Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not get DS vaccinated

311 replies

Florence282 · 06/10/2021 08:42

I think this probably not allowed but I'm very interested to see what the general population thinks about vaccinating our DC. DS is 12 and after a tonne of research we've decided not to vaccinate. Other mums in the school are struggling to make a decision.

Yanbu=no to the vaccine
Yabu=yes to the vaccine

OP posts:
edwinbear · 06/10/2021 11:16

www.theguardian.com/world/2021/sep/10/boys-more-at-risk-from-pfizer-jab-side-effect-than-covid-suggests-study

This is what concerns me, as such, we'll be waiting until there is more information available.

trumpisagit · 06/10/2021 11:15

My preteen and teenager aren't being vaccinated for now.
We all agree.
In my opinion it is unnecessary.
Adults are all fully vaccinated.

millymolls · 06/10/2021 11:13

No it was not aimed at transmission
All the research on mRNA technology is about limiting the effect and outcome of the illness To those vaccinated
And based on the fact that teens typically have mild symptoms ( even mr whitty states this fir those that respect him), the virus statistically to this age group is less dangerous than flu ( and we don’t all vaccinate teens each year for that ) therefore each parent should weigh up the risks and benefits for their own children without this hysteria and pressure out on them

Geamhradh · 06/10/2021 11:06

@Comedycook

Ive been very unsure. I've been vaccinated. I haven't consented for my teenage son to be though. I am concerned after hearing what the JCVI said. My feeling is he can always have it in the future but once it's done, it's done
It concerned you that they said benefits outweighed risks? Really? How bizarre.
Geamhradh · 06/10/2021 11:05

@edwinbear

YANBU OP. DS turned 12 end of August so only just 12 as well. DH and I are double jabbed, DS will have HPV and flu vaccines, DD (9) will have flu. Both have had all childhood immunisations.

I've just declined consent for DS to have the Covid vaccine because of the increased risk of myocarditis in boys - I would make a different decision for DD if she was old enough to have it. DS is an elite athlete in a CV intensive sport, his training/competitive schedule is between 15-20 hours a week and I'm not prepared to take any risks with his heart. He's had 3 periods of self isolation due to close contact so far, there are a number of his close school friends who have tested positive over the last few weeks. None of his peers have had any symptoms other than a slight sore throat and runny nose, and given he plays a full contact sport with many of them, I suspect he's probably already had it and been asymptomatic (despite regularly testing negative with LFT's which clearly aren't terribly accurate).

For him, personally, the risks outweigh the benefits. I don't think it's black and white with children and it's a situation where families need to be allowed and respected to take a decision in their DC's best interests.

The risk of myocarditis in your son is 3-6 cases every 1 million doses. He's more than 100 times more likely to spontaneously develop myocarditis.
Comedycook · 06/10/2021 11:05

Ive been very unsure. I've been vaccinated. I haven't consented for my teenage son to be though. I am concerned after hearing what the JCVI said. My feeling is he can always have it in the future but once it's done, it's done

Skinnymuffin2823 · 06/10/2021 11:03

I have a teenage son and we've said no for now, my son doesn't want to yet either.

Another parent in the school rang to cancel her daughters appointment for the vaccine and the receptionist mentioned that the reason she couldn't get through was because the majority of calls that morning were vaccination cancellations for teens.

My son had covid and had no symptoms whatsoever, so when I weighed up how I know he has reacted to covid against how I don't know he'll react to the jab, we're going with a delay.

If you say no now, you can always change your mind

Geamhradh · 06/10/2021 11:03

@millymolls

It’s not selfish

I hate this narrative about protecting others

Of course there is varying Information but scientific data published ( not just media reports) show that a vaccinated person and unvaccinated person chance of catching and passing are astonishingly similar. There is very little difference.

This vaccine ( which is not a vaccine in its traditional sense) was designed to reduce severity of illness not to prevent catching or transmission. Therefore vaccinating teens is not going to prevent them catching it, passing it, or protecting anyone who is vulnerable and it is naive of anyone who thinks that their vaccinated teen is now ‘safe’ to be around their medically vulnerable grandparent.

