Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the monarchy will end at Charles?

184 replies

freudien · 06/10/2021 00:26

I've just noticed a lot of republican talk recently (prompted by the other thread on the earth shot prize, also generally twitter and recent republican stuff happening in Wales) and I wonder whether it's because I'm in an echo chamber? Or is MN also an echo chamber? Either way. Are you a royalist or a republican?

Personally I feel the royal family is worth the money spent but should be kept out of politics. Kind of like other european monarchies.

But then on the other hand by dissolving the aristocracy wouldn't we be solving the problems of inequity in society?

OP posts:
Brefugee · 06/10/2021 15:39

Imagine Boris as president.

Why would he be? Assuming the HoC wouldn't give up power, and that the Mother of Parliaments would continue to be an (elected) 2 chamber affair like many other modern democracies then executive power would remain with the PM. The head of state would do exactly what the queen does but without the crowns and the ridiculous bowing/curtseying.

There is no reason it must be an ex politician. We could invite anyone to stand for election. I'd even vote for Princess Anne. Or how about Floella Benjamin? Tanni Grey-Thompson? Doreen Lawrence?

The German president isn't voted for by the public, there is no reason why a UK president would have to be voted for by the public either.

Brefugee · 06/10/2021 15:34

I think the queen should abdicate now and that should be an end of the monarchy and all titles.

There is no need for them at all.

Queen Elizabeth realises the importance/power of silence,

she realises the importance of never ever letting anything she says/writes see the light of day. And getting her flunkies to do things like apply for the winter heating grant for her etc.

As for William and Kate - privately i have always thought Kate wanted to marry the heir to the throne and went all out to do it. She'd be hugely disappointed to miss out Wink

RaspberryRoyale88 · 06/10/2021 15:30

Get rid of them. If I had any respect for them it would have been wiped with the whole Andrew affair and him hiding behind Mummy’s legs.

IcedPurple · 06/10/2021 15:25

Nobody knows what the future holds, but to the best of my knowledge monarchies have only been deposed at a time of war or other great upheaval. I don't think any country has got rid of a monarchy through referendum, but there's always a first time I guess.

I'd say what's more likely is that the monarchy will be 'trimmed down' to more closely resemble a ceremonial head of state. That means everyone other than the sovereign, their consort and the heir will have to get jobs. More royal properties should be put to profitable use too.

I think the monarchy will stumble on, but it will not be the extravagant affair of the past. Benign indifference will likely be as good as it gets for them from this point onwards.

Brouhahaha · 06/10/2021 15:20

@TheKeatingFive

Sure, let's get rid of one of the UK's unique selling points because a few people can't handle anything akin to authority or prosperity very well and naively believe that eliminating one of our main sources of revenue will bring 'equality'

What a bizarre thing to say.

There's no evidence they produce any revenue. If we got rid of them we'd still be able to hawk the history stuff to tourists in the way that Versailles does. We could divert duchy and sovereign grant money to the actual public.

Many people misread how the U.K. is seen from abroad. Anyone I know just thinks it's a bit embarrassing that the U.K. clings to a mode of government that made sense in medieval times, but is totally ill suited to the present. It comes across as a very childish way to want to be governed.

There's no evidence they produce any revenue.

Totally agree. If anything they produce revenue to enrich their own coffers.

Brouhahaha · 06/10/2021 15:14

There's no place today for unelected representatives like the royal family or the House of Lords. Both need to go, and I really don't understand the reasons for keeping them (tourism not a reason people will still come to visit the palaces etc.). I know English people and some from the other home nations have affection for the family but I just can't see how the royal family and the aristocracy and everything that goes with them can be justified.

HighNetGirth · 06/10/2021 15:09

The Brexit referendum was bad enough, I absolutely could not face a monarchy/republic one. I'd have to leave the country for a while. I think we let their popularity fade until everyone agrees to Wexit. Shouldn't be long now.

DrSbaitso · 06/10/2021 15:08

You wouldn't know it from MN or many online circles, but at this time, most people like the monarchy and want to keep it. They might be wrong to feel that way, but they do.

It would be interesting to see a king giving the necessary royal assent to the Act of Parliament that gets rid of him and all he stands for.

mustlovegin · 06/10/2021 15:05

She can (and does) put pressure on PMs

How do you know? Have you been to the private weekly meetings or read it on Twitter?

