Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have a 10 month old baby in a nursery 5 days a week?

281 replies

Toomuchworkon · 06/10/2021 06:58

Just been reading another thread where it’s generally agreed this is a lot / potentially too much and I’m all worried now.

Honestly, would you be judging me harshly?

OP posts:
pointythings · 06/10/2021 11:46

@MissChanandlerBong81

So cold and unfeeling. Why have the baby at all?

I’m really curious about what sort of person genuinely thinks this is an OK thing to say to another parent. And I really question whether someone who is spiteful enough to say is fit to parent another human being.

100x this. What a hateful thing to say - as is implying that women who don't work aren't proper mothers - or mothers at all.

The model of women staying at home to look after children is also a very recent development. Go back 100 years and you'll find a lot of 'cold and unfeeling' women - because hey, food and housing doesn't just fall out of the sky for free.

user1471523870 · 06/10/2021 11:44

My son went to nursery around that age and I went back to work full time, as his father. I don't get the 'too much' comment. It's not like they make him work when he's there Confused.
It worked well for us and still does. No attachment problems, in fact the three of us are a strong unit and me and him have a very special bond. There is no confusion on the roles and never felt I missed any milestones.
We picked a small nursery, very close to home, minimal staff rotation and we just felt so loved! He absolutely adores going in and his key person. Communication is great and I know he's in great hands having a good time.
The comments about reducing hours etc well, not every job is like that. I am in middle management for a huge company, quite complex role and looking after a big team. Life-work balance is great but I can't go part time, or drop a day.

pointythings · 06/10/2021 11:41

Of course you missed things. You were at work. It's great that you're happy with your choices but you can't pretend you didn't miss out on 40 hours per week with your child, every week if that is what you did indeed do.

Why pretend?

I'm talking about milestones. There are 168 hours in a week - I 'missed' 40 of those with my DDs. Excluding holidays, obviously. When they were at school, I used leave to attend school plays, nativities etc. - though by then schools were starting to accept the reality of working parents and accommodating that by arranging things after school hours.

So what did I miss? What did I not have that I otherwise would have had?

And when my marriage went tits up and my husband ended up dead, I was glad that I'd always worked because it meant I could provide everything my DDs needed alone.

MindyStClaire · 06/10/2021 11:40

I have similar Skinny. I respond "Well DH really loves his work so I could never ask him to give it up even though he earns less than me". Grin

SkinnyMirror · 06/10/2021 11:34

@WeepySheepy

No one even questions it when a dad goes back to work 5 days a week after paternity leave and "misses milestones"
When we had DS me and DH worked at the same place. When i returned to work I lost count of the number of people who told me how awful it was that I'd had to return to work full time. Not one person said that to DH ....they soon shut up when I pointed that out.
MissChanandlerBong81 · 06/10/2021 11:33

So cold and unfeeling. Why have the baby at all?

I’m really curious about what sort of person genuinely thinks this is an OK thing to say to another parent. And I really question whether someone who is spiteful enough to say is fit to parent another human being.

SirSamuelVimes · 06/10/2021 11:33

Dd1 was full time nursery from 10months, she had patches when she'd cry at drop off when she was about two years old but was always happy by the time I'd hit the car park (there was a window I could see her from as I walked past) and overall she loved it there. She left ready for school, a confident, happy little girl. Her best friend is someone she went all through nursery with. Very fond memories all round.

Dd2 I didn't go back to work until she was 2 and a half. She goes to nursery 2 days a week and is always grumpy about going, has to be physically handed over at the door because she won't walk in. Has taken a long time to adjust and is still getting used to it really. I have many more concerns about her than I did dd1. Don't think she's going to find the transition to school easy at all.

So from my experience I'd say full time nursery from early on works better!

SkinnyMirror · 06/10/2021 11:31

Of course you missed things. You were at work. It's great that you're happy with your choices but you can't pretend you didn't miss out on 40 hours per week with your child, every week if that is what you did indeed do.

Why pretend?

I've genuinely never felt like I've missed out and I've worked full time since DS was 10 months. I might not have seen him do everything for the first time but that doesn't mean I've missed out - these are not one off occasions! I'm just as proud and as excited for him even if I didn't witness it the first time it happened..
DS scored his first goal in a football match last week. I didn't see it as it was DH's turn to take him.... i heard all about it and will see him play this weekend.
Unless you are never going to let your child out of your sight then you are not going to see everything.

