Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it's not a housing problem, it's a landlord problem?

36 replies

Sylvvie · 06/10/2021 15:38

Boris has promised to build more housing so young people can get on the property ladder. Fine, brilliant.

But as with all new builds, 75% will get hoovered up by second home owners and Landlords to be rented out. This doesn't fix the problem because young people then either compete for that 15% left which is always ridiculously expensive or end up renting those properties. (Not accurate figures obviously, just an example, but certainly feels that way!).

There are an insubordinate amount of second homes and Landlord houses standing empty at the moment. Young people are stuck renting because the rental prices are so high that they can't save the capitol for even a help-to-buy property unless they get really bloody lucky or inherit. Not to mention wages at the moment are abysmal and cost of living is rising due to Brexit and Covid issues.

AIBU? Am I genuinely missing something here? I don't think more homes that young people can't afford or that get snapped up by landlords is the answer but I would love to be told I am wrong (currently saving for our deposit).

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
FancyFlipFlops · 07/10/2021 16:19

My DH and I have been saving a house deposit and were looking to buy this year. Unfortunately the houses that we could afford and were suitable for our family before the pandemic have gone up around £150k and don’t look to be coming down that much at all. Added into the scenario we’ve become a a one income family due to my disability. We also live in a tourist and big second home county.

We have been in our current rented house for four years and we are hoping and praying that the LL doesn’t put the rent up. Looking at the rental market around us at the moment there are 10 houses for rent in our town on Rightmove. The 1 bed flats are currently going for around £50 under what we’re paying. The 2 bed houses are currently around £150-200 over what we are paying and the 3 bed ( which we need) are currently £400-600 what we pay now on average and we just couldn’t afford the rent.

billysboy · 07/10/2021 09:58

supply and demand will keep house price costs high and on the increase
This Govt could not afford a massive 20% + adjustment downwards

A lot of people quite happy to pull the housing ladder up behind them at the same time

Also Nimbys all agreeing that there is a need for more housing but just not here

tellittomeslowlyandclearly · 07/10/2021 09:50

New builds are expensive to buy and the few on our new build development that are privately rented out cost more than a mortgage on them ( I doubt any have been bought mortgage free as from £350,000) . So it's about people saving for deposits and not fast living. It's really tough to deprive yourself for years to save.

Gingernaut · 07/10/2021 01:08

The trouble with any shared ownership scheme is that prices have outstripped wages to such an extent, that people are mortgaged to the hilt and still have to find the remaining rent, with no realistic prospect of ever buying the other portion of the property.

Added to this, many leasehold, new build flats are covered with cladding, like Grenfell Tower.

Anyone who owns one of these death traps has to find more money to pay the management companies' fees to replace the cladding, can't sell what is effectively an unmortgageable property and keep up with the rent and mortgage.

I really feel for those poor people.

Crikeyalmighty · 06/10/2021 21:31

When Tony Blair first came in there was a very good scheme available called DIYSO ( I know as we bought a flat under it when I was pregnant) - it stood for Do it yourself shared ownership - basically you bought 50% yourself (on mortgage with a 5% payment on the 50%) and the remainder owned by the housing association— the big difference with today’s shared ownership and help to buy etc was that you picked yourself on the open market. There were certain conditions and some price level limits- but it did mean that nice 2 bed flats even in London in ok areas were doable with a reasonable family income (we bought in crouch end) and very doable elsewhere- as were houses. It was phased out I suspect because the housebuilders didn’t like it!!!!

arrangeyourface · 06/10/2021 20:59

Build more social housing and remove Right To Buy.

nosafeguardingadults · 06/10/2021 20:51

Homeless application to councils for domestic violence and they tell you to rent private but no landlord takes benefits. Is why women get murdered and injured.

nosafeguardingadults · 06/10/2021 20:49

Is why so many women get murdered. Nowhere safe to go to live in. Was in refuge but had to go back cos no safe places after. The murders and domestic violence most of it. Not to do with police. No way will I ever tell police truth cos of the housing thing. Is better being hit or even killed is better than homeless.

coldwarenigma · 06/10/2021 20:24

New builds...It should be 90% social housing and the remaining for open sale. We need a mass social build to get people housing. Homes should be a right not a luxury. Won't happen, and housing will continue to be used to divide the populace.

