Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to turn down developer’s offer of £££ and keep our garden?

414 replies

Emelene · 06/10/2021 18:19

Hi MN. I would appreciate some opinions. We have very recently moved to a village, with an outstanding school, village green out the front and a garden in excess of 100 ft out the back. Our kids are almost 3 and 1 and we see ourselves living here for at least a decade.

The thing is the last owner was intending to sell 60% of the garden to developers, along with the next 3 neighbours along (we are the end plot on the plans). She lost patience and sold the lot to us. Planning permission has finally been granted after previous appeals were turned down.

Under the plans, there would be a house and a half built on our land, so we would be overlooked and lose 60 percent of the garden. We don’t have to sell, but the developers have offered a final offer of £100k. That would pay off about a third of our mortgage. They are pressuring us to make a decision ASAP.

Obviously it’s a huge amount of money and a privileged position to be in … it’s very hard to say no. But. Losing the garden is a high price. We’d planned chickens, Wendy house etc. The house currently feels so peaceful, trees out the back (that would be cut down) and birdsong. So I think it would change the whole feel of our home. But there will be a house built in the neighbour’s garden, so there will be a small element of overlooking…

I’m scared we will regret turning down the money. But our kids are so young and we moved here to give them a wonderful childhood (with a garden!)

So AIBU to turn the developers down and keep the garden? WWYD?

OP posts:
Vancouverorbust · 06/10/2021 19:16

Do you have a mortgage?In which case you have to apply to them get revaluations and they may not allow it. Unless you live in an area with house costs lower than national then £66k a plot is outrageously low

Is there a requirement to pay the previous owner if planning is successful?

buttermutt · 06/10/2021 19:14

& if the building work will happen regardless then why not?

Couldhavebeenme3 · 06/10/2021 19:13

What's the rebuild cost of your house op? What did the surveyors say it should be insured for?

The reason I ask is that the actual bricks and mortar cost is waaaay lower than the price you've paid for the house and the land - I remember researching this and the rebuild cost was a quarter of the price I paid for the whole thing.

You said that £100k would reduce your mortgage by a third, how much did you pay in total, can you work out if actually losing that much land is good value - even before you put in the rest of the cons?

You might have these figures handy if you've just moved in, could be on survey paperwork or buildings insurance under total sum insured.

Emelene · 06/10/2021 19:13

Thank you for thoughts so far. Speedy responses! I’ll answer some points raised -

DH and I are 28. Maintaining the garden will be a challenge as we both work but I think will get easier when my little one can walk and not eat the dirt etc. I am concerned that we will end up with an overgrown mess and not these lovely garden dreams!

The development can’t go ahead as planned without our land. They will do what they can on the other gardens, and apply for a change in planning to build a smaller house on our neighbour’s land only. So they will end up with 2 full size (3 bed detached) houses and a smaller one, rather than the 4 originally planned. We will scrutinise the new plans and be given a chance to object i believe, on grounds such as being overlooked. But as they had planning previously I can’t see us stopping it. I believe each house was planned to sell for around £450k. However the planning process is far from transparent and we are struggling to get reliable information.

The developers apparently can’t afford to buy the house and land with it. It does make their assurances that “not everyone wants a big garden so you wouldn’t lose much house value” sound rubbish.

I don’t think we could find another house we liked better for our sale price +100k. Particularly with all the costs of moving again. We have scrutinised Rightmove etc. I think a “step up” house is in the region of 200k more (another bedroom, big garden, detached) and then we wouldn’t be able to afford the repayments.

We absolutely love the location of this house and it works very well layout wise etc. It’s probably not my dream forever home but I do feel like it’s my dream home for the budget we have, and a great childhood house for my kids, if that makes sense?

I’m not sure what the neighbours think. We haven’t met them- they’ve been away and later when we knocked they were out. I don’t want them to hate us, but I need to do what’s best for my family…

OP posts:
buttermutt · 06/10/2021 19:12

Loosing 60% of my garden and becoming overlooked would easily knock £100k off the value of my house. But that's based on SE house prices.

I'm in London with a postage stamped sized garden & can see into about 6 gardens from my upstairs, doesn't impact the prices.

Ourlady · 06/10/2021 19:12

Definitely not. Your garden and plans for it sound bloody wonderful.
The building work will be a nightmare for months on end, dirty and noisy. You will have no peace and then be left with another house overlooking your once idyllic garden.