For us, we are just happy and proud to see our child thrive, develop and learn new things. If those thing happen out of my sight then they still happened and it's still a good thing!

MindyStClaire · 06/10/2021 11:27

@WeepySheepy

No one even questions it when a dad goes back to work 5 days a week after paternity leave and "misses milestones"
So cold and unfeeling. Why have the baby at all?
WeepySheepy · 06/10/2021 11:26

No one even questions it when a dad goes back to work 5 days a week after paternity leave and "misses milestones"

SkinnyMirror · 06/10/2021 11:23

And only ever directed at mothers, never fathers.

Yep! So predictable.

SkinnyMirror · 06/10/2021 11:22

It's like MN bingo!! but i'll bite........

would say - why think about having a child - to then hardly ever see him/her ?
How rude. You don't know the OPs working pattern.

You are letting someone else raise your child

Wrong.Not to mention insulting. Being able to provide financially for your family is part of being a parents. Choosing childcare options is still being a parent. Parents who use childcare are still raising their children. What is your opinion about men going out to work while the baby is only two weeks old? Are they not raising their children after that point?

will miss precious milestones
Completely wrong. If a child does something at nursery will they never do it out of that setting?

and regret long term
You're making assumptions now. I've never regretted using childcare.

I would much prefer to have a career break and be with my child, and be a mum
ooooh where to start with this one! Not all careers are suited to a career break, not all women want to take a career break, not all women can afford a career break.

Oh and just because a women works that doesn't mean she stops being a mum.

there are ways of earning money from home - set up an on-line business ? sell on ebay ?

hahahahahahahahahhahahah yeah because it that easy.

My sister put her son in nursery - is a teacher and even put him in out nursery when she was on school holidays - I can never understand why she did this - he is now 13 and there is no real emotional attachment between them.
So all your evidence is based on one example?

I stayed at home with my 2, worked small shifts when DH was at home - we did not have much money - but my children never did without - sorry I sound harsh

Good for you for making it work. Other families do things differently.
Yes you do sound harsh and rude.

MissChanandlerBong81 · 06/10/2021 11:22

I’m definitely going to give up my career that took 6 years to train and qualify into to ‘sell on eBay’.

SVRT19674 · 06/10/2021 11:19

Mine went to nursery from 5.5 months as statutory maternity leave plus holidays tagged on the end lasts that amount in my country. She is absolutely fine and 3.5 years old now. No, I would not judge anyone. Everyone has their circumstances to deal with. Good luck with whatever choice you make.

bluerecruit · 06/10/2021 11:18

@pointythings

I stayed at home with my 2, worked small shifts when DH was at home - we did not have much money - but my children never did without - sorry I sound harsh

You sound naive. You were lucky that your DH earned enough that you could afford to stay home. Lucky. It really is that simple.

I missed nothing. My DDs took their first steps at home, with us. They said their first words out, with us. Their attachment to us as parents were full, normal and healthy. You seem to think the attachment issues between your sister and her DS was 100% due to him going to nursery. What evidence do you have that this is so? Correlation does not equal causation.

Of course you missed things. You were at work. It's great that you're happy with your choices but you can't pretend you didn't miss out on 40 hours per week with your child, every week if that is what you did indeed do.

Why pretend?

pointythings · 06/10/2021 11:15

I stayed at home with my 2, worked small shifts when DH was at home - we did not have much money - but my children never did without - sorry I sound harsh

You sound naive. You were lucky that your DH earned enough that you could afford to stay home. Lucky. It really is that simple.

I missed nothing. My DDs took their first steps at home, with us. They said their first words out, with us. Their attachment to us as parents were full, normal and healthy. You seem to think the attachment issues between your sister and her DS was 100% due to him going to nursery. What evidence do you have that this is so? Correlation does not equal causation.

