Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to turn down developer’s offer of £££ and keep our garden?

414 replies

Emelene · 06/10/2021 18:19

Hi MN. I would appreciate some opinions. We have very recently moved to a village, with an outstanding school, village green out the front and a garden in excess of 100 ft out the back. Our kids are almost 3 and 1 and we see ourselves living here for at least a decade.

The thing is the last owner was intending to sell 60% of the garden to developers, along with the next 3 neighbours along (we are the end plot on the plans). She lost patience and sold the lot to us. Planning permission has finally been granted after previous appeals were turned down.

Under the plans, there would be a house and a half built on our land, so we would be overlooked and lose 60 percent of the garden. We don’t have to sell, but the developers have offered a final offer of £100k. That would pay off about a third of our mortgage. They are pressuring us to make a decision ASAP.

Obviously it’s a huge amount of money and a privileged position to be in … it’s very hard to say no. But. Losing the garden is a high price. We’d planned chickens, Wendy house etc. The house currently feels so peaceful, trees out the back (that would be cut down) and birdsong. So I think it would change the whole feel of our home. But there will be a house built in the neighbour’s garden, so there will be a small element of overlooking…

I’m scared we will regret turning down the money. But our kids are so young and we moved here to give them a wonderful childhood (with a garden!)

So AIBU to turn the developers down and keep the garden? WWYD?

OP posts:
godmum56 · 06/10/2021 19:55

I'd turn it down without a second thought

TataMamma · 06/10/2021 19:54

I'd turn it down.
But potentially, could you sell a smaller part of the garden for one smaller house? You wouldn't get as much for it, but it might be worth considering.

maryberryslayers · 06/10/2021 19:54

Don't do it OP. By the time you've paid agents fees, solicitors fees, stamp duty, moving costs and lost value from your home if it finally sells, you'll be left with pretty much nothing out of £100k.
Pop some fast growing trees down your boundary so you're not overlooked from next door and enjoy your lovely home with your children.

ChargingBuck · 06/10/2021 19:52

I’m scared we will regret turning down the money.

It's £100k in your hand now, & a huge chunk off the mortgage.

But ... balance that against the financial hit you will take hen your house & garden value is depreciated by the development.
& then factor in the at-least-10 years of family lifestyle & enjoyment you bought the property for.

Vancouverorbust · 06/10/2021 19:52

@buttermutt

No-one will make £100k Fees, solicitor, valuer, capital gains, the amount required by the mortgage company to adjust the value and/or loan to value (is your money eventually but only realised when you sell). Depending on the mortgage type and company- redemption fees and remortgaging costs

You don't have to pay CGT & there is no strict rule that the OPs property will automatically be devalued

Why do you think you don't pay capital gains?
Talipesmum · 06/10/2021 19:52

Don’t do it - we’re in a terrace and while 100ft garden sounds like lots, terraces are often narrow so for kids games, the length makes a big difference.

TheCraicDealer · 06/10/2021 19:51

No I wouldn't do it. 100k doesn't reflect the loss of the actual garden plus the impact on your property's value, plus the inconvenience of extended building work, loss of privacy etc. The developers are having a laugh at that money.

That garden is what could allow you to stay on the house a long time; now it's a play area for your DC, but it also gives scope for additional storage, a workspace/cabin or possible extension of your home in years to come.

Your house is a terrace and presumably older with a more traditional layout than the new builds on offer. The trade off, for many buyers, is the garden. If you sell the land you're going to have the downsides of a house that is older without the added benefit of the more generous plot size.

Vancouverorbust · 06/10/2021 19:50

@Noeuf

www.thefriendlyaccountants.co.uk/tax-implications-of-selling-your-garden/ Helpful but here.

Also, if your mortgage is 300k you are likely to have a maximum overpayment per year (ours is 10%) without charges kicking in. So you’d have to work out what you would do with the money?

That is a website just about the tax (an it is very vague) No mention of mortgage company or the implications.

How big is your current loan to value?

BellaNutella88 · 06/10/2021 19:50

I wouldn’t sell it. Unless finances were at a point where it could make a huge difference. We moved before Christmas and I think neighbours nearby have taken an offer for similar. Luckily it doesn’t impact our privacy. We had a hypothetical conversation about what we would do. We are comfortable as we are so we wouldn’t give up the garden.

Plus if you lose some of your garden and become massively overlooked could it affect resale value anyway. Although not enough impact compared to the gain!

Whatever you decide is right for your family is right at this moment in time so try not to use hindsight later down there line !

campion · 06/10/2021 19:50

Sounds like not everyone was happy for this to happen if previous appeals were turned down.

Garden grabbing developers want to make maximum profit for minimal outlay. They won't pay you the true value and you will live with the disruption, noise, mess and then houses in close proximity. No doubt they'll try to get permission to squeeze a couple more in. If it pisses off your other neighbours,so be it. You didn't agree to anything.

buttermutt · 06/10/2021 19:50

No-one will make £100k
Fees, solicitor, valuer, capital gains, the amount required by the mortgage company to adjust the value and/or loan to value (is your money eventually but only realised when you sell). Depending on the mortgage type and company- redemption fees and remortgaging costs

You don't have to pay CGT & there is no strict rule that the OPs property will automatically be devalued

2389Champ · 06/10/2021 19:50

I agree with most of the other posts. Don’t do it.

