Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I shouted at MIL for leaving my baby to cry himself to sleep and now she is suicidal ?

434 replies

Anon199000000 · 06/10/2021 16:03

My son is 4 months old and he stayed the night at my MILs. This has been planned for weeks, prior to my son staying me and partner kept thanking MIL for offering to take our son for the night as he’s so young. MIL insisted we didn’t even need to thank her, she couldn’t wait to look after him for the night.

Now..bit of background, me and my partner have totally different views on parenting than my in laws. They often give unsolicited advice and brush off what we have to say as they say they have had two kids and know what they are doing. They have a bit of an old school approach I believe..they have often said they left my partner to cry as he had a temper as a baby and their own parents told them they needed to leave him to cry to “break him” (their own words) and show him who’s boss type thing..

Now..I never leave my son to cry. I’m really against it and so is my sons dad, which my in laws know. I was hesitant to leave my son with them because of this but my partner assured me his parents only
Did that to him as a baby and wouldn’t do that to our son.

Now Cut to Saturday night we decide to phone in laws to find out how they getting on at around 9 o clock. MIL answers and says “ he has some cry doesn’t he !!! Oh he reminds me just of you when you were a baby ! I thought that cry is just sheer temper ! So I put him in his cot and left him and checked in on him every 10 minutes and now he’s sleeping.” Me and my partner just stared at each other for a few seconds after she said this and he said “aw mum..please don’t leave him to cry” and she said “aw he’s fine ! He’s sleeping now” and I instantly burst in to tears..

I’m not being dramatic but I genuinely felt heartbroken that my little boy had been left there crying in his own..I know how upset he gets just being left crying for a few minutes while I’m at the toilet or I’m getting a bottle or
Something !

My partner wasn’t happy she had left him and decided to text his mum and ask her again please not to leave our son to cry and I was so upset. I started to feel really angry and He asked me to ohone his mum and I said no Because I will shout at her on the phone so I’m not going to speak to her the now. She then starts to phone my partner and he answers and blooming puts her on loudspeaker ! I couldn’t help myself and I shouted “don’t you dare ever leave my son to cry again !! How dare you !!” And my partner hung up the phone.

My partner then started to get messages from her and his dad saying how upset his mum was and she was in tears! He is a proper mummies boy and this immediately made him turn on me. He was shouting at me and saying things like his mum will always come before me and he can’t believe I’ve upset her and his mum is in tears etc and even that he doesn’t want to be with me he is totally finished with me ! His mum keeps messaging him that she is soo upset, in tears and then changes her tune completely and says that in fact she never left our baby to cry at all and she would never ! That he got lots of kisses and cuddles and lovely warm milk and yes he was crying but she sat with
Him the whole time stroking his head...so now my partner is even more angry at me because he has suddenly forgot what his mum said in the first place? Like what she said was pretty black and white to me..she definitely admitted to leaving him to cry ..my partner even said the same at the time and wasn’t happy either so what ?!

I’ve never argued with my in laws once and always gotten on well with them. They’ve treated me like a daughter and said numerous times I was the best thing to happen to their son and have now completely turned on me because of this I feel and I just find the whole thing crazy. I don’t know if it’s just because I’m shy and never stood up to them before so now they’re not happy..

The next day in laws were meant to drop my son off at our house but wouldn’t as his mum was still in tears apparently and his dad waited for me to go out before bringing my son home .. I tried phoning MIL twice and she never answered. I the. Messaged her apologising for shouting and thanking her for doing us a favour and she never replied..that night partner kicks off at me again. Apparently his mum had messaged him saying she is still crying and upset by everything and the next day she says she doesn’t feel she has anything to live for.. he’s telling me I need to phone her and I try explaining that I already have and she hasn’t
Answered or tried phoning back and he just gets angrier and angrier with me and says I need to keep trying.. and need to keep apologising to her.

