Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Self identifying as black or white

190 replies

MontEthna · 06/10/2021 16:53

Please hear me out.

I have two dcs, both dual citizens who have lived in the UK all their lives. When the census came, there was no way to put two citizenship on the form so I asked them what they wanted me to put. One said british, the other his other citizenship. So they clearly self identified/realted more as as having different citizenship iyswim.

I also have a cousin who mixed race. Her mum (my aunt) is white but her dad is black. But she has never had the opportunity to actually chose which race she is (the way my dcs could chose their main citizenship). She has always been considered black. That's despite the fact she has never lived in her dad's country/africa and was actually raised by another white aunt (having become an orphan). She doesn't relate to 'black culture'. The only way she feels 'different' culture wise is her hair - because she struggles to find a hairdresser who nows how to deal with it.

So my question is: why are people not able to chose which race they are? What if someone who is mixed race feels more like being white than being black (insert any other race there, it doesn't really matter)?

OP posts:
LaetitiaASD · 07/10/2021 09:25

@MontEthna

Please hear me out.

I have two dcs, both dual citizens who have lived in the UK all their lives. When the census came, there was no way to put two citizenship on the form so I asked them what they wanted me to put. One said british, the other his other citizenship. So they clearly self identified/realted more as as having different citizenship iyswim.

I also have a cousin who mixed race. Her mum (my aunt) is white but her dad is black. But she has never had the opportunity to actually chose which race she is (the way my dcs could chose their main citizenship). She has always been considered black. That's despite the fact she has never lived in her dad's country/africa and was actually raised by another white aunt (having become an orphan). She doesn't relate to 'black culture'. The only way she feels 'different' culture wise is her hair - because she struggles to find a hairdresser who nows how to deal with it.

So my question is: why are people not able to chose which race they are? What if someone who is mixed race feels more like being white than being black (insert any other race there, it doesn't really matter)?

Surely it's simple racism?

White people are pure white. Black means black or non-white.

Yes, you can call someone mixed race if you want, but ultimately they're not pure or white therefore they are black.

FWIW, it seems to me that a mixed raced person has every right to identify as mixed race, and they also have a right to identify as black which by definition means that they also have a right to identify as white.

Linning · 07/10/2021 09:25

@MontEthna

I fully agree with someone being the sums fo many different parts rather than just the race part of things.

@Linning, I can see what you mean about being both but relating to a specific culture.

It’s an interesting point because listening to black people in the US, I get the strong feeling that being black and being part of the black culture are two things strongly intertwined and inseparable. So you have people who black but with a ‘pale’ colour (their words) who still feel black - as culturally part of the black community. There seems to be quite a bit of tension around that too with ‘darker’ skin people saying that they still have it harder than the lighter skin people and telling them they can’t call themselves black Confused
They also don’t seem to have the concept of mixed race (unless I’m mistaken)

I used to live in the US and it’s true that black people (regardless of their shade of blackness/darkness) are very attached to their black identity and culture. In fact while in the US, I too fell a very strong sense of attachment to my black identity and to black culture and it did become a center point of my identity and, in many ways, life there. BUT that’s because race and racial divide is SUCH SUCH a big thing in the US.

I used to live in California so probably the most liberal and multicultural place in the US alongside NYC and it was impossible to detach yourself from your ethnic background, no matter which one you belonged to. You are litterally forced to. Not by society as much as by how the US system works. Every form you ever fill ask you about your ethnic background, treatment of individuals from different ethnic backgrounds are treated differently. African-American people are shot by police, Asian- Americans are being beaten up and killed by fellow citizens, Mexicans and Latinos are treated like dirt under people’s shoes. There is NO other way than to become even more fiercely proud and protective of your culture and identity.

In the US there was NO WAY I could even pretend I was white. I absolutely feared the police, and equally feared vocally racist and agressive white folks. The treatment of black people, the stereotyping of black women, the conditions of life of black kids. It’s impossible to ignore. You simply cannot ignore statistics and it was impossible to deny my African black side when there because things that were happening were too outrageous, too painful, too infuriating, and too unfair for me to hide behind any white identity. In fact in the US I became angry, angry at the white side of me/my family. I became even more aware of the ingrained racism in my (white) family, even more outraged by it, at me for not noticing and not standing up to it for too long and at them for bathing in their white privileges all while denying how harmful their views/actions and lack of actions are.

As a mixed race light skin person I absolutely DO NOT have the same experience as darker black folks. I never have and I never will. Black folks are right in saying a brown girl only knows parts of the struggle. As an half-white woman, I have benefited greatly from white privileges. I have a white mom who can get me out of trouble if need be, I have had access (to a certain extent) to the wealth, education and power of my quite family, I have half the generational trauma of a full-black family, I am lighter skinned and therefore seen as more attractive than darker skin women, I don’t suffer from the same negative stereotype as darker black women, I don’t fear the police the way I would if I was darker (it doesn’t mean that I don’t fear them, but that I know that if my family got involved I would have more chances of it being solved without or with less violence than if my entire family was black) and I don’t suffer racism to the extent someone darker does.

