Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the monarchy will end at Charles?

184 replies

freudien · 06/10/2021 00:26

I've just noticed a lot of republican talk recently (prompted by the other thread on the earth shot prize, also generally twitter and recent republican stuff happening in Wales) and I wonder whether it's because I'm in an echo chamber? Or is MN also an echo chamber? Either way. Are you a royalist or a republican?

Personally I feel the royal family is worth the money spent but should be kept out of politics. Kind of like other european monarchies.

But then on the other hand by dissolving the aristocracy wouldn't we be solving the problems of inequity in society?

OP posts:
CounsellorTroi · 06/10/2021 07:44

I like having a ceremonial head of state, and our PM answering to them (even if it is mostly courtesy), and Parliament and Lords. I wouldn’t want Boris Johnson having the same level of power that POTUS has for example.

You can have an elected ceremonial head of state.

DazzleDrops · 06/10/2021 07:13

Interesting question op.
I'm a republican - I don't think abolishing the monarchy will lead to greater social equality, but it would be a start.
I think it's totally wrong that MP's have to swear an oath of loyalty to the sovereign and their heirs. As Norman Baker pointed out, even if a political party got elected on the promise of abolishing the monarchy, the MP's would have to swear the oath before taking their seats making them guilty of treason (or something like that.)

There is little accountability of the RF due to the secrecy that surrounds their financial affairs and their exemption from the FOI Act. They like to say 'never complain, never explain' but they do frequently complain - remember William getting uppity about Tatler mentioning the fallout with Rose Hanbury?

The idea of curtseying etc, Your Highness, can't speak first to a Royal, etc etc is ridiculous in this day and age.

As for tourism etc, that's a load of bunkum. France gets more tourists than we do. We'd probably attract more tourists if the palaces, castles etc were open all year round.

Has anyone seen the footage of the Queen getting booed at her recent opening of the Scottish Parliament? I do think they're on borrowed time now.

Atmywitsend29 · 06/10/2021 07:13

If anything, once William and Kate get on throne their popularity will be at an all time high

There are scores of people who massively disagree with that. They might be the press darlings but many general public are not quite so easily persuaded.

LoveGrooveDanceParty · 06/10/2021 06:59

Which reigning monarch hasn’t been boring and charmless?

I’m old enough to remember the Queen in the pre/Diana years, and believe me, everyone thought she was boring and charmless back then, too. If you’re watching The Crown, you can surely see why.

UsedUpUsername · 06/10/2021 06:56

@echt

I am a thoroughgoing republican.

The monarchy is far more durable than any reprehensible behaviour by some of its members. It will not end with the death of the Queen.

That family will always be like this. Better to vote for someone like the Irish system rather than someone born into it.

The queen is ok but Charles/William are both boring and charmless. How can they be fitting representatives?

dayswithaY · 06/10/2021 06:55

But where are they supposed to go, people will still be insanely interested in them. What will happen to all the palaces and the art work and jewels, surely some of them are privately owned by the royals?

If anything, once William and Kate get on throne their popularity will be at an all time high. Charles will be on the throne for a few boring, non eventful years.

MimiDaisy11 · 06/10/2021 06:45

@JuneOsborne

The issue I have is with the alternative, a president.

Imagine Boris as president.

If we did it like the Irish system where the president is a figurehead then he wouldn’t be making policy and governing. As much as I dislike him id much rather have him in a ceremonial role than his current one.
HaudYerWheeshtYaWeeBellend · 06/10/2021 06:43

No I’d don’t believe it will.

JuneOsborne · 06/10/2021 06:41

The issue I have is with the alternative, a president.

Imagine Boris as president.

echt · 06/10/2021 06:38

I am a thoroughgoing republican.

The monarchy is far more durable than any reprehensible behaviour by some of its members. It will not end with the death of the Queen.

SarahBellam · 06/10/2021 06:26

I wish they would. They're pointless and expensive, but they're bread and circuses for the great unwashed who enjoy tugging their forelock to someone because they're wearing a dress that cost the same as an average salary.

Doingtheboxerbeat · 06/10/2021 06:15

I'll settle for getting rid of the Tories - and that seems impossible, so no, I don't think it will happen in my lifetime.

LoveGrooveDanceParty · 06/10/2021 05:58

YABU - it is absolutely, categorically not going to end with Charles.