And based on statistics which even jvci stated for most teens it’s not necessary. Politics is pushing it, not scientific evidence

Mine won’t be having it, for reasons as above and simply because I want to see long term effects first. Maybe in a few years I’ll feel different

Link to the statistics please? Because most of us have seen the JCVI statement about benefits outweighing risks, but oddly, not the opposite.
LarkspurLane · 06/10/2021 11:03

@Incognito22333

I was on the fence regarding my 13 year old. However, having spoken to a number of friends who are GPs and whose children 12-15 will not be having the vaccine, we are not getting it either now. That tells me enough.
What were their reasons for not getting them done? Did they have different reasons or was it one main one?

I have a few medical friends (mainly nursing staff) who jumped at getting their kids vaccinated, but I don't personally know any GPs.

Geamhradh · 06/10/2021 11:01

@Sprayedwithdettol

The OP has since clarified she has a science background. Which makes her confusion over the vaccine all the more astonishing.
As does the fact she neglected to mention her scientific credentials in her OP.

One might almost sense a faint whiff of Eau de Agenda.

HoppingPavlova · 06/10/2021 11:00

Mine are young adults and so far only one has been vaxed as their risk profile is different due to medical issues. It doesn’t stack up for the others and yes, they have caught Covid and only knew it because of testing positive, no symptoms whereas DH and I were sick as dogs (pre vax availability). My kids have always been fully vaxed, believe in vax but at this point it’s at starting to take the piss a little for young healthy people to keep making sacrifice after sacrifice for those in care homes or vulnerable, there has to be a limit at some point. Their vulnerable sibling has been double jabbed and we are all happy and comfortable with that living under the same roof.

Belladonna12 · 06/10/2021 10:59

@HoppingPavlova

I don’t understand how people feel they can do more research and know more than the medical professionals who recommend vaccination.

Well, you’ve had JCVI tell you the benefit/risk doesn’t stack up for the average individual in this age population.

The JCV1 said that the known benefits marginally outweighed the potential known risks actually and that was without weighing up effects on educations etc.
luckylavender · 06/10/2021 10:58

I'll make no comment on the decision. But why when there's a Coronavirus board and boards dedicated to children, would you chose to put it on AIBU where you're asking for a bun fight?

HoppingPavlova · 06/10/2021 10:55

I don’t understand how people feel they can do more research and know more than the medical professionals who recommend vaccination.

Well, you’ve had JCVI tell you the benefit/risk doesn’t stack up for the average individual in this age population.

a8mint · 06/10/2021 10:54

I am in my early 50s and in good health and double AZ vaccinated. I am just starting to recover from 2 weeks of 'mild' covid which was extremely unpleasant and extremely disruptive. I am so glad i eas double vaccinated and the symptoms no worse. I would definitely get my iwn dc vaccinated. We need to stop this horrible disease. My youngest daughter is 16 and has lots of friends with long covid.

edwinbear · 06/10/2021 10:54

YANBU OP. DS turned 12 end of August so only just 12 as well. DH and I are double jabbed, DS will have HPV and flu vaccines, DD (9) will have flu. Both have had all childhood immunisations.

I've just declined consent for DS to have the Covid vaccine because of the increased risk of myocarditis in boys - I would make a different decision for DD if she was old enough to have it. DS is an elite athlete in a CV intensive sport, his training/competitive schedule is between 15-20 hours a week and I'm not prepared to take any risks with his heart. He's had 3 periods of self isolation due to close contact so far, there are a number of his close school friends who have tested positive over the last few weeks. None of his peers have had any symptoms other than a slight sore throat and runny nose, and given he plays a full contact sport with many of them, I suspect he's probably already had it and been asymptomatic (despite regularly testing negative with LFT's which clearly aren't terribly accurate).

For him, personally, the risks outweigh the benefits. I don't think it's black and white with children and it's a situation where families need to be allowed and respected to take a decision in their DC's best interests.

lentilsandeggs · 06/10/2021 10:52

OP - Is AIBU a trusted source of medical advice?
In this forum if your partner pours the tea first before the milk you’ll be told to LTB and if your child acts up you’ll be advised they must get tested straight away for ADHD, autism, Aspergers …

Belladonna12 · 06/10/2021 10:52

@millymolls

It’s not selfish

I hate this narrative about protecting others

Of course there is varying Information but scientific data published ( not just media reports) show that a vaccinated person and unvaccinated person chance of catching and passing are astonishingly similar. There is very little difference.

