Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to mortgage ourselves over our heads?

489 replies

NCFC4now · 06/10/2021 16:19

DH will read this so I suppose your opinions will help settle a debate.

DH is 32 and I am 27. We currently own a 3 bed semi Victorian house, it is in a desirable area we love, in the 18 months since we’ve moved in the value increased £75k (bank mortgage valuation) because of the housing bubble.

We over pay our mortgage every month and have a growing amount of equity (especially with the increase!)
However, whilst I love our house, it doesn’t have parking and I find the garden just a bit sad (neighbour has huge trees that block out a lot of sun because the garden isn’t big). Due to the area, parking is difficult and you tend to have to park down the road from your own house.

Because of our location, which we won’t compromise on, a 4 bed with parking, nothing fancy will be £1m. We can get a mortgage for £800k. In my mind, we should wait 2 years (fixed rate ends) and save as much as possible and go for it.

Using present rates available to us, our mortgage minimum payment would be £2.7k a month over 30 years. We can afford this but would mean we can’t really do a step wrong. It would also mean our savings are wiped out due to SDLT so would need to replenish those.

I grew up in poverty and we have achieved everything without any help so I suppose a big house has always been a symbol of achievement to me.

Is it a dumb idea? Tell me your thoughts! I am a bit scared about losing our jobs and whilst DH is a teacher so safe, his extra income comes through a business he runs which I think is stable but you never know. I also hate working and have some mental health issues. Also this could be made worse financially if we do have kids as planned in a couple of years…

DH wants the house but doesn’t want the debt and thinks we should stay put. My argument is simply that having a child and no parking space will cause a breakdown at some point if I’m already stressed whilst fit and childless about the situation.
Thanks

OP posts:
wewereliars · 07/10/2021 10:48

@TataMamma No, I mean you. You are the one referring to "doommongers" and "oldies" in respect of people urging caution, which is very rude indeed.

ballsdeep · 07/10/2021 10:46

Crazy I'm sorry op.
We moved from a three bed to a four bed and our council tax has doubled , heating bills obviously higher and we pay for childcare too. I didn't realise how expensive children were until I had them. I have three and they always seem to bed things at the same time, for example they'll all need new clothes as they've grown . It's expensive.

yellowgingham · 07/10/2021 10:45

Personally I think that stretching yourself on a mortgage (to an extent) is underrated, we did it and I don't regret it for a second. I also think people on MNers are often at the extreme end of caution when it comes to financial matters.

Having said that, this would be a step too far for me and I wouldn't do it.

MrsSkylerWhite · 07/10/2021 10:44

Yes. Interest rates will rise eventually.

TataMamma · 07/10/2021 10:43

@wewereliars
It is possible to disagree without being insulting and rude you know.
That's my point. It is somebody else you should be saying that too I think!
Demand means being wanting and being in a position to buy. It makes no sense to say "demand and supply won't matter if..." which was what I was objecting to. There is low demand for multi million pound yachts, which isn't too say lots of us wouldn't mind one for a tenner.
Yes there are general problems, but focus on OP. She has 3 sources of income, substantial amounts wasted, and the mortgage is not much more proportionately than what she is paying. All the uncertainty etc and banks getting more unwilling to lend in the future, is therefore I think a good reason to do it now whilst she can. That must of us could never do this - and I doubt right now I'd get a mortgage for a quarter of what OP is talking about - isn't the point.

Blossomtoes · 07/10/2021 10:41

You keep hoping people who disagree with you and would make different decisions to you, suffer terrible consequence and learn their lesson!

I don’t. In fact I quite specifically said I hope they don’t. 🤷‍♀️

wewereliars · 07/10/2021 10:38

@TataMamma It is posible to disagree without being insulting and rude you know.

And you know nothing about economics if you think a market crash, which may be just around the corner, is avoided by " supply and demand". Demand does not mean wanting a house, it means being able to raise a mortgage or other funding for it and being confident that you will be able to mainatain that affordability into the foreseeable future, which depends on job security and a healthy economy. The latter will also drive how willing banks will be to lend.