Bazinga007 · 06/10/2021 15:01

It is time to get rid of them. They serve little purpose.

TheKeatingFive · 06/10/2021 14:42

It's likely you're hanging out with the wrong crowd, same as the OP

🤣 🤣 🤣

Yes I'd much prefer to be part of the crowd curtsying to Andrew

mustlovegin · 06/10/2021 14:40

Anyone I know just thinks it's a bit embarrassing that the U.K. clings to a mode of government that made sense in medieval times, but is totally ill suited to the present

It's likely you're hanging out with the wrong crowd, same as the OP

mustlovegin · 06/10/2021 14:39

Can you provide a link to figures showing the royals are one of our main sources of revenue?

This question is always asked on these threads, and it denotes a complete lack of understanding of how the economy works.

British traditions (which include a reigning monarchy) are a key driver of economic output. It's not the takings of a few postcards and a couple of mugs at a souvenir shop. They permeate many and vast sectors as diverse as hospitality, entertainment, education, fashion, property, the list is endless. Also industries are closely intertwined and the continuous feedback cycle makes it impossible to cleanly attribute revenues to the monarchy in this way - but if it were possible, it would be much more than £86million pounds, that's for sure.

Andante57 · 06/10/2021 14:29

Freudian are you going to answer my question about your plan to ‘disssolve’ the aristocracy?

ChewChewPanda · 06/10/2021 13:39

I have never had strong views on the monarchy but after Prince Andrew’s conduct and the Queen’s support for him in evading proper process, I want the monarchy to end as soon as possible. I don’t see them as positive role models and I don’t think we should support the institution.

RubyFowler · 06/10/2021 13:27

I have a hunch William will be the last king.

OhWhyNot · 06/10/2021 13:25

No

But I would like it too

After the Queen dies her legacy is what shall carry the royal family forward

freudien · 06/10/2021 13:23

@Marcipex

I don’t know, but when you say end at Charles, end how? Do you think he’ll abolish the monarchy himself? Does William then get a say? I think William and Kate are quite popular.
By this I meant there would, at his death in a few decades, be a big enough republican appetite to warrant a big constitutional change in the role of the monarchy in political institutions.

An example: the fact our current 94 year old queen still has a (private) weekly address with the prime minister is unacceptable but it is still very much part of the fabric of government. She can (and does) put pressure on PMs.

OP posts:
ChequerBoard · 06/10/2021 12:12

@HarrietsChariot

The civil list was abolished a decade ago.
OK then the Sovereign Grant which replaced it which has risen from the original £31M in 2012/13 to £86.3M for 2021/22.
CathyorClaire · 06/10/2021 11:32

Sure, let's get rid of one of the UK's unique selling points because a few people can't handle anything akin to authority or prosperity very well and naively believe that eliminating one of our main sources of revenue will bring 'equality'

Can you provide a link to figures showing the royals are one of our main sources of revenue?

TheKeatingFive · 06/10/2021 11:26

Sure, let's get rid of one of the UK's unique selling points because a few people can't handle anything akin to authority or prosperity very well and naively believe that eliminating one of our main sources of revenue will bring 'equality'

What a bizarre thing to say.

There's no evidence they produce any revenue. If we got rid of them we'd still be able to hawk the history stuff to tourists in the way that Versailles does. We could divert duchy and sovereign grant money to the actual public.

Many people misread how the U.K. is seen from abroad. Anyone I know just thinks it's a bit embarrassing that the U.K. clings to a mode of government that made sense in medieval times, but is totally ill suited to the present. It comes across as a very childish way to want to be governed.

NotFrozen · 06/10/2021 11:16

I support a heavily scaled back monarchy, which I hope in time will lose its power and public funding. This could be done gradually over the next few generations

maofteens · 06/10/2021 11:16

Nope.

Dora33 · 06/10/2021 11:15

I would not be a supporter of a monarchy but have always had respect for the Queen until this year.
The way that she has enabled Prince Andrew to try to evade being served legal papers is disgraceful.
The rest of them are just an elite brand

ChurchofLatterDayPaints · 06/10/2021 11:11

Sure, let's get rid of one of the UK's unique selling points because a few people can't handle anything akin to authority or prosperity very well and naively believe that eliminating one of our main sources of revenue will bring 'equality'

Awesome, all this argument needs is a shred of evidence for the "main sources of revenue".

A few people can't handle anything akin to ethics and integrity, maybe?