Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have a 10 month old baby in a nursery 5 days a week?

281 replies

Toomuchworkon · 06/10/2021 06:58

Just been reading another thread where it’s generally agreed this is a lot / potentially too much and I’m all worried now.

Honestly, would you be judging me harshly?

OP posts:
MelKarnofskyCrane · 06/10/2021 21:41

I went back to work 4 days per week when mine were each 10 months. I’m a big fan of the nursery. Our nursery is lovely. The staff turnover is low, and the children (and us parents) have built fantastic relationships with “the ladies” over the years. My eldest sometimes comes with me to collect my youngest from nursery and she’s excited to go. They’re always so happy to see her, ask her how she’s getting on at school etc. It’s lovely.

Could we have cut back so that I could have stayed at home with them while my husband worked? Probably. But I wanted more than that. For me and for them. I worked hard for my career. I want them to have a nice house. Good holidays. I wanted to be able to afford for them to go to clubs. Swimming lessons. Birthday parties. I want to be able to put money away for them. I wanted them to see a woman working in a successful career, earning her own money and having a successful part of life that is just hers. More importantly, I wanted a safety net for them and for me, in case my marriage failed or whatever.

This was the right call for us and I have no regrets. I don’t feel like I have missed out. I have a day off in the week with my youngest now (plus weekends) and we have a lovely day together. She’s loved by so many people. She has genuine little friends at nursery who will go to school with her. She’s confident and happy and more independent than I ever was at that age (according to my mum).

On the shared leave point - absolutely no way was I surrendering any of my maternity leave to my husband Grin

Talkwhilstyouwalk · 06/10/2021 21:07

I would do it if I had to and wouldn't judge anyone for doing it. Nurseries are great for babies/toddlers etc in that they learn, and socialise with other children.

Would this be my first choice given the option to work part time or not at all? No because they are only little once and I want to be the one who gets to see all their firsts first!

Wrenna · 06/10/2021 20:48

You are fine! Some babies are in nursery at 6 weeks (fine also!)

PufferFishGoneWrong · 06/10/2021 20:43

Both my children were in nursery full time from 12m and then straight to school when the time came.

You do what you have to do.

Missmissmiiiiiiiiisss · 06/10/2021 20:05

@SkinnyMirror

I'm a university academic in an education faculty at a university. While early childhood education isn't my specialist subject I do teach and moderate work on modules attached to our childhood studies degree programmes. This means I'm quite familiar with the research.

It's not as black and white as people suggest. The key bits of information to take away are:

  • quality of childcare is key. Most quality research will acknowledge this.
  • poverty is the biggest indicator of ongoing issues and disadvantage as it usually means there are other things going in at home.
  • poor families tend to be using poorer childcare which exacerbates the issue

Interestingly, all the academics that teach on our early years and childhood studies degrees have used childcare themselves. I think that speaks volumes!

Of course it’s all about quality but the vast majority of even expensive childcare in the UK is poor quality. We don’t have a high wage, high skills early years workforce in the UK because the government isn’t willing to pay for it. We have mostly very young women who didn’t do that well in school being shepherded towards childcare courses. Don’t hear me wrong, it absolutely is a skilled job but we don’t train or pay people as if it is. So if you do find highly skilled staff with a very good understanding of child development and the broad academic knowledge to answer children’s questions well and the stable, warm personality to model empathy etc… then snap them up!

We all know they are the exception though, not the rule.

HarrisMcCoo · 06/10/2021 20:00

I appreciate others have to do it, or choose to use childcare. I value time over money and after DC1 I returned to my career but two months in jacked it in. It was a nightmare working round DH's shift pattern, and negotiating shifts that I needed for childcare purposes. Impossible with night shifts in the mix. We both decided that long term if we were having another child that staying at home was the best option. I found I was dumping 6mo DC off at grandparents house whilst doing my shift then had long commute home afterwards with a sleepy child.

We don't fall into the 'norm' as majority on this thread will work 9 til 5, a straightforward type of lifestyle Monday to Friday - all predictable, very easy. Nurseries aren't open overnight if you're both back shift/night shift at the weekend🤷

I have 4DC now and don't regret staying at home with them. My career just wasn't compatible with family life. Fortunately we don't need two incomes (for now 14 years in).

