Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to mortgage ourselves over our heads?

489 replies

NCFC4now · 06/10/2021 16:19

DH will read this so I suppose your opinions will help settle a debate.

DH is 32 and I am 27. We currently own a 3 bed semi Victorian house, it is in a desirable area we love, in the 18 months since we’ve moved in the value increased £75k (bank mortgage valuation) because of the housing bubble.

We over pay our mortgage every month and have a growing amount of equity (especially with the increase!)
However, whilst I love our house, it doesn’t have parking and I find the garden just a bit sad (neighbour has huge trees that block out a lot of sun because the garden isn’t big). Due to the area, parking is difficult and you tend to have to park down the road from your own house.

Because of our location, which we won’t compromise on, a 4 bed with parking, nothing fancy will be £1m. We can get a mortgage for £800k. In my mind, we should wait 2 years (fixed rate ends) and save as much as possible and go for it.

Using present rates available to us, our mortgage minimum payment would be £2.7k a month over 30 years. We can afford this but would mean we can’t really do a step wrong. It would also mean our savings are wiped out due to SDLT so would need to replenish those.

I grew up in poverty and we have achieved everything without any help so I suppose a big house has always been a symbol of achievement to me.

Is it a dumb idea? Tell me your thoughts! I am a bit scared about losing our jobs and whilst DH is a teacher so safe, his extra income comes through a business he runs which I think is stable but you never know. I also hate working and have some mental health issues. Also this could be made worse financially if we do have kids as planned in a couple of years…

DH wants the house but doesn’t want the debt and thinks we should stay put. My argument is simply that having a child and no parking space will cause a breakdown at some point if I’m already stressed whilst fit and childless about the situation.
Thanks

OP posts:
TataMamma · 07/10/2021 23:51

@DroopyClematis

I might be wrong but if your parents are going to be paid to look after your future children then I believe that they need to be registered.

Hopefully someone will come along and put me right.

Nope that's not the case. If OP wants to get the £2000 per year tax thingy then grandparents need to be registered, and if OP wants to use the Government 30 hours thing then yes, but simply to use grandparents and pay them, then no. It seems like OP is hoping to combine professional paid childcare with (presumably) lower paid grandparent care. She will therefore be able to use all her governmenty help things on the private care, and then reach a separate arrangement with her family. It's a risk, but if OP manages this, it should make things much more affordable particularly when her DC are eligible for the 30 hours. It presumably helps a lot that her DH is a teacher and therefore they don't need as much childcare as many.
DroopyClematis · 07/10/2021 23:42

I might be wrong but if your parents are going to be paid to look after your future children then I believe that they need to be registered.

Hopefully someone will come along and put me right.

HeddaGarbled · 07/10/2021 23:37

I have no maternal instinct but know I want children

😵‍💫

TataMamma · 07/10/2021 23:31

Buy it then. You are determined that you're right, but I'm going to point out you are in finance and your husband is a teacher, yet you've turned to an online forum of strangers for advice on money. If the pair of you can't use a calculator and/or excel, you're screwed.

Wow....and people have been saying I'm rude! Jees she knows about her own life and hasn't made the same decision you would. Calm down dear!
And OP didn't turn to an online forum of strangers for advice on money - her and her DH had different views on whether something was too risky or no (ultimately a matter of opinion, based very largely on your personal attitudes towards risk), and she sought to see how others viewed the whole thing. Clearly she wasn't asking for financial advice, but gauging how her feelings of risk were compared to others, and seeking info about childcare and other related costs.

FreedomFaith · 07/10/2021 22:32

@NCFC4now

Wow, OK so lots of views here and a lot I should explain.

Would like to thank my mortgage broker @buttermutt (I joke)

So I am not risk averse with property, if it’s the right one. We were paying almost 4% on our first mortgage because we were struggling for affordability (long story).

I suppose that past has encouraged me.
DH’s job is secure, however, if he lost it then his side job could take over. They do not need to go hand in hand but do well.
My job is in finance, it’s fine. I have only been in my current job 2 months and I took a pay cut for it - this was because I faced racial discrimination and needed out (I am awaiting a settlement).

I know that it is possible I’ll hate work after a child. The reason I’m so blasé is because I am so uncertain about children - it’s another thread in itself but I have no maternal instinct but know I want children. It’s strange and confusing. DH is on the same page.

I spoke to my mum today about childcare, we discussed costs based on what I’ve been told here and she thinks I’d be better using her and paying her a small amount. I’m happy to pay my parents for things and currently do, they are still not at retirement age and it makes me feel comfortable knowing they’re ok.

