Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not get DS vaccinated

311 replies

Florence282 · 06/10/2021 08:42

I think this probably not allowed but I'm very interested to see what the general population thinks about vaccinating our DC. DS is 12 and after a tonne of research we've decided not to vaccinate. Other mums in the school are struggling to make a decision.

Yanbu=no to the vaccine
Yabu=yes to the vaccine

OP posts:
Awalkintime · 06/10/2021 18:48

Given the impact I have seen covid have on children I would say the vaccine is worth it.

trumpisagit · 06/10/2021 18:42

@Belladonna12
Yes possibly most school children who haven't had covid will do so this winter.

There is still a lot of unknowns, plus the fact that many children will be asymptomatic.

I am not worried about my children catching covid.

I don't think the balance of risk tips in favour of the vaccine for 12-16 year olds.

I also think it's a private medical decision and no one should be pressuring parents to take up the offer.

I believe Chris Whitty said similar.

Waxonwaxoff0 · 06/10/2021 18:42

@Belladonna12 they'll probably catch Covid even if they get vaccinated. I caught Covid after I was vaccinated.

MarshaBradyo · 06/10/2021 18:38

It is as simple as either (or perhaps both) now. You are deluded if you think that they won't catch covid if they are not vaccinated and haven't already had it. It is ripping through schools at the moment. There are no strategies to prevent transmision in schools. They don't even have to isolate if everyone else in their family has it.

This is why I think people are overstating the it’s unfair that the unvaccinated will be spared disruption due to others vaccinating. It’s likely they will isolate (if it’s not asymptomatic) at some point. Still likely they will anyway if vaccinated and get symptoms. And haven’t had it yet.

It’s still an individual decision for each person

whymewhyme · 06/10/2021 18:36

ComedyCook.....bore off!

whymewhyme · 06/10/2021 18:35

@tttigress

Your child is unlikely to get seriously ill from Covid, so I think you have made the correct decision.
Absolutely 💯
whymewhyme · 06/10/2021 18:32

You are not being unreasonable.

Florence282 · 06/10/2021 18:32

AmaryllisNightAndDay there's nearly 300 replies on this thread. I haven't 'ignored' your comment I simply haven't got time to reply to them all. Don't make assumptions.

OP posts:
Belladonna12 · 06/10/2021 18:32

[quote trumpisagit]@Belladonna12 but it's not a simple choice (as you are implying) between having the vaccine and having covid.

My children could be vaccinated at school on a specific date in November. There are very small risks involved (slightly bigger for boys). They can still catch covid ( approx 50% less likely than if they were unvaccinated).

If not vaccinated they could catch covid at some unspecified date in the future, or might not.
They are likely to already have had covid, although have never tested positive (many of their friends and children they sit next to at school have) . Possibly they have gained some natural immunity.

They may get covid at all.

It is not a simple either/or. [/quote]
It is as simple as either (or perhaps both) now. You are deluded if you think that they won't catch covid if they are not vaccinated and haven't already had it. It is ripping through schools at the moment. There are no strategies to prevent transmision in schools. They don't even have to isolate if everyone else in their family has it.

Witchcraftandhokum · 06/10/2021 18:31

A quick scan of the forms I took in from my students last week showed about a 2/3 take up. I quietly judged the parents who had not consented, but we have a specialist provision attached to school which has a number of immuno-supressed students and at least one member of staff who has a serious illness and is very vulnerable.

Belladonna12 · 06/10/2021 18:24

@Comedycook

The vaccine doesn't work very well on the immunsuppressed though. That's 500,000 people you think should stay indoors including some children

And there's always been viruses and contagious illnesses which are considered a threat to those people.

Not all threats are equal. The threat from covid is much higher to immunosuppressed people than anything else I can think of at the moment in the UK given how prevalent, contagious and deadly it can be. Why do you think immunusuppressed people have had to shield for the last 18 months?!
MarshaBradyo · 06/10/2021 18:22

On the disruption issue

‘The CMOs said it was not possible to quantify with confidence to what extent vaccination would reduce school disruption.

But as part of the review they did release some modelling which, based on assumptions on uptake of the jab and spread of the virus, suggested 30,000 infections could be prevented in England between October and March.‘

Not sure how many will still be infected based on this and roughly half having had it. But I doubt vaccinated dc will do much to stop unvaccinated getting it. It’s too transmissible. Plus Ds vaccinated still had 10 days disruption as did his friends so not sure how much better that will be.

Mostly though the above means it’s still an individual decision, not to be guilt tripped or pressured. I’m pretty sure Chris Whitty said same - up to each person to decide.

The idea that anyone should be pressured isn’t right imo (and Ds had vaccine - for him though not adults)

trumpisagit · 06/10/2021 18:16

@Belladonna12 but it's not a simple choice (as you are implying) between having the vaccine and having covid.

My children could be vaccinated at school on a specific date in November. There are very small risks involved (slightly bigger for boys). They can still catch covid ( approx 50% less likely than if they were unvaccinated).

If not vaccinated they could catch covid at some unspecified date in the future, or might not.
They are likely to already have had covid, although have never tested positive (many of their friends and children they sit next to at school have) . Possibly they have gained some natural immunity.

They may get covid at all.

It is not a simple either/or.

helpthewhos · 06/10/2021 18:10

But it's up to the child isn't it? They can over rule the parent's decision if they demonstrate they understand the choice they are making. I would have thought most 12 year olds uand older could do that.