Do as you need to do OP. Bit harsh those judging though, if you have to work to keep a roof over your head. Needs must.

RedMarauder · 06/10/2021 19:46

@Missmissmiiiiiiiiisss if the OP is sending her baby to a nursery with a low turnover of staff the baby will bond with it's key worker and will be fine.

I send mine to a CM partly because the nearest nursery to me, which is literally on my doorstep, has a high staff turnover.

Also I have friends and acquaintances in countries where they give women that long off. Those women who are clever actually find looking after babies and young toddlers full-time boring, and have found there is no formal childcare for children under 2 so you have to use relations. Only one could do that due to living near both sides relations.

Calamityhuman · 06/10/2021 19:27

I would not judge anyone in the slightest for using full time nursery as childcare.

However since you have asked for opinions I personally wouldn’t choose it and it wouldn’t have been right for me or my children.

SkinnyMirror · 06/10/2021 18:23

I'm a university academic in an education faculty at a university. While early childhood education isn't my specialist subject I do teach and moderate work on modules attached to our childhood studies degree programmes. This means I'm quite familiar with the research.

It's not as black and white as people suggest. The key bits of information to take away are:

  • quality of childcare is key. Most quality research will acknowledge this.
  • poverty is the biggest indicator of ongoing issues and disadvantage as it usually means there are other things going in at home.
  • poor families tend to be using poorer childcare which exacerbates the issue

Interestingly, all the academics that teach on our early years and childhood studies degrees have used childcare themselves. I think that speaks volumes!

FloconDeNeige · 06/10/2021 18:13

@Pices
The research also showed that good-quality childcare had a positive effect on cognitive and language development.
And either way, the effects were very small.

Therefore, parents need to use knowledge and observation of their own children to judge whether it’s right for them. Personally, my kids have always really enjoyed crèche and we’ve had zero problems (DS2 sometimes even asks to go on a Saturday!), so I’m entirely confident that it has been the right decision. If they’d have not settled or otherwise struggled, we’d have looked at other options, but fortunately this never arose.

CanICelebrate · 06/10/2021 17:59

@Pices

Some people can’t simply ‘research and decide for themselves.’
Many people need to work for financial reasons.
That article you’ve posted will just make some working mums on this thread worry and feel guilty Sad

Pices · 06/10/2021 17:55

It's not great for under 2s. There's a whole host of research showing it's not ideal. Have a look through the research and decide for yourself. Ts not a choice I would make for my own kids but I certainly wouldn't judge you.

huntersfieldec.com/

SkinnyMirror · 06/10/2021 16:24

They still get their mums, dads, grandparents etc and also the benefit of attention from others too. Mums really don't need to be hovering at their child's side 24/7

Absolutely. My DS definitely benefits/has benefitted from a wide range of interactions from nursery, after school club, family, friends etc. We've taken a 'it takes a village' approach and it's worked well.

I'm a better mum for working. I love my job and it is a privilege to be able to work and be a parent.

I'm also self aware enough to understand that our way isn't the only way and wouldn't work for everyone.

MissChanandlerBong81 · 06/10/2021 16:20

I’ve said it before but I really don’t understand why people think it’s acceptable to say to working mothers (let’s face it, it’s never said to men) ‘why bother having a child if you aren’t going to raise them’ or something similar.

Have you actually thought about what you’re actually saying and what it means? Would you say it to someone in real life or is it just something you say to be spiteful on the Internet? Either way you really need to sit back and reflect on your empathy and social skills - or lack thereof.

Ironically, empathy is pretty key to being a good parent. Spite categorically isn’t. I’d bet that a child’s better off spending 40 hours a week in nursery and the rest of the time with someone who actually has some empathy than spending every waking hour with a parent who doesn’t.

