Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not get DS vaccinated

311 replies

Florence282 · 06/10/2021 08:42

I think this probably not allowed but I'm very interested to see what the general population thinks about vaccinating our DC. DS is 12 and after a tonne of research we've decided not to vaccinate. Other mums in the school are struggling to make a decision.

Yanbu=no to the vaccine
Yabu=yes to the vaccine

OP posts:
Theredjellybean · 06/10/2021 15:02

We've had few "I don't like needles", "I feel sick I don't want it"
They get a nice sit down and a chat.. Is it fear of needles, fear of vaccine...?
Do they understand the consequences of both going ahead or not...
What can we do to make it easier? If it's just needle fear...?

Comedycook · 06/10/2021 15:01

@Theredjellybean

Same response, discussed with all parties but definitely not giving it if child says no. That would amount in law to assault
Thanks!
Penfield · 06/10/2021 15:01

Sorry I missed your answer.

Penfield · 06/10/2021 15:00

Can I ask what you do if a parent consents to the vaccine and the child doesn't want it?

What would you do @Theredjellybean?

Theredjellybean · 06/10/2021 15:00

Same response, discussed with all parties but definitely not giving it if child says no.
That would amount in law to assault

MarshaBradyo · 06/10/2021 15:00

@Wroxie

I am "respectfully" telling you that you are, indeed, selfish. You think that the (basically nonexistent) risk to YOUR precious child is more important than the real risk to the people he could infect - for whom Covid is actually deadly, not just a bit of a cold. How can that be defined as anything other than selfish? Just because you have the "right" to do something and it's the thing you want to do, doesn't mean it's the right thing, or that it's not selfish. You don't get to be antisocial and then expect to be praised for it.
Of course the op’s dc are important to her as most dc are to parents.

But also the JCVI decided with a child centred approach, which is good. It’s not just parents who think the benefit needs to be for the vaccinated group.

Comedycook · 06/10/2021 14:59

@Theredjellybean

I'm. Not a teacher.. I'm a GP, and clinical lead for the vaccination programme. Its my job to try and encourage a dialogue between parents who won't give consent and young people who want the vaccine and who I deem gilick competent. Legally I can give it without the bother of trying to discuss it further with the parents or legal guardians but it is much better to try to find common ground and involve them. Perhaps read what I wrote first... And frankly I'm stunned by the way parents on here continue to persist in the belief that they and only they have "rights" over medical decisions relating to their children. Children are not your possessions, they are seen as independent entities
Can I ask what you do if a parent consents to the vaccine and the child doesn't want it?
Theredjellybean · 06/10/2021 14:58

And this is what Victoria gilick discovered when she challenged the doctor who gave her daughter contraception.
I'm polite and sensitive to parents views to try to have some kind of discussion with them and get them on board, but bottom line is they are not my patients the young person is.

roarfeckingroarr · 06/10/2021 14:57

Hell no to kids and I've been double jabbed

Theredjellybean · 06/10/2021 14:55

I'm. Not a teacher.. I'm a GP, and clinical lead for the vaccination programme.
Its my job to try and encourage a dialogue between parents who won't give consent and young people who want the vaccine and who I deem gilick competent.
Legally I can give it without the bother of trying to discuss it further with the parents or legal guardians but it is much better to try to find common ground and involve them.
Perhaps read what I wrote first... And frankly I'm stunned by the way parents on here continue to persist in the belief that they and only they have "rights" over medical decisions relating to their children.
Children are not your possessions, they are seen as independent entities

Wroxie · 06/10/2021 14:54

I am "respectfully" telling you that you are, indeed, selfish. You think that the (basically nonexistent) risk to YOUR precious child is more important than the real risk to the people he could infect - for whom Covid is actually deadly, not just a bit of a cold.
How can that be defined as anything other than selfish? Just because you have the "right" to do something and it's the thing you want to do, doesn't mean it's the right thing, or that it's not selfish. You don't get to be antisocial and then expect to be praised for it.

Penfield · 06/10/2021 14:50

We have contacted their parents with their permission and have had a conversation, tried to understand the parents reluctance and supported the young person to make a decision.
Three out of five went ahead with the vaccine.

Wow - I'm glad my kids are not at your school @Theredjellybean

If any teacher/school called me trying to do the same I'd give them a piece of my mind to be sure.

It's none of your business whether any of your school kids are vaccinated.

Am I right that you challenged their parent's consent? Did I read that correctly?

Maray1967 · 06/10/2021 14:49

An unvaccinated 13 year old passed it to my unvaccinated 13 year old - that’s the most likely source. Not their fault - not had the chance to be vaccinated.
I am surprised by all this talk of risk as though it only lies with taking the vaccine.
The biggest risk by far lies in not being vaccinated- as it always has - for the vast majority of people.
I am absolutely furious that my child has not had the chance to be vaccinated.