Comedycook · 06/10/2021 18:02

The vaccine doesn't work very well on the immunsuppressed though. That's 500,000 people you think should stay indoors including some children

And there's always been viruses and contagious illnesses which are considered a threat to those people.

AmaryllisNightAndDay · 06/10/2021 17:31

It can not be applied to a parent doing what they feel is best for their child.

If a parent is doing what's best for their child at the expense of other people's children who are at the same risk as their own, then it is selfish in a particularly unpleasant way.

have not ignored any of the facts at all.

I have pointed out more than once that there are some reasons for getting your child vaccinated which benefit your own child (as well as everyone else's) The risk to your child's health has to be balanced against the benefit to your child's education. That's a benefit which the JCVI very clearly say that they did not take into account. That's a fact, and so far you do seem to have ignored it.

It is, however, a good and moral thing to do which would help save others' lives and so I signed the permission slip.

Depends whether you are relying on other people to do the scary thing so as to keep you (or your children) safe. We all share the risk of giving blood to share the benefit. Same with vaccination - it's fine to dither around until you have more information about vaccine safety but not if you're relying on other people's children being vaccinated to keep your child in class.

Magicalwoodlands · 06/10/2021 17:28

To be honest, I don’t feel vaccinations or any medical procedure should be presented as a moral issue. It isn’t.

Vaccinations should happen to benefit the person being vaccinated. It is wrong to try to coerce or guilt trip people into having an invasive procedure to benefit others.

Belladonna12 · 06/10/2021 17:28

@Comedycook

Fuck that, quite frankly. It's not my child's responsibility to make adults feel safer

Exactly. All adults have now had the chance to be double jabbed. If you are still worried, I'm afraid the onus is now on you to stay at home.

The vaccine doesn't work very well on the immunsuppressed though. That's 500,000 people you think should stay indoors including some children.
Belladonna12 · 06/10/2021 17:26

@tttigress

Your child is unlikely to get seriously ill from Covid, so I think you have made the correct decision.
They are unlikely to get seriously ill from the vaccine too.
tttigress · 06/10/2021 17:06

Your child is unlikely to get seriously ill from Covid, so I think you have made the correct decision.

Comedycook · 06/10/2021 17:03

Fuck that, quite frankly. It's not my child's responsibility to make adults feel safer

Exactly. All adults have now had the chance to be double jabbed. If you are still worried, I'm afraid the onus is now on you to stay at home.

Waxonwaxoff0 · 06/10/2021 16:58

[quote Wroxie]@trumpisagit what really is the risk to the child though? It's a tiny risk, much much smaller for a healthy than even the risk to that same child if they got covid while unvaccinated! So it's not just a selfish decision, but a stupid one. So, yes, while I don't think that ANYONE should be forced to take any medical treatment that they don't want, I do think that in this case, the risk posed to society by unvaccinated children is greater than the risk of vaccinating those children- by a LOT- and that a bit of social pressure and clarity for parents to make the sensible and moral choice here should indeed be the policy.[/quote]
Fuck that, quite frankly. It's not my child's responsibility to make adults feel safer.

Wroxie · 06/10/2021 16:09

@TableFlowerss when my daughter was 16, we moved back to the states for a year. Her school had a blood drive and since she was under 18 it required me to sign a permission slip. There was a very small risk to her from this procedure - as outlined in the permission slip - probably similar to the risk of a covid jab. Maybe greater. I don't know exactly but it's definitely not risk free. It is, however, a good and moral thing to do which would help save others' lives and so I signed the permission slip. Would you not? Do you think that because someone is under 18 that the most infinitesimal chance of the possibility of risk to them is more important than real and measurable risk to others? I don't. And I think that teaching your children to make the right choice in these situations through your encouragement, is going to serve them far better in life than teaching them that it's OK if other people die as long as you are comfortable and don't have to feel anxious. Because that's all this is - to be very, very clear, the children in question are FAR more likely to die from actual covid, caught while unvaccinated, than they are from the vaccine.

TableFlowerss · 06/10/2021 15:57

[quote Wroxie]@trumpisagit what really is the risk to the child though? It's a tiny risk, much much smaller for a healthy than even the risk to that same child if they got covid while unvaccinated! So it's not just a selfish decision, but a stupid one. So, yes, while I don't think that ANYONE should be forced to take any medical treatment that they don't want, I do think that in this case, the risk posed to society by unvaccinated children is greater than the risk of vaccinating those children- by a LOT- and that a bit of social pressure and clarity for parents to make the sensible and moral choice here should indeed be the policy.[/quote]
Another example of someone questioning the morality of parents for choosing not to vaccinate the kids at the moment, because they think they should be vaccinated for the benefit of others…… ‘the risk posed to society by unvaccinated children is greater than the risk of vaccinating those children’

Trying to pressurise parents to make a decision for the benefit of other people, is morally wrong!

MarshaBradyo · 06/10/2021 15:55

[quote Wroxie]@trumpisagit what really is the risk to the child though? It's a tiny risk, much much smaller for a healthy than even the risk to that same child if they got covid while unvaccinated! So it's not just a selfish decision, but a stupid one. So, yes, while I don't think that ANYONE should be forced to take any medical treatment that they don't want, I do think that in this case, the risk posed to society by unvaccinated children is greater than the risk of vaccinating those children- by a LOT- and that a bit of social pressure and clarity for parents to make the sensible and moral choice here should indeed be the policy.[/quote]
I’m very glad we’re not following this approach for children.

But also I don’t think societal pressure works if it’s just others telling people they are selfish. Probably puts them off.

Swipe left for the next trending thread