As a light(er)-skin black woman I felt deeply black in America, but I am NOT black. I am brown, and I go through life being treated as such.

Mixed race is a thing in the US but remember that most African-Americans are mixed race, a lot are
more dark-brown than black and most African-American have NO clue of their ancestry due to slavery. The notion of Bi-raciality is therefore way less understood and less inclusive/accepted than in Europe. It’s a problem but it’s also not surprising when you look at the US history.

apalledandshocked · 07/10/2021 09:17

I also think it is a particularly tense discussion in America because although many black people have white ancestors further back their family tree and therefore paler skin this is largely due to historical rape. So saying to people they can't define themselves as black/should define themselves as mixed race because of this would be insensitive to say the least. Plus as others have said the one drop rule, and all of the historical ways in which racial boundaries were drawn.
A child born today to two parents of different ethnicities/races as part of a consensual relationship (like my son) is going to have a very different relationship to both sides of that identity.

PRsecrets · 07/10/2021 09:13

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

apalledandshocked · 07/10/2021 09:10

I think part of the problem is that race is often defined by difference and (whether rightly or not) at least in part assigned by other people.
So my son is mixed race. He would probably be described as "black" in the UK, certainly in the USA. When he visits West Africa (where his dad is from) he is white (or sometimes referred to as Chinese because apparently white+black=Asian but that's a whole other thing...)
Where we live now is very ethnically diverse, with a lot of other mixed race/mixed heritage familes. So he tends to refer to himself as "brown, like my friend X". This is the way he chooses to define himself and is, in my opinion, the most accurate. But there is no doubt that it is easier for him to define himself so because of where we live and who his peers are.

PlanDeRaccordement · 07/10/2021 09:02

listening to black people in the US, I get the strong feeling that being black and being part of the black culture are two things strongly intertwined and inseparable. So you have people who black but with a ‘pale’ colour (their words) who still feel black - as culturally part of the black community. There seems to be quite a bit of tension around that too with ‘darker’ skin people saying that they still have it harder than the lighter skin people and telling them they can’t call themselves black

Because you can be biologically black and have light skin colour. There is more biologically to being black than dark skin. The same with being white, or Asian you can be light or dark skinned and still white or Asian.

The tension you mention is called colourism. Which is different from racism and is present in all the races for different reasons.

PlanDeRaccordement · 07/10/2021 08:59

@MontEthna
The US does have the concept of mixed race, they call it multiracial and on their census but they only have one box to tick if mixed race titled:
“Two or more races”

Not sure how far back they have had it, but this shows it was on both the 2010 and 2020 census.

www.census.gov/library/stories/2021/08/improved-race-ethnicity-measures-reveal-united-states-population-much-more-multiracial.html

PlanDeRaccordement · 07/10/2021 08:55

This is why they added mixed boxes to tick in the ethnicity sections of forms. I wouldn’t over think things.

Bagamoyo1 · 07/10/2021 08:48

I don’t think race is purely a social construct. There are biological differences in terms of tendency to develop certain medical conditions and response to certain medication.

Bagamoyo1 · 07/10/2021 08:44

@Bimblybomeyelash

This is all quite goady.
It’s called discussion.
MontEthna · 07/10/2021 07:58

I fully agree with someone being the sums fo many different parts rather than just the race part of things.

@Linning, I can see what you mean about being both but relating to a specific culture.

It’s an interesting point because listening to black people in the US, I get the strong feeling that being black and being part of the black culture are two things strongly intertwined and inseparable. So you have people who black but with a ‘pale’ colour (their words) who still feel black - as culturally part of the black community. There seems to be quite a bit of tension around that too with ‘darker’ skin people saying that they still have it harder than the lighter skin people and telling them they can’t call themselves black Confused
They also don’t seem to have the concept of mixed race (unless I’m mistaken)

OP posts:
SnowyQueen · 07/10/2021 07:49

@Theoldprospector

‘I am mixed race. White and East Asian. Different races. This is different to saying you’re half English half Italian etc (mixed heritage).’

There are no races in human genetics or biology.

Are you white? It’s always the white people who tell me I can’t be mixed race, even though my mum and dad are 100% different races! I am half this and half that. And proud.
SnowyQueen · 07/10/2021 07:44

[quote MontEthna]@MurielSpriggs, yes that’s one question I’ve been asking myself.

How far are you supposed to go back?
Is my cousin son, who has one black grand parents and 3 white grand parents still considered black/mixed race? What about his own dcs if he gets married with a white woman or someone from an entirely different race??

When people are looking at ancestry and are doing genetic testing, it is clear that we all have very varied background race wise. But somehow we are all bogged down by the colour of our skin and our facial features.[/quote]
I wouldn’t say that he’s black as he is only a quarter. I would say he is the last in his line that could say he’s mixed race. If he has DC with a white woman then their DC would not be mixed race.