People have talked like this since the dawn of the Monarchy, and yet here we still are.

If the commonwealth countries - who talk about leaving often enough, but never actually do - still have the Queen as the head of state, you can bet your last $£€ that the Monarchy has a long, looooong shelf life yet, and is no going anywhere.

MimiDaisy11 · 06/10/2021 05:57

I’m a Republican. Sure democracy is flawed ( “democracy is the worst form of government – except for all the others that have been tried“) and people can choose idiots - though that’s often when it’s just a choice of two and there’s a lack of choice due to the particular system in place. I don’t like the US system and think a system like Ireland with division between head of state and government works best. You still have a figure to unite the country like you supposedly do with a monarchy.

Obviously people are free to disagree I just wish more people would read up on the monarchy, to look into how the duchy of Cornwall works for example. Sure Prince Andrew’s scandals make it into the press but there’s not much on more core aspects.
The blurred lines between public and private funds is often worked to royalist advantages.

Queen Elizabeth realises the importance/power of silence, Prince Charles doesn’t. On issues such as brexit I bet both remainers and leavers think she supports their position. When Charles is around when divisive issues come around he won’t be able to keep his mouth shut. That will put cracks in the monarchy but lots of people like William and he seems better at staying silent. So I don’t think the monarchy will go in my life time in the UK but I do think so for other countries like Australia and New Zealand.

londonrach · 06/10/2021 05:53

There's been alot less interest in them since covid, Andrew and harry situation. Saying that it be impossible to get rid of them as there's still enough support..weather that goes when the queen dies...don't know.. Charles is not popular but Kate and William are.

Lightswitch123 · 06/10/2021 05:24

I hope it ends with the queen.

Elsie296 · 06/10/2021 05:21

I wouldn't like to see the monarchy abolished, I think that people attribute more power to them then they actually have, and then see that as the problem.
I see them as an centuries old institution that has evolved into a beloved British tradition that I would love to see continued.
Plenty of badly behaved families to take their place if they were gone and, even if not 'official' the family would still be prominent and provide prime headline material and I doubt we would notice much difference tbh.
However, I do think we will see generational changes, I think that once millennials/gen z become the older members of society, the royal family will be less thought off. They haven't had quite the same upbringing in terms of respecting the queen, and have only ever viewed the royal family in terms of scandal- starting right from Diana in the 80's.

Cattitudes · 06/10/2021 03:56

I consider whether in 1000 years we will have a monarchy, probably not. In that case will we have a monarchy in 100 years, harder to tell but again probably not, in that case just rip the plaster off now. Give the family enough of a pay off to last a few generations and find a system based on merit. I know they argue that the Royal family bring in tourists but I have never gone to Spain, Denmark, Norway, etc because they have a royal family. I guess I might visit a castle, but just because we stop having a monarchy it doesn't mean we have to pull down all the castles or stop having army parades.

Saoirse82 · 06/10/2021 03:27

I'll be glad to see the back of the lot of them.

Flunked · 06/10/2021 03:25

@Atmywitsend29

Personally I'd be happy if the monarchy died with the Queen.
Same.
1forAll74 · 06/10/2021 03:18

A paired down monarchy might be better., as in removing those that don't contribute anything, or not much, to the royal set up.

Oaktree1952 · 06/10/2021 03:17

The thought of a president is absolutely abhorrent to me. I much prefer the idea that the "top job" is not fought over and someone is brought up trained to do it. It's right that we vote for parliament and PM etc but it's also right that they have someone to answer too.

I also don't think we would notice any tax reduction if we got rid of the monarchy but we would loose a lot of our identity as a county.

I agree that the actions of one or two of the family have not been acceptable and maybe there needs to be something put in place but to get rid of the monarchy would be very short sighted.

Atmywitsend29 · 06/10/2021 02:51

Personally I'd be happy if the monarchy died with the Queen.

GiantHaystacks2021 · 06/10/2021 02:19

No, they'll never go.
Not quietly anyway.
The establishment and their voters prop up the monarchy and honestly there would need to be a full scale revolution, on the scale of the French one, to make it happen.

480Widdio · 06/10/2021 02:15

I have no respect for the Queen,,the way she is protecting Andrew is despicable.

I hope the Monarchy ends,there is little support for it now.