I’m just really taken aback by the whole thing..it’s been days and my partner is still off with me and if I’m honest I can actually see this being the end of us ..I mean for godsake he thinks that ive made his mother suicidal. yes I shouldn’t have shouted at her and she was doing us a big favour but she shouldn’t have done that still and why is no one telling her she’s overreacting ! I’m just so shocked by this whole situation...please tell my I’m not being unreasonable

OP posts:
ILoveJamaica · 07/10/2021 08:32

What a massive drama over nothing. I can't understand why you spent your baby free time ringing MIL. Shouting what you did, probably means you've lost your babysitter. Your son is fine. Everyone seems to hate MIL's on here. They were looking after babies before you were born.

AhNowTed · 07/10/2021 08:17

@EnidFrighten

Is this the alcoholic unemployed financially abusive possibly cheating partner who nags you for sex soon after birth OP? www.mumsnet.com/Talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/4330729-My-partner-said-he-was-seeing-someone-else-and-then-said-he-wasn-t

You're only 23. Don't spend your life with this toerag.

Oh dear. That's awful.

GingerScallop · 07/10/2021 08:08

Op, I have read your other threads and I realise your reaction was probably less about baby being left to cry (checked every 10 minutes) and more about everything you've been through with this man. His mother's reaction doesn't even matter. What you need is to start putting together the resources and courage to leave him. You will be doing yourself a massive favour. You are only 23 and have a whole life ahead of you. Don't waste them with this man and his family.
WomensAid and other such groups can be your starting point.
You are beautiful and amazing and have a gorgeous boy and deserve so much better

3scape · 07/10/2021 07:44

Plus no wonder she thinks tears are just manipulation!

3scape · 07/10/2021 07:43

Hell no. What a gaslighting family they are. Get your baby, never allow them to have him over night and let your partner go back to his mum if she's such a priority. Focus on the child. The adults can look after themselves.

NichyNoo · 07/10/2021 07:42

Your DH and MiL are out of order ramping up the drama so much but seriously, the baby will be fine if left to cry it out. You had a nice night out and didn’t have to listen to him cry so it’s really not an issue. I can’t believe you actually shouted at your MIL !

furbabymama87 · 07/10/2021 07:34

When you send your young baby to spend the night elsewhere, they are not going to parent your baby the same way you do. You overreacted shouting at her, she overreacted saying she's got nothing to live for. Your partner should be on your side, not his mum's. I don't agree with leaving a baby to scream, but if they're just whimpering or grizzling for a few minutes, it's how they learn to self settle. It's hard to know what exactly went on, but don't leave your baby with anyone for a while because you probably weren't ready.

malificent7 · 07/10/2021 07:32

Tbh I don't think you should have left him with your MIL if you disagree with her aporoach. It's not the end if the world...he slept. He won't be scared for life.

EnidFrighten · 07/10/2021 07:23

Is this the alcoholic unemployed financially abusive possibly cheating partner who nags you for sex soon after birth OP?
www.mumsnet.com/Talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/4330729-My-partner-said-he-was-seeing-someone-else-and-then-said-he-wasn-t

You're only 23. Don't spend your life with this toerag.

Awalkintime · 07/10/2021 05:59

If it's ok for your baby to be left crying then it is ok for MIL to be left crying. What's good for the goose is good for the gander.

midsummabreak · 07/10/2021 05:21

Do you know any parents with young children who would like to trial taking turns to babysit

50ShadesOfCatholic · 07/10/2021 05:08

You are all being ridiculous. Except the baby. Jesus, you and your partner need to buckle up because this is the easy part of parenting.

Silvetmoon · 07/10/2021 04:57

I said MIL was too upset apparently so FIL never dropped son off until 2 o clock which I was angry about as well but again, didn’t want to keep argument going due to partner shouting at me all night.

