Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Self identifying as black or white

190 replies

MontEthna · 06/10/2021 16:53

Please hear me out.

I have two dcs, both dual citizens who have lived in the UK all their lives. When the census came, there was no way to put two citizenship on the form so I asked them what they wanted me to put. One said british, the other his other citizenship. So they clearly self identified/realted more as as having different citizenship iyswim.

I also have a cousin who mixed race. Her mum (my aunt) is white but her dad is black. But she has never had the opportunity to actually chose which race she is (the way my dcs could chose their main citizenship). She has always been considered black. That's despite the fact she has never lived in her dad's country/africa and was actually raised by another white aunt (having become an orphan). She doesn't relate to 'black culture'. The only way she feels 'different' culture wise is her hair - because she struggles to find a hairdresser who nows how to deal with it.

So my question is: why are people not able to chose which race they are? What if someone who is mixed race feels more like being white than being black (insert any other race there, it doesn't really matter)?

OP posts:
NumberNineTwo · 07/10/2021 13:51

Surely it has nothing to do with “relating to the culture”? Otherwise Rachel Dolezal could claim to be black because she identified with black culture. I’d expect it to be based on your heritage i.e. genetics.

MontEthna · 07/10/2021 13:48

Well I can see why tbh.

I’ve raised my dcs with my own culture (they got the Britishness form DH). I see no reason why I should have raised them BRITISH when my own country/culture is also part of who they are.

But on a race pov, if people are going to constantly assume you are black and treat you as such, it is essential for the child to also have the tools to deal with that.
I mean I ve never experienced racism because I’m white. But I’ve experience xenophobia, its cousin. It made sense to me to teach my dcs how to handle xenophobia and to be sure they were proud of ALSO being half something else.

Plus, there is no way I could have raised them BRITISH because I’m not BRITISH. I’m going to assume that it’s quite hard to raise a child to ‘be white’ if you are not white yourself….

OP posts:
LaetitiaASD · 07/10/2021 13:28

@PRsecrets

Both he and his mum have suffered untold racism in the UK but that doesn't change who he is. He just happens to be a mixed race man who's suffered untold racism in the UK - his suffering doesn't turn him into Black. By that logic, a black person isn't really black if they haven't suffered racism yet.

As I've said before, I learned a lot of what I know now from him.

While his view is valid, you should remember that your husband is just one person. So if you yourself are not mixed race or black, you would do well to learn more about race than from that tiny pool of one. Many mixed race brits identify as black - Lewis Hamilton, Afua Hirsch and Akala being a few off the top of my head. And they do so for very valid reasons. Some of which are why, as I explained more fully upthread, I'm raising my mixed children to proudly identify as both mixed race and black.

In all seriousness why aren't you raising them as white too? Other than because the country is predominantly white, quite racist, and you can;t identify as white unless you pass the Yaxley-Lennon test
TheOneDropRuleIsRacist · 07/10/2021 11:53

@PRsecrets

I think we're coming at this from slightly different angles but generally on the same page. In many ways, I understand and agree with what you're saying. I disagree with a few bits but I'm not going to push it, as it's not about forcing my opinion on anyone.

I'm just stating mine, like everybody else.

PRsecrets · 07/10/2021 11:44

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

TheOneDropRuleIsRacist · 07/10/2021 11:35

And not because I've suffered racism or I may suffer racism again. There's more to me being Black than that. I was surrounded by a whole community of Black people so I know.

I've actually suffered far fewer incidents of racism than he has, so I suppose he's Blacker than I am. If that's the key factor.

VladmirsPoutine · 07/10/2021 11:31

I've had this discussion with some of my mixed race friends and interestingly there is a difference in identity depending on which parent is of which race. In the most general sense (and true of myself also) if your mother is black you're more inclined to identify with your black side than if your mother is white (not sure how this stacks up in other mixes). Anecdote is of course not data - but I find people's individual reasoning very interesting as there's no 'rule'.

