Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Self identifying as black or white

190 replies

MontEthna · 06/10/2021 16:53

Please hear me out.

I have two dcs, both dual citizens who have lived in the UK all their lives. When the census came, there was no way to put two citizenship on the form so I asked them what they wanted me to put. One said british, the other his other citizenship. So they clearly self identified/realted more as as having different citizenship iyswim.

I also have a cousin who mixed race. Her mum (my aunt) is white but her dad is black. But she has never had the opportunity to actually chose which race she is (the way my dcs could chose their main citizenship). She has always been considered black. That's despite the fact she has never lived in her dad's country/africa and was actually raised by another white aunt (having become an orphan). She doesn't relate to 'black culture'. The only way she feels 'different' culture wise is her hair - because she struggles to find a hairdresser who nows how to deal with it.

So my question is: why are people not able to chose which race they are? What if someone who is mixed race feels more like being white than being black (insert any other race there, it doesn't really matter)?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Starseeking · 10/10/2021 13:47

So my question is: why are people not able to choose which race they are? What if someone who is mixed race feels more like being white than being Black

As far as I understand it, race is a social construct, designed to organise hierarchically, and according to power structures.

Put simply, white at that top, Black at the bottom, and the various shades in between, with associated levels of power. White has always been exclusionary. Such is the power of the conditioning, I've never heard of a person with visibly darker skin than pale being described as white. I've seen and heard of many mixed race people being accepted into Black communities.

I know of one mixed race family where the Black dad left the white mum when the DC were toddlers. The DD is white passing, hates anything to do with anything Black or related, and refers to herself as white. The DS is closer in skin tone to his DF, and calls himself Black. That's just one example, but most likely based on what others project onto them, rather than what they actually are (they have the same parents).

So to sum up, to me, the answer to your query is not about the individuals themselves, but about the wider societal view of race, which can be more complex, depending on where you are, and your history (e.g. people with both white and Black heritage will have extremely different experiences in the US, UK and South Africa).

PlanDeRaccordement · 09/10/2021 22:44

@ddl1
No haven’t seen thuletide before. But I did read the study that the blogger referenced and looked up where he/she got the cluster data from and it is faithfully replicated. I find that no source can be completely trusted or not trusted (been let down too many times) so I tend to take each article on its own merits. Same with MN posters tbf. Sometimes I think a poster is bat shit on one thread, but on another they are the voice of reason. We all have our strengths and bias weaknesses.

mustlovegin · 09/10/2021 22:39

Have you seen the other articles on 'Thuletide'?

The blogger is just commenting on work by Harvard University plus a study published in Nature.

In 2014, Harvard University’s Reich Lab published one of the largest genetic cluster analyses to date, featuring (almost) the entire human race. The analysis is an incredibly useful resource; it conclusively demonstrates the biological existence of human races, and provides an excellent overview of human genetic diversity

ddl1 · 09/10/2021 21:38

[quote PlanDeRaccordement]I thought this was interesting as it illustrates using genetic clusters the biological existence of races. Which is the opposite of what many posters are arguing? That if you look at DNA/genetics there are no races?

thuletide.wordpress.com/2020/06/29/a-race-by-race-breakdown-of-human-genetic-diversity-illustrated-guide-for-novices/[/quote]
Have you seen the other articles on 'Thuletide'?:

E.g.:

Operation Lockstep: 2010 Rockefeller Foundation paper perfectly "predicts" the COVID scamdemic [Full text]

Timeline of the New World Order

COVID19, The Great Reset, and Transhumanism

The World League for Sexual Reform: Pioneers in abortion, birth control, and transgenderism

An article claiming that 'Chemical birth control destroys women's bodies and the environment'

As such, I don't think anything on the site can be trusted!

Deadringer · 09/10/2021 21:21

I am white and Irish and grew up in a time when everyone around me was white so i can't begin to understand the issue, but i do find it very interesting. When i was reading Barack Obama's book i thought it was fascinating that despite being half white, and being brought up in a white area in a white family, everyone just saw his black half, so to speak. It was assumed that he would identify with his black heritage, and represent black people in politics, despite his white background.