Missmissmiiiiiiiiisss · 06/10/2021 16:12

I wouldn’t “judge you harshly” as I know most people do what needs to be done. But developmentally babies need secure attachments to a small number of people so ideally I think a baby is best cared for by a parent, relative or nanny. However many, many people aren’t in a position to do that. So zero judgement for you, definitely judgement for our society that we don’t offer paid leave for two years which would be in children’s best interests.

wonkylegs · 06/10/2021 16:09

Just think children need their mums
They still get their mums, dads, grandparents etc and also the benefit of attention from others too. Mums really don't need to be hovering at their child's side 24/7
I have a great relationship with my kids and both went to nursery. They also got the benefit of a sane mum (I love my career, most of the time) who didn't resent them in any way and also as I'm disabled, nursery enabled them to do things with them I'm physically not able to (get down on the floor to play)
I didn't miss out on any key moments, in fact I would say that good childcare enabled us to enjoy those moments and lots of special times because we savoured them as so special rather than being part of the mundane everyday.
I would say good childcare is the key as obviously rubbish childcare can be crap but that's not just limited to childcare, rubbish parenting can also be damaging.
My mum excelled at being a crap mum when I was a child so I can say with some certainty I wish she had less involvement in my life back then.

WeepySheepy · 06/10/2021 16:08

No judgement here. This mum thing is hard enough without other mums thinking their way is better than yours.

CanICelebrate · 06/10/2021 16:05

I wouldn’t judge you at all @Toomuchworkon

Mums judging other mums for working or not working is the worst thing on MN.

Over the years I’ve worked full time, part time and had a brief spell as a SAHM and in each scenario my dc have been happy, settled and loved.

Flowers
FloconDeNeige · 06/10/2021 16:01

Just think children need their mums

I don’t think mums are inherently better parents than dads and I feel quite sad for all the loving dads who are viewed as second class parents by some people.

A1b2c3d4e5f6g7 · 06/10/2021 15:58

[quote Suspicioussam]@Hardbackwriter we have had a fantastic shared parental leave take up at our company. Loads of men have taken between 3-6 months off and loved it. I think it is one of the most welcomed policy changes I've seen actually and most men I know who've had a baby have taken at least a couple of months.
Maybe the issue in many companies is the fear of judgement from employers (many don't actually support men taking it in reality as they aren't forward thinking) and partners who don't want to sacrifice any of their leave.[/quote]
I'd agree with this, I think it is coming along and big improvements being made. My partner is the third man on his smallish team to be taking it, and it's full pay for 4.5 months for him at any point in the first year.

A lot of companies have changed their shared parental leave entitlement for men, and given similar benefits to maternity leave. In my circle quite a few men have taken it, or are taking it. However I do know the take up wasn't big nationally when they last released the data, so obviously not that many people are making use of it yet. Does take a while for a cultural shift though

Isababybel · 06/10/2021 15:54

@DinkyDaffodil

Just think children need their mums - those whose children/babies have been cared for by others in their early years - will be fine - they won't know any different - anyway everyone has their own opinion - put your big girl pants on and understand that.
But they don't need their dad and its ok for the dad to work fulltime and it doesn't impact the child at all? Hmm
SkinnyMirror · 06/10/2021 15:52

Just think children need their mums
Not dads too?

DinkyDaffodil · 06/10/2021 15:49

Just think children need their mums - those whose children/babies have been cared for by others in their early years - will be fine - they won't know any different - anyway everyone has their own opinion - put your big girl pants on and understand that.

SkinnyMirror · 06/10/2021 15:35

@FloconDeNeige

We need more men making use of parental leave. The more they do, the more childcare will be seen as a shared responsibility rather than primarily the preserve of the mother. In the same way, the role of ‘provider’ will also be seen more equally too, rather than primarily the preserve of the father.

Which will make for happier parents all round as men won’t be judged for not taking their work seriously to spend time with their kids and women won’t be judged as inferior mothers for being breadwinners.

This is key. And it needs to be taught from a young age.

When you ask men and women about their career choices it's very common for women to have factored in the impact of having children before they've even had them - so they're more likely to go for jobs that are seen as flexible and family friendly.
I'm my many,many years or researching this I've never come across a man saying that he factored future childcare into his career plans.

Swipe left for the next trending thread