Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think my employer demanding I go back to the office is just cruel

319 replies

Runnyrose · 06/10/2021 00:55

I work full time over 4 days. DD attends nursery and DH and I split drop offs and pick ups between us. We live 45 minutes from my work in one direction and an hour from DHs in the other but I've been working from home since returning from mat leave in February. My job used to involve a lot of travel around the county and before mat leave, I could easily not step foot in our main office for weeks at a time and generally would start from home and finish at home and go to meetings or appointments in between. Because of the efficiency of Teams, these meetings are almost exclusively virtual and there is no plan to go back to face to face meetings. There is literally not a single aspect of my job that requires me to be in the office.
Suddenly, it's been announced that we have to go back to the office and work there. This will be impossible to manage with DDs childcare setting so the only way will be for my DH to take over both drop offs and pick ups which will mean, to ensure he's there on time, losing 2 hours of work a day. He's self employed so this is a significant amount of money lost every day. I will also lose 2 hours of seeing DD for travel time every day. Not to mention the sudden increased cost in fuel.
I've spoken to my manager and she was completely inflexible and the only solution we could come up with was for me to drop my hours so that I can drop DD off as soon as nursery open, race to work, leave the second the clock strikes 5 to race to pick her up again which frees DH up at least but makes my day a race everyday and costs me a full day a week's pay which works out at nearly £5k a year in bring home pay, not to mention the impact on my pension etc . I can't work full time over 5 days because the nursery don't have availability for her current day off and also, I don't want her going in 5 days a week. Going part time won't even feel like a break for me because I'll literally just be replacing the 2 hours a day working with traveling.
I feel so unbelievably angry at my employer that I work so incredibly hard for them, they know this and my manager said she knows this, but there is no flexibility to allow me to keep working from home when it's going to cause complete devastation to our family set up and financial situation and not in any way shape or form change what they get out of me whilst I'm at work.
I'm trying to find another job but my work is quite niche and there just aren't that many jobs around that pay the same level I'm at now. And I do love my job and don't want to leave it.
I have no problem going back into the office, I just want the option to still be allowed to start and / or finish at home like the job was when I first started and what DH and I planned our situation around before we even had DD.

OP posts:
Franklin12 · 06/10/2021 14:57

I worked for a company for 30 plus years most of which was spent working from home with client meetings as required. I was a middle manager and had a team of people and also interfaced with other parts of the business.

There are huge issues with wfh for some people. Sadly the more junior members and often women saw it as an opportunity to be unavailable during school run times, who declined calls after 1530 because they knew their children would make a noise having come back from school. Who took it as an opportunity to save on childcare and who were bloody difficult to manage because you couldnt see them but you knew they were slackers.

There was always some reason why they couldnt attend something which meant others had to pick up their work. That caused resentment with the rest of the team.

You would be very surprised how many people think if you work from home family can drop in, you can take a break to do school runs, attend school plays, take kids to the dentist, to play dates etc etc because actually no one can see what you are doing.

The call centres I worked with had people who put themselves on busy with 'customers' and it was found that they were chit chatting to each other!

Our young people need to be rubbing shoulders with people, getting on with their careers not at home being only a voice at the end of the phone.

TheKeatingFive · 06/10/2021 14:33

The benefit to the business is not having to pay for office space, business rates and electricity etc

It's entirely up to the business whether that's a benefit or not. Many have no intention of getting rid of office space, regardless of what individual employees want to do.

Plus having a dedicated employee who is not dashing away to nursery pick-ups stressed out of her mind and seething with resentment

Having employees more focused on putting washed on/prepping dinner/doing the nursery run during work hours probably isn't a better result either.

Lightswitch123 · 06/10/2021 14:22

"calling their bluff " but " refusing to resign " when they've already tried to be flexible will just help them make the decision..... Goodbye!

Why would they want an employee as inflexible as that!?

Literally refusing to do what her company has quite reasonably requested. Hmm.