We are on the brink of unprecedented economic uncertainty, and people who have lived through financial shocks have learnt the hard way what that can mean.

LivingLaVidaBabyShower · 07/10/2021 10:36

Yanbu.

We had a bigger deposit but did basically the same. We didn't want to mess about climbing the ladder and throwing money away on stamp duty.

We got a 10 year fix and 2 years in it works fine for us. We both have had promotions and payrises since buying. we know things can change and so have saved a fairly substantial amount and this will cover mat leave and 2 years of mortgage payments. We can also sell if its unbearable so we are fairly chilled about it all.

TataMamma · 07/10/2021 10:34

@ Blossomtoes
You keep hoping people who disagree with you and would make different decisions to you, suffer terrible consequence and learn their lesson! WTF is the matter with you?
(And just to be clear living the life OP does is about as likely for me as winning the lottery. I still think she should do it, and wish her the best, even if she doesn't do exactly what I tell her to!)

Blossomtoes · 07/10/2021 10:30

You are extremely rude @TataMamma. How is it arrogant to disagree with you? Clearly your degree in economics didn’t have a module in manners or mature debate. Incidentally neither my bachelors nor masters are in “life”.

TataMamma · 07/10/2021 10:26

@Blossomtoes
Thank you but I have a degree in economics. Really don't need to be patronised by you and your degree in life. Think about what you have said to me and how arrogant it is.
The evidence looks pretty good that OP would be able to "ride the storm" and that's why I think she should do it. They have 3 sources of income, currently spend "like idiots" (hardly essential), and not insignificant equity. For others it would be different, of course, and not such a good idea. For OP, I think it's a good investment.
Not surprised your son is single.

Blossomtoes · 07/10/2021 10:22

I think your extreme response speaks volumes @TataMamma. Clearly a nerve has been hit. The economy goes through cycles. Not only is a recession due, but all the signs are there - do you seriously think there was no demand for property in the 90s?

Obviously some people will be able to ride the storm but many won’t.

By the way, my son is single!

TataMamma · 07/10/2021 10:17
  • Anyway = anyone
  • own = down

Let’s hope she doesn’t have to learn the hard way, eh? - you sound like the sound of oldie who likes bad things to happen to others so that you are proved right about everything!

OP - have you and DH discussed this yet? Any conclusions? We'd all to know!

Wazzzzzzzup · 07/10/2021 10:17

OP is 27, hopefully not a complete risk averse frightened oldie like so many on this thread......

I was the same age as OP when I bought (early 30s now). There is time and place for risk. There is time and place to be sensible. This is the latter situation imo.

FreedomFaith · 07/10/2021 10:17

No no no.

OK with childcare, do not under any circumstances be hoping your parents or anyone other paid people will look after your kids. It's nice if they do, but you CANNOT expect it. It's just stupid. You factor in how much they will cost you every month. If you end up less than that, great, but you have to factor in 1k childcare fees at minimum. Maybe bump that to 1500 because by the time you have kids, that fee has probably raised. You also can't look after your kids while working from home. Not going to happen. You need to do way more research on how much kids cost before having them. You don't seem to know a lot at the moment, they cost a ton of money.

You can't afford it. I doubt you could even afford a slightly less expensive one to be honest. I'd bet you'll probably struggle with what you have, nevermind more expensive.

TataMamma · 07/10/2021 10:14

@Blossomtoes
I really hope those words don’t come back to haunt you although I suspect they will.
Ooooh don't we always know more than everyone else, particularly if they are younger than us and disagree with us. I suspect you are one of the MILs others complain about on here!

Supply and demand is irrelevant if the economy goes tits up and mortgages become unaffordable
Anyway who says supply and demand is irrelevant knows nothing about economics and the economy and should be ignored totally. It don't matter what else is going on if demand and supply keep up. Duh. More importantly you acknowledge house prices are unlikely to implode, and this is particularly true in the SE BECAUSE OF DEMAND AND SUPPLY! Therefore OP is not really risking negative equity, repossession, death and damnation as everyone who lived through the 80s and 90s just knows. She's the one who came from a very modest background and has a brilliant well paid career in finance aged 27. Even if house go own slightly for shortish period which is certainly plausible, there's no long term risk to her - she's looking for her forever home not a short term investment.