Iggly · 06/10/2021 16:47

@gogohm

75% of new builds are not bought by second home owners or landlords - perhaps in specific areas but not nationally. In fact there is a property surplus in some places! We have a jobs distribution problem rather than housing stock, companies should be incentivised to move to areas with empty housing or brownfield sites suitable for housing development.
That makes no sense.

People need more than houses. They need decent transport connections, schools, doctors and other amenities. Building houses isn’t enough and there’s a reason that they say “location, location, location”

EvilPea · 06/10/2021 16:46

The changes to taxation on buy to let have had a huge impact, but the drop in supply of rental properties that has resulted has then pushed rents up for those properties that remain. A large number of rental properties are needed for society to function which have to be provided by either individuals, the state, or private enterprise. At present the financial situation seems to favour private enterprise
It’s also come at a time with the stamp duty relief. Combine that and lots came on the market. They were all snapped up quickly and house prices are booming again.

To be honest they brought that in too late, they needed to take the heat out of buy to let years ago.

You’ve now got buy to let and air B and B competing with people just trying to have a stable roof over their heads

gogohm · 06/10/2021 16:45

75% of new builds are not bought by second home owners or landlords - perhaps in specific areas but not nationally. In fact there is a property surplus in some places! We have a jobs distribution problem rather than housing stock, companies should be incentivised to move to areas with empty housing or brownfield sites suitable for housing development.

astoundedgoat · 06/10/2021 16:43

@Gingernaut

We have a drastic need for good quality social housing.

Build houses, out of solid materials and allow them to go to local councils to rent them out.

BTL landlords should be specifically exempt from purchasing schemes and buying any new builds unless councils say otherwise.

The situation is disgusting.

Fully agree, @Gingernaut. There needs to be a steady stream of sustainable, high quality social housing being built around the country with NO right-to-buy schemes attached.

And BTL mortgages phased out completely. We don't need them in our economy. Maybe landlord licences? So the number of properties bought by professional landlords can be more strictly restricted and managed.

TheQueef · 06/10/2021 16:39

It'll be ok.
When interest rates get high enough btl and accidental ll will sell and someone big, Amazon say, buy up all the houses because they have such financial flex.
Then we can work at Amazon, spend at Amazon and rent from them too.
Brilliant eh?
At night we can all stand in the garden and watch Jeff's rocket spunk our money into space.

Or we could be practical, prudent and sensible and build a tonne of SH and not emergency/poor housing either, true social housing not ghettos.

Wroxie · 06/10/2021 16:37

Unfortunately falling prices would pull the rug out from under a large part of a generation relying on it as a store of wealth for retirement.

Oh well. Should have thought of that before predicating your retirement on hoarding a vital resource ¯\(ツ)/¯

Yes I know it's more complicated than that - and in fact many of the pensions we are put on in our regular jobs include property in their funds- but I just can't get too upset about landlords losing money. They knew what they were getting into.

InTheNameOfAllThatIsHonest · 06/10/2021 16:35

A couple of points:

LLs would rather not buy new because the cost is higher and hence the return lower

Not everyone wants to buy: be it because they need the flexibility to up sticks for work, because they want to move to their spouse's country (or their own if they are not from here), because they want to stay somewhere for a couple of years e.g. a big city, and then move out. I have tenants (couples usually, sometimes a single person, in greater London) and hardly any, in over 20 years of letting, was renting because they couldn't buy

If LLs didn't offer properties to tenants, what would those people who cannot buy for whatever reason, do? Be homeless? Because the government could not afford to buy or build enough properties to house all the tenants currently in private rental.

IncessantNameChanger · 06/10/2021 16:29

I dont think being a landlord is appealing anymore and hasnt been financially worth it for years now. It was fine if you was already a landlord but it's so much harder to get a buy to let now.

I would love to sell up and would if the tennants left. It was our only house when we bought it ( long term renters in a nicer part of England for work. To expensive to buy here). It got us onto the property market so has worked out well for us over 15 years but I would never ever do it for a income now. When / if sections 21s end I go as far as saying you would be insane to set up a new btl.