TheOneDropRuleIsRacist · 07/10/2021 11:30

I am Black.

PRsecrets · 07/10/2021 11:26

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

TheOneDropRuleIsRacist · 07/10/2021 10:30

My husband is biracial - His dad is white British and his mum is a monoracial Black woman from Nigeria, so not mixed (People often forget that there are Black people who are "pure" too and aren't mixed). He calls himself biracial because he's a product of two races.

He was raised as a whole person to identify with and be proud of both cultures without the need to choose one. This gave him a strong grasp of who he is from an early age. He said he's never allowed anyone to make him choose where he belongs when he doesn't belong to one community but both. If he's to choose, then it's a whole new community of mixed race, rather than go to either side. (Meghan Markle and her dad said the same thing).

In Nigeria, he's seen as both Nigerian and British, as well as either mixed race (because of who he is) or white (because of how he looks to them). There's no one drop rule in Nigeria, you are what you are and what your parents are. Although, in some places there, you are what your father is. In the UK, he looks mixed, not black or white.

Both he and his mum have suffered untold racism in the UK but that doesn't change who he is. He just happens to be a mixed race man who's suffered untold racism in the UK - his suffering doesn't turn him into Black. By that logic, a black person isn't really black if they haven't suffered racism yet.

As I've said before, I learned a lot of what I know now from him.

BiBabbles · 07/10/2021 10:30

We can choose on most paperwork - you get occasional situations where someone official else asks and they choose to put down a different answer or they just put something down without asking which is really fucking annoying, but for most things, people can pick what to put down and how to identify their backgrounds.

Whether others agree with us is a different matter. Other people identify me as all sorts of backgrounds - no Brit ever gets it right. It doesn't change what my heritage is, but there are times it noticeable changes how people treat me. Part of our identities is always social - how other people treat us affects how we see ourselves and cultures create ways to divide people.

My kids are mixed and get remarks about how they're "not really British" based on how they look and even more on how they sound. My DS1 identifies as White British and he always puts that when asked. He's not erasing anything, it's how he views himself - he doesn't think being a bit darker than most White people he knows or having one parent of another background changes that he's British. His accent doesn't change his cultural background, what we celebrate in our home with him doesn't change it either.

My DD1, who has probably had the shitty remarks the most out of my 4 kids, puts down Mixed or 'Prefer not to answer' though she also very clearly identifies as British too when asked. She's not erasing anything either, she just hates that so many people make assumptions about her on how she looks and sounds and prefers not to see herself that way.

There is no singular black culture, just like there is no singular white culture, or any other racial category. Cultures change as their populations change, and people can continuously change how they interact with the ideas, social norms and behaviours, stories and other creations around them and how that affects our sense of self may change over time. Few in the UK are only within one culture these days and what makes British / English / Welsh / Scottish / Cornish / Manx... culture depends on who you ask. Kids like mine, immigrants like me, we're part of that.

MontEthna · 07/10/2021 10:29

As for the OP's original query, the cousin would be categorised as a POC now (the term which seems to be replacing BAME). Basically everyone who is not completely white is a person of colour. Which is bloody weird actually, it's basically saying there's a "default" or "normal" (white) and then an "everything else" bucket.

Yes. That's one thing that is making me deeply unconfortable.
It's putting whiteness above everything else.

There has been some talk too about being 'pure' white which I am finding deeply uncomfortable too.