SpeckledlyHen · 06/10/2021 14:19

@TorringtonDean

The benefit to the business is not having to pay for office space, business rates and electricity etc. Plus having a dedicated employee who is not dashing away to nursery pick-ups stressed out of her mind and seething with resentment. Or they could drive her away and have all the recruitment costs and a possible industrial tribunal?
Exactly, it is so short sighted of employers i feel. I worked for a company for four years and at the interview expressly asked if I could WFH at least 3 days a week, my boss said yes, no problem. When it actually came to it he wanted presenteeism despite me having a track record of home working, and I was commuting 120 miles a day (I would not have taken the job on this basis). He said I could work from home the "odd day" but not a Monday or Friday as it would look like I was taking the mickey. Out of a team of 6 people I was the only one not able to work from home as the others were field sales and based round the country. I lasted 6mths and handed in my notice, with seething resentment. Another department head found out and offered me a job (a much better one and actually one I preferred), I was able to work from home as much or as little as I wanted. Basically I resigned and was rehired immediately.

It was a relatively small office so I used to see my old boss on any given day I went into the office and we kept on good terms. The hilarious thing was when Covid hit and he was sent home to work I once spoke to him on teams and he was delighted at being able to work from home and acted like he invented it..

10Cheethahcubs · 06/10/2021 14:14

I would be tempted to call his bluff. Say sorry that isn't going to work for me, I plan to continue with the current arrangement. Effectively: Your move.

You could say as a compromise - you would be prepared to come into the office 'periodically' should the need arise but on a day to day basis it will not work for you.

Carry on doing what you are doing. Say you will not be resigning. It is up to them how they deal with it. If they value you and want you to continue working there then they will work around it. If they fire you/make you redundant - then really do you want to be working for a firm as inflexible as this?

TorringtonDean · 06/10/2021 14:08

The benefit to the business is not having to pay for office space, business rates and electricity etc. Plus having a dedicated employee who is not dashing away to nursery pick-ups stressed out of her mind and seething with resentment. Or they could drive her away and have all the recruitment costs and a possible industrial tribunal?

SpeckledlyHen · 06/10/2021 14:07

I am with you OP. The job I do means I visit a lot of client sites and pre pandemic I worked from home as I was often travelling to client sites during the week and I obviously set off from home. My job (used to) take me out of the office maybe 3 days a week, due to the long hours driving to client sites and staying away from home it was an unwritten rule that I was home based even though my contract stated I was based in the London office. If I suddenly had to commute to the london office everyday I couldn't do it and would have to quit.

I recently started a new job and the company drafted a brand new contract just for me - it explicitly states I am based at home rather than the nearest regional office. What this means - post pandemic or for whatever reason they can not change my location to an office. I was glad of this security as I have worked from home now for about 20 years and could not go back to commuting.

HaudYerWheeshtYaWeeBellend · 06/10/2021 13:54

ApplesinmyPocket

I’m neither rude or dismissive, whether you like it or not child care is not the responsibility of the employers, you may dislike that however it doesn’t make it any less accurate.

OP has to make a flexible working request that is in the benefit of the business not her personal circumstances.

vivainsomnia · 06/10/2021 13:13

It's been a win all round, really, as it must save a lot of public money, too
Totally agree that there are roles for which working from home is more or as sufficient.

The point is that managers are much more apt to decide which is which because...that's their role to assess efficiencies.

vivainsomnia · 06/10/2021 13:11

If flexible working is associated with productivity falls over time then the employer should be able to demonstrate that
For a start, that's not true, it's not always easy to demonstrate it all.

Even if it is possible, the process of doing so is time consuming, complex, and stressful in some cases.

Why add this role to managers who are stretched to the max already when having all the staff in the office means they can keep an eye on productivity?

Many people working from home do treat it like an office. Others however treat it like being at home and doing the strict minimum work to tick the box.

For instance, staff could get on with their call with customers and then do household duties in between and nothing else. If they were in the office though, they might also do self learning, create better filing systems and indeed file. Write more succinct reports, read executive reports etc...

