Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to mortgage ourselves over our heads?

489 replies

NCFC4now · 06/10/2021 16:19

DH will read this so I suppose your opinions will help settle a debate.

DH is 32 and I am 27. We currently own a 3 bed semi Victorian house, it is in a desirable area we love, in the 18 months since we’ve moved in the value increased £75k (bank mortgage valuation) because of the housing bubble.

We over pay our mortgage every month and have a growing amount of equity (especially with the increase!)
However, whilst I love our house, it doesn’t have parking and I find the garden just a bit sad (neighbour has huge trees that block out a lot of sun because the garden isn’t big). Due to the area, parking is difficult and you tend to have to park down the road from your own house.

Because of our location, which we won’t compromise on, a 4 bed with parking, nothing fancy will be £1m. We can get a mortgage for £800k. In my mind, we should wait 2 years (fixed rate ends) and save as much as possible and go for it.

Using present rates available to us, our mortgage minimum payment would be £2.7k a month over 30 years. We can afford this but would mean we can’t really do a step wrong. It would also mean our savings are wiped out due to SDLT so would need to replenish those.

I grew up in poverty and we have achieved everything without any help so I suppose a big house has always been a symbol of achievement to me.

Is it a dumb idea? Tell me your thoughts! I am a bit scared about losing our jobs and whilst DH is a teacher so safe, his extra income comes through a business he runs which I think is stable but you never know. I also hate working and have some mental health issues. Also this could be made worse financially if we do have kids as planned in a couple of years…

DH wants the house but doesn’t want the debt and thinks we should stay put. My argument is simply that having a child and no parking space will cause a breakdown at some point if I’m already stressed whilst fit and childless about the situation.
Thanks

OP posts:
TheWayTheLightFalls · 06/10/2021 20:35

Said kindly, I think you’re being unreasonable to get yourself in that much debt if the main attraction is parking. We keep a buggy in the car just in case we can’t park close enough for toddler to walk home and just get on with it. Shopping is delivered. It’s fine.

This. And for the love of all that's holy get onto the website of the three nearest nurseries and work out what 3(?) full days' care will cost from age 1-3 / six months to 3 / whatever you think is likely in your circs.

In your shoes - and it sounds flippant, I'm sorry - I'd stay put, enjoy yourselves, hire a garden designer, revel in your disposable income for a bit and when the time comes buy a YoYo or Bee to stay in the car.

Frazzled2207 · 06/10/2021 20:34

@NCFC4now

I obviously don’t understand the free childcare hours by a few comments here. My understanding was they get 30 free hours if you earn at least x amount and below NET £100k. We earn below £100k on net income.
Not until they’re 3!
FourLaneEnds · 06/10/2021 20:31

I'd be so worried that with such an expensive house and so much borrowed, that a property price drop ( likely and certainly unpredictable given current BREXIT/COVID times) will be catastrophic and you will lose your hard earned money. The gap between equity and the cost of house puts you at risk.

Wait a while.

Buttons294749 · 06/10/2021 20:29

My 2 cents is.. if you live you will be the breadwinner and can never cut your hours. I would rather be in a smaller house and have the option of being a SAHM if I wanted. It sounds like you can afford it ok but my reservation would be tying yourself into a crazy busy City role and never being able to step back. Can you not get a 3 bed with better parking? How much did you pay for your current house?

FWIW I had 2 non walking babies with a car a lift journey, through the complex, out the back across the road, down a side road and sometimes down another side road. It was a pita but was doable. Parking on the same road sounds so easy!

Frazzled2207 · 06/10/2021 20:28

You’ve got a nice house in a nice area. A 3 bed semi is more than enough space for a couple and two youngish kids. I am speaking from my own experience here. Only now the kids are 6 and 8 are we looking at moving.

I would totally stay put for now and save and overpay your mortgage as much as you can. It will likely increase further in value. The non parking issue is annoying but def not a reason to upgrade your house right now.

Bear in mind when/if you have kids you may not go back to earning what you do now. I ended up quitting my job and going self employed instead. Right decision but financially it has meant a lot less money coming in from my side.

Newmumatlast · 06/10/2021 20:20

@nellyburt

I think that kids and a massive mortgage will be more stressful than a lack of parking. Keep overpaying and see where you are in two years and factor in £1k a month for nursery.
Agree with this. You'd be setting yourself up for a much more stressful life OP.
Wazzzzzzzup · 06/10/2021 20:15

@Flup

because8 even mama have to work nowdays ya know Except in OPs case she could give up work and move into her dream house, mortgage free, if she wanted, if she moved up North and her DH could teach anywhere . Could even find somewhere with nice little shops.Grin
No one should move up north. We have no nice shops. No culture here. Horrible place. Whole north. Everyone should stay south. so our prices don't go even more crazy and we can still have mortgages 10% of our incomes still
flippertyop · 06/10/2021 20:13

Gosh you are so young and your earnings will go up. Do it

Kfjsjdbd · 06/10/2021 20:02

We have just had exactly this debate. Something ‘meh’ in this area is still £1mn.