FortniteBoysMum · 09/10/2021 21:11

I was thinking about this the other day. In a society where it is OK to identify as a different gender to that of your physical body, where politicians are effectively saying we are no longer females but bodies with vaginas in order not to upset the trans community it would be very different if this was about race. If a white person felt they identified as black I highly doubt that would be accepted, people would treat them as if they were racist and taking the piss. In reality you are who you are based on birth and genetics. You can identify how you choose, it does not change who you are.

Mrstamborineman · 09/10/2021 20:54

Not sure of point beyond self congratulations for asking your dc what they wanted to declare.

PlanDeRaccordement · 09/10/2021 20:34

The article that Plan quoted uses language that is perhaps too emphatic

I agree, the historical summary is absolutely biased and a bit over emotional. But I largely skipped that to get to the good stuff...the genetic clusters and how the different admixtures combine to result in the different ethnicities across the globe. Didn’t really care how they saw history of race as we know it was in fact full of racism and racist theories.

LadyTiredWinterBottom2 · 09/10/2021 19:48

Ethnicity is mixed in this case but they can choose the culture they identify with more

I don't agree with white people identifying as black, it's the epitome of white privilege. Black people can't 'pretend ' to appear white.

mustlovegin · 09/10/2021 19:44

The article that Plan quoted uses language that is perhaps too emphatic. But the concepts do make sense.

What we don't need is history to repeat itself with Galileos being censored and shouted down because they commit the crime of stating what they see.

Personally I don't know what's controversial about the existence of races, ethnicities or populations, whatever one wants to call them. It's what we decide to do with that fact that may be wrong (e.g. discriminate someone based on race).

I feel for all the scientists who since the 17th century have devoted their lives to research only for us to be told now that race is a 'social construct' because it does not suit a particular narrative

laudete · 09/10/2021 14:33

You can't choose your biological heritage (your ancestry) but, if you are mixed heritage, you can choose the part with which you most identify.

PlanDeRaccordement · 09/10/2021 13:52

It explicitly states that the (not at all Scientific) old subspecies classifications are in use by Scientist but have been renamed due to a conspiracy to hide 'the truth':

“The world’s most powerful forces have spent the last 7 decades attempting to brainwash the masses into believing race is an aberration — an “ideology” or “social construct” — fabricated by “European imperialists” during the 19th Century, specifically to justify “the oppression, persecution, and exploitation of People of Color.”

? You say the article explicitly states that subspecies classifications...etc but then quote a quote that doesn’t say subspecies? Races are not subspecies. Why are you conflating the two?

PlanDeRaccordement · 09/10/2021 13:49

@donquixotedelamancha
The genetic differences it uses to classify 'race' are small compared to the background levels of genetic diversity in humans.

? There is very little genetic diversity in humans as a whole, we haven’t be living isolated from each other for very long evolutionary speaking and the constant migrations over prehistory and history have kept the diversity low across all humans

What it shows is the various genetic clusters you find within and between races. It literally explained that every race is simply a different admixture of common ancestral genetics...remember the example of the Maya individual being most Amerindian genetic ancestry clusters but also have European, African, and E Asian mixed in? Then it showed quite well, I think, that race is a spectrum of overlapping and shared ancestral genetic clusters so that the diversity within each race is higher than the diversity between the races (all true) because there is so much overlap in genetic clusters.

BiBabbles · 09/10/2021 13:11

Plus, there is no way I could have raised them BRITISH because I’m not BRITISH. I’m going to assume that it’s quite hard to raise a child to ‘be white’ if you are not white yourself….

I wasn't British until my oldest was 16, but all my children identify as British and will correct you if you try to infer the xenophobic idea that one of their parents being an immigrant means they are less British.

I found it a lot easier to expose and help my children explore British ideas and social norms because it's all around us compared and really, many of them aren't really solely British compared to trying to teach my children the cultures I was raised with since it was just me.