OP posts:
TheOneDropRuleIsRacist · 07/10/2021 10:28

I agree julieca

Jenala · 07/10/2021 10:26

I worked with someone once who was very concerned about a teenage boy she was working with, whose heritage was half white, half black African. His black African parent had abandoned him as a young child and he had an strong feelings of anger and rejection around it, understandably. But my colleagues concern was that the young person insisted he was "white" and wouldn't identify as "black". To me this was just representative of his feeling towards his parent, and I felt with time he may want to explore his heritage and that side of his family. However right now we had a young, dual ethnicity teenager who needed support. However my colleague pushed for him to join our BLM group, be part of our BAME looked after children group etc, really pushed for him to 'embrace his black identity'. It made me think for the first time about how children with one white and black parent are told they are black. It made me think of the old one drop rule in America and how racist that was. How does it feel to be have one white parent and white black parent, and yet be told all white people are all racist against black people, whether they mean to be or not, knowing one of your parents is white? Being told no you're black, not white, despite your white parent, and white people are all by default racist. It must be so hard. And it's told to you in the name of anti-racism.

While the teenager in my example no doubt would be better off making peace with all of his identity, to me the starting point felt like looking at his trauma and parental relationships, not pushing an ethnic 'identity' on him that he just didn't want to be embracing at that time. We wouldn't insist a child who had a parent from a traveller background that they hated should join a special group for traveller children, or if a child with a different, non-black mixed heritage felt that way we wouldn't push Japanese or Lithuanian or whatever culture they were from on them. I worry about how dual ethnicity children feel when we boil race down to white vs non white, which seems to often be the view promoted specifically by anti-racists. Like in the channel 4 documentary about a school trying to end racism, where the dual ethnicity girl was being forced to choose black or white... Who is that helping? How is that reducing divisiveness?

julieca · 07/10/2021 10:10

I don't think it is goady. It is just an uncomfortable subject because it raises so many issues.
But lets face it we don't really talk in Britain with any nuance around race at all. It is like this whole subject that people are afraid to talk about unless it is to spout racism.

Theoldprospector · 07/10/2021 10:06

‘Are you white? It’s always the white people who tell me I can’t be mixed race, even though my mum and dad are 100% different races! I am half this and half that. And proud.’

I am not telling you you can’t identify as mixed race. You can identify is whatever you want.

I am stating that race is a social category for humans not a biological one.

This is simply a matter of fact. The field of biology does not divide humans up into different races; it doesn’t recognise them as existing biologically.

Yes there is human geographical variation in certain health conditions, but these do not map on to outmoded models of different races that were invented based on slavery.

VladmirsPoutine · 07/10/2021 10:04

Is the phrase "passing for black" ever used? Not frequently, I would guess.

In a different context, say blackfishing, yes. Though I accept in that instance it's that they aim to pass for mixed / ambiguous rather than fully black. It's a huge and very profitable industry.

AGameOfCrones · 07/10/2021 10:01

All humans are one species, sure, but all dogs are one species - you still get different categories (e.g. wolves are the same species as a poodle, but very different physically and in terms of temperament)

Wolves are canis lupus and dogs are canis familiaris- same genus but distinct species

knittingaddict · 07/10/2021 09:59

@Bimblybomeyelash

This is all quite goady.
It's making me uncomfortable too. Not necessarily goady though.

I think it's all the "passing for white" comments. It's as if you think people with lighter skins and more "white" features are obtaining something that isn't rightfully theirs. I suppose it at least acknowledges that being white is an advantage, so that's something.

Is the phrase "passing for black" ever used? Not frequently, I would guess.

Brainfogmcfogface · 07/10/2021 09:51

My daughters are both mixed race (white British/black Caribbean) one is darker skinned and may not be obviously mixed to anyone who doesn’t know. Neither sees their black
Family and are being raised in a predominantly white area where they are the only people of colour in their classes. But both relate to and are proud of their black heritage because it’s my job as their mother to educate them, to bring black culture into their lives and show them black excellence and pride. Granted I can’t directly relate but I have learned and educated myself, I've sought guidance from black friends and support, I’ve made sure that they aren’t being raised to just identify with my side as their blackness is something that I want them to be comfortable with and understand and take pride in. I’ve seen the results of someone who is mixed race being raised entirely white, and the self hate is so strong, I feel sad talking to her, her family has messed her whole sense of self up to the point she is basically racist towards black people. So imo it’s not for your cousin to chose, it’s for the person raising her to make sure she doesn’t have to and is proud of all her aspects heritage and is comfortable with who she is. And if they’re not doing that (and the fact this thread exists where you expect her to choose suggests they aren’t) then your family are setting her up for a lifetime of feeling like an outsider and never truly knowing herself because a whole part of her identity is being ignored.