We have gone for the huge mortgage (£700k in our case) to buy a renovation project at £1.1mn. The mortgage is about 25% of our take home income which isn’t bad, but we have two in expensive childcare which makes it tight for a few years.

We are really happy that we did it. However we are in a position where childcare costs will reduce soon, we both expect promotions and we still have something in savings should the shit hit the fan. I’ll admit that I do feel uncomfortable knowing that at the moment we couldn’t pay the mortgage if something went wrong.

DeepaBeesKit · 06/10/2021 19:56

Never borrow more than 4 times joint income.

Then test:

  • can you pay the mortgage payment off one of your salaries? How much money is left over?
  • work out your monthly income after tax. Now take out at least £1,000 for childcare and baby costs. Remember your utility bills are higher in a bigger house. Can you still afford it?
CSJobseeker · 06/10/2021 19:53

I agree re: the current economic outlook. All the signs point towards the next few years being very difficult indeed.

RazzleTitz · 06/10/2021 19:50

Our mortgage is 21% of our joint net take home, it’s about 13% gross. We’ve only ever taken my husbands salary into consideration when buying houses, obviously not everyone is in a position to do this and know we’re very fortunate, it allowed me to take full 12 months maternity for all of our children and whilst I did go back, Hubby said I didn’t have to work, which made going back to work a lot easier as it was a choice, there was no pressure.

With increased equity and a maxed mortgage we could nearly double what we paid for this but half my salary goes on childcare at the moment. We would completely sink if we maxed out. Spent years being skint climbing the ladder and renovating properties, we are in a good position now because we bought young but children are still expensive and it didn’t happen without sacrifices. In my very humble opinion there is no point having a £1m house if you can’t enjoy it because you’re both out working all hours to pay for it. Your doing the right thing by overpaying and weighing things up and you might find it’s doable. Just be mindful the property market could be completely different in a couple of years, you don’t want make any rash decisions to tuck yourself up with a big mortgage, especially if prices go south or interest rates go up. Like others have said factor in a hefty contingency for child care and inflation. Your current home sounds lovely and full of character.

Graphista · 06/10/2021 19:48

@2bazookas I agree I think we're headed into seriously dodgy times economy wise in this country. Tories have really fucked up there and we're only seeing the v beginnings of what that means for the public

Twocrabs30 · 06/10/2021 19:42

I only over-extended myself with debt once, and it took 5 years to correct. The mental stress from the debt was too much. It was an important life lesson and I wouldn’t do it again.

So my advice is stay where you are, and reconsider your position in 2 years.

Angliski · 06/10/2021 19:36

I’m surprised at people’s desire to overstretch on the home they own. This maxing massively restricts your freedom to make different choices about lifestyle like pausing work for a while. It also leaves you extremely vulnerable if a job gets lost or you lose one income. If you go on maternity, presumably this 3k becomes around 50 or more % of household income. Plus at two days a week with two kids, childcare will increase your cost of living by 1200 per month. Just figured that bear considering. Also, always stress test for a 5% mortgage as rare are currently at a record low. If it’s affordable now, would it still be so when rates go up?

BoredZelda · 06/10/2021 19:33

I think it’s a case of the grass being greener. You bought a property and only 18 months later isn’t what you want. What’s to say the next one won’t have some problem you can’t live with.

I stretched myself to move to this house but we didn’t have very many choices for various reasons. I had many, many sleepless nights over it. Luckily it paid off but if anything had gone even slightly wrong for a couple of years we’d have been in real trouble. I wouldn’t ever do it again unless I was really stuck. I certainly wouldn’t do it because parking was bugging me.

Graphista · 06/10/2021 19:32

I think you'd be v irresponsible to do this at this time.

Financially Brexit effects are only just starting to come through, ditto the ramifications from the pandemic.

Not to mention all other potential rising costs (interest rates, energy bills etc) and you'd have higher council tax to pay too

I tend to be risk averse anyway and think it's better to allow yourself some leeway in case of things changing (as they often do in life) rather than over extend yourself and cause yourself stress from that let alone if anything happens in life to negatively impact income (redundancy, illness, disability, divorce/separation, having a child with an illness or disability meaning at least one of you has to go part time or sah)

Always better to hedge your bets and maybe even have some savings for a rainy day.

The "issues" you have with your current house are fairly minor!

We can afford this but would mean we can’t really do a step wrong

That's a stressful position to be in

whilst DH is a teacher so safe

The profession may be fairly secure but you never know what's down the road for him personally

I think that kids and a massive mortgage will be more stressful than a lack of parking.