I would never ever leave my child with them again, my god.

timeisnotaline · 07/10/2021 04:49

Oh read the other thread. Don’t bother talking to your partner. Leave him. He’s a dead weight and you’re better without him.

timeisnotaline · 07/10/2021 04:48

Imagine maliciously hanging to a 4 month old baby for more than half of the following day to punish its mother- Thats pretty nasty behaviour. I think it would be a long time before my baby saw their parents in law again. Nor would I apologise, mil can practice crying it out.
You really do have a partner problem though. Look after your baby, consider a few days with your parents to think. Tell him if he meant that his mother will always come first then there’s no point talking really, it’s nothing like the relationship he had promised after all. And why is it ok for his mum to leave your baby to cry but his mum crying is terrible? This just makes you feel worse for your baby.

Crazycatlady83 · 07/10/2021 04:35

Leave MIL to cry, she seems to think it works for the baby .....

Blessex · 07/10/2021 04:31

Ah have read your other thread. Question is why you are still with this man?

twoandeights · 07/10/2021 04:29

Read your other thread OP.
Pick up your baby and go to family. This bloke is no good. His family are no good. Get out. Rebuild your life with your families help

TrishM80 · 07/10/2021 04:21

Oh no, the baby was left cry himself to sleep, what a disaster.

Get a grip, OP.

Blessex · 07/10/2021 04:13

Why did you leave him with them if you have such strong ideas?

Balonzette · 07/10/2021 03:55

I never let my children cry themselves to sleep, I think it's barbaric, so I'm with you there.

But your MIL did you a favour, and while she SHOULD have listened to your desires, you shouldn't have yelled at her. That was really not on. I always say that just because you're sorry, doesnt mean that the other person isn't hurt anymore. The upset doesnt just vanish because the person who upset you said the word "sorry". So maybe she's just really shaken at being yelled at and needs some time to calm down.

You are being a little pfb and your child won't be traumatised by being left to cry for literally one night. People do it every night (which again, I think is awful, but the kids seem to turn out fine anyway!).

AnnieSnap · 07/10/2021 01:28

@Anon199000000 I’m not surprised you were upset. Leaving your baby to cry when she knew your views on this was totally unacceptable. As for the MIL’s and husband’s behaviour, I wouldn’t indulge it for one more moment. As PPs have said, ignore the MIL and tell your husband that he is being ridiculous and has his priorities all wrong. Then leave him to come to his senses if he can.

SudokuWillNotSaveYou · 07/10/2021 00:28

Oh damn. I commented on OP’s thread in August and didn’t realize it was the same “anon”. OP- he’s said and done much worse than this argument. He’s horrifically abusive; it isn’t going to get better.

We told you then, and I stand by it - do not worry about money, babies DO NOT need much (Finland gives new parents a box that costs £140 and that covers everything, and even serves as a cot and they have incredibly low infant death rates); just make an appointment with your GP, take baby with you, and when you go, stuff as much as you can in your purse and baby’s nappy bag. Maybe try to take an “extra” shopping bag that you say you have to drop at your mum’s or some excuse for taking an extra bag, even if it’s just a bag for life; that’s still extra room for some knickers, bras, change of clothes, jewelry, keepsakes, important papers. This man is increasingly violent (punching the wall to the point of breaking his hand, drinking constantly, taking your card to take your money, leaving you to pay bills you can barely afford). Remember: first they punch near you, then they punch you. Take your baby and get out. Your MIL and that whole argument is such a tiny red herring.

For others who don’t know:
www.mumsnet.com/Talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/4330729-My-partner-said-he-was-seeing-someone-else-and-then-said-he-wasn-t

Sorry for sharing OP, but it’s massively relevant.

HyacynthBucket · 07/10/2021 00:15

You poor thing OP. YANBU about the baby and MIl, not in the slightest, but they are not really the biggest problem here. The real issue is that your DH said you would always come second to his mother. You surely cannot live in that situation.
If he has not grown up enough to separate himself as a man from his mother, then he is not mature enough to have had a baby with you. This would be dealbreaker for me.
To start off with, get away for a week or so with your baby to your own parents if possible. That will give you and your DH time to think .Particularly you, as you need to plan a future that does not include a man who cannot put you and baby first. It is outrageous that he said you would come second to his mother. Please don't accept that.

SkiingIsHeaven · 07/10/2021 00:12

Let her cry it out like she made your baby.