Somehow the posts on here seem to have made DH less on the other side. I should preface this with the fact we are both in Economics. Whilst he doesn’t believe we will go back to historic high interest rates, he’d argue this is now the time to overstretch. He’s just worried.

Thinking it through I’ve penned scenarios for 2 years time when we move house, this would only happen if fixed on a large mortgage for 5 years. This means in the beginning we’d have little childcare issues. We can assume our salary will be a lot higher but for this exercise I will not increase it:
£3,000 mortgage
£1,000 bills (they do not need to be higher, they’re not this high at the moment and we aren’t going much bigger)
£1,500 nursery fees according to this
£1,000 on baby related items and expenses

That means £6,500 spent of which £1,500 remains free for savings?

This is why I’m so convinced I’m not taking a risk but maybe I’m being silly again.

Buy it then. You are determined that you're right, but I'm going to point out you are in finance and your husband is a teacher, yet you've turned to an online forum of strangers for advice on money. If the pair of you can't use a calculator and/or excel, you're screwed.
timeisnotaline · 07/10/2021 22:28

If you are both in economics this should be straightforward. You talk about future plans, but they would have to be cancelled if you took on this mortgage. You cannot count on your parents for childcare as you would lose the house if your mom got sick. You would not be able to both go parttime as you will need your incomes. You will be very unlikely to be achieving your expected double triple income if you went part time, and possibly even if you went on mat leave (very unfortunate but certainly happens)

Mortgage rates- are at an all time low. 3% extra is the basic bank stress test for whether you can afford the loan so if that’s your stress limit then it’s a bad idea. Agree 12% is very high but globally rates are starting to pick up, nz lifted rates this week. If you can’t pay 7% you risk being highly stressed. You mention your mental health, another reason not to overstretch. There is no stress like financial stress! I can assure you parking is nothing compared to the stress of trying to keep the house if something goes wrong at work or if your child is sick.

I have been where you are and appreciate the parking can be a nightmare, I would challenge you to see if this is something where you can decide not to be bothered about it. That stress rise every time you are looking for a spot? You can control it, think of it as. A mental health exercise. I part managed it by not driving a lot with children, as it is even harder when you have to get bags and child and pram out of the car and walk two streets to home.
That said, wait the 2 years and reassess. A lot can change in that time.

GoWalkabout · 07/10/2021 21:59

You can't have everything you want. Your dh is a keeper, listen to him.

LazySundayPlease · 07/10/2021 21:51

In London, our nursery for 1 child full time was £1750. That was a few years ago

BarbaraofSeville · 07/10/2021 21:49

I'm not saying you can't afford the big mortgage, just that you might not have as much spare as you think.

BarbaraofSeville · 07/10/2021 21:48

^£3,000 mortgage
£1,000 bills (they do not need to be higher, they’re not this high at the moment and we aren’t going much bigger)
£1,500 nursery fees according to this
£1,000 on baby related items and expenses

That means £6,500 spent of which £1,500 remains free for savings^

I'm not sure the £1000 bills will cover everything, but £1000 monthly baby related items over and above nursery/childcare sounds like a lot.

Your £1000 bills seems to have to cover

council tax
gas/electric
water
broadband
TV licence and services
mobile phones
prescriptions/opticians/dentist
food
travel/car costs

Which doesn't seem like much. Remember that utilities are on the rise and you're planning to move to a larger house which could mean that bills will rise. Also what about holidays, home improvements, car replacement?

Plus also there's personal spending money clothes, haircuts, meals out, hobbies, leisure etc. Many couples who are used to buying lunch, having haircuts and beauty treatments etc could spend £1k pm or more on those things alone.

NCFC4now · 07/10/2021 21:38

Wow, OK so lots of views here and a lot I should explain.

Would like to thank my mortgage broker @buttermutt (I joke)

So I am not risk averse with property, if it’s the right one. We were paying almost 4% on our first mortgage because we were struggling for affordability (long story).

I suppose that past has encouraged me.
DH’s job is secure, however, if he lost it then his side job could take over. They do not need to go hand in hand but do well.
My job is in finance, it’s fine. I have only been in my current job 2 months and I took a pay cut for it - this was because I faced racial discrimination and needed out (I am awaiting a settlement).

I know that it is possible I’ll hate work after a child. The reason I’m so blasé is because I am so uncertain about children - it’s another thread in itself but I have no maternal instinct but know I want children. It’s strange and confusing. DH is on the same page.

I spoke to my mum today about childcare, we discussed costs based on what I’ve been told here and she thinks I’d be better using her and paying her a small amount. I’m happy to pay my parents for things and currently do, they are still not at retirement age and it makes me feel comfortable knowing they’re ok.