That's the thing - culture isn't an individual static thing from our DNA. It's a social thing with the people and environments around us. Cultures change through the variations in how people pass them and interact with them - that's how they live. Most of them have some overlap. Like many things immigrants bring in - they can then become part of British cultures no matter what DNA was involved. Even before their British-born father and I were engaged, we discussed creating a unified home culture and how to deal with the clash that would arise just as much from him not wanting to pass down what he was raised with as bringing mine in - we're all part of the dialogue in cultural change.

I'm mixed. My parents are mixed. None of us are fractions - that's blood quantum talk which I'm strongly against. I don't teach my children to deal with people acting xenophobic by cutting themselves into parts to explain why they don't look or sound or do things differently than some others expect British kids to do. I'd rather support my mixed children pushing at the boundaries of what it means to British. For my oldest who identifies as white, I support him in pushing at what it means to be white - that it isn't about being "pure" anything. I know people who look similar to him pushing against that in other directions. It's considered really important for technically Metis and Mestizo people to be able to confidently identify with our American Indigenous nations if we so chose. I think it would be hypocritical of me not to extend that same concept to a technically Metis and Mestizo person as my children are to confidently identify as White or British. They're part of a very long history of mixed people moving around racial lines. People have been raising children to be part of the dominate groups well before our modern races were used to culturally divide people.

donquixotedelamancha · 09/10/2021 10:00

No, that’s not what it says. You are mistaking the historical section for current thought.

I quoted the conclusion of the historical summary section.

The article is not racist...you are misrepresenting it.

I don't agree. I think it's misrepresenting data to make a completely false argument in support of race theory which might be accepted by someone without qualifications in this area. The genetic differences it uses to classify 'race' are small compared to the background levels of genetic diversity in humans.

There is a reason sensible people get their info about scientific arguments from peer reviewed articles and reputable sources.

It doesn’t say that races are subspecies except earlier in historical context when early 18th c. scientists thought they were subspecies.

It explicitly states that the (not at all Scientific) old subspecies classifications are in use by Scientist but have been renamed due to a conspiracy to hide 'the truth':

The world’s most powerful forces have spent the last 7 decades attempting to brainwash the masses into believing race is an aberration — an “ideology” or “social construct” — fabricated by “European imperialists” during the 19th Century, specifically to justify “the oppression, persecution, and exploitation of People of Color.”

Xenia · 09/10/2021 09:43

Yes, lots of good points above and it depends on the context. Some things are facts in life eg what your DNA test says and others are an expression of how you feel (my son's friend is half white and half African (or whatever term we are supposed to use these days) and has I think never see her black father and has grown up with a white step father (and white mother) and white siblings in a very middle class white home. I am sure she describes herself as mixed race which is what shis is an an immutable fact but without doubt (other than her explorations of black culture and I presume any discrimination she has suffered) she will be very much be white culture (if that exists).

On the medical side of things we live in or near one of the most Jewish parts of London and they certainly have genetic tests before marriage to check for genetic disease which a white British couple would not need. Also my borough is minority white and with a lot of people at risk of sickle cell (in essence because they have superior genetics for the place from which they come because they developed resistance to malaria in a way my genes and ancestors did not). Another interesting issue with medicine is sex - some women have different reactions to medicine than men do so doing sex differentiated research is not sexist - it is life saving.

Ibelieveinghosts · 09/10/2021 09:25

Well it depends what you mean. By race it has become a very broad term.

Biologically speaking you are what you are, the ethnicity of your ancestors make up your ethnicity, in that way most people have very mixed ethnicity, some of the mix far more watered down than others. Probably the main relevance here is medical as it leaves you more susceptible to certain diseases than others. You can’t choose this.

How you look - you can’t alter this to any great extent unfortunately this will mean being affected by prejudices where they exist

Culture-now this is the big one -in theory yes, anyone can identify with any culture. Unfortunately you have all this crap about cultural appropriation dividing people. But actually stopping division like this is probably one of the main ways that we can try and break out with racist division and all integrate more. Historically this has been the more successful way of inter grating societies

PlanDeRaccordement · 09/10/2021 09:09

What i said I don't find insulting is saying someone looks White or Black or Latinx.

