Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to mortgage ourselves over our heads?

489 replies

NCFC4now · 06/10/2021 16:19

DH will read this so I suppose your opinions will help settle a debate.

DH is 32 and I am 27. We currently own a 3 bed semi Victorian house, it is in a desirable area we love, in the 18 months since we’ve moved in the value increased £75k (bank mortgage valuation) because of the housing bubble.

We over pay our mortgage every month and have a growing amount of equity (especially with the increase!)
However, whilst I love our house, it doesn’t have parking and I find the garden just a bit sad (neighbour has huge trees that block out a lot of sun because the garden isn’t big). Due to the area, parking is difficult and you tend to have to park down the road from your own house.

Because of our location, which we won’t compromise on, a 4 bed with parking, nothing fancy will be £1m. We can get a mortgage for £800k. In my mind, we should wait 2 years (fixed rate ends) and save as much as possible and go for it.

Using present rates available to us, our mortgage minimum payment would be £2.7k a month over 30 years. We can afford this but would mean we can’t really do a step wrong. It would also mean our savings are wiped out due to SDLT so would need to replenish those.

I grew up in poverty and we have achieved everything without any help so I suppose a big house has always been a symbol of achievement to me.

Is it a dumb idea? Tell me your thoughts! I am a bit scared about losing our jobs and whilst DH is a teacher so safe, his extra income comes through a business he runs which I think is stable but you never know. I also hate working and have some mental health issues. Also this could be made worse financially if we do have kids as planned in a couple of years…

DH wants the house but doesn’t want the debt and thinks we should stay put. My argument is simply that having a child and no parking space will cause a breakdown at some point if I’m already stressed whilst fit and childless about the situation.
Thanks

OP posts:
namesnamesnamesnames · 07/10/2021 18:05

Don't do it. Don't overstretch, it's miserable having all income going on bills with nothing left for play. We moved to a cheaper property some time back.

buttermutt · 07/10/2021 18:03

But low earners can become harder up, life is unpredictable. But it's disingenuous to say there are no exit routes & in many ways higher earners have more exit routes & more protection from unexpected turns.

Many have been arguing the OPs idea will lead to financial ruin which is certainly not inevitable.

RashOfBees · 07/10/2021 18:03

I can’t remember reading a thread where I’ve changed my mind so much. It reflects the op’s updates. MH problems, hating work and not saving made this sound like a recipe for disaster. Then it transpired the MH and hating work have no bearing on earnings (not sure why they were mentioned! I too have ocd but have never connected it to my career as like op, it seems, it doesn’t really influence it) and actually they save £2500 every month without even trying.

Usually with threads like this I have that suspicion the op is not being fully factual. I don’t here - op comes across as genuine but utterly disorganised and confused.

Op, I would get a big pad of paper and get all your thoughts and plans on there. All the pros, cons, obstacles and so on for a move. Ideas and options for childcare. Different scenarios about your career and your partner’s. Think about how risk averse you are - I think some of the advice on here is excessively cautious but I know I couldn’t mortgage myself to the max either. We all have different tolerances for risk and the unknown.

Really explore all of the different strands too. You mentioned hating work in this thread about finances, despite then batting it away. But does it mean you want to reserve the ability to scale back your career in future? Full time in the city and not working at all are not the only two options. If you do want to commit to working, what does that realistically mean for finances?

At the moment the thoughts about this move come across as a stream of consciousness.

Ireolu · 07/10/2021 18:01

All I know is my life changed in terms of earning after DD arrived. Salary dropped by a third cos I had to work part time. Nursery fees were £1k per month 3 days/week. Buying things she needs and doing things around the house also costs money. We do ok but financially were much better off before having a child. These are the things to factor in before taking on a large mortgage.

wewereliars · 07/10/2021 17:58

yes buttermutt, but the risk can be mitigated by not having such a high mortgage that you have no exit routes if life takes an unexpeced turn.

A high earning childless couple in their 20s and 30s can become hard up for any number of reasons over a 30 year mortgage term.

Which is what some people, who may have seen it for themselves, have been saying . That's hardly news. And hardly need for the insults and rudeness thrown around by some on here.

buttermutt · 07/10/2021 17:43

So all is fine until something happens so that the debt can't be serviced. An uncertaim economic outlook and pretty much guaranteed interest rises in the nar future increase that risk.

But that's true for anyone buying a house & that uncertainty is often more certain than renting.

buttermutt · 07/10/2021 17:41

true @TataMamma

wewereliars · 07/10/2021 17:38

Tatamma are you this obnoxious in real life?

There is no fairy money if you can't sell your house and it gets repossesd. A house in this country has been a one way bet for many years.

That is, if you are able to service any mortgage until the end of its term.