Somehow the posts on here seem to have made DH less on the other side. I should preface this with the fact we are both in Economics. Whilst he doesn’t believe we will go back to historic high interest rates, he’d argue this is now the time to overstretch. He’s just worried.

Thinking it through I’ve penned scenarios for 2 years time when we move house, this would only happen if fixed on a large mortgage for 5 years. This means in the beginning we’d have little childcare issues. We can assume our salary will be a lot higher but for this exercise I will not increase it:
£3,000 mortgage
£1,000 bills (they do not need to be higher, they’re not this high at the moment and we aren’t going much bigger)
£1,500 nursery fees according to this
£1,000 on baby related items and expenses

That means £6,500 spent of which £1,500 remains free for savings?

This is why I’m so convinced I’m not taking a risk but maybe I’m being silly again.

OP posts:
DerAlteMann · 07/10/2021 20:28

Kids and a massive mortgage just to get a parking space? Which is what this seems to come down to. Don't do it. If you do this and anything should go wrong you are sunk and could lose the house and everything. If parking means so much, move to an area where prices are cheaper.

meadowbleu · 07/10/2021 20:04

@RashOfBees that's all good advice, well balanced and expressed.

We all take risks in some way, every day, but when they're major risks it's good to look at the very worst downside and then work back to the amount of sacrifice and the gamble that we're comfortable with and if that risk is worth the potential gain.

YukoandHiro · 07/10/2021 19:46

That's a huge amount of debt. How would you manage it if one of you lost your jobs? How would you manage to pay childcare (£1k a month usually) if you had children and needed to work to cover the mortgage as well - or just wanted to work, of course?

I think your DH is right.

Lincslady53 · 07/10/2021 19:42

Interest rates are very low at the moment and have been for many years. However, with fuel prices increasing, wages being pressured to rise and general shortage of labour pushing up costs of materials, inflation is set to increase. To combat rising inflation, the first thing the BOE will do is to raise interest rates. If you maxed out the amount you can borrow and rates rise by say 2 or 3 % - base rate would still only be 2.5 - 3.5% which is much lower than it has been for 40 odd years before the 2010 crash. Just calculate what would happen to your monthly payments should interest rates rise. If you get a 5 year fix that you can afford, and if after 4 years rates have risen meaning your next rate fix will be unaffordable, sell up, take the extra equity and downsize.

Babamamananarama · 07/10/2021 19:34

OP speaking from experience I wouldn't leave yourself with no room to manoeuvre.

We recently moved into a much bigger house. It's a renovation project and we extended our mortgage a bit to give ourselves some capital to do the works. Luckily our mortgage is still small as we had loads of capital in our last place and moved out of London to a rural area where property is cheaper - but our bills and house maintenance costs are much higher here, which comes with having a bigger house.

Shortly after we moved I got diagnosed with cancer and have been in and out of hospital ever since. I didn't have critical illness cover/income protection insurance. I've retained my part time salary but lost all the freelance income I would normally make on top - about 1/3 of my income. DH has also had to cut down on work to look after me and the kids. The mental and emotional strain on our family has been enormous as you can imagine. Luckily we've not fared too badly financially as we haven't gone out much (at all!) and our mortgage is low so we've been able to absorb the drop in income without going into our savings or into debt. But a big house with significant upkeep does feel like a burden at times like these.

I guess my point is that life throws you curveballs and you need to have enough flex in your lifestyle to absorb some blows. There are a million reasons why you may not both be able to work to the same capacity you are now - and why you may not want to. I would hate to be in a situation where your options were keep your nose to the grindstone or lose your house.

NameChangeforMoneyThings · 07/10/2021 19:12

I'd really recommend reading some of the Mr Money Mustache blogs. He's in the USA and a mad keen Financial Independence Retire Early person. I take a good chunk of what he says with a pinch of salt - e.g. I am quite happy to pay someone to look after my house because I like my job a lot more than I like cleaning.

But he does do a really good job of dissecting and actually almost flipping entirely the attitude have in your mind that you need a bigger house to be successful.

I have to stop and think back to them sometimes lifestyle creep is really really easy and it's important that is conscious not accidental at least.

WhereYouLeftIt · 07/10/2021 18:57

"Using present rates available to us, our mortgage minimum payment would be £2.7k a month over 30 years. We can afford this but would mean we can’t really do a step wrong. It would also mean our savings are wiped out due to SDLT so would need to replenish those."