I agree with this too.

TheOneDropRuleIsRacist · 09/10/2021 09:06

Now I’d agree calling a mixed race person by a racial identity other than what they identify as, after you know this identity is insulting. So with MM, as she identifies as mixed race, it is insulting her imho to call her anything other than mixed race whether that is white or black. And with Iloveabourbon2* who identifies as black... it would be insulting to call her/him/them anything other than black.

I agree. What i said I don't find insulting is saying someone looks White or Black or Latinx. But yes it is disrespectful to call them what they don't call themselves.

Even in Nigeria, the "you look white" comments start only when they know he isn't and stops after it's been said. People call him his name afterwards, and what he looks like doesn't matter or isn't brought up anymore. He's known more as "the son of the soil" (Nigerian), which he cherishes, and British than mixed or white or black.

PlanDeRaccordement · 09/10/2021 09:04

@donquixotedelamancha

I thought this was interesting as it illustrates using genetic clusters the biological existence of races. Which is the opposite of what many posters are arguing? That if you look at DNA/genetics there are no races?

Holy fuck that is one terrifying racist article. It even admits the drivel it's spouting has been completely rejected by Science:

Following the Second World War, these classifications were declared “pseudoscientific” and “obsolete” by the newly established global order. Their primary argument against the scientific existence of race is that scientifically classifying human biological groups is “evil and mean, and will somehow cause a second Holocaust”

Of course the idea that there are 'caucosoid sub species' of humans has not been rejected because it is mean but because it's without basis.

There are 4 different species of giraffe which look alike but there are no subspecies of human, despite our physical variety.

No, that’s not what it says. You are mistaking the historical section for current thought.

It discussed the history of scientific thought about race and the backlash against “race” as a biological reality post WWII due to Nazis and eugenics. Which is what you have quoted.

It doesn’t say that races are subspecies except earlier in historical context when early 18th c. scientists thought they were subspecies.

(Heck 20th c scientists thought Neanderthals were a different human species, but only in 21st c. did we find evidence that modern humans and Neanderthals were the same species.)

The article is not racist...you are misrepresenting it.

donquixotedelamancha · 09/10/2021 08:53

I thought this was interesting as it illustrates using genetic clusters the biological existence of races. Which is the opposite of what many posters are arguing? That if you look at DNA/genetics there are no races?

Holy fuck that is one terrifying racist article. It even admits the drivel it's spouting has been completely rejected by Science:

Following the Second World War, these classifications were declared “pseudoscientific” and “obsolete” by the newly established global order. Their primary argument against the scientific existence of race is that scientifically classifying human biological groups is “evil and mean, and will somehow cause a second Holocaust”

Of course the idea that there are 'caucosoid sub species' of humans has not been rejected because it is mean but because it's without basis.

There are 4 different species of giraffe which look alike but there are no subspecies of human, despite our physical variety.

TheOneDropRuleIsRacist · 09/10/2021 08:52

obviously he knows she is not white though. That's a different thing altogether I know DS dad is not being racists or implying anything along them lines obviously not.

I agree and this is what I was getting at. If people were using her skin tone to justify being racist against her, then it's unacceptable.

The MM situation is far different as she is shunned because of her lighter skin tone within the black community.

I find this interesting because I noticed the opposite much more. Lighter skintone or not, Most Black people (in the US/UK, especially the US) tend to call Mixed race people Black. I didn't see the shunning in that regard.

But I know people's experiences differ so I don't mean to say you're wrong here. You saw what you saw and that's valid.

TheOneDropRuleIsRacist · 09/10/2021 08:38

@Iloveabourbon2

I didn't say you were pleased. I said if you mean it's an insult because some people used "she looks white" to justify the treatment she got from the RF, then I agree it is terrible.

I called your opinion weird because you decided to say IF I was black...and you wrote that I need to "educate myself culturally" if I thought she looked white, as though my opinion means I can't be black or have no idea what it means to be. I actually still don't know what that meant. That "IF" packs a whole lot.

