guessing not.

I really don’t think it is likely that you can go from a huge garden to a tiny one and it not affect your house value. Also to go from not overlooked to overlooked and not affect your house value - of course it will.

I think the other houses will be built even if you don’t sell. There is a rule of thumb of a third cost for the plot, a third for the build and a third for profit so it sounds like it would stack up. Even if the developers pulled out your neighbours can offer their plots for sale with a precedent for planning permission being granted.

Maddy456 · 06/10/2021 21:27

No no no no no. If you sell do that land then the value fo your house will come down by the same amount. Keep hold of any land you have got.

PrincessNutella · 06/10/2021 21:26

100,000 pounds doesn't seem like such an incredible offer, honestly.

Claudia84 · 06/10/2021 21:24

Don't sell.
Even if the garden seems a lot of work now you can maintain it simply and enjoy it far more in the future.
A big garden massively adds value and gives you options. Even if not chickens could be an outside office or cinema room..?
The developers will tell you what they like in order to get you to sell.
I don't know anyone with children that wishes they had a smaller garden in a new build. All of them desperately looking for outdoor space.

Beautiful3 · 06/10/2021 21:24

No I wouldn't do it. I would love a large piece of land to have chickens and a tree house! Sounds Amazing. I'd hate to be over looked too. Remember that money is not everything. This is your dream home and you're going to enjoy it.

bellabasset · 06/10/2021 21:23

I'd keep the garden and obtain planning when I wanted to sell, and sell it with planning.

billy1966 · 06/10/2021 21:23

30ft is a tiny garden if you had a 100ft.

It will utterly change the feel of your home having a house so on top of you.

What about aspect and sun?

Will the new builds block your direct sunlight?

THAT will also spoil your garden if you are put in shade.

As for the dust and dirt?
Just awful.

I have a very large garden too and my children and their friends adored it when they were growing up.

Maintenance can be as little as keeping the grass cut.

100,000 is nothing when you think of the reduced value of your home and the huge decrease in your quality of life.

I think you should say no and object.

Good luck.

Williamshatnershorses · 06/10/2021 21:16

No way - keep it! If there’s established planning precedent now, you could build there yourself years down the road and make much more than £100k.

Wineat5isfine · 06/10/2021 21:15

I wouldn’t do it!!

Not only will it devalue your your house, you will lose your lovely view, trees etc and then have to put up with building work / constant noise for a long period of time.

Developers are money hungry bastards 🤬

Keep your beautiful big garden and get those fingers green!

FlyingWhistle · 06/10/2021 21:13

How much are the planning on selling the houses for? I would ask them to double their offer and see what they say. You hold all the cards.

NewlyGranny · 06/10/2021 21:11

No
No
No
No
No
Don't sell.

TertiusLydgate · 06/10/2021 21:11

60% of the garden? No way.

We are lucky to have a large garden and when my kids were small, it was the dream - they had their own dens, rabbits with a huge garden of their own, massive trampoline hidden away from view...and the birthday parties and campouts were fabulous.

I'm sure it will be a very special childhood memory for them and I wouldn't trade it for money.

Doris86 · 06/10/2021 21:10

There used to be a row of houses near me with massive gardens. A developer got planning permission to demolish the houses and build flats on the site. Most of the house owners accepted offers from the developer. However there was one owner who dug his heels in and wouldn’t sell. The development couldn’t go ahead without his house. He held out for ages, and apparently ended up accepting an absolutely enormous offer from the developer.

Hugoslavia · 06/10/2021 21:10

I think that you already know the answer. The house will not be the same house that you bought as you bought it partly for the garden. You will not be gaining £100k. You will be gaining £100k - the depreciation in value of your property due to being overlooked and losing 60% of your garden. So, your property could depreciate by tens of thousands. At the very least you should get an independent valuation. I think that you would always feel that someone else was living in your garden and resent that.