Blossomtoes · 07/10/2021 10:08

OP is 27, hopefully not a complete risk averse frightened oldie like so many on this thread......

Ah, the triumph of hope over experience. Let’s hope she doesn’t have to learn the hard way, eh?

Zenithbear · 07/10/2021 10:06

I'm very pro stretching yourself for climbing the property ladder, I've done it and also took a few calculated risks regarding our investment properties too.
However this is a step too far for me. £800k mortgage? No thanks.

Blossomtoes · 07/10/2021 10:06

And the fact remains that house prices cannot sink massively in London simply because of supply and demand.

I really hope those words don’t come back to haunt you although I suspect they will. Supply and demand is irrelevant if the economy goes tits up and mortgages become unaffordable. It’s pretty obvious that we’re heading for recession, rising inflation and consequently interest rate increases. The property market is unlikely to implode but it could slowly deflate over several years, then people just won’t buy,

TataMamma · 07/10/2021 10:04

@Blossomtoes
Inflation is on the increase, and therefore interest rates will increase (so why not lock in now, which is kinda my point), and yes therefore demand will decrease. So far, so obvious.
However, there is a massive shortage of homes in the SE, and a massive shortage of homes coming on the market in the SE, with yet a bigger and bigger population. Prices coming down hugely are therefore remote. With their income and background, OP is very very unlikely to be facing any repossession at all - if nothing else she would surely sell herself if facing such a situation.
Remembering the 90s doesn't give you a veto on everything, or make you an expert on the economy.
OP is 27, hopefully not a complete risk averse frightened oldie like so many on this thread......

3luckystars · 07/10/2021 09:59

Your gas and electricity is €500 a month?? That’s mad!

I wonder will the op come back or did she collapse when she looked at childcare prices. All the best to her anyway!

TataMamma · 07/10/2021 09:58

@CSJobseeker
20% on a house worth a million is £200,000 - enough to buy a home outright in most of the country! Chances of negative equity are therefore small. And the fact remains that house prices cannot sink massively in London simply because of supply and demand. Obviously nothing is risk free, but with such high incomes they should be able to manage. Yes, they might both have a brain haemorrhage tomorrow and never work again, but that's not too likely and, seriously, you cannot live your life assuming things like that will happen. For starters, no one would ever have a children and then they'd be no mumsnet......
OP has admitted they spend like idiots and the new mortgage is only £700 more than they are in fact paying at the moment, which on their income is very little. Providing they always pay the mortgage before spending like idiots - and a high career in finance and a teacher are hopefully not complete idiots - then the risks are very low.

Blossomtoes · 07/10/2021 09:57

Too many doom mongers here - house prices are a function of demand and supply, and there's not enough being built - even yesterday the Tories basically said they are not building too many more in the SE where they are needed most.

Supply and demand is linked to the economy. If interest rates go up there won’t be any demand because mortgages will become unaffordable by today’s standards. Some of us have seen it all before. When I bought in 1991 nearly every house on the market was a repossession.

CSJobseeker · 07/10/2021 09:51

to me these are arguments for moving when you can. You may not get another opportunity if things all go wrong, and you can lock yourself into low rates for some time, and if the worst happens you have a substantial home you can almost certainly sell for at least some profit.

The OP is talking about 20% LTV - she does not have a large equity cushion. Do you remember the 90s? The number of people in negative equity? When you're in negative equity, you can't sell up.

Moraxella · 07/10/2021 09:50

In same region so I understand the issues. I’m worried about the looming increase (or reform) of council tax. Would seriously look at other outgoings associated with the slightly bigger house (assuming Victorian/Edwardian): our gas&elec is now £500/month and council tax £300 at moment, obviously will increase more depending on whether they go with size of house/value of house/area of land you occupy. At least the mortgage is “fixed”.

Swipe left for the next trending thread