A house is also a home for most people though, and most people have to keep working to pay that mortgage. So all is fine until something happens so that the debt can't be serviced. An uncertaim economic outlook and pretty much guaranteed interest rises in the nar future increase that risk. Simples

Lweji · 07/10/2021 17:37

and £200 000 in equity is a decent cushion should they need to sell, even if prices go down.

Worst case, and while aware that it carries cost and risk, the OP could rent the large house, if not able to sell. But, in that respect, I'd check the rental market in the area for similar properties, to see if that could be a realistic perspective.

TataMamma · 07/10/2021 17:31

Also the fairy money still gives you security - my house price increase fairy money will hopefully enable me to buy a bigger house with more bedrooms and a larger garden in the future. But if it all goes tits up for whatever reason, I can live in a cheaper part of the country and less nice area, and so the fairy money is a boon, and not very fairy at all.
If OP is looking to move on a longer term basis and the chances of anything going tits up and not being able to pay the mortgage in the short-medium term is slim (and it clearly is), then it's surely an economic no-brainer to do it. The fairy money either doesn't matter at all if she stays put, or it will help her with whatever she does next.

buttermutt · 07/10/2021 17:23

I admit that my equity money is largely fairy money because I need to use for future purchases or renovations. However for my parents & others like them it certainly isn't. And don't forgot those high interest rates were very favourable for savings & investment vehicles. I think my inlaws had an interest only mortgage but were able to pay it off with a different investment fairly early. As tata says you have quite a one sided economic view which is presumably why you accused me of being the OPs broker 😆

TataMamma · 07/10/2021 17:14

@Blossomtoes
Just stop trying to lecture everyone on economics. You know nothing. You have strong risk averse views and think you know it all because you remember the 90s. You are not focused on OP and her situation, and really basic economics which everyone knows doesn't meant that being very risk averse is always the best approach.
The point is the house is likely to go up over time. You appear to have finally accept that is what happens - long term - to house prices, albeit there can be comparatively big dips along the way. Now you are dismissing this increase as "fairy money" and all "relative". Which is also a load of nonsense as others have pointed out. You might find more similar people to yourself on Gransnet.

buttermutt · 07/10/2021 16:59

House prices have kept rising because interest rates have been at record lows since the 2008 crash, so many people have very big, but cheap mortgages.

Absolutely agree & the gov should have allowed small rises yrs ago instead they have thrown more props at it.

buttermutt · 07/10/2021 16:57

@Blossomtoes no they paid less as they had a good deposit from selling a smaller house, they had a very good mortgage as my dad worked for a bank. They were lucky to not really feel the rate rises that much.
Why would they need to pay 2m for a comparable property? They don't need such a big house anymore. They would be looking at spending about 800k on a much smaller property or a bigger one further out if they chose to stay in London.
My inlaws sold a house for about 3m a few yrs ago, also bought in the 80s. They certainly have been living it up with the "fairy money"!

Blossomtoes · 07/10/2021 16:57

Exactly that @wewereliars. And there are enough Tory voters with savings and no mortgages for that not to be politically catastrophic.

wewereliars · 07/10/2021 16:55

House prices have kept rising because interest rates have been at record lows since the 2008 crash, so many people have very big, but cheap mortgages.

Current government policies, along with the unprecedented gas price increases are stoking inflation, the only way to put a brake on that is increasing interest rates. And that's on the way.

buttermutt · 07/10/2021 16:49

I can understand people who have only known boom thinking bust can never happen but it’s inevitable because the economy is cyclical. The thing to do when a storm’s approaching is batten down the hatches.

But housing has defied logic & prices which should have been corrected years ago keep rising.
After 08 lending changed & many home owners have significant equity so it's too simplistic to say the past will repeat again. Unfortunately assets are the best vehicle for making money.

Blossomtoes · 07/10/2021 16:47

They didn’t pay £60k for it though, did they? Interest rates were ridiculous for almost the entire duration of their mortgage. Inflation was also sky high so money was worth considerably less when they paid off the mortgage than when they took it out. So they paid a lot more than £60k.

Then, of course, if they sold it, they’d have to pay £2 million to get a comparable property. The money’s just fairy money until they no longer need a home. And, if house prices go down, so has the fairy money.

So, yes, it’s all relative.

buttermutt · 07/10/2021 16:40

If you bought a house in 1989, then 10 or 15 years later it was worth much more.

In simple terms, yes. Relatively, no. High interest rates and inflation also have to be taken into account.

Really? my parents house was about 60k in the mid 80s & they sell for 2m now.

meadowbleu · 07/10/2021 14:05

I come at this having been on both sides of the argument.

