Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Self identifying as black or white

190 replies

MontEthna · 06/10/2021 16:53

Please hear me out.

I have two dcs, both dual citizens who have lived in the UK all their lives. When the census came, there was no way to put two citizenship on the form so I asked them what they wanted me to put. One said british, the other his other citizenship. So they clearly self identified/realted more as as having different citizenship iyswim.

I also have a cousin who mixed race. Her mum (my aunt) is white but her dad is black. But she has never had the opportunity to actually chose which race she is (the way my dcs could chose their main citizenship). She has always been considered black. That's despite the fact she has never lived in her dad's country/africa and was actually raised by another white aunt (having become an orphan). She doesn't relate to 'black culture'. The only way she feels 'different' culture wise is her hair - because she struggles to find a hairdresser who nows how to deal with it.

So my question is: why are people not able to chose which race they are? What if someone who is mixed race feels more like being white than being black (insert any other race there, it doesn't really matter)?

OP posts:
Linning · 06/10/2021 22:22

I am mixed race black/white (I am brown) and I consider myself culturally “white” (culturally French) as I grew up with the white side of my family but it wouldn’t occur to me to identify as “white”. I am NOT white. I am NOT black either though to the world I am a few shades closer to black than I am to white but I am brown. Calling myself white, on top of being erroneous, would be implying that I go through life experiencing life as a white person. I don’t. Your cousin doesn’t either according to the experiences you have said she faced.

She is brown (from what I get) and I am afraid she doesn’t get to pick that.

I don’t relate much to the African culture but I am still half-African. I relate most to French/“White” culture but I am still not white.

I would never identify as black (though I might self-describe as such for as the quickest descriptive), not because I am white, but because black folks face a very different reality to Brown/Mixed race/ lighter skin people of color, the same way white people have a totally different reality to mine and identifying as either would be detrimental to me and people like me.

I am mixed. Irrelevant of which side I relate to most or which one I wish I was. I will always be mixed, pretending I am not adds to the stigma surrounding mixed race individual and won’t make my life any better.

BakingOfTheFoodCats · 06/10/2021 22:01

I’m mixed race black/white and I consider myself white, I look white (everyone is very surprised when they find out my dad is black) even my kids insist I’m white 🙄

SnowyQueen · 06/10/2021 21:44

@donquixotedelamancha Humans are not remotely genetically grouped enough to have races. Race theory was disproven at the start of the 20th century.

I am mixed race. White and East Asian. Different races. This is different to saying you’re half English half Italian etc (mixed heritage).

charlestonchaplin · 06/10/2021 21:43

Radio silence from MNHQ as to why my posts keep getting deleted. I remember now why I told myself to avoid even opening threads on ethnicity/race, let alone engage.

Mummadeze · 06/10/2021 21:38

Her Dad has not really passed any of his culture on to her. He is mixed heritage himself but has lived in the U.K. for a long time. He doesn’t feel British but I don’t think he felt he really belonged in the country he grew up in either. We have never visited there as a family and he hasn’t taught her the language. It is his lack of cultural identity that has led to her being culturally British. She does say she is half xxx but those are just words to her. She knows very little about the country he was raised in.

Iloveabourbon2 · 06/10/2021 21:21

@Mummadeze

My DD is mixed / other. She doesn’t look black or white. She looks mixed. She is proud of being of mixed heritage and wouldn’t identify any other way. As a family, we truthfully never really think about racial differences. She is British in terms of her culture as she has only ever known life as a British person (despite her Dad being a different nationality). I don’t think it needs to be so complicated. If you are mixed, you are mixed!
It's interesting you state your DD is British yes because that's where she was born. But most people who have a foreign parent would class themselves as British like your saying but things like different foods... even accents from your parents can be picked up sometimes despite been born in UK. So your DD only relates to a British culture? With a foreign parent.
MontEthna · 06/10/2021 21:16

@Mummadeze does your dd not feel part of her culture is also her dad’s?

OP posts:
TheOneDropRuleIsRacist · 06/10/2021 21:06

Indeed @Mummadeze

Mummadeze · 06/10/2021 21:05

My DD is mixed / other. She doesn’t look black or white. She looks mixed. She is proud of being of mixed heritage and wouldn’t identify any other way. As a family, we truthfully never really think about racial differences. She is British in terms of her culture as she has only ever known life as a British person (despite her Dad being a different nationality). I don’t think it needs to be so complicated. If you are mixed, you are mixed!