The staff think they do their job by dealing with customers. The manager however expects the rest to be undertaken.

LakieLady · 06/10/2021 13:11

@Bumtum126

On every single thread of this type, and there have been many, the OP is adamant that they are working better, more efficiently, and far more productive than being in the office. It would be VERY interesting to hear the employer's take on it as it seems unlikely that they are insisting that everyone go to the office just for the hell of it.

Agreed I suspect alot would have lots of vague ideas , nothing concrete they would ever reveal to staff. I think alot of management are stuck in old ways of thinking , if I can't see them they aren't working so get them back in. Rather than review how to manage people and projects they switch to default because it feels safe and what they know.

My employer has recognised that WFH is much more efficient for us. Not having to waste time doing 90-mile round trips for client appointments and doing loads of work by phone means that we all now have caseloads that are 60%-80% higher than they would have been pre-Covid.

"Attending" a tribunal conducted via conference call takes an hour, it would take me an hour just to get to the venue if it was F2F, and sometimes a 3 hour wait if they're running late (which they often used to). And we're seeing no difference in success rates and getting more decisions changed before they actually get to the tribunal. And clients prefer it, too. It's less stress for them, which is great as my clients all have MH issues.

It's been a win all round, really, as it must save a lot of public money, too.

helpfulperson · 06/10/2021 13:09

She worked from home pre pregnancy and pre covid that is what this makes it different and not as simple as employer saying 'I've changed the basis of the job you were employed to do. All the experiences of those who only WFH because of Covid are not relevant to this situation.

TractorAndHeadphones · 06/10/2021 12:56

@gogohm

What did you think would happen when you got pregnant? There was no covid then, did you think they would let you wfh?

Whilst many employees love wfh employers often don't. Dp brought everyone back in last May because 2 of the team were essentially slacking, they believed they were more efficient though! In reality most companies need the interaction of employees that simply doesn't happen over zoom. Interestingly one of dps employees that was causing the issues has since left because she found working full time too much.

Couldn't you find a nursery close to work to help with the drops offs

I’m thinking that employees might not have been as productive given zoom. If people were having X meetings including travelling they should now be having X + n. Instead people are still having X. Or thé increase is less than n.
Whycangirlsbesonasty · 06/10/2021 12:53

I my company my department could easily wfh hit other departments couldn’t, so we are being asked to come in to make it ‘fair across the company. Seems fair enough to me as no ones contracts are changing as we are contracted to work from the workplace and the employer is not required to do otherwise.

C8H10N4O2 · 06/10/2021 12:41

@vivainsomnia

I think this is a sign of employers not caring about their colleagues. I know I'll likely get flamed for saying that, but I can't see what justification an employer has to bring employees back into the office, knowing it will have an adverse impact on their staff Because staff saying that they are very efficient working from home doesn't make it a fact. Who, who is desperate to work from home, would agree that they are not as productive at home? They wouldn't admit to themselves let alone anyone else.

Organisations want to run their business smoothly and cost effectively. From some, it indeed means allowing staff to work from home. Many however will have assess that working from home is does not bring efficiencies for different and various reasons.

Not knowing or understanding these reasons doesn't make them inexistent.

If flexible working is associated with productivity falls over time then the employer should be able to demonstrate that. Instead what we here over and over is staff being pulled back into the office for no better reason than a manager says so.

From observation, many of them haven't conducted any such assessment but just made an assumption based on their own limited outlook.

Not knowing or understanding these reasons doesn't make them inexistent

It doesn't make them non-existent but if the employer is too clueless to say to the workforce "this is what happened, here were the costs and benefits to the business, this is how it was measured and this is why we need X, Y and Z" then I'd be astonished if they had conducted any kind of meaningful assessment.

The reality is most of these decisions are from middle management layers, coincidentally the layer that tends to have the most men landed based on the Peter Principle.

gogohm · 06/10/2021 12:37

What did you think would happen when you got pregnant? There was no covid then, did you think they would let you wfh?