However, if you do decide to do it, drive a very very hard bargain with the developers. We sold my late MIL’s bungalow on a reasonable size plot for £380k. We thought we’d got away with a great price as the property needed a lot of updating etc.

The developer applied for planning permission, demolished it and built two detached houses which sold for £850k EACH! We clearly undersold without understanding the market.
£100k is a drop in the ocean to a serious developer.

bestsoupintown · 06/10/2021 19:49

I would say no. An ex did this with the same size garden and they were horribly overlooked. It ruined their garden and devalued their house. The big appeal of that house was the big garden.

AlmostAlwyn · 06/10/2021 19:48

If a developer can fit a detached house in your garden and has already obtained planning permission for it, then why don't you turn it down, but look on it as an emergency nest egg, should the need ever arise for additional funds or when you're planning on moving on?

I would enjoy the garden while your kids are young. My grandparents had a really big garden and it was amazing for me and my siblings to play in when we were young. When they decided to sell up/downsize, they sold half of the garden and a developer built two houses on the land.

If you sold now, I think you'd regret it more than if you don't accept!

EmKayEm · 06/10/2021 19:48

Don't do it.
Developers just lie. Full stop.
Imagine looking out onto a smaller garden and regretting it.
Think of the chickens, the playhouse, the hedgehogs.
Think of a building site in your back garden for as long as it takes and more because developers....
Keep your lovely garden.

Frazzled2207 · 06/10/2021 19:48

I would not sell 60% of my garden for 100k. Your house could easily devalue by most of that for starters.
Don’t let them bully you. What your neighbours think is irrelevant although ideally everyone would say no and the developers would go elsewhere

Although if you’re very bothered by the whole scenario I am curious as to why you moved there as the scenario has clearly been on the cards for some time.

Vancouverorbust · 06/10/2021 19:48

@LaetitiaASD

Only you can decide what to do but I'll say two things -

(1) Have you considered the selling the garden, then the house, then moving elsewhere?

(2) There is one thing that you DEFINITELY don't want to do. Refuse to sell and then see the person you sold to make the £100k that you could have made DO NOT LET THAT HAPPEN, EVER.

No-one will make £100k Fees, solicitor, valuer, capital gains, the amount required by the mortgage company to adjust the value and/or loan to value (is your money eventually but only realised when you sell). Depending on the mortgage type and company- redemption fees and remortgaging costs
ViceLikeBlip · 06/10/2021 19:47

I'm guessing that when you bought your house you could have looked at houses for 225 without a nice garden, but you chose not to do that. So if that's not what you wanted to live in, why create that living situation for yourself now?

Whatever happens, do NOT let the developers pressure you into making a quick decision. It's your decision to make. If they don't want to wait for your decision, then that's their perogative, and they can carry on without your land (FYI they won't do this!)

But if, for example, an extra 200k WOULD get you the sort of "step up" house that you wouldn't otherwise be able to afford, then set that as your price. Well, 250k probs to allow for knocking value off your current house.

latte101 · 06/10/2021 19:47

Do not sell. Keep your lovely garden. A friend of mine sold 2/3s of theirs and bitterly regrets it. House has considerably devalued, too.

Noeuf · 06/10/2021 19:47

www.thefriendlyaccountants.co.uk/tax-implications-of-selling-your-garden/ Helpful but here.

Also, if your mortgage is 300k you are likely to have a maximum overpayment per year (ours is 10%) without charges kicking in. So you’d have to work out what you would do with the money?

SoupDragon · 06/10/2021 19:47

I wouldn't sell the land.

Doris86 · 06/10/2021 19:44

If you love the garden and don’t need the money then say no, you’ll regret it.

In any case despite what they say, it won’t be the developers final offer. If they own the rest of the land and have planning permission, they’ll get more and more desparate to buy it from you.

Barnabyted · 06/10/2021 19:44

I would keep the garden as it is an spend a little time and money future proofing the boundary with shrubs/trees to provide privacy if the development goes ahead.
100k is not a lot for a plot of land, and in real terms, it could be less than this when you factor in depreciation on your own house, capital gains tax/tax on the 100k windfall and the cost of buying and selling if you decide you hate living with a smaller garden.
If you do want to sell and you have easy access to the rear of the garden, you could always apply for your own planning permission and then sell on the plot for a lot more than what the developer is offering.

MrsSchadenfreude · 06/10/2021 19:43

Turn it down. My parents were in the same position. The garden was why they loved the house. The developer was pissed off and there was nothing he could do. They had to replan the housing development as the houses both sides of my parents sold their gardens.

SisforSoppy · 06/10/2021 19:43

Don’t. £100k is a very small amount for a developer, so it won’t be their last offer. No amount of money would persuade me to sell the bottom of our garden, unless I was also planning on moving.