Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to mortgage ourselves over our heads?

489 replies

NCFC4now · 06/10/2021 16:19

DH will read this so I suppose your opinions will help settle a debate.

DH is 32 and I am 27. We currently own a 3 bed semi Victorian house, it is in a desirable area we love, in the 18 months since we’ve moved in the value increased £75k (bank mortgage valuation) because of the housing bubble.

We over pay our mortgage every month and have a growing amount of equity (especially with the increase!)
However, whilst I love our house, it doesn’t have parking and I find the garden just a bit sad (neighbour has huge trees that block out a lot of sun because the garden isn’t big). Due to the area, parking is difficult and you tend to have to park down the road from your own house.

Because of our location, which we won’t compromise on, a 4 bed with parking, nothing fancy will be £1m. We can get a mortgage for £800k. In my mind, we should wait 2 years (fixed rate ends) and save as much as possible and go for it.

Using present rates available to us, our mortgage minimum payment would be £2.7k a month over 30 years. We can afford this but would mean we can’t really do a step wrong. It would also mean our savings are wiped out due to SDLT so would need to replenish those.

I grew up in poverty and we have achieved everything without any help so I suppose a big house has always been a symbol of achievement to me.

Is it a dumb idea? Tell me your thoughts! I am a bit scared about losing our jobs and whilst DH is a teacher so safe, his extra income comes through a business he runs which I think is stable but you never know. I also hate working and have some mental health issues. Also this could be made worse financially if we do have kids as planned in a couple of years…

DH wants the house but doesn’t want the debt and thinks we should stay put. My argument is simply that having a child and no parking space will cause a breakdown at some point if I’m already stressed whilst fit and childless about the situation.
Thanks

OP posts:
CityCommuter · 07/10/2021 11:34

@NCFC4now I think it would pure madness to have a mortgage of nearly 3 grand a month to pay! The stress of that plus kids would be a lot worse than having no parking... also, you cannot guarantee a good income once kids come along no matter how hard you try to juggle things... there's just no certainty and the last you thing you want is to go into arrears, more borrowing or being repossessed..,

Cordeliathecat · 07/10/2021 11:34

In pure financial terms, investing in a highly leveraged house in the UK is the best investment you can make with your money.

This is due to you benefitting from the appreciation of the whole asset despite only investing in say 20% of it at the outset.

To illustrate in simple terms, you buy a house for £1m but only invest £200k as you have £800,000 mortgage. Say the house increases in value by 10% or £100,000. You have made a 50% return on your investment and turned your £200,000 into £300,000. There are very few ways to match that sort of return.

The likelihood of a house price crash in the UK is very small as market prices for anything are largely informed by supply/demand. We are a small island with not enough housing and that will never change.

For these reasons we have always pushed ourselves to the absolute max in terms of mortgage. That said, we do earn very well and so can absorb temporary economic fluctuations.

RussianSpy101 · 07/10/2021 11:28

If you grew up in poverty as you said in your OP, don’t bank on receiving a substantial inheritance.
I think this is way out of your budget and wouldn’t want to ever be in so much debt.

NorthernBirdAtHeart · 07/10/2021 11:28

I wouldn’t either, not at the moment. If I was in your position (and we have been in the past), I’d wait and see what happens to interest rates and housing market over the next 12-18 months.

And on nursery costs (also in SE), full time for our two DD’s including after school care for 7 years, cost us over £100k.

ThreeFeetTall · 07/10/2021 11:28

Yes hats a good point- other threads teachers are talking about working 60-90 hour weeks. What's his side hussle?

HouseOfFire · 07/10/2021 11:21

What I dont understand, is how your DH has time to be a teacher, run a business and volunteer at food banks.

You say you take home around 3,200 a month, but you are a high earner in City Finance? thats only around 51k, without any deductions for pension etc, thats not really a high earner, although the 40% bonus is nice

Also - how do you expect to keep this level of earning up if you go part-time?