Whilst many employees love wfh employers often don't. Dp brought everyone back in last May because 2 of the team were essentially slacking, they believed they were more efficient though! In reality most companies need the interaction of employees that simply doesn't happen over zoom. Interestingly one of dps employees that was causing the issues has since left because she found working full time too much.

Couldn't you find a nursery close to work to help with the drops offs

noideawhatusernametochoose · 06/10/2021 12:29

Might be worth speaking to an employment solicitor for some initial advice. Your home insurance might cover you for this?? Or ACAS as mentioned previously?

I'm somewhat flummoxed by the amount of posters saying you should just suck it up. You weren't expected to work from the office before, so this is a change. But I'm not an employment lawyer so I don't know much the "how it worked in practice" vs "what the contract says" actually counts.

Good luck OP, hopefully some common sense will prevail. If you can do the work more effectively from home (and be far less stressed, which has got to be good for all concerned), then it would seem nonsensical to insist you work from the office.

TheKeatingFive · 06/10/2021 12:18

OP, apologies if I've missed this, but what's stated in your contract as your place of work?

GreenFingersWouldBeHandy · 06/10/2021 12:13

I know they are within their rights to, but it's just so unnecessary.

Sorry, but they employ you. Not the other way around. Suck it up or find another job that suits you better.

Franklin12 · 06/10/2021 12:12

People who work at home ALWAYS insist they are more productive. Why would they say they werent!

They really arent in every single example. I worked for a FTSE company for many years who did allow home working but it was so abused, people not being where they should be, children crying in the background and people feeling as another PP said once the school run was done they were also done.

If working from home was better for productivity then we would see the results over the last 18 months and we havent.

HannaHanna · 06/10/2021 12:09

@Jangle33

Get another job if you aren’t willing to follow company policy.

It’s not a charity if company policy is to require you to be in the office then your childcare issues aren’t their problem.

Amazed by some of the comments here and wonder if the people making them are living in some kind of Dickensian world.

No one should be content for their employer to suddenly change the terms (different location, expanded hours, removal of expense reimbursements) of your work without discussion and without changing their compensation.

BackAwayFatty · 06/10/2021 12:07

Have you put in an official flexible working request? If not, I would start there. If you are a member of a union then contact them for advice. If not, ACAS & CAB can advise also

ChrissyPlummer · 06/10/2021 11:48

@TorringtonDean

WFH is meant to be a major part of the package job applicants are looking for at the moment. So where are they going to find your replacement?

I’ve thought for many years that what really holds women back in the workplace is the tyranny of the hours. Who says a workday should be 9-5 (with 5 often extending to 7.30/8) and that the working week is Monday to Friday? People should be able to negotiate a deal that works for them in terms of hours and days. Of course men can easily do the standard hours because usually there is a woman in the background doing the childcare/drop-offs for them. It’s changing a little now as men are more involved with their kids but mine are almost grown up now and for most men of my age it was default that the wives did it. Meanwhile the working women are run ragged trying to do it all. I was.

Let’s hope the pandemic has now proven that we have the technology for a much more flexible working world - one where the able people are employed, not just those who are can be bums on seats for enough hours.

I saw something a few years ago, I think it was in the Guardian that as technology has advanced, WFH has actually decreased. So many managers seem to favour presenteeism (or perhaps I’ve been very unlucky). One boss I had insisted that people on training courses stay until 4, even if all the material had been covered by 3. Why? I have found this attitude over and over when I’ve been in offices.

This is why I no longer do office work, I do fixed shifts and I can’t be made to change/do overtime/cover for someone who wants to leave early. We are all treated exactly the same.

kegel · 06/10/2021 11:44

Has your manager actually given a reason why you are now required to go into the office? I'm not sure what the law is around flexible working but it could be something to research what your rights are

CookPassBabtridge · 06/10/2021 11:41

I can see why you're frustrated OP. Why can't some employers see that when staff are happier and feel their workplace is flexible then they are more productive? Why is your employer obsessed with being in the office?