Present interest rates are currently at a historical low. They will go up. Inflation is going to be kicking in big-time soon, and that means interest rates will be increased to try to control it. How much will your monthly payments increase if your mortgage rate increases by 1%, 2%, 3% ... 10%?

This plan wipes out your savings and as you said, it "would mean we can’t really do a step wrong". And if you haven't built the inevitable inflation and interest rates rise into your calculations, sorrySad, but you have already done a step wrong.

MrsKeats · 07/10/2021 18:29

No way would I do this.
Far too risky.

TataMamma · 07/10/2021 18:22

@wewereliars

Tatamma are you this obnoxious in real life?

There is no fairy money if you can't sell your house and it gets repossesd. A house in this country has been a one way bet for many years.

That is, if you are able to service any mortgage until the end of its term.

A house is also a home for most people though, and most people have to keep working to pay that mortgage. So all is fine until something happens so that the debt can't be serviced. An uncertaim economic outlook and pretty much guaranteed interest rises in the nar future increase that risk. Simples

Perhaps you haven't been reading some of the crap @Blossomtoes has written? There is no fairy money if you can't sell your house and it gets repossesd Not true at all. If you buy a house for £500,000, with £200,000 in equity, can't keep up with payments and it's repossessed and sold for £600,000, then there is very real money that is still yours. It is only when you do not move that the increased value can be described as fairy money. (Even then it can help you remortgage for a lower rate because your equity is higher, and can provide you with reassurance should the worse still come.) The repossession though is unlikely: a) they are clearly savvy people and they would sell for more before it came to that; b) there is no reason at all to think this is on the cards.

A house in this country has been a one way bet for many years.
And long term, which is what OP is talking about, it still is.

That is, if you are able to service any mortgage until the end of its term.
Nope. It's still a good investment and still a one way bet in the long term, even if that is not as long as a full mortgage term.

A house is also a home for most people though
And it is for OP. She's looking for her forever dream home, not a short term investment, where the economics would work very differently and it would all be much much more risky.

So all is fine until something happens so that the debt can't be serviced. An uncertaim economic outlook and pretty much guaranteed interest rises in the nar future increase that risk.
Well, it might be the right thing anyway, and that is really my point. If OP couldn't pay for the new mortgage say at the end of a 5 year fixed term then she would still have made money - not fairy money at all - even if she had to sell up. Interest rates rising in the near future is a good reason to move and lock in to a good rate now.

Simples
Indeed it is! Three sources of income, only slight increase in actual payments being made, guaranteed long term house price increase, and dream one. And she's still only 27!!!

buttermutt · 07/10/2021 18:21

I’m not being rude to anyone or insulting them either, tempting though it is.

You called me financially reckless 😆.

I'm still intrigued as to why my parents have to spend 2m on their next property, I mean London is expensive but not quite that expensive.

Blossomtoes · 07/10/2021 18:16

[quote TataMamma]@Blossomtoes
Just stop trying to lecture everyone on economics. You know nothing. You have strong risk averse views and think you know it all because you remember the 90s. You are not focused on OP and her situation, and really basic economics which everyone knows doesn't meant that being very risk averse is always the best approach.
The point is the house is likely to go up over time. You appear to have finally accept that is what happens - long term - to house prices, albeit there can be comparatively big dips along the way. Now you are dismissing this increase as "fairy money" and all "relative". Which is also a load of nonsense as others have pointed out. You might find more similar people to yourself on Gransnet.[/quote]
No, you’re right. I stopped talking about OP many posts ago. I’m not lecturing anyone. I’m not being rude to anyone or insulting them either, tempting though it is.

buttermutt · 07/10/2021 18:10

I have read what you said, try reading what I've said.

We don't know enough about the OPs circumstances to assume she has no exit routes

Auntycorruption · 07/10/2021 18:09

@NCFC4now

I want to make it clear that I would not stop working to have children. That’s the plan anyway, even if money was not an issue and I became a millionaire.

I hate working but I hate not working (I was on gardening leave recently and there were perks but I did get very bored). It is depression.

Mental health issues = diagnosed OCD, it’s not going anywhere but it’s under control!

You don't know how your OCD would change after a child.

Don't make any decisions based on "free" childcare which can be taken away by the govt at any stage. I'd budget £1.5k/month between your return to work & until they are 5 and then you'll probably have some wiggle room.

Massive mortgages are restrictive & life limiting. I wouldn't do it. Plus what happens if you do split up (you mention divorce) and neither can buy the other out - it's a money pit.

wewereliars · 07/10/2021 18:08

Buttermutt don't call me disingenuous thank you. Try reading what I have actually said