Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the monarchy will end at Charles?

184 replies

freudien · 06/10/2021 00:26

I've just noticed a lot of republican talk recently (prompted by the other thread on the earth shot prize, also generally twitter and recent republican stuff happening in Wales) and I wonder whether it's because I'm in an echo chamber? Or is MN also an echo chamber? Either way. Are you a royalist or a republican?

Personally I feel the royal family is worth the money spent but should be kept out of politics. Kind of like other european monarchies.

But then on the other hand by dissolving the aristocracy wouldn't we be solving the problems of inequity in society?

OP posts:
Comedycook · 06/10/2021 16:44

If Charles comes even close to being as long lived as his Grandmother and parents Wills will be sixty or more before he takes the throne. It's hard to picture him seeming modern and relevant if that's the case and that's before factoring in the resting pissed-off face

What popular role do you see for George's spares?

Kates hugely popular...I think being married to her massively helps with Williams popularity. Who knows what roles Charlotte and Louis will have? They have names...no need to refer to them as 'spares'. They are people in their own right.

CathyorClaire · 06/10/2021 16:39

@Comedycook

William and Kate will be hugely popular. They seem to be doing an excellent job raising their kids, so I predict they will all be popular too.
If Charles comes even close to being as long lived as his Grandmother and parents Wills will be sixty or more before he takes the throne. It's hard to picture him seeming modern and relevant if that's the case and that's before factoring in the resting pissed-off face

What popular role do you see for George's spares?

IcedPurple · 06/10/2021 16:36

I'm not sure any individual heir to the throne even HAS the power to dissolve the monarchy without the consent of parliament?

Would even that be enough? Wouldn't the Commonwealth countries also have a say? They did when the rules were changed to allow girls to outrank their younger brothers was passed a few years ago.

I think abolishing the monarchy would be a massive headache, since the monarchy is entwined in so many aspects of British life. That alone, barring unforeseen circumstances, might be enough for it to continue.

SirChenjins · 06/10/2021 16:32

Brexit taught us that lots of people are very stupid and believe everything they read on red buses.

Bollindger · 06/10/2021 16:31

Yet again Mumsnet is misreading the minds of Joe Public.
The Monarchy is safe.
This is the age of Celeb and people fight to get to be involved with Our Royal Family, look at her and him in the USA.
Do you think the fact we have all the pomp of a coronation in the next few years and William and Catherine and their children stepping into the limelight will be passed over.
Did Brexit not teach people that the liberals are out of touch, and that is why they will always misread the UK.

freudien · 06/10/2021 16:30

@IpanemaPeaHen

I think William and Catherine as a team are very popular. She saves him from coming across as too remote.
Rose hanbury might have finished him off. I mean figuratively of course.
OP posts:
SirChenjins · 06/10/2021 16:26

I think it will continue with Kate and Wills, but i suspect they will significantly pare things down and hopefully they'll strip out the rotten and dead wood.

Comedycook · 06/10/2021 16:25

William and Kate will be hugely popular. They seem to be doing an excellent job raising their kids, so I predict they will all be popular too.

freudien · 06/10/2021 16:22

@Atmywitsend29

If anything, once William and Kate get on throne their popularity will be at an all time high

There are scores of people who massively disagree with that. They might be the press darlings but many general public are not quite so easily persuaded.

Plus they will be somewhere in their 70s probably
OP posts:
Comedycook · 06/10/2021 16:21

@Andante57

And... I suspect that in the vanishingly unlikely case of a referendum (launched by a suicidal political party? Hardly the Tories, and Labour knows better than to risk it)

There seems to be plenty of support for abolishing the monarchy on mumsnet. Is this a particularly republican minded forum or do you think it represents a cross section of what British people believe?
If the latter then why would having a referendum to keep/abolish the royal family be ‘suicidal’?

I don't think its necessarily representative. There was a thread the other day about free range chicken and it seemed a majority of posters refused to buy factory farmed meat. If you actually look at the stats on what people buy, vast majority of meat sold in the UK is factory farmed. Honestly I think if there was a referendum on the monarchy tomorrow, the British public would overwhelmingly vote to keep them. Honestly I reckon is would be 90% plus
Fatya · 06/10/2021 16:21

I don't know if it will end with Charles but I suspect it will end. There's a huge generational gap in support for them (and younger people seem to have really soured on them in the last couple of years).

It'll be a good riddance from me.

CathyorClaire · 06/10/2021 16:19

attending

CathyorClaire · 06/10/2021 16:18

Charles has been fighting environmental issues since before most politicians could spell environment

And having wagged his finger at the great unwashed he'll jump into a helicopter probably followed by attend a weekend wildlife massacre.

Andante57 · 06/10/2021 16:11

And... I suspect that in the vanishingly unlikely case of a referendum (launched by a suicidal political party? Hardly the Tories, and Labour knows better than to risk it)

There seems to be plenty of support for abolishing the monarchy on mumsnet. Is this a particularly republican minded forum or do you think it represents a cross section of what British people believe?
If the latter then why would having a referendum to keep/abolish the royal family be ‘suicidal’?