As an aside my kids arent planning to move out until.at least theirs 30's. Its impossible to buy here unless a shared ownership which isnt without it's own problems

Iggly · 06/10/2021 16:18

@Asdf12345

Unfortunately falling prices would pull the rug out from under a large part of a generation relying on it as a store of wealth for retirement.

The changes to taxation on buy to let have had a huge impact, but the drop in supply of rental properties that has resulted has then pushed rents up for those properties that remain. A large number of rental properties are needed for society to function which have to be provided by either individuals, the state, or private enterprise. At present the financial situation seems to favour private enterprise.

You could have a separate private market for people who want to own outright and a publicly owned rental market.

A home is a fundamental right, in my view, so shouldn’t be used as a profit making exercise.

Wroxie · 06/10/2021 16:18

I agree with you but I think you meant to say inordinate, not insubordinate.

KrisAkabusi · 06/10/2021 16:17

I would love to see prices come down for the sake of the young and I'd have no problem with my house being worth a lot less than it is now if it meant all other property was cheaper too.

And what happens if you need to move? You've bought a house with say £400,000 mortgage. 5 years later you need to move. You still owe £380,000, but in your utopia, your house is suddenly only worth £200,000. What do you do now?

Iggly · 06/10/2021 16:17

I find it quite telling that as a country, the UK has one of the highest levels of rooms per person across Europe.

The problem isn’t the physical number of properties - it’s the cost of them which puts them out of reach. I’d like to know how exactly we’ve ended up here.

My guess is that it is the privatisation of housing. Much like other privatised industries, the priority is about making as much money as possible and that’s at the expense of those who need homes.

We need great public ownership of homes which are open to all - much like we had in the post war days. If the government rented more homes, it could do so at a decent rate (because it’s cost of borrowing is much lower). Anyone who wanted to buy outright would have to go on the open market.

woodhill · 06/10/2021 16:14

@ChloeCrocodile

Lower prices are not the answer.

Prices staying the same while wages catch up would help a lot though.

I find it rather irritating when people who already own a house and will have the mortgage paid off before retirement moan about lowered house prices affecting their pension. Maybe have a think about those who can't afford to buy a house and can't afford to pay in to a pension because they are paying eye watering private rents.

I'd rather house prices were lower as it's easier to trade up for everyone etc even if you don't get as much for your house
Tal45 · 06/10/2021 16:11

I think lower house prices makes total sense, when I was younger I bought a house and it went up in value by £50,000 in one year. Prices have just got sillier and sillier. I would love to see prices come down for the sake of the young and I'd have no problem with my house being worth a lot less than it is now if it meant all other property was cheaper too. We've been here a long time but it's worth nearly double what we paid for it. I think we really need to cut back on foreign investors and second homes, and stop covering the countryside in ugly, cheap houses that are all bought up as shoddy BFL's.

FreedomFaith · 06/10/2021 16:10

@TractorAndHeadphones

LL’s should be required to pay massive taxes and jump through hoops , they’ll sell their houses cuz they cant afford to keep them which happened quite a bit during pandemic and people can buy. Job done.
Agreed. Be a landlord if you want, but pay for the privilege of being able to afford multiple homes. Otherwise sell them. That applies to those who inherit. I'll inherit my parents house when they die. It's going straight on the market, and I'll be making sure some landlord wannabe won't be buying it.

Houses here for a new build 3 bed tiny bungalow start at £315,000. The 2 bed homes are obviously even smaller although still high prices. To afford said house, you either need one wage of £79,000 or two wages of nearly £40,000. The average wage in the area is minimum wage. Most can't afford that, and those who could don't want to buy a tiny house. It's completely stupid. So if you have kids too, you either live in a small house cramped or keep renting.

There's no answer that won't piss someone off though, and the tories aren't going to piss current home owners off, especially the older ones. It's kind of their main voting group.

Asdf12345 · 06/10/2021 16:09

Unfortunately falling prices would pull the rug out from under a large part of a generation relying on it as a store of wealth for retirement.

The changes to taxation on buy to let have had a huge impact, but the drop in supply of rental properties that has resulted has then pushed rents up for those properties that remain. A large number of rental properties are needed for society to function which have to be provided by either individuals, the state, or private enterprise. At present the financial situation seems to favour private enterprise.