julieca · 07/10/2021 09:50

My family has children, young adults who look very different. One who is clearly Middle Eastern, one who could pass for Mediterranean or white on a beach, and one who looks totally white, down to the freckles and very pale skin. If I didn't know better, I would wonder if they really were related Grin
I have also noticed that people in Britain don't accept if a white person says they are African. A friend, totally white not mixed was born and brought up in Africa but now lives in Britain. If he says he is African this is never accepted. A white person can't be African!

julieca · 07/10/2021 09:42

Race is a social construct, but a powerful one. Yes some ethnicities are more prone to certain illnesses or biological factors such as lactose intolerance. That is simple genetics and sometimes cultural lifestyles. Because for all the talk of mixing, until relatively recently, most people married and had children with someone who was born within 50 miles of where they lived. So certain genes become more concentrated in geographical areas.
For example near me was a large village that was known fifty years ago for having an unusually high number of people with six fingers. An extreme example, but genetic susceptibility to some diseases is about genetics and breeding, not race. It simply correlates with race.
Cultural lifestyle can also be a factor. So diabetes is far higher amongst white people in Britain than in Japanese communities. Because the lifestyle is so different. Although again there can be an inherited propensity probably through epigenetics. If you have parents who have diabetes from a young age, you are more likely to develop diabetes.

HarrietsChariot · 07/10/2021 09:40

Personally I don't understand why I could legally change my gender, but cannot change my age or race.

To me, I feel I am physically closer to being a black woman than I am a white man. I'm physically closer to being a 20yo or a 60yo woman than a 40yo man (and my current body is probably closer to the 60yo than my actual age, ahem).

I'm not sure how race is no longer deemed an actual thing, as some posters claim. All humans are one species, sure, but all dogs are one species - you still get different categories (e.g. wolves are the same species as a poodle, but very different physically and in terms of temperament).

If race didn't exist then by definition racism can't exist either. You can't discriminate on the basis of something that isn't real. The law, and my own eyes, tell me otherwise.

As for the OP's original query, the cousin would be categorised as a POC now (the term which seems to be replacing BAME). Basically everyone who is not completely white is a person of colour. Which is bloody weird actually, it's basically saying there's a "default" or "normal" (white) and then an "everything else" bucket.

TheOneDropRuleIsRacist · 07/10/2021 09:32

Great post, Linning and thought-provoking.

apalledandshocked · 07/10/2021 09:28

@PRsecrets To be honest, I have worried about that as well. The country we live in can be quite racist in parts, but I have noticed that he is often assumed by other people to be Morrocan or North African. Of course they are also subject to prejudice from the police, but most of the Moroccans I know describe themselves as Moroccan rather than black. My son would always correct someone if they asked if he was Moroccan - not because he is prejudice, he has friends who are, but just because he isn't. In the US he would definitely be considered black but his father point blank refuses to go there (I don't blame him) - so he hasn't experienced that yet. Its not that I'm against him defining himself as black, but because he visits his fathers family a lot I know that would be confusing to him because over there he isn't black. Ironically I think if he had less contact with that side of his heritage, it would be easier to define himself as black but having contact with that side is extremely important. What I don't want to do is create a situation where the white side of his family (me) is telling him he isn't white or mixed race, he is black and his relationships on the African side telling him he isn't black. As that would leave him with nowhere. So I am happy, for the time at least, that he is happy with his identity of mixed race, and has people around him who also reflect that. But I know he could have problems as he grows up.

Swipe left for the next trending thread