Anyway, that's fine. We've probably misunderstood each other. So I agree let's leave it there.

I rarely look at names so I didn't remember we've interacted before. It's okay to agree on one point and disagree on another, though. I'm fine with that.

PlanDeRaccordement · 09/10/2021 08:30

I thought MM was white when I first saw a picture of her and hadn’t read anything about her background. She is white passing to many who first see her as you would a stranger on the street.

I know now, she is and identifies as mixed race, so I think of her as mixed race because I’m not going to tell anyone I know their racial identity better than they do! It’s a matter of respect.

I have a cousin who is mixed race white and Asian (Chinese). But when he visited the US, many random people he met mistook him for Latino (he is very tan). Even Latinos would mistake him because he said he’d be approached by someone speaking Spanish to him. It’s not an insult to him that strangers thought that or that he was “Latino passing” while in the US.

Now I’d agree calling a mixed race person by a racial identity other than what they identify as, after you know this identity is insulting. So with MM, as she identifies as mixed race, it is insulting her imho to call her anything other than mixed race whether that is white or black. And with @Iloveabourbon2 who identifies as black...it would be insulting to call her/him/them anything other than black.

Iloveabourbon2 · 09/10/2021 08:27

@TheOneDropRuleIsRacist

Your view isn't the only. You seem to think there's one way of being Black or Mixed race. I can assure you as a full black person, not 3/4 black, that there isn't.

If people are saying she's white when they know she is mixed race, then I can see what you're saying. But saying she looks white isn't the same as saying she is white. Also you seem to be saying what you can see only because you know her mum is Black. It will be obvious to "see" these things when you already know.

I don't see it as an insult. That's a very weird thing to say unless you're saying it was used to justify the treatment she got. Then that is bad. Otherwise it's your opinion and that's fine. But your opinion is not law.

I didn't look twice at Meghan when I first saw her on Suits and only "noticed" she wasn't white when they introduced her dad, Wendell Pierce. I'm not sure when you got to know her but I did long before her relationship with Harry. Doesn't make me less Black to think so and that is another odd thing to say. Quite offensive and really bizarre. You seem to have notions of Blackness that you may want to "re-educate" yourself on.

I don't know the Black people you were around though but I'd say it was divided what people saw her as. I think those who saw her as White or Black or Mixed would depend on where you go. Lipstick Alley was divided with both H&M unpopular opinions threads and Appreciation threads. So you'd see different opinions based on that.

As I've said, my husband is seen as white by some people in Nigeria but he's biracial. He looks mixed but I'm sure he'll be seen as Black by some people especially in the US. Don't think it's an insult however he's seen unless it's used to justify something bad.

Isn't the whole "I'm black, not mixed race" because of how others see you? Are you saying that everyone has to see you the same or doesn't it fit your narrative that not everyone will see you the way you want to be seen?

Most Black people I know in real life (including me) are just busy living their lives and not following what happens in the Royal family but one can definitely be forgiven to say that Meghan looks like a tan white woman if they didn't know at first she had a Black mum. It's no insult. How in the world can you expect everyone to "see her hair is straightened" and know "she goes to the hairdresser"? All these are things you know because you know about her. If you knew intuitively then, good for you.

Meghan herself says she's biracial or mixed race, not Black so you'd want to accept what she calls herself, if you're claiming to respect others' opinion.

www.elle.com/uk/life-and-culture/news/a26855/more-than-an-other/

She's also mentioned in another article i think that she knows she can look white or black or latina depending on styling so she's gone for auditions for those roles.

What are you talking about. I didn't argue about what MM calls herself. It would be like me saying I'm mixed race people are entitled to do that if they wish I know but what I'm trying to say to you IS. If I was to walk around saying I'm mixed race people would look at me oddly because my hair is FULL afro and I'm not light enough. So that's my main point!

I think we will leave it hear. Your calling my opinion weird.... nobody asked you to agree with me. As stated I agree with some of what your saying but other parts I don't. Let's leave it at that.