Penfield · 06/10/2021 14:47

I think schools are writing their own individually crafted letters - they will all be different.

I think this because ours was so so considerate. The parent's consent part was bolded. They had a separate stand alone part saying that we did not HAVE to have our children vaccinated. It felt to me that the Headteacher was not happy about being forced into doing this.

MarshaBradyo · 06/10/2021 14:46

@GnomeyGnome

Does anyone have the stats on how much one dose of the vaccine will lower the chances of catching or transmitting Covid? I caught Covid after 2 jabs and then passed it on to my (double jabbed) husband and DD. Just trying to understand how much of an impact it will really have on education if vaccinated children are still passing it on. I think if it's quite a big drop in transmission rates then that would definitely sway me a little more. DS is currently reading the info school have sent and researching a bit for himself and ultimately we will let him decide but it's good to have as much info as possible.
Only what I know from friends etc but Ds has one dose and has tested positive for Covid. Many of his friends too.

That’s not to say I’d change approach as he had no side effects from Pfizer and now has mild flu type symptoms. Think his friends similar

Impossible to know the outcome without that dose - the same or feeling worse

Theredjellybean · 06/10/2021 14:45

@Comedycook.. Yes, if I believe they are gilick competent.

Comedycook · 06/10/2021 14:45

*answering

Comedycook · 06/10/2021 14:44

@Theredjellybean

Legally schools cannot decide they are not considering gillick competency and not vaccinating without parental consent. Gilick competency is established in law. And yes I have had five teens so far ask for it. We have contacted their parents with their permission and have had a conversation, tried to understand the parents reluctance and supported the young person to make a decision. Three out of five went ahead with the vaccine. It really is down to the clinical lead in each vaccination programme, where I work, we have a clinical lead at every vaccination session, wherever it is taking place. This is always a GP
Thanks for answer
HoppingPavlova · 06/10/2021 14:44

If you don't believe in the vaccine, you don't believe in modern medicine. You shouldn't pick and choose at your own convenience.

This is so silly. You do realise that not all clinician groups completely agree with all treatments or paradigms in ‘modern medicine’, and that it varies not only amongst groups but institutions, areas and countries. Even looking at vaccines in general (not Covid specific), not all countries have all vaccines approved, there is even differing opinions among Regulators who approve these as to what they believe in regards to efficacy/safety and risk/benefit. You seem either oddly black and white in beliefs or staggeringly naive and believe the medical scientific community is some kind of Borg.

Theredjellybean · 06/10/2021 14:43

Legally schools cannot decide they are not considering gillick competency and not vaccinating without parental consent.
Gilick competency is established in law.
And yes I have had five teens so far ask for it.
We have contacted their parents with their permission and have had a conversation, tried to understand the parents reluctance and supported the young person to make a decision.
Three out of five went ahead with the vaccine.
It really is down to the clinical lead in each vaccination programme, where I work, we have a clinical lead at every vaccination session, wherever it is taking place.
This is always a GP

Belladonna12 · 06/10/2021 14:35

@GnomeyGnome

Does anyone have the stats on how much one dose of the vaccine will lower the chances of catching or transmitting Covid? I caught Covid after 2 jabs and then passed it on to my (double jabbed) husband and DD. Just trying to understand how much of an impact it will really have on education if vaccinated children are still passing it on. I think if it's quite a big drop in transmission rates then that would definitely sway me a little more. DS is currently reading the info school have sent and researching a bit for himself and ultimately we will let him decide but it's good to have as much info as possible.
There is a big difference in number of cases between sixth form and the rest of the school years in my dc school.
Comedycook · 06/10/2021 14:34

@Theredjellybean. So if these teens don't have parental consent and ask for the vaccine, do you give it to them?

mcmooberry · 06/10/2021 14:33

@geamhradh eh?? Why on earth would it be on the news?? Neither she nor the hospital would contact the papers, it's known complication, not that newsworthy.

Hope you are not implying I have made this up!

trumpisagit · 06/10/2021 14:31

I believe one does reduces chance of catching by 55%. I don't know much about transmission.

GnomeyGnome · 06/10/2021 14:22

Does anyone have the stats on how much one dose of the vaccine will lower the chances of catching or transmitting Covid? I caught Covid after 2 jabs and then passed it on to my (double jabbed) husband and DD. Just trying to understand how much of an impact it will really have on education if vaccinated children are still passing it on. I think if it's quite a big drop in transmission rates then that would definitely sway me a little more. DS is currently reading the info school have sent and researching a bit for himself and ultimately we will let him decide but it's good to have as much info as possible.

Swipe left for the next trending thread