Totally agree

My mum is a baby person so would definitely help

I would caution against making assumptions there too. She may not want to and/or she may not be able to depending on age and fitness. My mum helped my sister a LOT with her eldest and sister ASSUMED the same would be true for subsequent children but then mum got cancer and her health deteriorated in other ways as she of course was older (in her late 60's by this point) and she simply wasn't up to it! Sister took several strops over this!

I'm prob closer in age to your mum at 49 and with my health/energy levels (I'm disabled and have my own mh issues) I wouldn't be able to commit to childcare.

Do you even have a budget that you work to just now? I've always had a budget spreadsheet since ex and I married and we joined our incomes partly as he's a bit of a nightmare financially!

But I always plan 6 months in advance and like to see how things should be if I stick to the budget, what I do is then copy and paste this to a 2nd sheet and on that sheet record actual expenditure so I can compare and see how I'm doing.

Works for me and I'm on a MUCH lower Income than you as I can't work and am on benefits.

My advice based on all you're saying about how you behave money wise at the moment would be to create a 6 month budget prediction spreadsheet and see if you can actually stick to it! You could even set aside the amount you'd be paying for the dream house mortgage in a savings account, see if you can live on what you have left. Even then that's just a glimpse of what it'd be like

@imnotdefensiveyouare yes it's 2021 but women are STILL paid less, discriminated against at work (especially in relation to maternity issues), still bear the brunt of childcare responsibility (especially when kids are off sick etc) and so on...

Things still aren't great/as they should be

nannybeach · 06/10/2021 19:25

I wouldnt having been through negative equity at one point, and the housing crashes. In the 1980s we bought a maisonette, nothing fancy, mortgage rate was 12% 18 months later its 16%, I ended up with 4 jobs. We had 2 mortgages (2nd DH) he lost his job a month after completion, then was made redundant 5 times in 8 years. We ended up moving to a cheaper area. There was no holidays,no takeaways, one old car that we shared. I went back to working nights, so as not to have to pay childcare.

Franklyfrost · 06/10/2021 19:24

This country is hardly a picture of stability.

Your cons for your current house are:

  1. shady garden
  2. no parking
  3. not prestigious enough

I would stay put, save yourself the horrendous stress of being financially stressed with dependants and spend some money on these solutions instead:

  1. get a garden designer so you can have a shady garden you love
  2. a buggy that fits into the boot of the car
  3. some therapy or a really expensive handbag

Children are expensive, life is stressful, holidays are great…

ToykotoLosAngeles · 06/10/2021 19:19

I'm also a bit confused on the maths to be honest, but then in terms of salary multiples I don't know what the £8k is gross when split out into 2 salaries and a side business income, plus OP's bonus, plus her TV work.

wouldthatbeworse · 06/10/2021 19:19

Said kindly, I think you’re being unreasonable to get yourself in that much debt if the main attraction is parking. We keep a buggy in the car just in case we can’t park close enough for toddler to walk home and just get on with it. Shopping is delivered. It’s fine.

MouseholeCat · 06/10/2021 19:16

This is a risk I would never take, especially if you're currently in a place where you aren't saving despite having an income as high as you do. If you're going to take this risk then you need to become a lot more financially diligent in the first place so you don't end up totally fucked.

MontEthna · 06/10/2021 19:13

Honestly, do not mortgage yourelf that much.

When we bought our house, we were botj working, both on the same salary. We planned a mortgage that could be covered with one wage 'just in case' Just in case, one of us eneded up redundant etc...

As it happens, I was made redundant whilst on ML (yep...) and then developped a chronic illness so can't work full time. Never wll be able to again.
We have been lucky that dh hasn't been made redundant in his current (but before that he had been - twice before).

You have no idea whta life will throw at you. Illness, redundancies, one of the children having some SEN. the list is endless.

You'd do much better staying where you are and saving/investing/paying current mortgage with all the money you would put in the bigger house.

LastToBePicked · 06/10/2021 19:07

We are a decade or so ahead of you, OP.

We have stuck with the house we could comfortably afford rather than trading up and now have enough equity and savings that we could easily move out of London/SE, be mortgage free and live off savings comfortably for a good few years.

We’ve made it through the expensive childcare years while still affording a comfortable lifestyle.

We’ve had some health scares, DH has had a really stressful time at work and not worrying about paying the mortgage through all this has been invaluable. We know if we wanted to we could pay off the mortgage or quit the rat race.

Cryalot2 · 06/10/2021 19:06

I grew up in poverty but unlike you op I never have felt the need for the big/nice house with roses round the garden or anything. I am happy to have enough food and clothes and owe no one.
No way would I be happy with such debit . I prefer to live owing no one anything. The freedom of that is enough. Yes I will have basic bills but that is enough.

A parking lot is not worth it to me, but clearly it is to you.