MathsyUsernameGoesHere · 06/10/2021 11:15

@DinkyDaffodil

I would say - why think about having a child - to then hardly ever see him/her ? You are letting someone else raise your child, will miss precious milestones, and regret long term. I would much prefer to have a career break and be with my child, and be a mum - there are ways of earning money from home - set up an on-line business ? sell on ebay ? My sister put her son in nursery - is a teacher and even put him in out nursery when she was on school holidays - I can never understand why she did this - he is now 13 and there is no real emotional attachment between them. I stayed at home with my 2, worked small shifts when DH was at home - we did not have much money - but my children never did without - sorry I sound harsh
Yup, almost so perfect it could have been generated by a bot. Grin

And only ever directed at mothers, never fathers.

MissChanandlerBong81 · 06/10/2021 11:14

Oh with working patterns another consideration is whether you plan to have another baby in the near future. I did and I wanted full time mat pay for it. I think if you are hoping to have another in the relatively near future there’s a lot of sense in staying FT.

MissChanandlerBong81 · 06/10/2021 11:11

I would say - why think about having a child - to then hardly ever see him/her ? You are letting someone else raise your child, will miss precious milestones, and regret long term. I would much prefer to have a career break and be with my child, and be a mum - there are ways of earning money from home - set up an on-line business ? sell on ebay ?

Lol. All the cliches in one paragraph 🤣

MissChanandlerBong81 · 06/10/2021 11:10

Went back to work full time at 12 months (very much aware that in many other countries women don’t get 12 months off, and they didn’t in this country until about 2006 I don’t think).

Never once felt guilty or odd about it until I read the kind of MN threads you’re referring to where people call it ‘sad’ and say you should only do it ‘if you have no other option’ and ask questions like ‘why did you bother having children?’ (I honestly don’t understand why anyone would think it was ok to say that, but there you go). So I stopped reading them and focussed on my life and the many full time working parents around me with thriving children and felt much better.

I also don’t really know what people mean by having ‘no other choice’ - I don’t have to work full time to keep a roof over our heads and food on the table, but I wanted more for our quality of life than that. I like my job, I like savings and financial security, I like being able to take my children on holidays and days out, I like being able to pay for them to do hobbies, etc.

DinkyDaffodil · 06/10/2021 11:07

I would say - why think about having a child - to then hardly ever see him/her ? You are letting someone else raise your child, will miss precious milestones, and regret long term. I would much prefer to have a career break and be with my child, and be a mum - there are ways of earning money from home - set up an on-line business ? sell on ebay ?
My sister put her son in nursery - is a teacher and even put him in out nursery when she was on school holidays - I can never understand why she did this - he is now 13 and there is no real emotional attachment between them. I stayed at home with my 2, worked small shifts when DH was at home - we did not have much money - but my children never did without - sorry I sound harsh

SkinnyMirror · 06/10/2021 11:03

@MindyStClaire

Those who judge are those who are lucky enough not to have to use full time childcare.

I know this is said to help OP (and by a few, I'm not picking on you Dont, it's just the most recent).

I don't consider myself in any way unlucky to use childcare, and nor do I have to do so. This framing just induces the guilt that so many working mothers feel (and so many working fathers don't!).

I choose to work, as does DH, and so our children are in childcare. There are lots of positives and negatives to that, but it works well for all four of us and doesn't need to be couched in terms of fortune, guilt, obligation.

I agree.

I considered us lucky to have such wonderful childcare as an option.

I also choose to go back to work and to work full time and saw DS attending such a wonderful nursery as a positive thing for him.

SkinnyMirror · 06/10/2021 11:00

Don't worry OP. In my experience, the only place you'll get judgemental comments is here!!

I choose to go back to work f/t when DS was 10 months. He absolutely thrived at nursery. He's 7 now and still talks about his 'first school'.

The quality of the childcare provision is key but I'm sure you've got that in hand.

MindyStClaire · 06/10/2021 10:58

Those who judge are those who are lucky enough not to have to use full time childcare.

I know this is said to help OP (and by a few, I'm not picking on you Dont, it's just the most recent).

I don't consider myself in any way unlucky to use childcare, and nor do I have to do so. This framing just induces the guilt that so many working mothers feel (and so many working fathers don't!).

I choose to work, as does DH, and so our children are in childcare. There are lots of positives and negatives to that, but it works well for all four of us and doesn't need to be couched in terms of fortune, guilt, obligation.

SkinnyMirror · 06/10/2021 10:58

@Spyro1234

I personally find it really sad.
Why?