StoatMilk · 06/10/2021 21:07

@Watchingyou2sleezes

How old are you? If you're young a large garden is easy to keep on top of, the kids will absolutely love the extra space... If you've even half a mind to sell then ask for double and let it be known you won't accept any offers
This

The balls in your court, name your price.

Get some advice on how much your house would devalue if you did sell.

Penistoe · 06/10/2021 21:04

How much would it knock off the value. I would say a fair whack. But your mortgage would be what the house WAS worth. So really £100000 may sound a lot but its minus the loss in value. A valuer could tell you exact figures.
You also couldn’t put a price on peace.
It would be a no from me for these reasons.

ShiningGonnaShine · 06/10/2021 21:03

100k isn't much for a plot for 1.5 houses... They'd be getting a bargain if you went for it. If I was in your shoes I wouldn't sell. Certainly not at that price.

ivykaty44 · 06/10/2021 21:00

If you are happy to lose your garden, why not commission your own house and make 200k profit all for yourself rather than lining someone else's pocket? You would also have more control over it.

^^

also why should any developer rush you into making a choice...

just say actually we haven't come discussion so we will have to pass you up on the offer, as we know you're in a hurry and we need more time...

they want to rush you so you do what they want

EmbarrassingAdmissions · 06/10/2021 21:00

So there would be windows facing our back garden, including where we eat in the conservatory.

I wonder if you can ask for this to be modified if they go ahead with the build because you'll have a chance to see the plans.

NorthSouthcatlady · 06/10/2021 20:59

Another no here. You can’t put a price on all of that inconvenience and being overlooked. My neighbours on each side have been having relatively minor building works recently and that’s been annoying (and dirty!).

BewareTheBeardedDragon · 06/10/2021 20:59

Even if they gave you enough more that you could theoretically size up, I don't expect you'd find it easy to sell a house with the prospect of building work in their back garden for at least 18month - 2 years and then being overlooked in a way they would not be able to judge at viewing. I just don't think it's a simple as pocket the cash and sell. I suppose that depends on the market in your area but worth considering.

2bazookas · 06/10/2021 20:59

Given the age of your children I'd hold onto the garden; in years to come you will all appreciate the space and flexibility, room for all sorts of sports and outdoor activities. Privacy and security. Safety for pets etc etc

It's not as if the land will lose value; it will still be there to sell in 20 years time. Think of it as a nest egg for your future, a potential pension pot Maybe one day you'd want to build a house for yourselves or your children; or a letting property.

HTruffle · 06/10/2021 20:57

I am going against the grain here and I’d likely take the money, but wouldn’t pay it off the mortgage. Or certainly not all of it. Travel with it, take your children to see the world. Donate some to the local food bank. Buy experiences with it. Your garden will be lovely either way and easier to maintain.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 06/10/2021 20:56

You need to ask an estate agent how much if any it will devalue your house by. If you are in a catchment for an outstanding school that is oversubscribed then it likely wont make that much difference as catchment will be a major factor in decision making, not big gardens.

If you dont want a garden that's just patio you could make it a condition that they remove this (and penalties if they don't).

It depends what your pensions are looking like as well. What would it look like if you had the 100k now in terms of less mortgage interest paid as well etc in terms of how much you could chop off your retirement age. When you're 60, if it's the difference between working for an extra few years you might think it's worth it.

If it was your forever home I'd say no way but if you're only planning to stay 10 years then one year of inconvenience and an average sized garden might be a price worth paying for a big jump in financial security

mellicauli · 06/10/2021 20:54

You'll also have to live with builders and all the noise and inconsiderate parking for a year or so

60% of our garden was developed on (school/compulsory purchase). We did miss having a big garden from the age of 5 up to teens. They had to go to the park for football. No room for a trampoline. Also room given up to big trees so we weren't overlooked.

Also bear in mind - they are giving you 100k, they will spend 100k building a house and will make 100k profit. Their profit is directly out of the worth of the land they sold you. If you are happy to lose your garden, why not commission your own house and make 200k profit all for yourself rather than lining someone else's pocket? You would also have more control over it.