Cuddlemuffin · 07/10/2021 11:18

Honestly I don't think the parking thing is massive. With a baby you'd carry the car seat to the front door when they are little or put them in the pram and take the. To the front door. No biggy. Being on debt will be waaaay more stressful. Kids are expensive. My daughter is in nursery 3 days a week at around £700 per month. Son at childminder 2 days at about £450 per month. Replenishing savings might be tricky and I think it's important to have savings when you have a child. Definitely have a good long think about it. Also you might decide you won't to move to a slightly different area once having children, it does change your priorities and perspective on these things which is why it's so common for young families to move out of London and other big cities x

Ilovefluffysheep · 07/10/2021 11:15

What on earth do you spend your money on? Seriously, you say between you you take home around £8k a month. That's a huge amount.

You say you eat out a lot, but don't spend much on other things. Yet you overspend each month? Are you really spending thousands of pounds a month eating out?

shreddednips · 07/10/2021 11:14

We had a similar dilemma, although much cheaper area. We have a Victorian terrace with no parking and the layout of the house isn't entirely practical either. We could technically get a bigger mortgage and have parking and more living space.

We stayed put. So glad we did. Yes it's a faff without parking (and we have steps up to the house so a nightmare with the buggy) but I'm so glad we did. Husband suddenly lost job and ended up on minimum wage for a year because he couldn't find a suitable position in his niche for ages, I found it harder than I expected fitting work around DC. Ended up having to use far more paid childcare hours than I expected to make it work. Suddenly, our previously affordable mortgage became a stretch.

I really understand your reasons for wanting to move, but there is no misery like being overstretched on your house. I'd get the nursery phase of DC out of the way and then think about moving once you no longer have the expense of childcare to factor in. We will eventually take the plunge, I imagine when DC is in school

lavenderlemon · 07/10/2021 11:12

I absolutely wouldn't do this.
If you plan to have children the last thing you want is to be stressed about money as well as becoming new parents.
The walk might be a pain but arguing with your husband because you're in a tonne of debt would be a lot worse.
Also, childcare is extortionate for the first 4 years.

TataMamma · 07/10/2021 11:11

@ballsdeep

Everyone is saying about the free childcare which is great, but I don't think you can rely on it. Who knows if it will be pulled?! Tories are making cuts everywhere. If they can take £20 off struggling families I am not holding out much hope for this to continue.
I think the difference is that those affected by the £20 don't vote Tory. Many using childcare do. Still, this would massively upset my finances and my DC are too young to be eligible.
TataMamma · 07/10/2021 11:09

*Substantial amounts wasted though is the problem. Someone who is wasting money right now and doesn't even know how much childcare will cost her is not likely to stop spending frivolous amounts on crap. Loads of people do it, they live month to month. Would you agree that she should continue her current lifestyle and get a bigger mortgage and kids? She literally cannot afford it.

If they both stop spending on crap from now, get a proper focus on their finances as it doesn't sound like they have one, and figure stuff out for childcare, then they can look at getting a bigger home. You don't get the bigger home first then do the rest.*

Sort of agree with this. The only thing is though, surely they would prioritise their mortgage and just have to stop all the silly spending? Yes, there are some people who ignore the mortgage and spend on crap, but OP and her DH don't some like they are that sort.

ballsdeep · 07/10/2021 11:08

Everyone is saying about the free childcare which is great, but I don't think you can rely on it. Who knows if it will be pulled?! Tories are making cuts everywhere. If they can take £20 off struggling families I am not holding out much hope for this to continue.

wewereliars · 07/10/2021 11:05

Wazzzzzzzup fair enough!

TataMamma · 07/10/2021 11:05

@ballsdeep

I think you dh has unrealistic expectations tbh. Both going part time and a private school with a huge mortgage?!
No....they want state school - she's said her DH as a teacher is opposed to fee paying schools.

Do agree with the general thrust - not sure how part time work (together with costs of children) could possibly fit in with all this!

Wazzzzzzzup · 07/10/2021 10:59

I actually agree with more cautious (I am one)

Wazzzzzzzup · 07/10/2021 10:59

@wewereliars

Wzzzzzzzup it doesn't matter if you are Milton Friedman or John Milton Keynes reincarnated.