Inthesameboatatmo · 06/10/2021 20:59

@ozanj.
Exactly the same as me romany and Indian.
There are 4 of us .
My brother and myself are tanned with black hair and dark eyes our 2 sisters are very pale with blond hair and blue eyes we all most definitely have the same father.

MontEthna · 06/10/2021 20:59

In some ways, to me, culture is more relevant than the colour of the skin.

I’m always reminded of friends of mine in the south of France. Some of them have dark skin, esp at the end of the summer. Here they would probably fall into the black/mixed race category. But there they are white that happen to tan very well.
Culturally, this makes more sense to me rather than assuming a mixed heritage/culture they don’t have iyswim

OP posts:
donquixotedelamancha · 06/10/2021 20:58

No, because race isn’t a biological category in humans and sex is.

Indeed. It's arguably reasonable to identify with a 'race' you've joined because so much is culture. It's utterly fucking batshit to identify as the opposite sex.

(NB this is not having a go at trans people. Most trans people know exactly what sex they are)

MontEthna · 06/10/2021 20:54

@MurielSpriggs, yes that’s one question I’ve been asking myself.

How far are you supposed to go back?
Is my cousin son, who has one black grand parents and 3 white grand parents still considered black/mixed race? What about his own dcs if he gets married with a white woman or someone from an entirely different race??

When people are looking at ancestry and are doing genetic testing, it is clear that we all have very varied background race wise. But somehow we are all bogged down by the colour of our skin and our facial features.

OP posts:
Theoldprospector · 06/10/2021 20:53

‘Is that the same sort of difference one would make between sex and gender?’

No, because race isn’t a biological category in humans and sex is.

donquixotedelamancha · 06/10/2021 20:52

You can’t choose your race as this is based on biological aspects.

It really isn't. In Spain there are villages 20 miles apart which are more genetically different than two people you might pick from different continents.

Some phenotypes (like African features and sickle cell anemia) correlate but that's not race.

Broccoli, Cauliflower, sprouts and cabbages are races of cabbage- all the same species. A great dane and a sausage dog are the same race.

Physical differences and similarities do not mean that a group are necessarily genetically similar.

MontEthna · 06/10/2021 20:50

I didn’t know that @MyMabel
Thank you.

Is that the same sort of difference one would make between sex and gender?

OP posts:
charlestonchaplin · 06/10/2021 20:46

I don’t know how to contact MNHQ so I’ve had to guess why my very considered posts were deleted and alter accordingly.

MurielSpriggs · 06/10/2021 20:46

I don't think there is any definition of black or white (or any other"race") that isn't based on how you look.

Black = African heritage? How many generations? Are Afrikaners black? What if I have an Afrikaner grandparent? In any event most of us who identify as black or white don't know where our ancestors beyond our grandparents were born. And anyway what makes them either black or white? We'd need to know about their ancestors.

We say we're black of white because of what we look like and what our immediate ancestors look like.

donquixotedelamancha · 06/10/2021 20:46

I don't get why people say that race is not real. The fact that I am Jewish is very relevant to my medical history, as there are certain conditions that are far more prevalent among Ashkenazi Jews than among the general population.

That was me. I'm a biochemist. Humans are not remotely genetically grouped enough to have races. Race theory was disproven at the start of the 20th century.

The idea that small phenotypic differences like skin colour or medical conditions in particular groups constitute a separate race which determines people's character is racism.

I am not for a moment minimising the importance of culture and heritage but I think OP is right not to use the racist's idea's and language to describe her family.

charlestonchaplin · 06/10/2021 20:45

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Theoldprospector · 06/10/2021 20:42

Ethnicity in the U.K. is a matter of self identification. You can choose whichever one you want.

MyMabel · 06/10/2021 20:42

I think you’re getting race and ethnicity confused.

You can’t choose your race as this is based on biological aspects.

But they can choose their ethnicity as this boils down to how you identify.

And like others have said in particular with disasters, things like sickle cell disease is much more common in people with African backgrounds, this isn’t something you would want to leave off of your medical history.

Wrenna · 06/10/2021 20:37

@MatildaIThink

If someone with a penis can self identify as female I don't see why someone with white skin cannot self identify as black. I think both are wrong, but one group should not get special "self-identifying" credentials if another does not.
^^This
TheOneDropRuleIsRacist · 06/10/2021 20:35

I wasn't stopping you from replying. We were crossposting and I thought we were having a conversation but you did what anyone who feels caught out or challenged does, attack and in the laziest way possible. Not any different from anyone else who does the same, is it?

Can't take you seriously after that.

TheOneDropRuleIsRacist · 06/10/2021 20:32

That was to charlestonchaplin

Swipe left for the next trending thread