We've bought and sold lots of properties to climb up the ladder and several times had mortgage interest rates in double figures. We always managed due to good health, full employment, no childcare costs and some savings. None of these things are a given. By nature, when moving up, we were always very frugral and happy to be so, no holidays or eating out etc. We also never maxed out on what a lender would give us, we always wanted a bit of a cushion and to feel fully in control, as much as we could be. We only bought properties on the basis of how easy they would be to sell on if we had to sell in a hurry.

Would I do the same in the here and now? No, I would be much more cautious due to the uncertainties surrounding the fallout from Brexit and the pandemic. I'm also accutely aware of both the financial cost of children and the commitment of time and energy, not to mention what toll it could take should a child have additional needs.

What I would do in your shoes @NCFC4now is a total life overhaul.

I'm confused about some of your maths and financial planning and the mention of recent garden leave. If you changed jobs quite recently what job security do you have and can you be certain maternity leave policies will stay the same? and government contributions, if any, which could stop at any time. You really need to do some thorough research about how family life works.

Like a previous PP I am concerned that you're effectively earning three incomes and a significant propertion of that is DH's side business. Working as a teacher in a deprived state system is not short hours or low stress, volunteering and also running his own business is a massive undertaking.

My advice in this life overhaul is start saving and living well within the means of that saving. You say you work from home, or get the train, you only buy second hand clothes for eco reasons and yet you have two old (less energy efficient?) cars despite liking your entertainment so close to home. Do a trial run of how life would be if you took this step and had a child too. While I don't want to get on your back, I do have to say I found the mention of an eventual inheritance very distasteful and on top of that, need to point out that this is far from a given if elderly parents need special care.

Instead of fixating on the things lacking from your present home, try appreciating what you do have a bit more. By that I don't mean being grateful, I mean enjoying the positives rather than bemoaning the downsides. A driveway and a bit more space may not be worth any added stress you could incur. Too often in life we feel like we want to rush to the end goal and don't enjoy the journey.

All said, I'm not particularly risk averse, but in your shoes and with your understanding of some of the main issues going forwards, I would follow a much more cautious path.

vickyp0llard · 07/10/2021 13:58

*I was wondering that… these kind of earnings/house prices/mortgages blow my mind to be honest.

We earn less than half of that between us and still save, eat out, have holidays etc. We live much more cheaply though. Cheaper part of the country. We could of gone bigger but the quality of life day to day means so much more to me and we are in a lovely area.*

I think it's London TBH. I earn 35k in the Home Counties and have always managed to have a nice life, go out for dinners, save, go on holiday e.t.c. However going into London is ridiculous - cocktails are £13 plus service charge, meals out end up being like £45pp, everything is so bloody expensive. We spent about £200 on a night out once you count up food, drinks, taxis, trains, kebab! London workplaces also seem to constantly be going out for lunches/drinks, whereas in the suburbs we don't really do much of that out of the office.

My friends renting a 1 bed flat in Canary Wharf pay twice as much as I do per month for a 3 bed semi. So everyone needs to earn a lot more to keep up the lifestyle.

Sprostongreen21 · 07/10/2021 13:53

@Ilovefluffysheep

What on earth do you spend your money on? Seriously, you say between you you take home around £8k a month. That's a huge amount.

You say you eat out a lot, but don't spend much on other things. Yet you overspend each month? Are you really spending thousands of pounds a month eating out?

I was wondering that… these kind of earnings/house prices/mortgages blow my mind to be honest.

We earn less than half of that between us and still save, eat out, have holidays etc. We live much more cheaply though. Cheaper part of the country. We could of gone bigger but the quality of life day to day means so much more to me and we are in a lovely area.

However I’m still quite concerned about rising costs happening now and in the future , mortgage/bills are affordable just about on on one wage. While @NCFC4now has a great income I would want to be planning anything risky right now to be honest.

Frazzled2207 · 07/10/2021 13:50

@Wilkolampshade

Suck up the parking and do a loft conversion instead?
she doesn't have any children so I struggle to believe OP needs extra space right now!
vickyp0llard · 07/10/2021 13:44

I wouldn't. We just moved from a rented flat into our first house, and even though the mortgage is only 21% of our take-home, I still feel a lot more squeezed than with the flat. We used to save about 50% of our income and now we save fuck all. Every month we're haemorrhaging money on the house, the garden, new car because I crashed ours....and there's things you apparently have to do to a house that I never even thought about (pruning trees, window cleaning, gutter cleaning!). We don't even have kids. Plus a huge mortgage leaves you no wiggle room for going PT, mental breakdowns, change in circumstances, recessions e.t.c.

saleorbouy · 07/10/2021 13:24

Interest rates won't remain low foreverhow will a rate of 5% or more affect your finances.
Find something more affordable that allows for the expense of having a family, maternity leave and interest rate increases to give you some financial freedom.

Swipe left for the next trending thread