We are the first Western society in modern times with a government determined to cause economic harm, so all bets are off.

I thought we are making up stuff just to argue and felt left out 😂
wewereliars · 07/10/2021 10:58

Wzzzzzzzup it doesn't matter if you are Milton Friedman or John Milton Keynes reincarnated.

We are the first Western society in modern times with a government determined to cause economic harm, so all bets are off.

Bayeight · 07/10/2021 10:58

I’ve found this thread very interesting as we are in a very similar situation and wondering what to do.

The mortgage we would be looking at getting would be £740k and would be right at the max of our affordability.

We want to move for more bedrooms & downstairs living space.

The difference for us is that we have our children and no more childcare costs to consider. Which obviously helps.

Both of our salaries should continue to rise.

However it would be very, very tight for 18 months.

The interest rate rise should be ok as we would fix for 5yrs and so should be able to cope if they had gone up at that point.

I’ve always been of the mindset to push if possible and fully relate to coming from poverty and how that influences decisions.

Good luck OP, not an easy decision and one that we shall continue to stress about too!

bigbaggyeyes · 07/10/2021 10:58

There are so many unknowns at the moment with Brexit and Covid. Stretching yourself so thinly means it only takes one thing, redundancy, interest rises, issues with your dh business to put you under.

Notwithstanding people who live alone, if you have two wages coming in, I'd always like to be in a position where one wage, could cover the mortgage and utility bills at a push. That way you can over pay or save whilst you have two wages.

I'm not sure why you'd need 4 bedrooms, surely there are 3/2 beds out there with driveways? Plus if you are looking at having kids, childcare bills can be the same price as a mortgage in most areas.

MisterMeaner · 07/10/2021 10:57

We did this recently. It's tight, but we haven't regretted it. All being well, your income will increase over time and what feels like a stretch now won't in 5-10 years.

And if the worst came to the worst, you could sell the house. Even if you made a loss on the sale, you'd still have enough money for a deposit on a cheaper property.

People are concerned with financial security, but you have to think about what "financial security" means. Having a job, earning enough for rent and bills, is great. Owning a house is a step up from that. Owning a dream house is another step up. You sound like you're in a very good position to me, and if I were you I'd take the risk.

ballsdeep · 07/10/2021 10:54

I think you dh has unrealistic expectations tbh.
Both going part time and a private school with a huge mortgage?!

FreedomFaith · 07/10/2021 10:52

[quote TataMamma]@wewereliars
It is possible to disagree without being insulting and rude you know.
That's my point. It is somebody else you should be saying that too I think!
Demand means being wanting and being in a position to buy. It makes no sense to say "demand and supply won't matter if..." which was what I was objecting to. There is low demand for multi million pound yachts, which isn't too say lots of us wouldn't mind one for a tenner.
Yes there are general problems, but focus on OP. She has 3 sources of income, substantial amounts wasted, and the mortgage is not much more proportionately than what she is paying. All the uncertainty etc and banks getting more unwilling to lend in the future, is therefore I think a good reason to do it now whilst she can. That must of us could never do this - and I doubt right now I'd get a mortgage for a quarter of what OP is talking about - isn't the point.[/quote]
Substantial amounts wasted though is the problem. Someone who is wasting money right now and doesn't even know how much childcare will cost her is not likely to stop spending frivolous amounts on crap. Loads of people do it, they live month to month. Would you agree that she should continue her current lifestyle and get a bigger mortgage and kids? She literally cannot afford it.

If they both stop spending on crap from now, get a proper focus on their finances as it doesn't sound like they have one, and figure stuff out for childcare, then they can look at getting a bigger home. You don't get the bigger home first then do the rest.

Sugarplumfairy65 · 07/10/2021 10:51

@JustMarriedBecca

Remember the 70s and 80s where interest rates went up to 11%. Absolute stupidity IMO. Stay put. You can't afford it.
Then in the 90's it went up to 15%
Wazzzzzzzup · 07/10/2021 10:48

I got Msc in economics. You are all wrong

Swipe left for the next trending thread