Bunnycat101 · 06/10/2021 19:12

Can you do a diagram to show where the houses would be in relation to yours. I wouldn’t do it (and have had similar offers for our garden).

tilder · 06/10/2021 19:12

Umm. Not sure I understand. Are you saying they applied for, and were granted on appeal, planning permission to build on land they do not own? That is in fact owned by 3 different people?

Sounds a bit odd.

TatianaBis · 06/10/2021 19:12

The size of your garden also impacts how much you could potentially extend your own house.

I think if you say yes you will regret it and end up moving which will cost a substantial part of that 100k.

buttermutt · 06/10/2021 19:11

How big is the remaining 60% garden?

buttermutt · 06/10/2021 19:10

Doesn't seem to have knocked any value of the house, neighbours have done similar & sold for more.

TatianaBis · 06/10/2021 19:10

A house in your neighbours garden will be nothing like the extent of overlooking as it would be on yours.

Elderflower14 · 06/10/2021 19:10

@UnitedRoad

You can make the money easily enough but you’d never get the land back
This!
Newmumatlast · 06/10/2021 19:08

I said yabu as there is about to be a development right next to you anyway. It isnt going to remain the look and feel it is now. So you may aswell sell. I would get an agent out to value based on the loss of garden though to check real value if the offer.

buttermutt · 06/10/2021 19:08

There was disruption but no different & further away to a neighbour doing work.

TatianaBis · 06/10/2021 19:08

I'd keep the garden every time. It will impact the value of the property anyway.

I wouldn't even consider it tbh.

You'd have no control over what is built and it may end up bigger/taller than currently planned.

buttermutt · 06/10/2021 19:07

A relative did this & it worked out well.
It was 110k about 6 yrs ago & they still kept 70% of their garden. In London so overlooking is normal

FuckingFlumps · 06/10/2021 19:07

I think a lot of posters are missing the point that the building work will likely happen regardless and that there is still a good chance the OP will end up overlooked at the end of the process without actually having any tangible benefit.

AnonymousAuroch · 06/10/2021 19:06

It would knock £100k off your mortgage, but it would also drastically lower your property value, so not exactly a win, possibly even evens out in the end, except you would now have a much smaller, overlooked garden. Don't do it.

MrsLeclerc · 06/10/2021 19:06

Also, consider the direction of the land and how much natural light will be lost with houses in that part of the garden. You may find that the 40% of garden that you’ll own will be in the shade for a large part of the day.

We’re the corner plot of a cul de sac and essentially have 2 parts to our back garden. One part is east facing, surrounded by dense trees and as it only gets a small amount of sun in the early morning and late evening, we struggled to get grass to grow there. We’ve now built a large shed there so at least we get some use out of it.

Personally, as lovely as the chunk off your mortgage would be, I wouldn’t sell. We have a 3yr old and it’s so nice to have a big garden that he’ll enjoy for years to come.

UnitedRoad · 06/10/2021 19:06

You can make the money easily enough but you’d never get the land back

BarbaraofSeville · 06/10/2021 19:06

Surely it depends on how much your house is worth? If it's under about £500k, it can't possibly knock anywhere near £100k off the value of the property for losing just over half of an enormous garden and being overlooked.

Many people would still be happy with the remaining 40+ ft or even prefer it if it's less garden to maintain and put up with being overlooked for £100k.

Of course if the value is in the millions, £100k might indeed be considered 'peanuts'.

Yourstupidityexhaustsme · 06/10/2021 19:05

Turn it down.

People often favour land over property.

You may make £100k but you could lose half of that if you have a pokey little garden and end up having to reduce your selling price.

I imagine if you changed your minds in six months/one year then they'd snatch your hand off.

You're already mortgaged in. Enjoy your garden and buy your chickens.

SwordBilledHummingbird · 06/10/2021 19:05

Not a chance. We also have a decent sized garden (a little less than 100 foot long) and it was the big selling point of the house for us. No way would I give up the feeling of space, the beautiful trees, the cute shed, the greenhouse/mini garden room we've built ourselves... just no. From what you've said I think you'd regret it.

Shmithecat2 · 06/10/2021 19:04

Hard NO from me. My back garden is 75ft long and about 100ft wide. Absolutely no way would I want another house in it!