Somuddled · 07/10/2021 07:38

[quote cinnabarmoth]@Somuddled other posters have already said it, but it bears repeating - race is no longer considered a biological fact, but a social construct.
Wikipedia is not a bad starting point en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Race_(human_categorization)
but for an interesting and accessible book on this subject, you could try A Brief History of Everyone Who Ever lived, by Adam Rutherford.[/quote]
Interesting, thanks for the recommendations. Will read up on it. I'd always taken it that hunam race categorization is certainly a social construct but on based on inherited (and therfore biological) observable physical differences between humans. Therefore, if you subscribe to the categorization system, you do so based on physical facts.

AgentJohnson · 07/10/2021 07:34

My sisters and I could have ticked different boxes on the census (we didn’t because only one of us lives in the UK), we come from the same ethnic background but we are individuals, whose cultural experiences have been different.

Your relative being able to ‘pass’ as a different ethnicity could have impacted how some people and society have treated her, and those experiences, may have informed how she identifies.

My old flatmate in Amsterdam and I came from the same ethnic and cultural background but our different skin tones, informed people’s differing reactions to us. Likewise, our similar educational backgrounds elevated us (in the eyes of some) from those in a similar income bracket. For many, my flat mates Britishness elevated her above the local Black community.

I am an individual, I am more than my individual parts. If some people wish to put me in a box because of particular aspects of my existence, that’s there lookout.

cinnabarmoth · 07/10/2021 07:11

@Somuddled other posters have already said it, but it bears repeating - race is no longer considered a biological fact, but a social construct.
Wikipedia is not a bad starting point en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Race_(human_categorization)
but for an interesting and accessible book on this subject, you could try A Brief History of Everyone Who Ever lived, by Adam Rutherford.

Somuddled · 07/10/2021 06:47

You can usually become any nationality you want though, through meeting that country's requirements. Race, age, sex are all biological, so you can't just self identify. They are static facts.

donquixotedelamancha · 07/10/2021 06:18

How do you explain research and conclusions like these then (and many others)? Researches seem to believe races do exist?

That research doesn't say that. It doesn't mention race once.

Why is anyone so determined to promote race theory?

Theoldprospector · 07/10/2021 03:39

‘How do you explain research and conclusions like these then (and many others)? Researches seem to believe races do exist?’

They are socially defined groups. Lots of biological research is done on socially defined groups. The populations of different countries, different regions, different cities, different classes can all form social categories in medical research. That doesn’t mean the groups themselves are biologically defined.

mustlovegin · 06/10/2021 23:47

There are no races in human genetics or biology

How do you explain research and conclusions like these then (and many others)? Researches seem to believe races do exist?

Moderate caffeine intake associated with higher level for Asians, lower for whites

www.nih.gov/news-events/news-releases/nih-study-shows-caffeine-consumption-linked-estrogen-changes

DaphneDeloresMoorhead · 06/10/2021 23:38

@toocold54

And the other way around, there was a story a few years back about a baby born from two black parents but was white.

Your genetics are your genetics. If you’re albino and your parents are both black, you are still black. I watched a documentary about a black family with albino children and the children identified as being black.

There are a lot of racial stereotypes which people think if they don’t fit into it must be because they identify as a different race but it’s not. Very similar to those who believe they must be born in the wrong body because they like cars instead of make up etc.

www.refinery29.com/en-gb/2018/06/201299/joanne-dion-model

This lady as well identifies as being Black - while she has albinism and therefore "white" colouring clearly there is more to her idenity as a black woman than the colour of her skin. Was a very interesting article.

donquixotedelamancha · 06/10/2021 23:07

I still don't see why recognising that biological differences and similarities exist among groups of people with common ancestry is false or racist.

Of course not. I'm merely suggesting that we avoid using the language of race theory.

That said, I'm not going to tell anyone how they should self describe- just saying I agree with OP's points.

Dilbertian · 06/10/2021 22:54

The idea that small phenotypic differences like skin colour or medical conditions in particular groups constitute a separate race which determines people's character is racism.

I entirely agree. Ascribing character traits or stereotypes to people based upon their skin colour or ancestry is racism.

I still don't see why recognising that biological differences and similarities exist among groups of people with common ancestry is false or racist.

Linning · 06/10/2021 22:33

Also OP, it’s white people who usually act as if brown folks can’t be remotely white and have no white heritage, black/POC usually like to emphasize the white heritage of Mixed individuals as a way to outcast them from POC struggles and experiences.

So no, Mixed race/brown people are FOREVER reminded of their dual heritages just not for the same reason and not in the same way. If anything, people have tried to suppress my black heritage more than my white heritage.

“Oh don’t be silly, you are not black, just a bit coffee and Milk.”

“Oh you look like you are from Brazil or one of the islands!”

I just have to self-refer as black for a white person to come jumping and reassure me I am not Confused.

I don’t even know where I could get away with self-referencing as white and it positively affecting my life. I think it would just make people laugh and likely expose me to bullying/harassment and potential physical harm from people who disagree all while not protecting me at all from the downsides I experience as an half-black individual.

Theoldprospector · 06/10/2021 22:32

‘I am mixed race. White and East Asian. Different races. This is different to saying you’re half English half Italian etc (mixed heritage).’

There are no races in human genetics or biology.

Swipe left for the next trending thread