Andante57 · 06/10/2021 16:08

while all the British Republic-leaning middle classes who talk about "abolishing the monarchy" over dinner won't actually bother going out to vote

Astoundedgoat why wouldn’t republicans bother to vote? I thought the main reason why remain supporters didn’t vote in the EU referendum was because they thought remain would easily win?

CathyorClaire · 06/10/2021 16:07

@mustlovegin

Can you provide a link to figures showing the royals are one of our main sources of revenue?

This question is always asked on these threads, and it denotes a complete lack of understanding of how the economy works.

British traditions (which include a reigning monarchy) are a key driver of economic output. It's not the takings of a few postcards and a couple of mugs at a souvenir shop. They permeate many and vast sectors as diverse as hospitality, entertainment, education, fashion, property, the list is endless. Also industries are closely intertwined and the continuous feedback cycle makes it impossible to cleanly attribute revenues to the monarchy in this way - but if it were possible, it would be much more than £86million pounds, that's for sure.

Yes, indeed.

It's impossible to say and yet the claim is made endlessly on these threads and then predictably refuted by vague flannel and waffle.

MintJulia · 06/10/2021 15:52

Charles has been fighting environmental issues since before most politicians could spell environment.

Who would you like as head of state as a replacement?

TrollsAreSaddos · 06/10/2021 15:50

There is no place for a royal family in modern society. They need to step down. The fact they haven't just shows how out of touch and deluded they are.
You can't help but respect the Queen as a person but the younger royals are a joke.

IcedPurple · 06/10/2021 15:47

[quote ChurchofLatterDayPaints]@IcedPurple yes, Italy did in 1946.

Interestingly the results showed a huge national north-south split, I think there were only 2 million votes more in favour than against. [/quote]
Thanks, I didn't realise Italy had a referendum.

It was in the immediate aftermath of WWll though, so my point about war and upheaval still stands. All of the European monarchies which were around after WWll are still around now. That doesn't mean they'll stay of course, but I think it would take something major to oust them.

astoundedgoat · 06/10/2021 15:46

I suspect that the demographic that most passionately supports the royal family and idolises the queen doesn't actually KNOW or care much about the Prince Andrew scandal, know or care that Virginia Guiffre has filed a civil case against him in the US, know or care that the queen is standing by him and covering his legal fees. Therefore none of it will impact how they feel about it.

And... I suspect that in the vanishingly unlikely case of a referendum (launched by a suicidal political party? Hardly the Tories, and Labour knows better than to risk it), they'd all vote in droves to protect their queen, while all the British Republic-leaning middle classes who talk about "abolishing the monarchy" over dinner won't actually bother going out to vote.

I firmly believe that remaining in the EU had vastly more support than leaving it, but complacency kept remainers at home, and I bet it would happen again if there was the opportunity to dissolve the monarchy.

I'm not sure any individual heir to the throne even HAS the power to dissolve the monarchy without the consent of parliament? Could they? It could be that all you could do is abdicate, and presumably legally the next in line could say "Hey, I'll do it!". You'd have to get a LOT of people to say they wouldn't take it if it passed to them. There's 20 people we've heard of and probably another couple of hundred after them!

www.harpersbazaar.com/celebrity/latest/g31928340/british-royals-line-of-succession/

ChurchofLatterDayPaints · 06/10/2021 15:44

@IcedPurple yes, Italy did in 1946.

Interestingly the results showed a huge national north-south split, I think there were only 2 million votes more in favour than against.

IcedPurple · 06/10/2021 15:44

@AppleBlueberryPie

What happens to the RF funding if the monarch ends? Presumably that would also be the end of taxpayer funded "working royals" so how would they afford to keep their homes and security. Would K&W have to find civilian jobs or would there be some kind of arrangement so all of them continue earning enough via property, investment funds etc?
I think the 'working royals' thing is coming to an end in any case. It's kind of an outdated notion. I think in the future only the sovereign, their spouse and direct heir will be publicly funded. The rest will have to get jobs and pay for their own homes. It's not as though they'll have any problems doing so. With their connections they'll have their pick of careers, no matter how dim they might be.
AppleBlueberryPie · 06/10/2021 15:40

What happens to the RF funding if the monarch ends? Presumably that would also be the end of taxpayer funded "working royals" so how would they afford to keep their homes and security. Would K&W have to find civilian jobs or would there be some kind of arrangement so all of them continue earning enough via property, investment funds etc?

LoveGrooveDanceParty · 06/10/2021 15:40

As for William and Kate - privately i have always thought Kate wanted to marry the heir to the throne and went all out to do it. She'd be hugely disappointed to miss out Wink

She won’t miss out though, because none of them are going anywhere.

changingstages · 06/10/2021 15:39

I wish they'd just end it now. Absolute waste of space, the lot of them.