This vaccine ( which is not a vaccine in its traditional sense) was designed to reduce severity of illness not to prevent catching or transmission. Therefore vaccinating teens is not going to prevent them catching it, passing it, or protecting anyone who is vulnerable and it is naive of anyone who thinks that their vaccinated teen is now ‘safe’ to be around their medically vulnerable grandparent.

And based on statistics which even jvci stated for most teens it’s not necessary. Politics is pushing it, not scientific evidence

Mine won’t be having it, for reasons as above and simply because I want to see long term effects first. Maybe in a few years I’ll feel different

Someone always pops up on these threads to say that the vaccine is not "designed" to prevent transmission. Why do you think they deliberately designed it to only prevent severe effects? Do you not think that they aimed to prevent transmission too?

While not completely successful there certainly a reduction in transmission among vaccinated people. That's why people who live with someone who is immunsuppressed are a priority for vaccination.

You do realise that while you are waiting to find out about the long term effects of vaccination your child will probably catch covid and even if their symptoms are mild at the time we don't know if there will be any adverse effects in the future? Why worry about vaccine long term effects but not covid itself?

Ugzbugz · 06/10/2021 10:52

@toomuchlaundry

You know there is a risk with myocarditis with COVID too
Exactly, a 15 year old girl passed away with it the other week.

Its everyone's own decision, but I wouldn't even know how to research a vaccine. I don't understand the ingredients. What do you believe and don't believe.

The say any side effects would be immediate not long term, it doesn't give you life long immunity?

Tittyfilarious81 · 06/10/2021 10:51

@Florence282 I had a feeling your thread may go this way ,the vaccine has caused huge division everywhere . On here you were selfish if you weren't vaccinated now you are selfish if your kids aren't getting vaccinated . I honestly haven't met anyone in real life who thinks like this ,some of my friends are getting their teens vaccinated and some aren't we have talked about why /why not but it's then just seen as fair enough it's your choice .

Pigeonpocket · 06/10/2021 10:51

I'm unsure, but my dd is only 2 and it hasn't been approved yet for her age range. I'm sure it will be though.

I was fine with her having the relatively new meningitis B vaccine, but meningitis is scarier for young children than covid is.

I'm pro vaccination but I don't really see the benefit (vs risk) of the covid vaccine for children right now unless they're medically vulnerable in some way.

daisyjgrey · 06/10/2021 10:49

You will always have the option. Just because you're not comfortable with it now doesn't mean you will still be in a year/two years time etc. you can at any point say "actually, I feel differently about this now" and then you can go and book them in.

My daughter is 11 so it's unlikely it will be offered before this time next year, by which time an enormous amount of data will be available that will help me make the decision.

I would say that even as a non medical PhD researcher, I don't think I have the adequate knowledge base to thoroughly research a vaccine well enough to categorically say I am 100% happy with a decision either way, and the "do your own research" and interpretation of medical data is extremely nuanced and takes skill to decipher and reach a conclusion on.

2Two · 06/10/2021 10:45

@Florence282

SprayedWithDettol I do have a degree in Biology and I work as an Advanced therapy medicinal product pharmaceutical technician.
And yet you were unaware of the research on the greater risks of Covid for children in terms of myocarditis?
Upsielazy · 06/10/2021 10:42

Well he doesn't want it at the moment either, the important thing is that you're all on the same page, which it sounds like you are. I'm sure there will be vaccines available in the years to come if he does change his mind.

Heidi1976 · 06/10/2021 10:40

My partners eldest son is 16 and has had his first as he wanted to have it. His body, his choice. However, our daughter who is 4 wouldn't have it if the pool opened up that low. I vaccinate my child against everything that is the norm and things I would consider threatening to them. Measles, Mumps, Rubella, Polio, all the usual childhood illnesses. I haven't chosen to vaccinate against chickenpox as catching naturally gives greater longevity to the immunity compared to the vaccine (as far as research I have read shows - correct me if I'm wrong though!)

However, if she reached older years without naturally acquiring the virus I would vaccinate to prevent more severe disease (as is the case the older they get catching chickenpox).

So my point is around risk - the risk of Covid to a 4 year old with no underlying health conditions, to me just isn't worth doing the vaccination. Plus she most likely already has natural immunity as I caught it earlier in the year and she had similar symptoms to me but we didn't test her.